Serial Critique
The Serial is a suspenseful audio storytelling podcast that explores
different and dramatic scenarios for each of their episodes. Investigator and
journalist, Sarah Koenig, hosted the podcast and she presents her story in a form
of reporter, in which she shares the story of a murder that occurred in Baltimore,
Maryland. This critique will review the very first episode of The Serial Podcast
and the quality of Sarah Koenig's report from the story of the murder, to the
interviews she shared with her witnesses.
In the first episode entitled, The Alibi investigates the story of a high
school student named Adnan Syed, who may not or have been falsely convicted
of a crime he committed in 1999. His girlfriend during the time named Hae Ming
Lee, was murdered and found dead by park in Northern Baltimore. She was
confirmed missing after school one day and in six weeks prior to the
disappearance, the Baltimore police department arrested her boyfriend, Adnan
Syed, for the crime. Even though Adnan kept his innocence throughout the
investigation, he was still convicted and the court sentenced him to life in prison.
Sarah Koenig's (the reporter) purpose in this podcast was to investigate
and gain more detail for the killing of Hae Ming Lee. She questions numerous of
high school students, one being her own nephew, who attended and who were
close friends to Adnan. The main questions she tends to ask are, "Where were
you on the day Hae Ming went missing?" and "Do you remember seeing Adnan
on that day?" These repetitive, but key, questions where asked towards the
students she interviewed during the podcast. However, before the questioning of
the crime, Koenig tells us a brief summary of the story and background
information of both Adnan and Hae Ming. She goes in great detail describing who
they were in high school to help us, the listeners, place an image towards the two
in the story. During the time she's telling the listeners information about the two
main students in the podcast, she also tells information about the other
interviewed students as well.
This paragraph contains my evaluation prior towards my last
paragraph, which described my experience listening to the podcast. In the
previous paragraph, I write regarding Koenig's approach towards the students of
the high school and the information she provides about each of them. Personally,
I believe this was an important, yet appreciable method Koenig took because it
helped me (the listener) understand more about the story. To me, I felt when
Koenig provided the background information of each student, including to the two
main students in the case, it helped me understand the personalities of them and
the actions they would partake in. Also, I consider that the questions that Koenig
delivers are very significant towards my experience with podcasting. The reason
being, is that the questions kept me intrigued throughout the podcast and the
more questions that Koenig carried, the closer she was towards solving the
crime, which me, as a listener to a mystery genre podcast, found it exciting as it
progressed towards the end.
Overall, I found that the podcast was highly entertaining and enjoyable. As
the story grows deeper, my level of interest increases. Because of the
production, quality, and storyline of the first episode, I personally would continue
listening to the other episodes that are created.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
A teacher found two girls smoking in the bathroom in a school located in New Jersey. Upon arrival to the principal’s office for disciplinary actions, one of the girls admitted to smoking, while the other (whose initials are T.L.O.) denied any wrongdoing. The principal ended up searching the girl’s purse which contained evidence to prove she was smoking in the bathroom along with marijuana paraphernalia. She eventually admitted to using this paraphernalia for selling marijuana in school. Using the evidence found within the purse and the confession, she was charged and taken into juvenile court where she was eventually sentenced to a year’s probation. T.L.O argued that her 4th amendment rights had been violated…
- 263 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Disclaimer: the victim written about is my friend who wanted to be the subject of a scenario. I’m not that awful of a person to write of her murder without her knowledge.…
- 1781 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays -
She analyzes people’s behavioral conduct at the time of a public beheading. Whether people were watching the beheading in person or online their behaviors and emotions were the same. The evidence Larson shows is that: “…the majority of the people who come to see are either enthusiastic or, at best, unmoved. Disgust has been comparatively rare…” Today, when people watch videos of public beheadings they experience the same kind of emotions: “…the action takes place in a distant time and place, which gives the viewer a sense of detachment from what’s happening, a sense of separation.” That leads to people thinking it has nothing to do with them because it has already happened. Larson keeps on going with her appeal to…
- 993 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
2) I thought the articles were fascinating. It was very interesting to learn how certain parts of your brain can trigger certain behaviors and criminal activity.…
- 464 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
While preparing a documentary about Dr. James Grigson, Errol Morris unearths the story of Randall Adams and David Harris. One fateful day, Adams’ car runs out of gas on the side of the road in Dallas, Texas. That same day, after running away from home, stealing a car, and his father’s gun, Harris drove his car through Dallas. Then he comes across Adams walking to get gas for his car. Harris helps Adams and they spend the rest of the day together. That night, Officer Robert Wood was murdered on Inwood Road. Adams is tried and convicted of the murder, and sentenced to death. After learning of this Morris changed the focus of his documentary and created The Thin Blue Line. Through his unconventional narrative, Errol Morris guides the viewer through many versions of the night in question. He uses juxtaposition of scenes, non-conventional reenactments, archival footage and other ways to tell the story of the murder of Officer Wood and the defense and conviction of Adams.…
