Scarlet Ibis Compare And Contrast

Blooming Life The life of a human being is parallel to a plant sprouting from the earth. However, if this plant were to be seeded in the cracks of concrete, is it best to let it flourish into a magnificent flower only to be plucked or only germinate into a stubby weed? In the short story “The Scarlet Ibis” by James Hurst, two brothers are present, but one is born with major disabilities. Throughout the story we see Doodle, the disadvantaged boy, get taught on how to walk, run, and row progressively by his elder brother, not out of kindness but a twisted pride and selfishness. After a grim sign from the death of a grand bird, Doodle is overexerted after being left by his brother in a violent storm and passes away. In the poem “Woman with Flowers,”
These pieces of literature parallel each other, but have important differences which give room for philosophical debate. “The Scarlet Libs” and “Woman with Flowers” have similarities and differences in their use of literary devices, character analysis, and overall message. In both of the narratives, literary devices are used to convey the author's thoughts on the theme of over-assistance. In Madgett’s “Woman with Flowers,” she utilizes symbolism in the way she expresses the plant. In lines one to two, the speaker warns, “I wouldn’t coax the plant if I were you”. Such full nurturing may do it harm." In this message, she compares the plant to a human being. Through coaxing, the plant translates to overly pushing along to achieve a goal, symbolizing the wrongness of the oversaturation of
Metaphorically, this stands for the challenged boy’s struggles and how he is mistreated by them by getting called a silly nickname. Through their symbols and metaphors, both compare similar themes but have different messages. “The Woman with Flowers” generally states to not push others and let them find their own path. While “The Scarlet Ibis” encourages not to make others forcibly improve for their own pride and selfishness. In both texts, the authors utilize characters to embody traits and meaning. In “The Scarlet Ibis,” there is much to unpack about Doodle's brother and what he represents. In the middle of the story, the brother forces a doodle to touch his coffin infested with owls. By this action, the cruel nature of the brother is shown, since it’s implying Doodle’s death. In the story, the boy represents greed and pride. When the brother first teaches Doodle to walk, he picks him up, and while Doodle pleads for him to stop, he lets go anyway. Although he eventually learns to walk, the repetitive abuse that Doodle suffers at the hands of his older brother portrays the narrator's evil nature and his unstoppable quest for