Preview

“Shrouded in Contradiction” by Gelareh Asayesh

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
357 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
“Shrouded in Contradiction” by Gelareh Asayesh
In the essay “Shrouded in Contradiction” by Gelareh Asayesh discusses the distention of gender in her Islamic society. She expresses her feeling toward wearing a hijab and how it’s not a big deal until it is. “None have been more daring than I. I've wound my scarf into a turban, leaving my neck bare to the breeze. The woman in black is a government employee paid to police public morals. ''Fix your scarf at once!'' she snaps. ''But I'm hot,'' I say. ''You're hot?'' she exclaims. ''Don't you think we all are?'' I start unwinding my makeshift turban. The men aren’t hot,” I mutter. Her companion looks at me in shocked reproach. “Sister, this isn’t about men and women,” she said, shaking her head. “This is about Islam.” I want to argue. I feel like a child. Defiant, but powerless. Burning with injustice, but also with a hint of shame.” In this excerpt, she clearly expresses the way that a hijab is about a lot more than a religious article of clothing. It’s a societal definition of genders. She expresses the way that the hijab can become complicated do to the societal views. She feels a strong sense of injustice because on a hot scorching day by the sea short, as a result of their sexuality women have to endure the heat in silence under there hijab. When she expresses her discomfort, she is reproach by a women officer. She reminded her; that the hijab has nothing to do with being a woman or a man, but is about being an Islamic woman. Thus, lies the contradiction, gender does play a role within the Islamic religion and society. This dictates the way in which a woman should dresses, and is expected to behave.
This excerpt correlates with the main topic of this essay, by explaining the role of clothing in an Islamic society. She also links this excerpt by expressing the powerless and guilty feelings she felt when the officer reproach her. There she was a women, yet she felt “…like a child.” Because of the societal rules and expectations that where being demanded of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Anne Applebaum’s "Veiled Insult" first appeared in the Washington Post in 2006. In this essay, Applebaum aims to convince her readers that it is disrespectful for Muslim women to wear their headscarves or niqabs (full bodied cloak) in our western society, just as it is disrespectful for our women to go to their society uncloaked. In delivering her message she also brings to attention the political issue of whether or not it is religious discrimination to allow, or not allow muslim women to wear their cloaks, and in the end she gives us her opinion, “it isn’t religious discrimination or anti-Muslim bias to tell her that she must be polite to the natives, respect the local customs, try to speak some of the local patois -- and uncover her face.” Applebaum uses her personal experiences combined with her American worldview to convince her readers (the American public) that for Muslim women to wear their cloaks in American culture is disrespectful and insensitive. Although those techniques may have worked, her strongest argument is perhaps playing on the emotions of the still sensitive and emotionally scarred, post 9/11…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    I think we can all agree, shirtless, old men in short-shorts are not a pretty sight. Hairy thighs and sweaty beer bellies—it’s practically blinding. I’d rather they all wear burkas. Burkas might have originated from oppressing roots, but they do promote modesty. It’s a universal fact: old, shirtless men could use some modesty. Don’t you agree? In a similar fashion, Diana Wagman uses popular opinion and cleverly chosen words to prove her points in her article, “First They’ll Come for the Burkas.” Wagman laces her article with relatable words and phrases—“Every summer when the temperature goes up, people start stripping down… Toddlers look cute in just a pair of shorts. Middle-aged men…

    • 1800 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Naheed Mustafa, a young Muslim who began to wear the hijab once she blossomed out of her teenage years, finds it difficult to apprehend the fact as to why society views her differently compared to other girls her age. Due to the mere fact that she wears a hijab, she gets a “whole gamut of strange looks, stares, and covert glances.” Because she lives in Canada, which adapts the Western culture, wearing a hijab is not very common. Because of this Naheed and many others like her, are often viewed as outcasts and treated differently. This takes a huge toll on one’s identity which can be either negative or positive. However, Naheed abides by her choices and wishes to make a positive change out of it.…

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Garments were arranged to display the patterns and quality of fabrics on all layers and add bulk to the body image. The more former the occasion or higher the status of the weaver, the more layers worn, with richer materials further indicating wealth.” Explained in Charlotte Jirousek article Islamic Clothing. Wearing the hijab was crucial while in public due to the exposer of the body. Any woman that was unveiled was viewed by men as a naked woman. Women should be covered to protect what is considered the men’s property at all times unless around immediate family in their homes. That is why “Women wear the Hijab around strangers (especially males) that they do not consider as part of their family. It is believed that this lessens the chance of them having bad thoughts about them, this includes sexual desires. They believe that the external part of a person is not important but what it inside.” Said in the article Why Do Woman Wear Hijab, Maureen. Women started to adapt to their cultural upbringings, they believed this was a way to keep themselves treasured. Some Islamic woman seen no harm in this, they didn’t feel as if the men dominated them, or were obeying them as their property. They felt as if all women should feel the need to be veiled so they’re not perceived as just a sex object. They would like men to be attentive to their personalities and mind not their looks. Today, women have more of a choice to be veiled. There are a lot of women who use the hijab and not the gown due to the evolving changes in fashion and liberal few points. They feel that it denies the women the freedom to decide on their own…

    • 1451 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Secondly, we also been conditioned to believe that a veiled woman is an oppressed woman. In truth women choose to wear or not wear their veils out of religious piety and social preference. These veils can also be used as a “tool of resistance” (Sensoy and Marshall, 124) “Women of Afghanistan documented the Taliban’s crimes against girls and women by hiding video cameras under their burqas and transformed the burqa from simply a marker of oppression to a tool of…

    • 1751 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Mona Eltahawy in "My Unveiling Ceremony," believes wearing a hijab (headscarf and clothing that covers the whole body except for the hands and face) is a form of oppressive behavior expected of women, and illustrates in her essay her experience with her loss of identity, resulting in her choice to stop wearing her hijab as symbol of empowerment and freedom. The following three points supports why Muslim women should not wear a hijab.…

    • 245 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    My favorite passage takes place after she gets in trouble for not wearing her scarf correctly. She states, "I want to argue. I feel like a child, defiant, but powerless. Burning with injustice, but also with a hint of shame. I do as I am told, feeling acutely conscious of the bare skin I am covering". I like this passage because you can really understand how she is feeling, and how difficult it is for her to adjust to two different life styles. Some of my friends from a Muslim country said “she should learn both culture in order to understand them. It is not hot to wear hijab when you are born and raised in Muslim society. It’s for to wear hijab because she didn’t practice her original culture. She was more western nice.”…

    • 297 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    Muslim women obviously dress very different than other Americans and their dress apparel stands out. This is one of the biggest issues and challenges that Muslim women in American face. They are taunted, and harassed every day because of the head-coverings that they wear, which is known as the “hijab”. Hijab, is Arabic for “cover”, which is extended to mean modesty and privacy. Hijab is actually a practice, but when women are practicing Hijab, is when they wear the scarf they wear. It usually covers the head, neck, and majority of the face in some situations, leaving the eyes open. Muslim women follow the rules of the Hijab, to show their submission to and love for God. However, this is all usually very misinterpreted. Women are looked down upon when they are wearing their head-coverings. Muslim women who wear head scarves are more likely than those who don’t to say they face discrimination and a hostile environment. Sixty-nine percent of women who wear hijab reported at least one incident of discrimination compared to 29% of women who did not wear the hijab. Muslim women have been prohibited from wearing their head-coverings in a number of contexts. These women have been…

    • 3795 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Boy Overboard

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Jamal’s parents wanted to settle in a place where safety and equality would be presented to the family, especially Bibi and her mother. In Afghanistan, life was not very equal when comparing boys and girls. Girls could not go outside without the company of a man, which meant that Bibi could not play soccer, but that did not stop her, no matter how risky it was. As a result, the family wanted to go to a place where it was safe and equal for women. The author shows the importance of equality for women when he writes: ‘…female soccer players. Bibi seems a bit overwhelmed.’ This shows that their ache for freedom, equality and independence inspired them to find a safe and equal environment for Bibi and her mother.…

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the poem she notes that even though we can not see her physic (because she is covered), we should appreciate that is her choice to be veiled, and that the veil liberates her in a way that she does not envy other women, she is not depressed, cheated or abused. Furthermore, in the poem she mentions that she works, drives a car, speaks perfect English and she feels equal to any male. At the end she refuses any pity, as she says being veiled, for her means freedom - 'as God has guided her to the truth '.…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the 1980’s the Iranian government decided to undergo a ‘Cultural Revolution’ to better their society and beliefs. Bilingual institutes were shut down, classes in schools were separated by sexes and young girls were assigned to wear veils. The veil carried multiple connotations and viewpoints the “fundamentalists” believed in. “And so to protect women from all the potential rapists, they decreed that wearing the veil was obligatory (pg. 74).” In one scene, Marji’s mother had been threatened by two fundamentalists, telling her that women like her (who aren’t wearing a veil) should be pushed against the wall and violated. And then afterwards, should be thrown in the garbage. To prevent such a horrid crime from occurring to women, the fundamentalists repetitively recited that wearing a veil would simply protect them. From a political aspect the government strongly believed that women’s hair emanates ‘rays’ that excite men, which was why it was strongly encouraged to cover up.…

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Religion is a set of beliefs on how the world ought to be, revealed through supernatural power and lived out as religious or secular spirit. It is different from nation to nation. It consists of: ritual activities that enforce, recall, instill, collective beliefs of a group of people, powerful symbols, and community of believers to give it a voice. By using knowledge of different cultures (symbolic and material) around the world most Middle Eastern women wear hijabs, which is the headscarves they wear that. It is tradition for a Muslim woman to wear the hijab for modesty as well as privacy, as it also represents a rite of passage (change in status) from youth to womanhood. Note that this is one of the few choices that they get, “For example girls might remove their headscarf when they came to school, or they might decide they don’t want to wear it anymore” (Adely 74). Clothing is a part of a culture that binds people of the same culture together. This refers to how symbols, help understand a particular society, such as clothing can have a sense of connection. In other words, these girls would feel like they are all connected by wearing the same thing. The modest covering represents their commitment to the culture and their respect to Abdullah. Since adolescents have a choice to when and where to wear it, that means that they want to be patriotic and they know what it means to be. As kids, people learn what they have to do every day to show they are patriotic for their country. If that means wearing their hijabs in the public eye or in…

    • 1972 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Banning The Burqa Campaign

    • 1925 Words
    • 8 Pages

    John Hirst’s article ‘Should we ban the burka?’ (2014) in The Australian newspaper provides us with some of the arguments for banning the burqa. It also contextualises society’s perceptions as it is a relatively representative position of many Australians both liberal and conservative. It is important to note though that The Australian newspaper’s editors are often critiqued by third-party scholars for an alleged bias as the newspaper often reflects the views of its owner, Rupert Murdoch a very wealthy Australian-born, American citizen with strong conservative ties. Observing this potential bias we can dissect Hirst’s arguments in favour of a burqa ban. Foremost in his argument is that wearing full body clothing is consistent with an attitude of “I can see you but you cannot see me”. He argues that this shows “contempt” for Australian values as it “discourages normal human interaction” on the basis that facial signals cannot be read (‘Should we ban the burqa?’, 2010, para. 3). This point seems fair in an open society such as Australia’s, however, this does not qualify as a reason for enforcing what women can or can’t wear. It may be a noble end but it is in no way a noble means. As outlined in earlier paragraphs the enforcement of such a ban denies the women it affects the agency to affect their own changes. The apparent neglect in addressing this point in the article is indicative of the accuracy of Mohanty’s argument that Western hegemonic discourse subjugates its…

    • 1925 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Negative Liberty In Canada

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This initially sparked controversy when there was a flurry of reaction to Stephen Harper's remarks on Twitter. The most popular Islamic clothing is a hijab that covers the head-and-shoulders; piece of cloth that covers the face, and the niqab that covers the entire face with the exception of few countries like Saudi Arabia where it is the law to wear the niqab. However, it is entirely up to Muslim women whether they choose to wear it or not. This situation is best described according to Isaiah Berlin’s “two concepts of liberty” (Swift 2014, 58-60).…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Mahmood looks to tackle the issue of not the cultures behind feminism but to understand the underpinnings behind feminism. She suggests that quite often the narrative is focused on feminism as a response to some sort of societal construct which allows the subordination of women. Her assertion is that we have to look at how feminism is defined in society. She brings up pertinent questions such as is feminism simply an expression of the desire for free will or is it merely a breaking from the societal constraints? And further more, is desire even relevant? She goes on to contend that it is, in fact, relevant and that it should be the basis of our focus when discussing feminist movements. To simply indicate that feminist movements arrive out of an opposition to another force minimalizes the role of the agents acting to bring about change and instead gives an inordinate amount of due to the oppressors. To reinforce this, she brings about many ideas. One is the “universality of desire” and how that is something we can all relate to and is in fact the basis of most liberal movements but in this case if often discounted. Another is the identity and purpose of the veil in Islam and the Arab world, which has had an increased prevalence in Egypt today. Some argue that the basis for this is functional. Others argue that it is a silent protest to the Western-liberal ideals that occupy much of the discourse in society today. However, the actual participants motivations – or as Mahmood suggests, the “real motivations” -are hardly ever mentioned. These “instruments of oppression” are also seen in other pieces we’ve studied. One where the veil also is utilized and its motivations are questioned is in “The Battle of Algiers” where women militants used the veil, a symbol of their national identity, as a front to hide the bombs and guns…

    • 403 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays