Preview

Tempest vs. Montaigne's "Of Cannibals"

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
613 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Tempest vs. Montaigne's "Of Cannibals"
Irene Appel Shakespeare’s and Montaigne’s Views In many cases, society seems to dictate that if someone is different than you, you may be superior to them for whatever reason. In Montaigne’s essay, “Of Cannibals”, Montaigne tries to disprove this theory by exposing a group of “savage” people’s simplistic lifestyle, versus Europe’s complex, and arguably more savage, society. According to Shakespeare’s play, “The Tempest”, through the character of Caliban, Shakespeare seems to disagree with Montaigne’s views on people in their natural state. These literary works appear to contrast sharply, as one tries to disprove the points and main thoughts of the other. Although they contrast, there are similarities. Montaigne writes:
“Now I find there is nothing in that nation that is either barbarous or savage” (Witt, 58)
He goes on to explain how these people, living according to Mother Nature, are not lesser than others with a more complex and advanced society or more “knowledge”. In the play, Caliban says:
“Be not afeard; the isle is full of noises, Sounds and sweet airs, that give delight and hurt not.
Sometimes a thousand twangling instruments Will hum about mine ears, and sometime voices
That, if I then had waked after long sleep, Will make me sleep again” (Witt 82)
Throughout his play, Shakespeare portrays the character of Caliban as a brutish, harsh, and coarse savage. Although he was portrayed in a negative way, Shakespeare gave Caliban several speeches that help the reader acknowledge his insight and his humanistic qualities, which isn’t savage-like at all. By him doing so, it almost helps Montaigne’s point. On the other hand, the majority of Caliban’s character is set to disprove Montaigne’s thought. Montaigne states:
“The laws of nature do yet command them, but little bastardized by ours, and that with such purity, that I am sometimes grieved that the knowledge of it no sooner came to light” (Witt, 58)

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Jared Dick final exam #1

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In Tartuffe (1664), as in his other plays, Moliere employs classic comic devices of plot and character. Here, a foolish, stubborn father blocking the course of young love: an impudent servant commenting on her superiors’ actions; a happy ending involving a marriage facilitated by implausible means. He often uses such devices, however, to comment on his own immediate social scene, imagining how universal patterns play themselves out in a specific historical context.…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Caliban being both the son of Sycorax and the devil, also seen as the product of nature, is very representative of how European people at the time viewed the natives in the Americas and his treatment foreshadows the brutal interactions between colonists and the American natives. As we see in Prospero's view his impression of him is that of distaste as he calls Caliban "not honored with human shape (I.i.17)". This can be interpreted as Prospero seeing Caliban as not having "human shape" due to his clothing, skin color and earthly look which automatically positions him below that of Prospero and Miranda. It can also be seen as possibly a first impression of a colonialists and how they would see natives in the Americas as inferior due to their lack of clothing and cleanliness. This initial view of Caliban can also be seen to represent the "De-evolution" or "dehumanization" of natives and of what was seen at the time in the African people, as referenced by Takaki in his analyzation of the play where Shakespeare depicted him as a "barbarian" and "savage incapable of nurture (I.ii.37). Using this as not only a description of Caliban's nature but also as justification for the treatement of not only him but also referencing a justification for the mistreatment of indigenous people in Africa and the furture…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Montaigne’s essay “On Cruelty” revels in satire, creating a work that questions the intricacies of European culture, specifically relating to the concept of “virtue.” Montaigne’s criticism is oriented towards questioning a Renaissance European view of virtue, the hardships and struggles it requires, and how to align an innate sense of morality with a virtuous, reason- oriented state of…

    • 1475 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In order to understand the characters in a play, we have to be able to distinguish what exactly makes them different. In the case of The Tempest, Caliban, the sub-human slave is governed largely by his senses, making him the animal that he is portrayed to be and Prospero is governed by sound mind, making him human. Caliban responds to nature as his instinct is to follow it. Prospero, on the other hand, follows the art of justifiable rule. Even though it is easy to start assessing The Tempest in view of a colonialist gaze, I have chosen instead to concentrate on viewing Caliban as the monster he is portrayed to be, due to other characters that are not human, but are treated in a more humane fashion than Caliban. Before we meet Caliban, we meet Ariel, Prospero’s trusting spirit. Even though Ariel is not human either, he is treated kindly and lovingly by his master who calls him “my quaint Ariel.” Caliban, on the other hand, is called a “tortoise” and a “poisonous slave” by Prospero. As Caliban enters in Act 1 Scene 2, we realise his fury at both Prospero and Miranda. He is rude and insulting and Prospero replies with threats of torture. Prospero justifies his punishment of Caliban by his anger at the attempted rape of his daughter, something Caliban shows no remorse for. Miranda distinguishes herself from Caliban by calling him “a thing most brutish” and inadvertently, a thing that has only bad natures. She calls his speech “gabble,” but doesn’t stop to wonder whether it was she that didn’t understand him because she didn’t know how to speak his language. Surely Caliban communicated verbally with his mother for the twelve years before Prospero killed her? It seems that Prospero and Miranda expect Caliban to be grateful for the knowledge of their language, but Caliban has just learned “how to curse” and justifies his anger by claiming rights…

    • 1325 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although both writers were from different times, their views were similar. Both pieces of writing were composed of life events and encounters with hardships. In the end, they ultimately gained success.…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    ▪ “It was the secrets of heaven and earth that I desired to learn; the physical secrets of the world”…

    • 659 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Shakespeare’s play The Tragedy of Hamlet explores humanities complex processes and the condition of which we live. In this play, the concept of revenge is studied cohesively with the ability of humans to make judgments over their actions and human’s curiosity toward seeking answers. Shakespeare, having written this play in the 17th century, creates the protagonist Hamlet as a forward thinking character with a philosophical quality and moral understanding regarding his ability to reason. These traits conflict against the crude revenge task at hand in the play. Through Hamlet’s complexity, Shakespeare makes direct opinions about the human condition and what it is to be human.…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Carson used a good number of supporting ways to boost her thesis and ideas, once of which is first simply pointing out what is wrong. She expresses her emotions and how it took ten years before her speech to realize her perspective. Then, she lays out that she wishes to speak of not just of man’s relation to nature, but more of his attitude towards nature. She ingeniously defines nature as, “The part of the world that man did not make.” Proclaiming that, “The whole era of man seems but a moment--but how portentous a moment! It was only within the past million years or so that the race of man arose.” Nature long preexisted before man, but Carson and many others are puzzled why a man who walks upright on two legs, with a forever developing brain in his skull, could have the lack of control and wisdom to understand his own actions will bring his own destruction.…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The relevance of “being different” depends on the relationship between the values and context within a society. This concept is shown through the comparative study of the 1600’s play “Othello”, by William Shakespeare, and the 1967 feature film “Guess who’s coming to dinner”, by Stanley Kramer. Both these texts have similar issues of difference in the form of race and character trait. Comparing the two texts it can be seen that the presents and or elimination of evil and the values of trust, honesty, protection and suspicion all impact upon the characters that are considered to be different. The values and character traits present in these two texts are part of the context of the society in which they were composed in; therefore showing the…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    “The voice of the sea is seductive; never ceasing, whispering, clamoring, murmuring, inviting the soul to wander for a spell in abysses of solitude; to lose itself in mazes of inward contemplation.”…

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Shakespeare’s tragic play Othello has the ability throughout time to relate to the intrinsic nature of the human condition. Exposing the vulnerability of humanity, Shakespeare confronts the universal concerns such as racism and discrimination, which have a sense of timelessness still present from the Elizabethan age to the modern day. Potentially leading an eternal life, the play Othello is able to be interpreted by each individual differently through the complex language and understanding which ensures its validity in different contexts in society. These diverse interpretations include my own which has further formed an insight on the concern of human emotion such as jealousy and love, when logical reasoning is overpowered by these sporadic emotional inclinations. The collapse of Othello from a stable and rational hero, to a man driven insane by passion is a prime example of this, also framing the power of society on an individual choices and development as a character.…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Tempest's Power

    • 404 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Caliban feels the flip side of the power struggle. He is the defeated. The reader, however, is distracted from this because Caliban is made out to be a villain, and a savage. The reader hears of his attempts to rape Miranda and he is first introduced as a "tortoise" and often referred to as a beast or monster with a deformed body. But, interestingly, despite Caliban's deformed body and…

    • 404 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Fiction Essay

    • 1657 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Both works are now studied as pieces of irony but I believe both to be great works in other, with a twist of deaths in the conclusion, although, worth mentioning, the similarities both serve to the other purpose rather than the plane simple.…

    • 1657 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the most common methods of showing social class is through the physical attributes of the characters. Caliban is the lowest person on the isle in terms of class; this is shown through his appearance in the play. “A freckled whelp, hag-born – not honoured with human shape” is how Prospero, the ruler of the isle, describes him to Ariel, a sprit under Prospero’s command. This is in sharp contrast to Miranda, Prospero’s daughter and of noble birth, who is a figure of desire on the isle by no less than three of the males. “the goddess on whom these airs attend” Ferdinand, the prince of Naples, thinks Miranda a goddess her beauty is that great. Then there is the difference in language that the classes use. In the Elizabethan age this difference would have been more recognizable, but it can still be seen today. The upper class of the isle use an archaic form of language, “I’th’air, or th’earth?” However the lower classes use less gilded language and are more to the point in their speech. The only exception to this rule is Caliban and that is only due to him learning how to speak from Prospero who is of the upper class.…

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Naturalness is the center of Montaigne’s argument against European society. Information about the cultures encountered in the new world had been flooding Montaigne and Europe for nearly 90 years. A new, exotic world, completely different from Europe, was full of mystery. Early explorers were shocked at how basic the inhabitants of this land were. The inhabitants were labeled barbarians and cannibals, based on their customs. Montaigne however does not believe this to be the case. By being closer to nature, he says, these societies are in fact the better. “The laws of nature still rule them, very little corrupted by ours; and they are in such a state of purity that I am sometimes vexed that they were unknown earlier, in the days when there were men able to judge them better than we,” (pg. 153). By being close to nature and the earth, according to Montaigne, this society can exist in its basic form. Free from the trials of possession, greed, and materialism that inundates a complex society.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics