Preview

Summary Of We The Public Place The Best Athletes On Pedestals

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
507 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Summary Of We The Public Place The Best Athletes On Pedestals
William Moller's article We, the Public, Place the Best Athletes on Pedestals is showing how easy it is to choose success over rules. It brings in specific examples of when he was in high school he had the option to either get an F on his test or take Ritalin to help him focus and pass the test. The author chose to take the drug along with breaking the rules and law. He compared this to baseball players, how once the players get offered steroids it's obvious they will take them. They all want to be the best and taking these performance enhancing drugs will help them get there. Within the article the fact that we, the people, know that this is going on yet we choose to ignore it until it is made public. Once it is made public we shun that athlete and look to his fellow teammates and how "pure" and "innocent" they are. We know the best athletes are on steroids yet we continue to praise them, put them on a pedestal, so to say. There are a few main points he hits on being that we encourage the athletes to be good but trash if we find out they weren't naturally good, the appeal for performance enhancing drugs is more alluring than you believe, and that we ignore what is painfully obvious for our own …show more content…
He proves this by talking about his personal experiences that related to the point that he was trying to prove. When using his own experience he connected it to the fact we encourage the athletes to be good but trash if we find out they weren't naturally good by the same way we look at grades; if he spends all night up on Ritalin studying for a history test that's the same as using steroids. The fact the Moller also used quotes within his article made it more believable. When Moller told the story if Bill Clinton and Obama smoking marijuana had given the people reading his article a higher likelihood to believe what was being

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Moller also states that, “The entire steroid outcry is pure hypocrisy” (Moller 548). He also goes on to talk about how we put these athletes on pedestals; however, I couldn’t disagree more. I don’t think everyone puts these people on pedestals. I also don’t believe we are to be blamed or thought of as the cause to their steroid use. These athletes, just like everyone else makes the decision on their own to use drugs.…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Use of anabolic steroids, like use of multi-vitamins, does not enable one to become a “Superathlete”. These drugs work, to the extent that they do, only when combined with hard work, dedication, persistence, and the exercise of other athletic virtues (Rosenthal, 2005). But if the nature of sports is that it is a competition to determine which athlete has developed his or her skills to the utmost, perhaps use of anabolic steroids frustrates such a determination, since the user/hard worker may have an unfair advantage over the mere hard worker (Quinn, 2005). Let's call this argument against the use of anabolic steroids the “Argument from Unfair Advantage”. The general form of this argument is the following: use of anabolic steroids gives the user an unfair advantage over non-users; therefore, use of them ought to be prohibited. A different reason to think that the premise is true is that, if use of anabolic steroids were allowed, athletes who would use them would have an advantage over those who would not. This might be true, but it does not itself tell us why that would be an unfair advantage. It is permissible in professional baseball for a pitcher to get daily massages in order to help his pitching arm muscles recover more quickly, and this pitcher has an advantage over another pitcher who, because of a lack of time, location or finances, cannot receive daily massages. But it is not clear why this fact alone means that the first athlete…

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the article “Kid on Steroids Willing to Risk It All for Success,” published on nbcnews.com, March 3, 2008, author Jacqueline Stenson, examines how professional athletes who are using steroids are having a strong influence on the younger generation to use steroids in order to help their performance and be able to fulfill their dreams of making the pros.…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The usage of steroids gives the user an unfair advantage over other athletes that have worked hard to gain muscle mass without using steroids. It is easy for someone to cheat and win. With steroids, you are tricking your body. You are creating something that is not you, and that is why you are cheating. It is estimated that as many as six million Americans have used or currently use steroids. It is unbelievable that somebody could somehow live more easily and more pleasantly because of chemicals. It is fine if someone is using steroids to recover from an injury so they can get back to work and behave like an ordinary person, but God forbid they should use anymore steroids than necessary and become unusually strong. That would be morally wrong. In the same way, it is fine if people use Prozac to feel normal, and it is fine if they use Xanax to calm down before giving a speech; as long as these drugs are used only for the point of functioning as a citizen. However, as soon as the person starts using Xanax for fun it becomes morally wrong. Athletes should be regulated closely because anabolic steroids are considered cheating. The use of these drugs violates the rules of all athletics. Anabolic steroids are traced far back in…

    • 2661 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He also thinks if he had to choose between using drugs or not, to boost his grades, he probably would. Moller feels that people expect too much of athletes. “Look, you and I both understand that the majority of the best players in baseball are steroid users.” (Moller and Birkenstein 548) When faced with the option of whether to do right and fail horribly or, to use drugs and have a great life; most people would use the drugs and cheat. Athletes have a choice of using drugs and becoming a legend, or not using them and risk being average or even worse, subpar.…

    • 1114 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine an athlete working their whole life to make it to the major league in a sport but then losing to someone who cheated and did not work as hard as the athlete. Instead they took drugs to get stronger and faster than others. How would an athlete feel if they lost a championship game to a cheater and watch them celebrate when they did not earn it. This is Common in the major league sports industry and even in non pro leagues. Most athletes have to deal with cheating that goes unnoticed. Some people think the only way to win is to cheat and so it starts a domino effect. This is a big problem in sports and it must be stopped. Performance enhancing substances should not be permitted in major league sports…

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As children, many people are introduced to the famous quote by late National Football League coach, Vince Lombardi, which is "winning isn 't everything; it 's the only thing" (Voy 204). Sports have always been about winning; however, some professional and amateur athletes take this simple saying too literally and it changes their outlook on their profession. As high school and even middle school athletes, they start to take drugs in order to be accepted, or to better their performance on the playing field (Louria n.pag). Once theses athletes reach the college level; they experiment, and are surrounded by even more drugs in order to get any advantage. It is not fair that one athlete can work hard in order to improve his performance, but then have another athlete improve more than him due to being wired on cocaine or bulked up on steroids. Also, Robert Voy states that drug use today is the biggest threat to the Olympics ideal, thus the Olympics and many other professional organizations are turning to drug testing. Testing is a huge controversy today because many believe that it violates one 's right of privacy; however, if there is no testing, many athletes will continue to have an unfair advantage to non drug users (180). Furthermore, it injures the user because it will result in mood changes, and it will hurt their health, if not immediately, then it will later on in their life. The chance of being caught using drugs is so small compared to the achievements one will have while using drugs which is so vast. No athlete should have an unfair advantage, these advantages only promote drug use, which many athletes believe it is a necessary means in today 's time. The only way to have the use of drugs decrease is to have mandatory drug testing across the board for all athletes.…

    • 2701 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    11% of High School boys say that they have tried steroids at least once to get that edge for a game. All the forms of performance enhancing drugs are Anabolic drugs, Stimulants, Ergogenic aids, Human biomolecules, Adaptogens, Nootropics, Painkillers, Blood Boosters, Sedative, Anxiolytics, Gene Doping. One drug that is used in the NFL are Painkiller. They help reduce the pain someone has. It is shaming us when you can go back in the books and see that the United States athletes are using peds.…

    • 258 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Steroid Pros and Cons

    • 650 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The effects of steroid use has been widely documented, especially in the past couple of years with all the high profiled athletes subjecting themselves to a tainted legacy because of the need to keep there competive edge while there skills where slowly diminishing with age. Sending shock waves through the sports world and fans feeling disappointed and confused, athletes have been slowly coming out in the public eye for their past and current steroid abuse. These athletes have been emotionally distressed and this I imagine is extremely hard to adapt to and handle. But what about the physical damagetheir bodies are enduring with these powerful anabolic drugs? This is where a lot of different opinions come in to play, between the so-called experts and the self proclaimed experts. The so called experts being doctors and self proclaimed experts being “JUICERS” in the bodybuilding world. Some people would say “_Well look, he is a doctor he must be right” _ and I would say that I rather take advice after a bad break up from a friend with the same experience than a happily married radio show love expert telling me what is politically correct. But it is very hard to argue science, which leads me to read up on many different articles from the other side. Rick Collins a writer for elitefitness.com had a interesting article in 1999, that stated how the public was fooled by the physicians into thinking that steroids was not a performance enhancer and did not make people stronger. He then went on to say that congress, was more worried about making competitive sports pure and not so much on the actual health of steroid users. This being his own belief (not fact) says to me that he might be right. The United States of America has a way of punishing athletes who use these drugs as criminals with huge penalties. This makes Rick Collins argument strong. Something that I also found pretty interesting was that the same physicians who said in the 1980’s that steroids did not enhance…

    • 650 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For years, the argument of whether marijuana is a beneficial or a detrimental thing for athletes has been a controversial topic. Many people believe that it is a danger to society, while others believe that it is completely harmless. Several athletes have confessed to using marijuana; as a result, the big question surfacing is whether or not athletes should be able to use marijuana in order to make their training easier. In the essay, “The Need for Weed,” by Chris Lee, the author argues that it should be legalized for athletes to use marijuana. Lee argues athletes should be able to use marijuana due to the fact that it’s a great recovery aid, it’s already being used effectively by several athletes without harm, and it doesn’t give athletes an unfair advantage; with that being said, I believe that Lee’s arguments are very logical, and I agree with him. Lee provides solid evidence, statistics, and credible sources throughout his…

    • 1402 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When a player moves up to the major leagues they have already achieved one of the highest status’s in their profession. Grasping for more is useless if someone cannot earn it. They are already among the best so there is no reason for these professionals to try to be better by cheating. This is causing their fans to look poorly upon them or worse imitate their poor actions. Children and young adults idolize many of these professionals, wanting to be just like them. If their role models take PEDs, then their fans will take the same drug to be just like their role models. In an effort to be cool and do what is popular children and young adults will be ruining their health to follow the leader, to follow their role model. Professional athletes are seen as an example of how people should be. Who sees their abuse of PEDs? Children, teenagers and young adults. What do they do when they see their idol do something? They emulate their idols. It does not matter if the athlete wants to take PEDs and it is their own decision. They are being watched by the nation’s youth and should hold themselves accountable for what they…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The primary reason why performance enhancing drugs (PEDs) are outlawed in professional sports is that they give users an unfair advantage over the rest of the field. Various professional sports leagues have attempted to set a level playing field by testing for drug use and suspending those found guilty. It’s a noble effort, but it’s clearly not working. Stiff punishments have done little to reduce the number of cyclists caught cheating every year; as Deadspin helpfully points out, the inheritors of Lance Armstrong’s seven abandoned Tour de France titles have all been implicated in doping scandals. Major League Baseball also hands down suspensions each season to players caught using outlawed substances, and it’s absurd to think those players are the only ones guilty of juicing.…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the article “Male College students believe taking performance-enhancing Drugs for sports is more unethical than using stimulants to Improve grades, according to new study,” author Audrey Hamilton argues that male college students believe that it is more of a necessity to use prescription drugs for success than using steroids. In this short rebuttal it will attempt to analyze the reliability, credibility, and the validity of the data. This will also identify any logical fallacies in the argument.…

    • 446 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the sporting world no matter whether it high school, college, or professional, there is always going to be the use of illegal drugs. There are many methods preventing the use of illegal drug but still they somehow find their way into the organization of sports. Athletes just want that little extra advantage over their opponent because they want to be the best and they will do almost anything to be on top, even if that means risking everything by the use of illegal drugs. But is it really worth it to risk everything you’ve ever worked for? There are many cases and examples that tell about athletes using illegal drugs and their consequences. The recent example I’m going to discuss is the quarterback, Ryan Mallett, from Arkansas and his ill edged drug use.…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hockey .vs. Football

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This paragraph talks about a very controversial substance that is used by millions of people around the world. This "wonder drug", which is not really a drug, but a natural occurring substance in the human body is called Creatine Monohydrate. This substance was used in the NFL until 2 years ago when the governing board of the NFL ruled that Creatine is a steroid type substance that gives the athlete using it a substantial edge in quickness, strength, and endurance over the players who choose not to use it. If a player is caught…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays