Education has played a significant role in our daily lives and has been a valuable asset for every human in understanding the events taking place everyday. Through education, we learn new ideas, came up with new inventions, able to bridge the gap between cultures, raised our standard of living and modernized the world. The rapid growth of technology and the internet revolutionalized education with the development of online education or e-learning. This mode of education has attracted several learning institutions, instructors, and students alike that the number of schools/universities simultaneously adopting e-learning with onsite education has been increasing annually. Several people support online education due to its flexibility and convenience, however, there are still some people who opt for classroom attendance rather than e-learning. As education has improved the way we live and has lead us to a more technological-dependent world, learning institutions should encourage and support online education especially among the working adults who lead a hectic lifestyle and wants to further their careers and those juggling their time between family and work. Online education does not only save time and costs for students, but also can provide a way for online students to manage their schedule without having to disrupt family and work responsibilities.
Critics have argued that there is a lack of personalization in online education which will have negative effects on the educational and social aspects in the student’s lives. Due to the absence of face-to-face interaction with instructors and students, online learners feel isolated because there is no physical interaction between students and instructors as well as a lack of oral communication skills that is usually occurring in a classroom education. I totally do not agree with this argument because communication technologies such as chat rooms, discussion boards, conferencing and bulletin boards have provided a way for students and instructors to interact with each other. In fact, online interaction provides students from different countries to forge friendship across borders and learn new cultures. It also enhances student’s knowledge through the exchange of different ideas and information. Communication skills can also be engaged in an online education through the use of audio equipments and softwares and hence, a diverse actual interaction through videos and audio technologies can be in par with a physical classroom attendance. However, I do not agree that online learning should be encouraged on grade and high school students as these students are still on their formative/learning phase and they require social skills and physical interaction with students/teachers to mold their character and guide them in their education. Onsite education is the building block of pre-university students and should be maintained and supported by schools and instructors alike. Hence, I would say that online education should only be encouraged to adults because they already have the necessary educational foundation and are matured enough to deal with virtual interaction as well as online education.
People who are against online education claim that e-learners are not good in critical thinking because of the absence of discussion board interaction which is a dominant feature in a classroom environment. The lack of physical discussion in e-learning restricts the student to think open-mindedly and limits his abilities to communicate effectively in finding out solutions to complicated problems. In my opinion, I do not think that both types of education differ in critical thinking skills because online students have already the necessary technological resources to interact with people all over the world. When a student is left alone to study, the tendency is that the student will search and try to engage his thinking skills into action. This was supported in an analysis conducted by Newman, Webb & Cochrane in which they asserted that “Online learners have more responsibility to engage themselves in the learning process than students in face-to-face courses since a classroom instructor can literally pull them into a discussion.” Usually, online students are self-directed and take control of their own studies which enable them to concentrate and think deeper through evaluation and analyzation. Their initiative to study with minimum tutor guidance can, in the process, develop their thinking skills due to the challenges posed by studying independently. They have to develop critical thinking skills to understand and analyze the information available to them, choose and reflect the correct materials and course content by themselves, solve complex problems and make the right decisions. As concluded in a research on the critical thinking subject by a US professor, Dr. Ellen Derwin, “there were no significant differences between face-to-face and online learners.”
A third criticism about online education is the lack of self-discipline, in which students perform better in the traditional learning method. Unlike a traditional class in which specific times are set, students are compelled to keep up with the tutor and submit assignments on a specified deadline, while online education let students set their own schedule, and hence, has the tendency to procrastinate. I do not really agree to this criticism because discipline is a characteristic of a student and not as a result, or specific, to online education. A student who does not possess this characteristic or who does not know how to manage his time is prone to procrastinate even in a traditional classroom environment. Procrastination is a human behavior which requires discipline on the part of the student. However, I do not think that procrastination plays a role in the performance of a student in an online environment because a student’s performance is based on his knowledge about the subject. Though a student might postpone doing a task until the very last moment, a student’s performance depends “on the student’s talents and capabilities, not on the proximity to the deadline that the work is performed.” The same can be said in a classroom setting in which students who do not have self-discipline may postpone doing an assignment until the deadline is near but can still have high academic performance just like an online student. On a study of the effect of procrastination on academic performance on online education, it was determined that “a negative relationship was found between procrastination and performance, and this relationship was mediated by the level of the learners' participation in discussion forums.” Hence, students can still perform well even when they procrastinate.
The remarkable development of education from classroom to online education has not only helped adults in securing higher education and job positions, but also has opened our minds to wider opportunities and possibilities that online education can offer with the help of technology. Online education has shown that people can interact with their instructors and other students beyond its own borders, and increases one’s knowledge as compared to a classroom setting. Moreover, online education has demonstrated that students develop critical thinking skills when they take account of their own studies and in fact, stimulates the thinking skills of the students. Lastly, the notion of procrastination which has been linked with online learning does not have any bearing on a student’s academic performance, irrespective of whether it is an onsite or online education. In conclusion, elementary and high school students should continue with the traditional classroom attendance while adults should be encouraged or given the option of online education, whichever fits their lifestyle. The rapid changes and challenges in this technological world have triggered instructors and students to expand their knowledge and seek ways to re-invent education. “To cope with the demands of the 21st century, people need to know more than core subjects. They need to know how to use their knowledge and skills - by thinking critically, applying knowledge to new situations, analyzing information, comprehending new ideas, communicating, collaborating, solving problems, making decisions.”
Newman, D. R., Webb, B., & Cochrane, C. (n.d.). A content analysis method to measure critical thinking in face-to-face and computer supported group learning [Electronic Version] from http://www.qub.ac.uk/mgt/papers/methods/contpap.html. http://mprcenter.org/mpr/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=209&Itemid=164 http://aaahq.org/AM2010/display.cfm?Filename=SubID_2738.pdf&MIMEType=application%2Fpdf http://portal.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=1872217&CFID=3510427&CFTOKEN=44385 Partnership for 21st Century Skills, (2003). Learning for the 21st century, Washington, D.C.: Author. Available online at http://www.21stcenturyskills.org
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
When comparing online education versus traditional education, the most important factor potential students need to analyze is their scheduling concerns. While there are numerous students who attend college directly out of high school, there is a substantial amount of college bound individuals who already have a full time job and family when they start. The author of this essay was like many other college students in that she had to withdraw from her classes on a physical campus…
- 1119 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
While online classes are a part of many colleges, there is intense debate over whether they should be incorporated into high school education. The advocates of online education key in on the convenience, flexibility, self direction, cost savings, safety, creativity, pacing aspect and access to resources. Those opposed to online classes feel that online education is driven solely by budget cuts and the result is a cheaper education that has less guidance, lacks the social aspect, has accreditation issues and as a result, less beneficial to the students. Others think that blended learning which combines virtual education and face-to-face instruction is the most effective route, but possibly not the most cost effective.…
- 1736 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Thesis Statement: Online education provides students with flexible schedules and the ability to work at their own pace, while a traditional education provides students with the ability to interact with teachers and peer while learning.…
- 252 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Online learning is growing rapidly. There are more students choosing to go to school online then there were ten years ago. Student demand is one of the many factors contributing to the growth of online learning. Some students are looking for the opportunities of the convience that online learning offers. Technology has made it possible for teachers and students to ineract thru the internet. Online learning is beneficial to students.…
- 1822 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
It seems that technology is growing, improving, and changing at an exponential rate. Technology now affects every part of our lives from the time we get up to the time we go to bed, and even as we sleep. One of the major areas that has been affected by technology is education. At one time, the only option for students to complete their education was in a traditional classroom setting. There has become a major need for non-traditional education because there has been a growth in the amount of non-traditional students that exist in our society. The advancement of technology has recently allowed for education to be completed in an online setting instead of in a traditional classroom setting. Online education is an effective and comparable alternative to a traditional classroom setting, and it can be a great opportunity for a non-traditional student to further his or her education and become one step closer to being a successful, self-sufficient individual.…
- 1769 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
Communication is important with classmates and professors. All students have a question or two with assignments or clarification about a grade. Online universities offer many forms of communication. Students may contact professors and other students through e-mail, instant messaging, phone, and sometimes video chat. Students may also contact professors and other students via posts in the class room. Attending an online university makes it difficult to form study groups, but not impossible. Sometimes, students must participate in group projects. Socialization is up to the student, students can be as social as they want. For students who are easily distracted or fidgety, online education may be the best option. With most online universities students also have a financial aid advisor as well as an academic representative to help guide students in the right direction. Traditional universities offer a more personal…
- 1054 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
With the ability to schedule your classes when it is best suited for you, it can be a huge advantage. With the hectic agenda of our everyday lives, it’s not easy to accomplish everything we want in one day. Through electronic learning, you are able to create a schedule that accommodates your lifestyle. Most instructors usually allow students to complete their work at their own pace. Online education allows you to do your work without ever leaving the comfort of your own home. Not only does this allow you to work at your own pace, but you can also learn in your own specific way.…
- 861 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
There seems to be a new type of education out there for people instead of traditional education. The type of education I am talking about is online education. You may be wondering what I mean by an online education is and how you learn with it. This compare and contrast essay will talk about the pro’s and cons of each of the types of education and why I prefer to do online education versus doing a traditional education. Throughout this paper I will be discussing three major points about the two types of education. The three points I will be discussing in this essay are how you learn with the two types of education, why I think online education is easier than traditional education, and why I choose to do online education myself rather than do traditional education. I will also be discussing the Pros and cons of each type of education. The ultimate goal of my paper will be to try and convince you why I think online education are better than traditional.…
- 930 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
To begin with, online classes can raise concern for attendance. Robert Mendenhall of Western Governors University addresses this by stating that although attendance can interfere with the quality of online courses, the important factor is if students can gain the knowledge they need to be successful through other means ( Mendenhall, 2). This statement can be interpreted by understanding what the “other means” could be. The statement by Mendenhall was directed towards large student, general education classes. Rather than going to every class, it…
- 1327 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Nowadays, many students have to work to cover for the college fees, which makes non-traditional student online class beneficiary for it gives the students a chance to learn in their own time. The online course provides flexibility regarding schedule. For instance, if a person works during daytime, s/he will not be able to attend regular classes in school. However, if colleges offer online classes, students could get a chance to study at night after work. Even at work, students can also to study or do homework during break time, or whenever they are free. For example, I work as a security in a company, and I can just sit and read or do my homework even during work time. It is always my priority to look for online classes because I don’t have to worry about fixing my work schedule to align it with my class schedule. Providing online course helps not only non-traditional students but…
- 669 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The minds of today's youth hold the outcome of the future. So, it is important we give them the best education for them to succeed. As technology becomes a bigger part of everyday life, there has been debate as to if online school or traditional school is better for students. While online school is more convenient, it isn't necessarily the best option. There on many pros and cons on both sides of the argument, as both are good in different ways. However, online school isn't as good as traditional school as students are isolated, they have less guidance from their teachers, and more easily lose motivation to do their schoolwork.…
- 584 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The “anytime, anywhere” aspect of online learning is the most significant advantage over traditional classroom (Arbaugh, 2004:171, cited by Brandon & Hollingshead, 1999; Dede, 1991; Harasim, 1990). Learners can process material at any time from any place (Paechter & Maier, 2010:296, citied by Artino & Stephens, 2009; Narciss et al, 2007). For students who cannot afford to take away from their time-dependent jobs, online programs provide flexibility in time and pace of study so that they are able to work meanwhile maintaining the universities’ academic commitment (Sharpe & Benfield, 2005; Conrad & Donaldson, 2004; Kruger-Ross & Waters, 2013). Moreover, by accessing a learning management system such as Moodle, Blackboard, course website, students can achieve clarity about their course information like assignments, test dates to the full extent (Kruger-Ross & Waters, 2013:181). On the other hand, online learning could be time-consuming…
- 1782 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Online classes are gaining more and more legitimacy and are fast becoming a legitimate alternative to traditional classes. It’s a great asset because all students are required to participate in the class, and participation can be measured objectively. Therefore, nobody can skulk in the back of the room and not talk or dominate the conversation. Classes can also be taken from anywhere that has computer access, so people don’t have to put off their education because of distractions or lack of school access. Online courses emphasize reading, writing and discussion elements that are proven to be effective, and that students can use in their own classrooms. Students can do their classes and coursework at any time that is convenient, especially when traditional classes don’t meet. Plus in today’s society computer literacy is more and more a requirement on many jobs and in some classroom settings and online classes requires that students become computer literate. Online classes tend to train future workers for general requirements that are accepted in every state. A student might be trained for certification in…
- 390 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Working adults and stay-home parents looking to further their education may use online education as a resourceful tool to extract a better learning environment. In today’s society, online education is designed specifically for working adults and stay home parents with busy schedules and social responsibility. Some employers are now demanding more education from their employees along with in field experience than ever before and the job market is increasing competitive for those who want to succeed in their career.…
- 1048 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
A modern technology has grown up in this world fastly. By using a modern technology, the human’s jobs, human’s activities can be finished easily and quickly. One of examples of modern technology it self is online teaching. Nowadays, a learning process is not only take place in the classroom where the students sitting in rows listening to a teacher who stands in front of them, but also it can take place anywhere by using online teaching. However, is online teaching good for students or not? To answer it, at the first we have to understand what online teaching is. As a result, we can decide is online teaching appropriate for students or not. “Online teaching is not about replacing or reducing the human dimension to teach and learn, but rather providing a range of avenues for dialogue to occur between staff and students. It allows for a new mix between face to face communication, independent work on the part of students and communication via the web,”_(Johnston, 2011). Besides, Rob Darrow gives his statement about online teaching as follow,” In online teaching and learning the student is usually on a computer reading or viewing the curriculum or completing assignments. The student is usually at home or in a computer lab as compared to sitting in a classroom with desks and a teacher in front of the room. The teacher is usually in some types of office setting which could be at school or office or home,”_(Darrow, 2012). From both definitions, I can conclude that online teaching is a modern learning process by using internet. Furthermore, it can take place anywhere without attend to class, so it will be more flexible on location and time. For those reasons, I totally agree if online teaching is good for students. Online teaching is good for students for three reasons.…
- 779 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays