Preview

Summary Of Pay For The Party By Armstrong And Hamilton

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1144 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Summary Of Pay For The Party By Armstrong And Hamilton
On their ethnography account, Paying for the Party, Elizabeth Armstrong and Laura Hamilton draws us our attention to MU, a Midwestern public university, where they recount the stories of women adapting to college life. Drawing on their findings from their five -year study, the authors demonstrate how universities and students reproduce social inequalities by affecting not only the large-scale interactions of college campuses, but also the social interactions among students. Thus, in their book, Armstrong and Hamilton highlights how social inequality is reproduced by discussing the university's commitment to organizational imperatives, the social interactions among students and by comparing these with other disadvantage women.
In their book,
…show more content…
For example, Armstrong and Hamilton claim that with the decreased of financial aid and the disengagement from individuals to equity topics, many universities have replaced low- income students with more affluent, yet unqualified individuals. Even though, Armstrong and Hamilton argues that educating low- income students would fulfill the university’s compromise to equity, they mention, however, that admitting these students is hard for the university, as its too costly and resource demanding. Thus, in order to solve their solvency issues, the universities choose between individuals who are unqualified, but can pay their tuition over qualified low- income students. That said, these organizational imperatives, such as solvency creates social inequality because it forces the university to accept students based on their affluent backgrounds, while forcing them, at the same time to refuse the entry of talented, yet impoverished individuals. Therefore, the universities’ commitment to organizational imperatives enhances social inequality because it rewards and reproduces the social advantages of students who are already mobile in the system, while excluding those who are …show more content…
Correspondingly, socially ambitious women performed symbolic boundaries when they seek to disengage, reduce contact and dissociate from people of low status. For example, Armstrong and Hamilton claims that many socially affluent women would avoid encountering the social isolates in order to set a higher rank for themselves. According to the authors, this in turn affected the social isolates whom experienced many academic, social and clinical repercussions. For example, Armstrong and Hamilton argues that since social isolates were alienated by their peers, they lack the social capital or the social networks to connect with other people. Especially at a university, having social capital is important because it’s an established conduit for information. For instance, people can not only learn about exciting majors and career opportunities, but can also discuss and elaborate on class materials with their friends. Therefore, since the social isolates lacked this social connection, many were prone to experience academic probation, depression and alcohol and drug abuse. Finally, all social isolates were at risk for leaving MU. That said, the exclusion of social isolates demonstrates social inequality because the women who were excluded were those who mainly lacked the social and cultural capital of the elites. Eventually, as a

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Yet in “Battle Over Merit”, Young describes this as “equality of opportunity to be unequal” (Karabel 556). Even though exceptional individuals from these groups can be accepted, the requirements for acceptance still favor those who have been traditionally accepted. Admitting just a few students from lower socioeconomic backgrounds allows the privilege to relax and think that their success is just reward for their own capacity, for their own efforts, and for their undeniable achievement” and people from lower socioeconomic backgrounds to think “that they have had every chance and have little choice but to recognize their inferior status is due not as in the past to a denial of opportunity, but to their own deficiencies” (Karabel 556). What adds to the façade of equal opportunity is that prestigious institutions are so competitive that it is less likely for a…

    • 1663 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mr. Burd argues that the federal government is not doing enough to help working-class college-goers pay for school. He plays up the argument that working class college- goers are being punished for being nontraditional while downplaying the argument that “standards for admission” are a necessary component of higher learning.…

    • 399 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Economic inequality is more relevant than ever. Smart kids are not able to get the education they deserve simply because of their parents income. High school students that live in a poor area don’t have quality public schools to go to, while the kids in a wealthy area have better schools. This inequality is seen in college as a huge problem because kids who are geniuses cant go to college due to them not being able to afford it. Two authors of two different articles discuss these issues, which are “Why Education Is Not an Economic Panacea” by John Marsh and “For Poor, Leap to College Often Ends in a Hard Fall” by Jason DeParle. Both Authors attempt to persuade his audience, but one is more successful than the other. Jason DeParle is more effective in accomplishing his persuasive purpose of making the reader believe economic gap is growing due to him using more evidence to support his point, discussing where the beginning of economic inequality starts, and having a heart breaking college story that people can relate to more.…

    • 943 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author reflects on specific instances relevant to him as well as people who have shared similar experiences. He then goes on to make broader generalizations based off of the collected data. For example, in all the anecdotes, the student breaks a strong connection with either their family, peer, or loved one due to the expansion of knowledge they were exposed to. Lubrano makes the point that while college kids are off formulating their own views, their close ones are at home unable to break the mob mentality and “shared opinions” that thrives within the working class (535). Hence the change of views between family and student also thrusts the student into a state of isolation in which they become a pariah. Is this always what happens to families when a child pursues what they consider to be in their best interests? Probably not, but based on Lubrano’s use of inductive reasoning it’s likely to be the most common…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Social Location In Haiti

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Question 1: In sociology, social location is a key component of how they determine your identification towards society. Social location is something you can’t necessary choose it’s based on race, gender, class, where you live, ability, age. Also with social location we know there level of power they have when it comes down to their society. Social location groups compare you to the other people’s social location all over the world. (Who gets to graduate, pg. 3) In the article, Vanessa is having an issue to get into her dream school due to social location, she may have the grades, but unfortunately cause of her social class. Her dream cannot come true. Yet, someone who comes from a higher class wouldn’t experience that issue. They might not even have a GPA that is above average, but because of their social class they get better opportunities.…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Social Class Framework

    • 174 Words
    • 1 Page

    Individuals are altogether raised in an unexpected way, socially influenced in an unexpected way, and advantaged in various ways. A nearer association with guardians or family may prompt more esteems including adoration and support, while an existence lived all the more alone and rashly may prompt esteeming cash and medications. The encompassing condition impacts how a man winds up seeing the world outside of their heads. It can now and then laud a certain something and reject that same thing in the meantime. The social class framework creates levels of energy and gives a mainstream definition to each level.…

    • 174 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Making college more affordable is “expanding access to higher education for every American without the burden of debt or financial hardship” which would include “incentivizing states to reinvest in community colleges” as well as “expanding federal investment in students” which is crucial in addressing America’s debt crisis (Hudson). As a result of the program, anyone from any socioeconomic class will have an equal opportunity to obtain a higher education and students would be more motivated to attend college aware that they will not accumulate tremendous debt while attending school. To aid in the growth of the universal community college education program, colleges will bring “more affluent students to community colleges, helping to make the schools more socio-economically diverse, and perhaps convincing legislators to fund them more generously” (Weissman). By having a more diverse school, the college will obtain more funding and recognition from the state. In recent studies, a diverse college is more likely to be academically successful because of the exposure to different groups enhances creative thinking, enhances social behavior, and increases the knowledge by giving different perspectives from different people. Regardless of social economic class, anyone will have an equal opportunity to a higher education by making college…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This is why Affirmative Action is so important but needs to be changed for economic classes. “He found that the most selective schools, instead of affirmative action, began using socioeconomic preferences, including family income and whether students were the first in their family to go to college. And in doing so, about 20 percent of the loss in minority admissions rates at Berkeley and 30 percent at UCLA were offset by changes in the admissions process” (Camera). This information proves that we can start making changes to the Affirmative Action plan to give people who are the first generation college students a better chance of getting in, impacting poverty as a whole for all races.…

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some of the stakeholders impacted by issues of cost and access include students, faculty and staff, local communities, and institutional administrators. Low-income students have a more difficult time in college (Berg, 2010). Berg writes, “the intense personal development that all colleges students go through in their lives is made especially hard for students from low-income backgrounds because they have been judged by society as coming from a community of underachievement and even immorality” (pg. 67). Knowing that the development period of their collegiate experience will be more challenging, these students have high stakes in how institutions are prepared, or not, to support them. If institutions do not have adequate support available for…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In this way, it was “strange not to be a student in this area,” as it defies the expectations of society as well as those of the students for the area (Perdue 5). What made those who were not students seem strange then, was not just the fact that they were not a student, but the fact that they also call into…

    • 1835 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    As I attend my local college fair, I observe my surroundings, noticing that I do not recognize many other students of my ethnicity. I feel as if I may be shooting too far into the stars, thinking that no one like me can ever attend such a top tier institution like the ones that I am visiting today. The tuitions are insanely higher than average, and coming from a low-income family, I wonder how I will ever get to start my future stress free? I am not the only one with these thoughts, for there are many young minorities across the nation who wonder the same thing. Furthermore, universities and higher education institutions across the nation target students from low-income families, or minorities, into not attending while students with high-income…

    • 1364 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Is a social life more important than a person’s own life? Many students become devoted…

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Education

    • 32863 Words
    • 132 Pages

    Stephan, Jennifer L., James E. Rosenbaum and Anne E. Person. (2009). “Stratification in College Entry and Completion.” Social Science Research. 38:572-593. Swail, Watson S. (2009). “Graduating At-Risk Students: A Cross-Sector Analysis.” Imagine America Foundation. USA Today, http://www.usatoday.com/news/education/2010-06-08-IHE-for-profit-collegesetextbooks09_ST_N.htm U. S. Census Bureau. All Across the USA: Population Distribution and Composition. 2000. _____ . Current Population Survey. U.S. Department of Education, Federal Student Aid, Grant Programs Fact Sheet. _____ . Federal Student Aid Programs Stafford Loans. U.S. General Accounting Office. (1996). “Higher Education: Ensuring Quality Education From Proprietary Institutions http://www.gao.gov/archive/1996/he96158t.pdf.” U.S. National Center for Education Statistics. U. S. Senate, Health Education, Labor and Pensions Committee “Emerging Risk?: An Overview of Growth, Spending, Student Debt and Unanswered Questions in For-Profit Higher Education.” 2010. Welch, Finis. (1974). Relationships Between Income and Schooling. Review of Research in Education 2: 179-201. Yilmazer, Tansel and Sharan A. DeVaney. (2005). Household Debt Over the Life Cycle. Financial Services Review 14: 285-304.…

    • 32863 Words
    • 132 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Myths In Education

    • 1541 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Education has been part of history with the function to serve as an intrinsically valuable asset. The youth is constantly being told that education is the key to success. However, some are being “excluded from the pond” based on socioeconomic status and race. In College At Risk, Andrew Delbanco, notes that American higher education was built on the premise that human capital is widely distributed among social classes. Selective nonprofit colleges are failing to enroll significant numbers of students from low-income families. They are reinforcing the discrepancies of wealth and opportunity in American…

    • 1541 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    College: Who Pays?

    • 1982 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Many students in America enter college with the primary goal of obtaining a pre-professional credential; which implies a fighting chance in the current job market. A college education in America has become synonymous with a flourishing middle-class and thus a stable economy. Ironically, the current state of the economy and America’s system of higher education are seemingly at odds; the economy, in its current state, hinders the growth of higher education as it pertains to equality and availability to all. This means that the scarce availability of funds for higher education make it impossible for there to be equal access to higher education in America. The American system of higher education, unable to accommodate the needs of students from lower socioeconomic backgrounds, perpetuates inequality in society and creates a system that sustains the wealth of Americas most privileged, while limiting the prospects of the former. This means that for a growing majority of the population, opportunities to pursue higher education are becoming increasingly narrow; and the goal and implications of obtaining a pre- professional credential are seen as risky. The pursuit of higher education can be seen as risky for low- income students because of low graduation rates and high accumulations of debt which are a result of the deficiency of government funding for grant programs and public institutions of higher education. Students from low-income families with aspirations to pursue higher education are at a huge disadvantage both financially and educationally and are faced with these realities when making the decision to actually attend college; and more often than not, these realities are the basis for decisions not to attend. The exclusion of this group of people, whether self-inflicted or institutionalized, is a regression back to the exclusionary history of higher education in America. This regression will potentially…

    • 1982 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays