Preview

St. Lucy's And Indian Boarding School Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
766 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
St. Lucy's And Indian Boarding School Analysis
“The view of boarding school life constructed from their words portrays how an institution founded to transform Indian youth was paradoxically given life by the very people whose tribal identities it was committed to erase” (eBook). So therefore, In the late 1800s, Native Americans were abducted from their homes by the government to attend assimilation schools, likewise, the wolf girls from “St. Lucy’s home for girls,” were sent to an assimilation school. Once the Indians and wolf girls came upon the institution, they were forced to adapt; wearing a new wardrobe, new haircuts, new language, and all together a new culture. Throughout the years, the kids struggled primarily to homesickness, it may have been months to years before the kids saw …show more content…
Lucy’s and Indian Boarding schools affected the students dramatically, with facing a great deal of …show more content…
Lucy’s and the Indian schools strained greatly; with tears and anxiety, the difficulty was dominating in this process. The procedure for the Indians to assimilate into the American culture was so troubling, one word from their native language left them crippled on the ground. The Native Americans were beaten with leather belts, punished severely (PBS). Many Indian students tried to escape the Institution, but were caught and brought back to the school (PBS). Afterwards, the boy or girl’s ankles and wrist were tied and he or she was forced to stand in the hallway; therefore if he or she fell the teacher would apprehend their fall, come out and lash them with a whip, then constrain them to stand again (Carolyn Marr). After a long day the kids had no warm, welcoming home to go back to and no family. It may have been months to years before they saw their parents again (Dr. C. Blue Clark). With constant abuse, attempts to freedom that came with more punishment, and feeling alone effected the students mentally and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Indian Squaw Summary

    • 188 Words
    • 1 Page

    When Anna Woodward and Josiah Flint lived in Steuben County, New York, it wasn’t unusual for Indians to stop by the cabin to trade. One day an Indian squaw with her papoose strapped to a board came to trade baskets for bread. When finished, they started down the path. They were scarcely out of sight when Anna heard a piercing scream and ran to see what was wrong.…

    • 188 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    For Ed, the residential school experience was meant to obliterate his Cree way of life. When he first arrives at St. Anne’s, he comments on his first greeting: “Long hair ad been illegal since before I was born… I remembered by grandmother saying our hair is a sign of our strength.” (Metatawabin, 39). The cutting of hair symbolizes a loss of Aboriginal culture. THe result of his loss of value structure is the decline into chaos and disarray, later in his life susceptible to addiction as an alternative. Ed’s experience is not solely unique to him, but part of a broader system of abuse. His parallels the plight experienced by countless other Aboriginals across Canada. In “School Days: The Residential School Experience”, the author comments on the effects of abuse in the future, “...people who were abused as children remain prey to feelings of shame and fear, increased susceptibility to a range of diseases, and emotional distress.” (TRC, 44). It is clear how the lack of traditional identity causes one to seek a new value structure to act out (e.g. alcoholism or drug abuse). But an effect can become a cause, and the results of imbalances of power become sources. Alcohol abuse or emotional instability often When enough take place, these isolated, individual cases of adherence or condemnation of one’s group identity produce oppressive structures on higher levels of…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The only way Lacombe could get children to attend the school was to bribe parents with money, gifts, and presents. The schools were so awful children would hide when scouts came looking for new students. One of his schools was criticized for its harsh tactics and ended up being burnt to the ground along with one of the students. These facts make Lacombe look unappealing but with further research came a bigger picture. He admitted his schools were an “experiment in educating the Natives” but felt that the students needed to be educated and let several students suffer so that an outline could be set for future students.…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Zitkala Sa’s “The School Days of an Indian Girl”, Zitkala herself was ill-informed to the intentions of the white people. She ignored her mother’s wishes for her not to go to the assimilation school, and because of that, when she returned home her mother could see her “suffering” with being back in her Indian culture (Sa 1099). Zitkala’s newfound unfamiliarity with both her Native American and white culture caused her to be unhappy in either culture. Another case of ignorance leading to discontent was in Mary E. Wilkins Freeman’s “A New England Nun”. Joe Dagget spent “fourteen out of…fifteen years” of their engagement “in Australia, where he had gone to make his fortune” (Freeman 656). Dagget was selfish in his thinking that Louisa would be patiently waiting for him at home, still as in love with him as she was before. In fact, Louisa felt “consternation” when she first saw the man she was to marry (Freeman 657). The misinformation given in this case, led to the misery of two people, no longer in love, but who both felt they owed it to the other to continue on with the marriage. In all these cases, ignorance of the truth was the root of each character’s displeasure in their…

    • 1468 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the years of its operation, students suffered from physical, sexual, and emotional abuse at the hands of their teachers. Over the course of its history, many investigations by the Department of Indian Affairs and several other government organizations failed to successfully bring forth any change in the school. Even the death of two male students (in separate incidences) brought forth no change. The deaths of the boys were blamed on the “wild nature” (page 112) of the First Nations, and that they “hate confinement” (page 112). The book ends with blaming the church and government’s inability to effectively stop the mistreatment at residential schooling systems, which has ultimately lead to much suffering and long-lasting trauma in First Nation’s people and their…

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Métis Residential Schools

    • 2013 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The history of the Métis and Residential Schools is not new. For a century, the mutual lives of the Métis children were controlled by the missionaries and the Catholic Church, and became wrapped up in Federal Government policies. The Metis Residential School experience was similar to the Aboriginal one; that of social exclusion and mental and physical abuse. The procedures that were created for the Métis in Residential Schools harshly exposed how bureaucrats felt about the social order of the Métis’ station in the New Canada. The Residential Schools took part in creating a lower class structure for the Métis, which separated them even further from their First…

    • 2013 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Louise Erdrich 's poem "Indian Boarding School: The Runaways" reads like a short story of Native American children dreaming of past experiences in their quest to return home and their failure to do so. This particular poem is made up of three short poems that could stand on their own; however, they are joined together as one. The first stanza describes the path to freedom the children must take. The second stanza shows the reader where the children are caught and their return trip to the boarding school. The third stanza explores the punishments and memories the runaways must endure after their escapade.…

    • 1516 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the short essay “Civilize Them With A Stick” Mary Dog writes about her experiences in a catholic boarding school as a child. The white race in American had a goal to civilize or integrate the Native Americans to the whites norms and values starting in 1879. They were doing this so the Native Americans became apart of the dominant society, which then was the whites society in America. They took the Native American children from their homes and from their families and placed them into boarding schools. Thousands of children were forced to live in these boarding schools their whole adolescent years. The children were abused in these so-called “boarding schools”. Many Native Americans now compare this incident to the Nazi concentration camps during world war II. The children had very strict rules and schedules. Their schedule usually went as followed, “Six A.M., kneeling in church for an hour or so; seven o’ clock, breakfast; eight o’ clock, scrub the floor, peel spuds, make classes” (Dog 565). If the children didn’t listen or were to disobey any rules they would be swatted many times by the nuns with a wooden stick. Other times they were placed in a dark boarded up room while only being fed bread and water for a week. The children were only able to see their families for just 7 days out of the 365 in the year. Many children tried to run away from the boarding school, but ultimately were found and brought back and then immediately swatted with a wooden sticks. As children got bigger and older they had thoughts about fighting back. Mary Dog, the author was one to fight back and ended up hitting one of her priests in the face after she tried to stand up for one of her fellow classmates. She was soon kicked out. The priest she hit ended up later realizing how bad the boarding school was treating the Native Americans and started standing up for them. Mary Dog wrote this…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Laura Ingalls Wilder

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The close-knit Ingall’s family survived the blizzards, prairie fires, grasshopper plagues, and illness of pioneer life. Laura and her sisters attended school whenever possible; any other time they were home-schooled by there mother, who was a previous school teacher. The Ingall’s girls enjoyed books, reading, and their father’s violin music.…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Impressions of an Indian Childhood and The School Days of an Indian Girl What is Gertrude Bonnin complaining about? Is she even complaining? She got to go to school and get an education for free. She even went on to go to college. Very few white Americans could say that in those days, much less Native Americans. Even today a free ride through college is a rare occurrence. Of course she experienced a few hardships along the way. Learning a new language was definitely a challenge for her in the beginning, although one she overcame quite well (after all, she did win an oratorical contest at her college). Living by the rules of a different culture was another challenge for her. But she eventually became accustomed to the new ways and she learned how to adjust. And of course she went through many years of discrimination and persecution, simply because of the fact that she is a Native American. But in the long run, wall the challenges she overcame helped to improve herself as an individual and as a representative of a culture. We must all go through hard times and face many difficult challenges in our lives if we want to make a better life for ourselves. As long as there are different races, racism will always exist. People like Gertrude Bonnin who can overcome racism and discrimination by succeeding in the "white man's world," are the people who help others like them be accepted in our…

    • 249 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his book, Privilege: The Making of an Adolescent Elite at St. Paul’s School, Shamus Khan provides an ethnographic perspective to the world of elite boarding schools through his experience both as a student and as a full-time faculty member at St. Paul’s School. To preface the book, Khan reflects on his experience at St. Paul’s as a teenager– specifically the factors that led to his enrollment as well as his experience as a minority in the community. A product of two immigrant parents, one from South Asia and the other from Ireland, Khan was provided unique experiences amongst the traditionally WASP students matriculating at St. Paul’s. Because his parents had to perform a “cultural catch-up,” as well as being physically identifiable as non-white,…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Indian Boarding School

    • 601 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Louise Erdrich's poem Indian Boarding School puts the emotions of a person or group of people in a setting around a railroad track. The feelings experienced are compared to things from the setting, which takes on human characteristics. The boarding school may have been a real place she went to, or where mistreatment of her people was not uncommon, or it could simply be a tool she used to express racism towards them in general. With that fact, the reader must remember that although the words are from the runaways' point of view, there are not necessarily any real runaways.…

    • 601 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Karen Russell’s short story, “St. Lucy’s Home for Girls Raised by Wolves”, she develops the progression of the characters in relation to The Jesuit Handbook on Lycanthropic Culture Shock. The characters, young girls raised as if they were wolves, are compared to the handbook with optimism that they will adapt to the host culture. The girls’ progression in the five set stages are critical to their development at St. Lucy’s. The author compares Claudette, the narrator, to the clear expectations the handbook sets for the girls’ development. Claudette’s actions align well with the five stages, but she has outbursts that remind her of her former self.…

    • 1892 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Best Essays

    Historically, Native American tribes have struggled to keep their unique culture identities. This is largely due to the actions made by the federal and state governments as a result of ethnocentrism and indifference. In order to maintain cultural identity, generational traditions must continue from parents to their children and their children’s children. It is the very essence of how culture lives on in families and generations (Basic, 2004). From the time of the 1800’s, the Boarding School Movement, backed by the Federal Government, began the attempted cultural annihilation of the Native…

    • 3653 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    The quandary about training in Albert Mission School isn't just the statement of the amazingness of British culture, yet in addition the aloofness of the typescript who should speak to the indigenous culture. Narayan…

    • 1636 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays