Summary: Hiring Illegal Immigrant Workers
Solving illegal immigration is by no means a small feat. It can be a very sensitive topic for many people from both the US and Mexico. The Bush Administration has developed the guest worker program. The guest worker program grants temporary legal status for a foreigner, allowing he or she to work. A great deal of difficulty lies in creating a plan than is a win-win scenario for both countries' citizens. To completely open our borders to all immigrants can pose great threat not only to America's safety but to the economy as well. Then again, to close them entirely would be a very unpopular solution for most in addition to a possible negative economic ripple.
Bush's program is designed to match willing immigrant workers with willing American …show more content…
employers when there aren't any American employees to be found. Part of the idea is to have current illegal workers come out from hiding and become legal while in America. The legal status will entitle them to civil rights that were previously not granted. An example of some basic rights would include labor laws, the right to change jobs, fair wages, and a healthy work environment. All these everyday rights that we as US citizens sometimes take for granted would be available to a foreign worker under the proposed program. If current illegal workers choose to act on this program, the Bush administration hopes this could deter future illegal crossing into the US. With the guest worker program as an option it may be more attractive to legally work in the US without the constant worry of being deported.
Many illegal workers are sought after by our country's agriculture industry.
Farmers usually find it easier to hire cheap illegal immigrant labor. This type of labor can be physically exhausting and is often found undesirable to many Americans. In addition, the work involved usually does not require any professional trade skills or more than an elementary school level of …show more content…
education.
This is an extremely controversial debate, some argue that illegal workers are needed in order to keep food prices reasonable and for farmers to earn a decent living.
While on the other side of the argument, it is believed that if farmers were to collectively stop hiring illegal workers and pay an appropriate wage they would find Americans willing to fill the position. Currently many farmers complain that they have little choice but to hire illegal workers just so they can compete with others who are taking advantage of cheap illegal labor. So many farmers feel that by not utilizing illegal workers they are simply shooting themselves in the foot. To hire an American would mean immediate loss of profit due to the increase in wage required to attract most legal citizens. Others say that the majority of Americans refuse to perform hard manual labor and this is why farmers are forced to seek employees elsewhere. This is a stereotype that may hold true for some but has not been shown to hold for most. Of course most Americans may not want their lifelong career to be picking strawberries on a farm with no real chance for progression in terms of salary or position. But then again this type of labor would be ideal for young adults looking to earn money to put themselves through school or even as a summer job. As mentioned earlier, low skill and minimal education is needed to perform the work required by most farms. It would be unlikely to under qualified and sure the work may be
difficult but that is why the young would fit. Many young adults are willing to perform manual labor but with illegal workers offering their services at much lower cost to employers it is virtually impossible to entice youngsters. Like the saying goes "work smarter, not harder"; why work for minimum wage at a farm when one can earn nearly double at local retail stores such as Home Depot, Sears or Circuit City just to name a few?
My sources . . . http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2004/01/20040107-1.html http://immigration.about.com/od/laborjobissues/i/GuestWorkrIssue_2.htm
http://www.commondreams.org/archive/2007/05/22/1364/
Bush's program is designed to match willing immigrant workers with willing American …show more content…
employers when there aren't any American employees to be found. Part of the idea is to have current illegal workers come out from hiding and become legal while in America. The legal status will entitle them to civil rights that were previously not granted. An example of some basic rights would include labor laws, the right to change jobs, fair wages, and a healthy work environment. All these everyday rights that we as US citizens sometimes take for granted would be available to a foreign worker under the proposed program. If current illegal workers choose to act on this program, the Bush administration hopes this could deter future illegal crossing into the US. With the guest worker program as an option it may be more attractive to legally work in the US without the constant worry of being deported.
Many illegal workers are sought after by our country's agriculture industry.
Farmers usually find it easier to hire cheap illegal immigrant labor. This type of labor can be physically exhausting and is often found undesirable to many Americans. In addition, the work involved usually does not require any professional trade skills or more than an elementary school level of …show more content…
education.
This is an extremely controversial debate, some argue that illegal workers are needed in order to keep food prices reasonable and for farmers to earn a decent living.
While on the other side of the argument, it is believed that if farmers were to collectively stop hiring illegal workers and pay an appropriate wage they would find Americans willing to fill the position. Currently many farmers complain that they have little choice but to hire illegal workers just so they can compete with others who are taking advantage of cheap illegal labor. So many farmers feel that by not utilizing illegal workers they are simply shooting themselves in the foot. To hire an American would mean immediate loss of profit due to the increase in wage required to attract most legal citizens. Others say that the majority of Americans refuse to perform hard manual labor and this is why farmers are forced to seek employees elsewhere. This is a stereotype that may hold true for some but has not been shown to hold for most. Of course most Americans may not want their lifelong career to be picking strawberries on a farm with no real chance for progression in terms of salary or position. But then again this type of labor would be ideal for young adults looking to earn money to put themselves through school or even as a summer job. As mentioned earlier, low skill and minimal education is needed to perform the work required by most farms. It would be unlikely to under qualified and sure the work may be
difficult but that is why the young would fit. Many young adults are willing to perform manual labor but with illegal workers offering their services at much lower cost to employers it is virtually impossible to entice youngsters. Like the saying goes "work smarter, not harder"; why work for minimum wage at a farm when one can earn nearly double at local retail stores such as Home Depot, Sears or Circuit City just to name a few?
My sources . . . http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2004/01/20040107-1.html http://immigration.about.com/od/laborjobissues/i/GuestWorkrIssue_2.htm
http://www.commondreams.org/archive/2007/05/22/1364/