- 1365 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
2. How has each writer organized the details that have been selected? Bear in mind that most news organizations present what they consider the most important information first and the least important information last. Each writer made clear on what they have seen basically who the suspect and killer were, where and when the actual assassination took place. They were very detailed. Each writer had their own specific way on how the event played out.…
- 389 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The podcast Cruel and Unusual covers the issue of the death penalty and whether or not it should be allowed in the U.S. It discusses the controversy within this issue, especially the lethal injection and the constitutionality of capital punishment in regards to the ban of cruel and unusual punishment in the 8th amendment. Some of the cases mentioned were Wilkerson v Utah where the Supreme Court initially ruled to allow a firing squad to be used in the death penalty and Baze v Rees (2008) in which the Supreme Court ruled that lethal injection was not cruel and unusual punishment, and therefore not unconstitutional. The impact that the issue of the death penalty and the court cases regarding it have on the country is that people are easily outraged…
- 331 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The aim of this task is to give a sense of closure to the play through the passage of time since it ends in a very tragic way. The storyline escalates a conflict to such an extent that every time one thinks that it couldn’t get worse, it does. More and more innocents suffer different consequences throughout the story. The reason I chose an Investigative report is because it is the most appropriate in revealing the true story to the world. Also, the investigation…
- 243 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The Amityville horror is my chosen topic which I am going to write about for my report. I have chosen this particular topic as the field of criminology is one I find really interesting and hope to study it further at university. I have recently seen the film of the Amityville Horror' and found it intriguing so I thought I would study it further. In this report I intend to cover the murderer', the murder' and the theory behind the crime.…
- 954 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In this novel a young girl named Susie Salmon was brutally raped and killed by a man in her neighbourhood. Her case is still an ongoing investigation but little to no proof leads towards the man who committed the crime. Lindsey, Susie’s little sister, is a very talented and intelligent girl. She was invited to attend the Gifted Symposium for her intelligence. Lindsey goes away to this symposium with other students in junior and high school. At the very end of the symposium, the students are given a challenge, normally it's to create the best mouse trap, but they changed it up this year. The new challenge was how to commit the perfect murder. I think the Gifted Symposium was wrong by initiating a How to commit the perfect murder challenge, because it’s a touchy subject.…
- 317 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The inSocial Work Podcast for this week main focus was about soldiers who get deployed and the effect it has on them and their families. Implications for treatment would be counseling and speaking with them to help them to get back into their life from deployment. One of the things that stood out to me is that it was said that the country needs to do more for their veterans then just put a stick on their car. Education is the key and it is said in the podcast. I do think it is important to learn more about active soldiers and veterans so that we can better serve them. It is better for a social worker to know more about what the family is going through to better help them get through military life better. It is important to know what the families…
- 472 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
What a gtreat name for a story. "The Utterly Perfect Murder." It was perfect bcause he didn't kill a person; he killed the anger that was inside. It was such an utterly perfect, such an icredibly delightful idea for murder, that he was half out of his mind all across america. Was he out of his mind because he wanted to murder? In some ways yes, but for what Ralph underhill did 36 years ago, no.…
- 219 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The story is about a young couple that attempts murder twice, committing it once. The story is told by a lawyer that works in a small town in Mississippi. He meets a devout Christian and solid citizen, Mr. Savage. On March 7th, 1995, Sarah and Ben, a young couple on a road trip, entered Mr. Savage’s office and shot and killed Mr. Savage. They took his credit cards and cash. There were no witnesses. The couple made their way down to New Orleans for Mardi Gras. Running low on cash, Sarah entered a convenience store and shot the 35 year old mother that was working that night. She then took the money from the register. The clerk survived but was completely paralyzed. An anonymous informant identified Sarah from the video from the convenience store.…
- 254 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Inherent Vice - Well I’m a bit nervous right now after Pete Hammond said he has heard mixed things from critics on Inherent Vice. I just took it out of my Best Picture predictions today. I heard that of a trusted critic who saw it, said they adored it but it’ll get very negative responses from other because of how insane is. I mean this excites in one aspect, but absolutely terrifies me because I want a PTA comeback with the Academy.…
- 1616 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Well-schooled in murder is a crime novel written by Elizabeth George. The novel is a crime novel because there is a mystery and the investigation of the mystery. Crime novels are vey popular because of the always exiting composition. The reader is therefore very curious of finding the mystery solution.…
- 1373 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays