Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Technology vs Man

Good Essays
991 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Technology vs Man
Technology versus man is not only a theme found in literature, such as when the scientist, Frankenstein, created the monster who came alive and turned on the scientist, but is also a theme found in the real-life world of American economy. The Economist is a weekly newspaper focusing on politics and business news and opinion. It ran an article called “Into the Unknown” which put forth the idea that changes in technology that destroy jobs can also create new ones. The machine (created by man) will not necessarily turn on the man to destroy him by taking away his means of making a living. Though the machine may eliminate one means of making a living, in so doing it may create a number of new means. When technology starts to eliminate jobs, it also creates an opportunity to profit from the creation of new jobs.
“Into the Unknown” says the fear that a rise in technology would cause a decline in jobs is not a new one. In 1929 American economist Stuart Chase in his book Men and Machines, made the prediction that the creation of machines to do the work that man once did would soon destroy the American economy. The machines would go on producing the same amount of product, but jobless people would not have the money to buy the product. He felt that this economic disaster was just around the corner. Time has proven him wrong according to this article. What Chase didn’t understand was that the machine that destroyed one job set the course for the creation of new, possibly unthought-of jobs. Economic predictions are often wrong and short-sighted. Even short-term labor-market predictions can be wrong as seen in the 1988 example of the twenty occupations that the government predicted would suffer the most job losses between 1988 and 2000. Half of those occupations gained jobs instead of lost. The fear of out-sourcing jobs to other countries is another modern day economic fear according this article; but the author feels out-sourcing could be a way of getting rid of less valuable jobs and then using those workers to do more valuable jobs. Retraining workers and remembering that human desire for new technology will help keep Americans working.
The idea that changes in technology that destroy jobs can create new ones is not accepted by everyone. Two hundred years ago in England a group called the Luddites – 19th-century English textile workers – revolted against industrialization by sabotaging mechanical looms. They felt these looms made it possible to replace them with less-skilled, low-wage workers, leaving them without work. An English economist of that day, David Ricardo, was the first to predict that technology would result in unemployment. There have been many others that have agreed with that prediction – economists such as John Maynard, Wassily Leontief, Pater Drucker, and Stuart Chase. Yet despite massive mechanization and automation, the U.S. economy has kept creating jobs. These fears are still being advanced today by people such as Massachusetts Institute of Technology professors, Erik Brynjolfsson and Andrew P. McAfee. If Stuart Chase thought economic disaster was just around the corner, these men believe we have turned that corner. They believe automation is replacing people faster than the economy can create jobs. Catherine Mann, who is quoted in The Economist article, disagrees with this assessment. She says that Information Technology (IT) jobs have risen from 1999-2003 (Behrens 246). IT jobs, such as health information experts, machine-to-machine communications enablers, and outsourcing/offshoring managers, are increasing. Ms. Mann actually predicts an IT labor shortage (Behrens 246). Is America on the brink of economic disaster due to IT replacing men with machines, or is IT actually producing more jobs than it is taking away as the theme states? History would cause one to believe that the economy will adjust as it always has, and new jobs will be generated; yet a new variable could prove that wrong. America’s gross domestic product has grown 75% since 2009, yet unemployment has hovered above 9% since the same date. This would indicate that Stuart Chase and his kind are right. The new variable is Moore’s Law – microprocessors double their performance every eighteen months. They have been doing this ever since they were introduced in 1958. To illustrate this growth, if one grain of rice was placed on a chessboard square and then doubled on the second square and then that amount was doubled on the third square, by the time all sixty-four squares were filled, the amount of rice would be equal to Mount Everest. Simply put, computers have grown far more powerful over the past fifty years. An example of this is the technological advancement in pattern recognition which now surpasses human capability. This is seen in autonomous vehicles and voice recognition software. Over time, a well-functioning economy should adjust to technological unemployment, but it’s important that workers learn new skills and new business models be invented. As the article states, computer professionals have learned that maintaining standard business-software packages is no longer lucrative, but tailoring business software and services is. There is not a big supply of IT graduates to recruit and train in America. Therefore, companies have to retrain their employees in these sought-after skills (Behrens 246).
When technology starts to eliminate jobs, it also creates an opportunity to profit from the creation of new jobs. Even though it is a possibility that we have actually turned the corner in our economy and that technology is actually eliminating jobs faster than they can be created, it is not the time to throw hands in the air and give up. It would be good to remember that technology has created jobs today that would not have been dreamed of twenty-five to fifty years ago. Who knows what jobs will be available twenty-five to fifty years from now?

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In another word, we became to blind to the potential dangers from technologies. People who have not been around technologies are, with no doubt, view it as strange and abnormal hence they discourage the usage of technologies. Others might not approve of the new and advanced technologies due their fear of losing their jobs to those machines. Indeed, people are losing their jobs to the newly developed machines: “it maybe hard to believe, but before the end of this century, 70 percent of today's occupations will be likewise replaced by automation” (300) Kelly. However, the new technologies also created more jobs to make up for our previous jobs.…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    But what does this answer in terms of the essential question mentioned in the intro? Technological advancement results in increased productivity. Therefore, this reveals the technological advancement results in more unemployment. Moreover, this means economic health is declining, ever so slightly due to the increasing technological advancement. Although productivity will be at an all time high, it will not be the result of human labor, but rather the result of artificial…

    • 1213 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The introduction of technology has surely made production process easier and has changed economic world ever since. It has opened new doors, enabled possibilities that humans could only dream about before and it has created new theories and terminologies. However, because not everyone, every firm could have access to technology, not all of them are directly affected positively by the holy influence of technology. Friedrich Hayek, in his book The Road to Serfdom, John Kenneth Galbraith, in his book The New Industrial State and Milton Friedman in his book Capitalism and Freedom have asserted the relationship between technology and the large corporations, who have attained higher positions in societies and economies thanks to technology.…

    • 2159 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In recessions of the past the American worker was laid off with the impression they would be rehired as soon as demand for goods and services were presented again. Now people in jobs from computer programmers to telephone operators are losing their jobs and never returning to the same field again. The big issue here is that if we continue outsourcing specific jobs overseas we could erase a whole industry of job opportunity from the American people. Economists say the framework of the U.S. labor force has been changed due to past outsourcing of jobs by this country. The more outsourcing that continues the more our job force's structure will change. As a result, the American worker can no longer wait to be rehired into the same job or profession. Using their time while unemployed, Americans are retraining themselves and attempt to step into an entirely different career.…

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the story “The Backdraft of Technology” Stephanie Alaimo and Mark Koester indicated the many disadvantages of technology in our society. Although there are many advantages to advance technology; Alaimo and Koester still warn the readers about the negative effects of technology in the present time and the future. They strictly blame corporations for bringing the technology to replace human service to earn more profit. Alaimo and Koester claim that because corporate brings the technology such as self-checkout, apps, Netflix they have eliminated the most basic job such as: bagger, cashier, bank tellers, employees of a renting videos, and gas station employee. The fast service that the technology provide will result in…

    • 1110 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Industry is driven by the machines that produce the product. Without these machines, creating what is necessary for an industry to thrive and grow becomes increasingly difficult; more man power is needed, more time is consumed. For these machines to function properly, all the pieces; the cogs, the gears, the wheels, the levers and so on within them must be working well together. In the Invisible Man, Ralph Ellison applies this idea in a sociological fashion. Tucked away underneath the surface of the prosperous face of the country lie the machines, but the machines within the machines are the people who struggle to keep them moving every day. The people who are underground are the ones who drive these machines, who work themselves ragged to make sure all the…

    • 2131 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Luddite Fallacy

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Technological unemployment is the loss of jobs due to labor-saving devices and more efficient processes. Machines causing job loss has been around for centuries as a disputed topic. Most of those who are uninformed tend to have a pessimistic view its effect on the job market and economy. In reality, machines should be filling jobs because of how the luddite fallacy is a common, flawed belief, the job-market’s ability to adapt, and its stimulating effect on the economy.…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Technology has changed our lives tremendously but there is a down side to have such incredible technology though. With the help of technology, the need of employees was not that necessary. The fact that technology can take the job of a human is detrimental to some people because they need to make a living in order to take care of their families. So the technology boom that happened in the 1990’s was a great thing and a not so great thing at the same time. Day by day technology grows more and more and humans are needed less and…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Workforce 2020

    • 2629 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Automation will continue to decrease the workers in the American manufacturing industries. Increasing machine use will automatically decrease the human labor.…

    • 2629 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The major challenge posed by new technology is whether or not it will be used for positive or negative ends.” In history, technology has been a double edged sword for humanity. It had been shown as the cause of destruction of a civilization or the saviour of one. Now in our modern era, visionaries and inventors alike would have to face the challenges of avoiding negative effects caused by how it is implemented in our society.…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Summary

    • 394 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Thinking, Writing and Reading Rhetorically explains that the readings at the end of chapter 4 “…address the issue of outsourcing or offshoring, the business practice of moving jobs from developed countries like the United States to poor, developing like Mexico, China, and India. Outsourcing offers companies a large qualified workforce willing to work for lower wages and often more lenient environmental and safety regulations for factories” (p. 169). A controversial issue has been whether outsourcing has become a good or bad thing in the United States to the economy and the people who have jobs. On the one hand the cause of high unemployment has been because of outsourcing. From this perspective, outsourcing has become an issue due to the cause of unemployment and how the economy degraded. According to this view, as shown in the cartoon by Mike Lane, outsourcing has caused the loss of many workers jobs. Lane shows a worker that sees a sign on a closed factory stating, “Labor Day: This year’s picnic will be held in Mexico, where your job went.” (p. 175). On the other hand, however, others argue that outsourcing is good for the economy and is better for the people. As stated by Thomas Friedman, “But I am saying that there is more to outsourcing than just economics. There’s also geopolitics. It is inevitable in a networked world that our economy is going to shed low-wage, low-prestige jobs. To the extent that they go to places like India or Pakistan—where they are viewed as high-wage, high-prestige jobs—we make not only a more prosperous world, but a safer world for our own 20-year-olds” (p. 171).…

    • 394 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Factories now no longer need as many workers to run them. Many people’s jobs have been outsourced to machines and computers. Those factories and mills that stayed opened were able to spend their money on new technology. Mills that continued to operate were able to replace their workers with a new generation of nearly autonomous, computer- run machines (Davidson 320). Factory workers became obsolete to machines. One by one almost every worker was replaced by a fancy new computer system.…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although the jobs involving a lot of time manually Pursuant to the plant and machinery has moved largely to cheap labor markets in Asia and Latin America. the world today requires job descriptions typical worker machines to read mechanical drawings and understand designs with the help of computers and operating the machines controlled tools computerized and make important decisions. The United States faces a sharp difference between what the labor market needs, and what produced by the education system. There are two aspects to this paradox. First, the United States lacks the skills, and the unemployment rate rises, while there have 3.5 million job available, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Some economists believe that «the skills…

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to Ritzer he states, “[people are] the great source of uncertainty, unpredictability and inefficiency in any rationalizing system…” (Ritzer, 101). What this means is, employers have better control over the rationalization process, through mechanization. For example, the job of a pilot has been completely mcdonaldized due to the fact that a computer runs the plane. Most places are now controlled by a system that has been put into place. In a mcdonaldized society, customers are also controlled by these technologies. The structural placings of the establishment also affect the customer to follow and act in an orderly way due to the norms of the restuarants. Although these technologies make things easier, they're also a step back for humans. They have a higher control, and as they become more advanced the need for workers declines. Essentially we are too become more dependent on not only technology, but the things mcdonaldization…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Outsourcing

    • 2746 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Former U.S. Presidential candidate Ross Perot once warned of the U.S. entry into the North American Free Trade Agreement as "a great sucking sound" as U.S. jobs "run" to Mexico. Many Americans feared that cheap labor in Mexico would cause many Americans to lose their jobs as U.S. companies could find cheaper labor south of the border. In the ten years since the beginning of NAFTA, the U.S. job market has remained strong. The types of jobs may have changed to a certain degree, but the number of jobs has only increased despite the fears of many. Today, many people are worried about the effects of the outsourcing of software upon U.S. jobs. Many people fear the "great sucking sound" as software jobs are outsourced to cheaper labor in foreign countries, such as India. U.S. legislators have faced the issue and are trying to reduce the incentives of companies to hire workers abroad. There are many fears and uncertainties about globalization and the new global economy as many people fear change and competition from cheaper foreign labor. Are these fears justified? Is the American job market going to collapse? In the words of Ed Yourdon, has the "decline and fall of the American programmer? 4 Also, is it ethical to outsource software for cheaper labor?…

    • 2746 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays