Preview

Specter And Gawande

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
595 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Specter And Gawande
Together Specter and Gawande both touch upon science, journalism and public policies in their own style. Gawande writes about science that has already been proven to be beneficial but slow at implementation. Antisepsis, anesthesia, kangaroo care and oral rehydration were all researched, experimented and proven to be the best solution for each pressing problem. Although people doubted the actual use of each treatment, they could not argue with scientific facts of benefits. On the contrary, Specter writes about science that is still in the process of research and experiment. The new and upcoming idea is gene rewriting with CRISPR is still a topic that fully researched and proven to be beneficial; many people still even fear it’s use. The unknown …show more content…
If the people who purchase and read The New Yorker were truly uninterested by articles that do not contain the presence of an individual, the editors and the executives of the company would not have published Gawande’s essay in it 88 years after the first issue debuted. The final topic both Specter and Gawande touch upon is public policy. Specter writes about public policies which do not exist yet but are on the verge of existing. As CRISPR becomes more precise, human testing is becoming a reality and with this reality comes policies that need to be enacted to ensure the safety of society. Whereas Gawande is questioning why indivuals don’t follow public policies enacted to ensure the safety of society. Even with public policies, society cannot be deemed safe from dangers associated with gene rewriting unless every person follows the them. Researchers and law makers must first know why people do not follow policies to ensure they are creating policies that will be follow. Specter and Gawande speak to each topic, science, journalism and public policy in their own way but each is also interconnected by the fact that they both share the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Copeland reveals logos--knowledge and reason--within the text by word choice and tone. “In 2014, 23andMe estimated that 7,000 users of its service had discovered unexpected paternity or previously-unknown siblings — a relatively small fraction of overall users” (Copeland), uses statistics to reason with the reader while also using word choice to create a professional tone. Copeland’s tone makes the article more rational and her, as the writer, seem more qualified. This also appeals to logos by using statistics to convince the reader that DNA testing is a revolutionary new technique to learn more about family lineage.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author, Yann Joly, supports their argument against legislation to protect genetic rights with three main points. The first point that the article mentions is that genetic discrimination cannot be “accurately described as a widespread practice within the life-insurance industry.” The author supports this with the fact that the practice of genetic discrimination has been found only in the context of Huntington’s disease, this being discovered after more than twenty years of trying to document genetic discrimination. The author also argues that “separating genetic information from other types of health information in law could promote the erroneous belief that most genes are the sole causes of disease.” In the opinion of the author, this could promote the…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although the article is written for a magazine, it doesn’t have a specific author, which makes it less reliable. Seed magazine does an exceptional job of stating the claim, and backing it up with fitting evidence to further support the stance. The article deals with topics that affect the readers, and can shed a light to someone undergoing the same issue. By discussing familiar subject matters, the readers are engaged. I strongly believe we should broadcast the piece because these same readers will read it eagerly. I am an advocate for the publication of this article and commend the newspaper for including this piece in The…

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Crake presents an example of what happens when the relentless pursuit of science and technology overrides ethical and humanistic concerns. He creates a group of people called “Crakers,” genetically engineered humans who are programmed to worship him as a deity. Later, seduced by his own genius, he creates a lethal genetic pandemic and uses it to kill off the majority of humanity. The result of Crake’s sadistic experiments? Genetic engineering gone completely, utterly…

    • 74 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Tierney is a well-qualified journalist spending his whole life involved in this field. He studied and graduated from Yale and began as a newspaper reporter for four years, then transitioned as a magazine writer for popular publications like, Discover, Esquire, National Geographic Traveler, and, Rolling Stone. He has since been with The New York Times for twenty-seven years writing in their Sciences and Findings columns. The audience of The New…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tuskegee Research Problem

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages

    As the research subject voluntarily or involuntarily enters into the unknown, the doctor must follow in their footsteps, embracing fear and inaccuracy before anything else. Scientific research can be risky for all, but if it is successful, it could mean justice for millions. Not only do the doctors and subjects tip-toe into the void, but the whole world follows behind to watch them fall, get back up -or fail. Scientific research is a tool that can be used to create strength and reliability for the future. As hills are climbed, crests are reached and bigger hills are waiting in the presence, research is present for ranges of world problems. Scientific research can offer a solution to world problems that are both social and medical, thus…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cited: Ofri, Danielle. “Common Ground.” The Best Of The Best American Science Writing. Ed. Jesse Cohen. HarperCollins: New York City, 2010. 115-125. Print.…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As the Dalai Lama said, “The rapid increase in human knowledge and the technological possibilities emerging in the new genetic science are such that it is now almost impossible for ethical thinking to keep pace with these changes” (Dalai Lama 133). Society needs to be able to be reasonable about the use of a new technology if it the ethics surrounding it is not right. There needs to always be an emphasis placed on the problems that theses technology bring in order to prevent a person ’s right from being taken away from them due to that technology. This requires that here is always reason-forcing conversation when the use of a new technology is being…

    • 1693 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    One’s health and any persons whose health they are responsible for, say their child, should be regarded as their most important priority. Doctors are the only people qualified to tell us how we should up keep that health and have earned that right through years of extensive schooling and research. Oddly though, doctors are not the individuals who write most of our headlined articles on medicine. These articles are written by medical journalists, politicians, and celebrities whose opinions, personal motives, and sources go unchecked and unquestioned by the general public. Educated reporters realize the public may take their words to heart and responsibly report on the event or issue in a factual manner. Other writers who are either uneducated or blinded by their ulterior motives report in ways that can confuse and misinform the public. Due to the populations devote faith in the media, if an issue of health is being reported on, whoever is responsible for writing and/or publishing said media, since they cannot be censored, must be held liable for any injury individuals sustain by listening to their advice. Two articles pertaining to the cause of autism in children will show the differences between educated and unsupported reporting and how poor reporting can leave the public at risk and no one to blame.…

    • 1215 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Largent addresses how the amount of trust the public places on researchers and program runners in the vaccine industry determines the success of immunizing children (136). Largent comments on the previously mentioned Jenny McCarthy, famous for her time as a comedian and model, whose advocacy of the anti-vaccination movement has “Solidified her position in the community of parents of autistic children, and further publicized her assertion that vaccines are one of the principal causes of autism,” (145). Although she is not medically qualified to speak on the topic, she is trusted and influential enough to spread the fear of vaccinations to parents all over America. Furthermore McCarthy, just as countless other authoritative figures in the media, blatantly disregarding the reliable scientific data proving her assertions incorrect (147). Adam Burgess compares the concept of McCarthyism, action of accusing someone or something without any evidence, to the behavior of figures in media such as Jenny McCarthy, as an “alarmist authority encouraging mass anxiety,” (334). Celebrities' influence dominates discourse online as well. While the internet's ability to spread information faster than anything else has always worried scientists, several analyzes show that despite the abundance of…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Human Genetic Engineering

    • 1495 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The ability to genetically engineer and modify our children before birth is now a reality. Genetic Modification is a new science that has created significant controversy for the human race. If genetic modification becomes a common practice without any legal restrictions, our world as we know it would completely change. With this unfathomable practice, our world is now open to an array of opportunities. Scientists can now prevent certain medical conditions passed down to children. The economic advantages that could be generated from this industry are huge. Even though there are advantages to genetic engineering, there are many disadvantages that will outweigh everything else. Richard Hayes, the executive director of the Center for Genetics and Society, talks about the major problems with genetic modification in his essay called “Supersize you Child?”. Hayes makes a very good and agreeable argument about the severe consequences of this scientific discovery. Genetic modification, if not restrained by strict regulations and limits, will be accompanied by detrimental consequences to the human race in social, biological, and economic ways. There is lots of evidence and many reasons to why this claims is true.…

    • 1495 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    On ABC’s Private Practice, one of the main characters, a pediatrician, began treating a child showing symptoms of the common cold, which later appeared to be the mumps. When the doctor offers the vaccine as the form of treatment, the mother refuses, as she noticed her middle child “acquired” Autism shortly after being vaccinated. When the youngest son also develops the mumps, the oldest son’s health begins to deteriorate, simultaneously, which leads to his death. At that moment, the pediatrician administers the youngest child with the vaccine, against the mother’s wishes, to save his life (Entertainment, 2009). Through the use of television as a medium to present the concerns present in this controversy, viewers saw a “digestible” breakdown of both perspectives. However, some may argue that the show overdramatized the issue, while focusing on the issue on an individual level rather than on a “big picture” one. However, the major question is whether this an example of fear mongering or an unbiased testament of the debate? Despite this answer, the media still is the easiest, most accessible form of receiving data on an infinite array of issues. Therefore, another question I would like to look at this semester is, how does the media, in its many mediums, use fear mongering,…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The presentation of ‘Bad Science’ gives the reader a seemingly accurate representation of its contents; the shape and size of a fulfilling novel, emphasising its entertainment value, and the cover which is bright red in colour symbolising fierce fiery danger, adorns an explosion from a medicine bottle of ‘Hacks, Quacks and Uncomfortable Facts’. This expresses the nature of the book, with the contents being a fiercely passionate argument against…

    • 1879 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    It follows that employment of mass media to disseminate health news (or other matters) has, in effect, reduced the world's size. The value of health news is related to what gets reported and how it gets reported. According to Ray Moynihan and colleagues:…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Shaha, A. (2008). Why is science important? Retrieved November 28, 2012, from Why Science?: www.whyscience.co.uk…

    • 1786 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Best Essays