Preview

Should the Internet Replace the Book As the Chief Tool of Learning?

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1217 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Should the Internet Replace the Book As the Chief Tool of Learning?
At present, the Internet and other technology are well-developed and keep improving. People use those new tools to do everything, and try hard to make human life easier and more perfect. From business to finances; industry to entertainment; services to education, the use of the Internet has increased and become more mainstream. Some people believe that the Internet and other electronic technology can replace all kind of jobs that humans do, including teaching students with screens and keyboards instead of books. They emphasize that the Internet can help people interact to each other beyond the barrier of distance, so books are somehow not necessary in human lives. However, in my opinion, this idea cannot be more ridiculous. Books are irreplaceable for people to read, to learn and to think, whereas web pages and electronic database offer limited and misleading information. Moreover, the use of the Internet may bring potential risks of health and learning hindering, let alone to help people to learn. There are three main reasons why the Internet and other new technology should not replace the book as the chief tool of learning: books are more credible, valuable and meaningful; using the Internet for learning limits developing social skills; the use of the Internet brings negative results such as wasted money, wasted time and health hazard. First of all, books cannot be replaced by technology such as the Internet because the book has its value, credit and meaning. Although the Internet has become more popular and more widely used, it cannot totally replace books and become the main way that human inherit literacy. According to Ursula K. Le Guin, the article, “Staying awake: notes on the alleged decline of reading,” states that reading book is a challenge and meaningful activity. When people read, they need to use their own hands to turn pages, use their own eyes to process language, and use their own brains to think; instead of just pressing the buttons (2008, ¶

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    According to “The Internet Can Make You Smarter, Experts Say” by Lance Whitney, experts agree that internet allows people to broaden their education, as well as their imagination. Whitney is claiming that the internet not only offers a source for higher education, but also offers a source of inspiration to those who choose to use it. Whitney then goes on to explain that most experts feel that “the gadgets and applications destined to capture our imaginations in the next 10 years” are going to be stunning to even the smartest minds today (9). Whitney is claiming that the internet can lead to astonishing contraptions that will improve lifestyles. Finally, Whitney states that sixty five percent of the 900 participants of the report “The future of the Internet IV” agree that the internet can enhance the human cognitive skills.…

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some might have said that Google invent new innovative ways to learn. In “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Nicholas Carr’s that the internet is a threat to our brains, but there is no evidence of such cause. I found that the internet is a tool when it comes to reading, studying, and anything that I am able to find on the internet. We are in a world that enable us to learn much than in a book could which might lead to believe that technology can improve teaching and learning, but there still some continue to insist in traditional reading or writing. For example, the baby Boomer generation might be more resistant to rapid technology changes and prefer to pick a book instead figuring out how or what technology could improve one reading or writing which a lot generation X prefer to do. We have to integrate both generations to find median ground to understand digital application can improve teaching and learning due to why literacy matter. We need to able to guide the…

    • 538 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Our world is rapidly progressing into a vibrant technological era. The internet and computer took the world by storm, and now Apple and Google are a vital part of every country. We can now access information in ten seconds that would of taken us days 20 years ago. Technology has been integrated into a majority of schooling systems, allowing students to be more successful in their classes. Without the internet, student would learn half of what they would learn without them. Knowledge and wisdom is shared across the world wide web, and it is visible to every single person. Technology has had a positive effect on students as too much screen time cannot harm them.…

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Students have a lot of pressure when it comes to homework and how much they count toward our grades. So when it comes to needing help the internet has helped us because its hard to do it on our own.In the article "Education 2.0: Never memorizing again" the text says "It is enough that they know about the Battle of Hastings, without having to memorize that it was in 1066. They can look that up and position it in history with a click on Google,” he said." Not every student can memorize everything as if it was programmed into our mind as a teacher taught it to us. With the internet the little things we forget it gives us many sources and information that become useful to us. Some may argue that technology is dangerous and causes issues.In which in the article" Attached to technology and paying a price" it says" The resulting distractions can have deadly consequences, as when cellphone-wielding drivers and train engineers cause wrecks. " In which has been and is still a huge problem ,But instead of taking away technology in which can help us but instead just teach teenagers the benefits of technology and to not use it unwisely. Taking away technology for a week would just make people want to use it more in which means when the week is over we would constantly use it in which could cause more wrecks and more…

    • 694 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    apush

    • 2051 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Studies have shown that people are spending more time on the Internet than reading books (Smith). Some critics believe that the reading habits of most people are fading away, and the Internet sources available are becoming more popular (Smith). With the E-book, it is easier to log on to the internet and download a full…

    • 2051 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Shallows Analysis

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages

    People used to read books, magazines, and newspaper articles for researching purposes. Now, the norm is to use Google’s search engine. Most books, magazines, and newspapers can be found somewhere on the Internet nowadays. A person can purchase almost any book on their E-reader, with an Internet connection, and read it from anywhere. Book stores are basically becoming obsolete. The book store, located where I live, closed down a couple years ago when E-readers, such as, Nooks, Kindles, and iPads, started growing in popularity. Because the action of reading and getting lost in a book requires a completely different brain function than skimming articles on the Internet, many people nowadays do not spend their time reading books.…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Dumbest Generation

    • 273 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The more we spent on the Internet, the less we read books. Yes, books. The most direct way to perceive knowledge. Not only reading books but magazines are also a brilliant way to get informed of what’s going on around the world. Even novels or literatures could improve our quality and temperament. Reading books and articles enables us to think critically, so that we can have more ideas about the worldwide issues. However, it is sad that we usually don’t read in our free time unless the teacher told us to read the text books.…

    • 273 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Considering the gift of computers Bill Gates bestowed upon libraries for students, I’m sure his intentions were for the students to excel and keep abreast of the ever changing world of technology, not to replace reading with surfing the web. I agree with Judith Levine when she stated, “It’s important for students to read books, magazines, newspapers, history, poetry, politics and listen to people who know what they’re talking about.” Reading books and other literature teaches students the past, present and future, not only for things happening in the world today but facts about things past.…

    • 1057 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    As days pass by in front of our eyes and as the generations are changing, the world is changing dramatically and being remodeled to where Google is the book of answers. Life isn’t as challenging for our community and does not push anyone to put in any effort as it did Fifty years ago. Nicholas Carr has every right to publish this article on how reading isn’t the same anymore. Books can be looked at as rare no-a-days, something that’s going to be extinct in a few decades. Our parents learned about the world and its news in the Newspaper. When students wanted to learn about the moon or had a paper that needed to be written, it was the library that helped them, not Google. Instead of clicking away, they flipped pages and no words were skimmed or wasted. At a point in time, people needed to make an actual effort to live and expand their mind with actual knowledge. Carr’s biggest claim was his opinion on the internet, he gives us the idea that the internet is giving people the chance to become lazier than ever and still assume that they will get things done. The internet allows people to put their brains aside collecting dust and forget about books because “Google” always has another shortcut for them. Carr proves this using many of his own experiences, quotes, and studies from other authors such as Scott Kurp and Bruce Friedman.…

    • 1365 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    I agree with the majority of the points author Annie Murphy Paul makes in her article “Reading Literature Makes Us Smarter and Nicer”. She states “the deep reading of books and the information-driven reading we do on the web are very different, both in the experience they produce and in the capabilities they develop”. There has been recent research completed to prove that “deep reading- slow, immersive, rich in sensory detail and emotional and moral complexity- is a distinctive experience, different in kind from the mere decoding of words”. Annie Murphy Paul also states “Although deep reading does not, strictly speaking, require a conventional book, the built-in limits of the printed page are uniquely conductive to the deep reading experience.” I find this statement to be incredibly true as it is easier to absorb what you are reading off of a real page rather than a digital device. The feeling of turning that next page to discover what happens next becomes less magical when it is digital. Experiencing nervousness or excitement as you see yourself coming to the last few pages of your book becomes so dull when instead you just flick your screen to the next page. The truth is, real printed books will not fail you or die on you; they are always there to inspire and create imagination.…

    • 702 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    According to (Packard), “There is 87% of 12-17 year olds now online.” Our society is now faced with the question of how we can make the Internet as effective in the learning process as literacy. One way to improve the functionalities…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Compared with traditional textbooks, the iPad and other devices for reading digital books have the prospective to save on textbooks costs in the long term, to provide students with more and better information faster, and – no small matter – to lighten the typical college student’s backpack. Santa Clara University student Christopher Paschal, 19, for instance, esteemed the search function in his economics e-textbook, and said the included video clips offered “An alternative method of learning,” and eliminated “The monotony of endless pages of reading.” But eventually, “I feel that I comprehend material better in regular textbooks, “Paschal says. “Textbook publishers haven’t had a chance to modify things for the iPad. If publishers really get behind the iPad, I can see a day where it’s the only thing I would bring to school.” Even then, some evidence recommends students see a downside to 24/7 interactivity when it comes to formulating for exams or doing homework. During visits last fall to libraries, coffee shops and other campus hangouts to scrutinize how students study, a test-prep company noted that, when it was time to study, cellphones, laptops and Kindles were put away. A 2005 review by researchers at Carleton University in Ottawa, Canada, of 38 studies initiate “Very little support” for the idea that all those links to additional information enhance the reader’s experience. The online environment “Promotes cursory reading, hurried and distracted thinking, and superficial learning, “ argues Nicholas Carr, who raises concerns about the long-term implications in The Shallows: What the internet Is Doing to Our Brain, which was published in June.…

    • 263 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Microwaves, MacBooks, and MP3 players all have one thing in common: they are all technology. Technology is used in schools across the nation, such as Empire High School which has replaced all textbooks with iBooks to make students excited about learning (Source A). But is technology always good? The Internet, a byproduct of technology, contains loads of information ranging from when Benjamin Franklin was born to how to conceal a dead body. “There is no quality control on the Internet.” (Source E) The lack of quality control means that students could be exposed to inappropriate material, on accident. Technology can both improve and hinder life, so when schools decide to implement new technological tools for learning, they must consider how it effects traditional learning, and how useful the technology truly is.…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Socrates feared writing would make us forgetful. He believed written knowledge didn’t give us the same wisdom as oral knowledge (100). Hieronimo Squarciafico, the Italian humanist, believed the easily available books that the printing press provided would lead to weaker minds (100). Writing and the easy access to books, two of the world’s biggest discoveries, yet they were seen as things that would harm people rather than help. Nicholas Carr advocates the harmfulness of the internet in his article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Carr believes the internet is changing the way we think. We are slowly losing our ability to concentrate. The internet is negatively affecting our brains. The fast paced world of the internet…

    • 582 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Synthesis on Smart Phones

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Before people had access to the internet so commonly finding answers for things was more difficult. When people needed an answer to something they would have to go to the library or look it up in a textbook. Now they simply have to google the question on a computer or phone giving them an easy one line answer in less than a minute. This seems like a good thing, but it has changed how people learn and take in information. For example, if a student needs to answer a question at school, he needs to use a textbook to dig for the answer hidden in a huge wall of text. This is hard because they are accustomed to one line answers provided from the internet. The article “Lazy Eyes” explains that the internet’s various distractions make people skim or skip reading big blocks of text. Doing this on the internet has carried over to the way we read everything. It makes reading long sections of a book for a single answer much more difficult because we are unintentionally skipping or skimming long paragraphs. This is not the first time our ability to learn has changed. According to Sherry Turkle, in the late 1970’s “Professors in engineering complained that the transition from slide rules to calculators had affected their students’ ability to deal with issues of scale.” The internet is making it harder to learn in some cases, but just like the professors being able to teach scale while using calculators, they will be able to teach while using the internet. In the end,…

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays