Sherlock Holmes: A Study In Pink Vs. A Study In Scarlet
Sherlock Holmes: “A Study in Pink” vs. A Study in Scarlet
Do you believe in deductive reasoning? Or that it may be possible to use it to solve criminal cases? This is what Sherlock Holmes does as a consulting detective in order to solve multiple affairs. He uses observations and knowledge to reveal information about illegal incidents. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle wrote A Study in Scarlet which tells us of Sherlock’s stories. There is also a modernized version, Sherlock: “A Study in Pink.” These are some ways in which A Study in Scarlet and “A Study in Pink” are comparable, yet diverse.
Sherlock Holmes has a colleague, Dr. John Watson, which he met through a friend in both the story and the episode. Dr. Watson shares a flat with Sherlock and accompanies …show more content…
In the literature, Jefferson Hope is motivated by revenge in which he gets closure from killing Joseph Stangerson and Enoch Drebber. These men were responsible for the death of his dearest, Lucy Ferrier, and her father, John Ferrier. In the show, Jeff is provoked to murder out of burden, because he is receiving money to send to his children for every person he is able to kill. Jeff is dying of an aneurysm and believes this is his only option to help his family. Jefferson Hope and Jeff were cab drivers, allowing them to kill without being perceived. By driving taxis these men were able to remain hidden among all other citizens and would not be suspected. Rache is an essential element of the storyline in “A Study in Pink” and A Study in Scarlet. The use of Rache is associated with the executions in both the episode and text. In the text, Rache is the German word meaning revenge. Sherlock notices that this is not written by someone who is German by the way that the “A” is written, and this leads him to tracking Jefferson Hope. In the film, Rache exemplifies the name Rachel. The lady in the pink coat carved this in the floor near her while she was dying. Rachel is the password to her email which allowed the detectives to track her phone that she planted on
Do you believe in deductive reasoning? Or that it may be possible to use it to solve criminal cases? This is what Sherlock Holmes does as a consulting detective in order to solve multiple affairs. He uses observations and knowledge to reveal information about illegal incidents. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle wrote A Study in Scarlet which tells us of Sherlock’s stories. There is also a modernized version, Sherlock: “A Study in Pink.” These are some ways in which A Study in Scarlet and “A Study in Pink” are comparable, yet diverse.
Sherlock Holmes has a colleague, Dr. John Watson, which he met through a friend in both the story and the episode. Dr. Watson shares a flat with Sherlock and accompanies …show more content…
In the literature, Jefferson Hope is motivated by revenge in which he gets closure from killing Joseph Stangerson and Enoch Drebber. These men were responsible for the death of his dearest, Lucy Ferrier, and her father, John Ferrier. In the show, Jeff is provoked to murder out of burden, because he is receiving money to send to his children for every person he is able to kill. Jeff is dying of an aneurysm and believes this is his only option to help his family. Jefferson Hope and Jeff were cab drivers, allowing them to kill without being perceived. By driving taxis these men were able to remain hidden among all other citizens and would not be suspected. Rache is an essential element of the storyline in “A Study in Pink” and A Study in Scarlet. The use of Rache is associated with the executions in both the episode and text. In the text, Rache is the German word meaning revenge. Sherlock notices that this is not written by someone who is German by the way that the “A” is written, and this leads him to tracking Jefferson Hope. In the film, Rache exemplifies the name Rachel. The lady in the pink coat carved this in the floor near her while she was dying. Rachel is the password to her email which allowed the detectives to track her phone that she planted on