Preview

Summary Of The Systemic Silencing Of Survivors By Goldie Taylor

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
357 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Summary Of The Systemic Silencing Of Survivors By Goldie Taylor
In Goldie Taylor’s piece, she noted an important concept in her experience: the systemic silencing of survivors. Our culture has denied her voice and that of other survivors, making them fearful of judgement or that it is their fault. The rape culture that has been created in our society makes it difficult for any person to come forward because we silence the survivor and culturally accept the actions of the perpetrator. The first thing that Taylor did that many survivors do is question how her identity and the identity of her perpetrator will affect how people believe her. She notes her identity as a black woman, and he as a white older man, a coach assured to be respected in their community. This idea has been engrained in her that women

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Shari Davies was once a carefree, optimistic young woman. This all changed one night twenty years ago, giving way to an unexpected course of injury, pain, fear, and anger. On November 5, 1986, Shari was abducted, raped, and almost killed (Davies, 1997, pp. 3-4). Rape is a very horrible crime that affects its victims both physically and psychologically, and these affects can last for years (Cooper, 2004). Shari even admits in the book that she still experiences grief, pain and confusion and shares that elements of these emotions will never leave her and her family (Davies, 1997, p 3). How family, friends, and authorities react to a victim has a major impact on how she will deal with the pain and heal. Rape victims who feel ignored or treated negatively may encounter what is known as secondary victimization. When police and other legal and medical providers put the needs of their agencies in front of the needs and psychological boundaries of the victim, victims often feel violated. The disregard of victims' needs by providers can so closely mimic victims' experiences at the hands of their assailants that secondary victimization is sometimes referred to as "the second rape" or the "second assault" (Schultz, 1999). Two sources of frustration and pain to Shari and her family were the police and the media. In this paper I will share how I interpreted Shari to be treated by these entities during her recovery process and the possible implications of such treatment. I will also delve into the issue of the scarcity of resources that Shari and her family encountered and how this has changed both in Australia and the United States.…

    • 1680 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Krakauer shows examples of that in Missoula when the women in the cases talk about how they are afraid to report their perpetrators. In the author’s note of Missoula, Krakauer talked about a survey conducted by the CDC in 2011. He shortly afterwards states that “19.3 percent of American women “have been raped in their lifetimes” and that 1.6 percent of American women-- nearly two and a half million individuals-- “reported that they were raped in the 12 months preceding the survey.” Maybe women are afraid they will be slut shamed, or called a liar. Or in like Allison Huguette's case, maybe the guy was well liked and it would be hard for people to believe that he committed such a crime. All college students need to be aware of these issues. Regardless of why women aren’t reporting these crimes, Missoula sends out a message that rape should always be reported in order to prevent it from happening again. If every college student were required to read Missoula, they would know that rape is a real life issue that happens all the time, and they would know what to do if they ever found themselves in a rape related…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Often when racial inequality and discrimination is being discussed, we get to think of terms such as “white privilege” and American history with the Civil Rights Act in 1964. But we think of it, mainly as history. And that, according to Tim Wise, an anti-racism activist and American writer, is the biggest self-deception of the modern American world. Throughout an article posted on his own webpage, concerning school shootings, Tim Wise discusses the general American attitude towards this relatively new phenomenon in American society. With the use of especially pathos Wise argues that the most concerning thing about these events is how society is handling them afterwards. The problem is, according to Wise, that white people tell themselves ‘white lies’, and therefore never think that such actions could be taking place in their communities. He claims that there’s a reason why this happens in the outwardly ordinary societies. It’s because the people, trying to maintain at certain surface of innocence, refuse to see the signs of trouble, even when it’s going on before their very eyes.…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Susan Ruddick highlights this in, “Constructing Differences In Public Spaces”. This article highlights that race, class and gender are interlocking systems in public spaces. Ruddick depicts the aftermath Just Desserts robbery in 1994, with other racialized crimes as prime examples of race and gender attributing towards the negative implications black people endure on a daily basis. A microaggression that can be seen here are marginalized groups being easily stereotyped from criminal incidents because of national headlines and the victims being mostly white women. In the middle of the article, Ruddick’s note of the Central Park Five case brings out the point that in the media, there is an immediate favor towards the victims, who are predominantly white women. In discussing marginalized groups, it brings the fact that black men are perceived to be a “menace to society, (Ruddick, 9)”. Towards the end of the article, Ruddick analyzes and comes up with the conclusion that in terms of public spaces, the media creates a medium that brings out local and national images of racial ethnicities which can be “constructed and contested,” (Ruddick, 10). This final point highlights that from these criminal incidents, the national media has portrayed a negative image towards minority groups, especially men of color. This article serves as one of the main components of how minority groups are marginalized and how…

    • 1661 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to Burt (1980), rape myths are defined as ‘prejudicial, stereotype or false beliefs about rape, rape victims and rapists’ that serve as a kind of denial and justify male sexual aggression towards women. Burt (1980) identified the examples of rape myths such as 1) “she asked for it”; 2) “it wasn't really rape”; 3) “he didn't mean to”; 4) “she wanted it”; 5) “she liked it”; 6) “rape is a trivial event”; and 7) “rape is a deviant event”. Rape myths vary among societies and cultures(Burt 1980). Rape myths are also highly related to why the rape cases are under-reported (Grubb and Turner 2012). However, they consistently follow a pattern, which they blame the victim for their rape, express a disbelief in claims of rape, exonerate the perpetrator…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sociologist believes that observance of rape myths promote an abuse climate that blames the person who has been violated, excuses the person who performed the crime and blamed the victim (Belknap 2015:347). In my opinion, any act that allows a perpetrator to shift blame is creating a climate of acceptability. Most of the rape myths introduced in this chapter as reasons a person violates another human being are ridiculous. I believe that the regardless of how a person dresses they still have a right to decide who they will or will not be intimate with, so I void that myth, as a sad attempt to blame the victim.…

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After ten months of a horrible marriage, November 21, 2010 in a public parking, my so called husband was angry at me for getting into a terrible car accident. He began choking me, and put a knife to my neck, I do not remember exactly what I did but I did scream until the cops got there. I denied everything, so they let us go, and the police escorted me to my family’s house and I stayed there. As I look back at my denial, I can find similarities with the Congolese women. For example in page 164, when Lisa asks the women “how many of you have been raped?” a few hands go up then quickly retreat. These women won’t talk about sexual violence in public, I am exactly the same…

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Vision, By Dean Koontz

    • 1213 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The essay opened people up to having honest conversations about rape, instead of suppressing it. Katie J.M. Baker states that rape should not be discussed in a “vacuum.” She wants people to take the discussions past the vacuum, where it will be opened up to a new audience.…

    • 1213 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    When a major act of violence takes place, regardless of whether or not it has extensive media coverage, the people that witness or hear about it can sometimes identify and relate to either the victims or the perpetrators. In three different stories, acts of violence are all defining characteristics of how the general population react. The first story, “How To Tell A True War Story” by Tim O’Brien discusses the difficulties associated with trying to explain to people what being in war feels like when O’Brien tells a woman about brutal events that took place while he was serving in the Vietnam war. In the next story, “The Power of Context” by Malcolm Gladwell, he talks about crime on the New York subway system and preventative methods to lower the crime rates on the trains and subway platforms. One event in particular was about a man who shot four teenagers that had criminal records who were pestering the man when he got on the subway in the projects and was actually portrayed by many people in the community as a vigilante. The last story, “Losing Matt Shepard” by Beth Loffreda, the brutal and violent attack that eventually lead to the death of a homosexual student at the University of Wyoming named Matt Shepard that caused a media uproar, bringing attention to people on both sides of the spectrum, ranging from other LGBTQ community members to radical anti-homosexuality groups like the Westboro Baptist Church and other religious organizations. Different factors affect the way we do or do not identify with perpetrators and victims of violent acts in a variety of…

    • 1501 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In this trial, nine African American teenagers were unjustly accused of raping two white women on a train. Even though the evidence clearly showed otherwise, they were still convicted again and again by the many juries that they faced because of their skin color, showing once more the power of Jim Crow Racism. During the multiple trials that this case spanned, there were many individuals who showed courage. One such person was, ironically enough, Ruby Bates, one of the women that had accused the boys of raping her. Aside from adding to the fact that the teenagers were innocent, Ruby’s recantation of her story was also, on her part, a courageous one.…

    • 1584 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Because Popular culture depicts a “typical” rape as being perpetrated by “sick” or crazy men where the rape is a “sudden, violent attack by a stranger in a deserted, public space, after which the victim is expected to provide evidence of the attach and of her active resistance” (Williams, 1984). This stereotype script frames rapists as strangers and the literature refers to such a description as the “classic” rape scenario (Williams, 1994).…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Not only is violence more than just the easy to realize physical harm, it is also a major culprit in shaping and influencing identity and self-perception. In the “Selections from Hard to Get: Twenty-Something Women and the Paradox of Sexual Freedom,” the author, Leslie Bell, interviews several women asking about their sexual identities. In one instance Jayanthi, one of the women interviewed by Bell, discusses an act of violence that changed how she would sexually identify herself. In addition, in “The Power of Context,” the author, Malcolm Gladwell, talks about how the Goetz incident, in which Goetz shot four black teens in a New York City subway train, contributed and affected how New York City would deal with its crime epidemic. Furthermore,…

    • 1673 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    When the topic of rape and sexual assault comes up in conversation, many people truly feel a strong sense of empathy for the victim, yet many others criminalize the victim for how they themselves got into the assault. Why does our society continue to persecute a victim? For the only ones who should be questioning in this fashion, are those investigating the crime in of itself. Rape culture has become a natural part of our society and the largest part of this “culture,” is victim blaming. Yes, there are two sides to this issue, but whether the victim was truly raped or not, it does not matter for there needs to be a better balance for this issue. Whether it is to stop blaming the victim or how the victim can avoid becoming one in the first place.…

    • 1897 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sexual Violence Sociology

    • 1589 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Throughout this essay, sexual violence is a major theme. Sexual violence has changed over time, however it seems like certain aspects of sexual violence have been passed on and have worsen with time. Sexual violence is a topic that is discuss solely young women through different outlets, such as media, educations, personal relationships, and etc., however if forget that both men and women can be sexual assaulted. Sexual violence is a major issue on both college and universities campuses with young adults who have found their freedom and tend to think about the consequences that are to follow. Even though sexual violence solely focuses on women, society has shaped sexual violence through class and race, rape culture, and consent.…

    • 1589 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    She was raped repeatedly by each of these men and was threatened to be killed if she told anyone what happened. As soon as Taylor was kidnapped, her friends who witnessed the crime went to the local community to give a statement on her behalf. Even with the report, Taylor’s assault was not made a priority and, as a result, her story was not taken seriously. An African American man named Eugene Henderson questioned Governor Chauncey Sparks for the assault of Recy Taylor. In his statement, he asked: “Isn’t Negro womanhood as sacred as white womanhood?”…

    • 935 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays