Preview

The Anti-Vaccine Fallacy

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
763 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Anti-Vaccine Fallacy
How does the writer of ‘Jabs myth is literally sickening’ attempt to persuade readers to share her point of view?
In the ‘Herald Sun’ opinion piece ‘Jabs myth is literally sickening’ (Monday, May 13, 2013), Rita Panahi structures her piece effectively to alert the public in general, and parents of babies and young children in particular, of the reasons anti-vaccination is a growing and dangerous trend and proposes some hard-nosed remedies.
The author’s stance is revealed in the headline. By labelling the anti-vaccination point of view as a myth the reader understands, through the play on words, that this is not only a ‘sickening idea’ but one that it will also lead to unnecessary illness.
The reader learns that celebrity Jenny McCarthy has successfully sold the anti-vaccination message during her appearance on Oprah Winfrey’s TV program. Ironically, Panahi uses this 2007 celebrity interview as a hook to attract her reader’s attention to achieve her purpose of persuading us to reject the anti-vaccination message. Panahi’s tone is accusatory but she concedes that McCarthy’s story was “harrowing” and moved Winfrey’s audience to accept that her son was indeed “struck down with ‘vaccine induced’ autism’”. This single anecdote, according to Panahi, led to a significant increase in the number of parents declining to have their children immunised. The reader readily accepts the cause and effect logic of the writer’s argument when she reports that contagious diseases such as measles, mumps and whooping cough were “reappear(ing) and that one quarter of Americans believe that there is a link between vaccines and autism. Panahi sways us to her point of view by asserting here, and substantiating it with evidence later, “that overwhelming scientific research” refutes the vaccination-autism connection.
The causal chain takes the anti-vaccination point of view to Australia. The writer encourages us to dismiss the proponents of this view with disparaging epithets labelling

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Drew then informs us of the 77,000 children that are not fully immunised in Australia, his use of statistics adds strength to his arguments convincing the readers that there is a purpose in vaccinations. “The death of children from diseases such as measles, whooping cough, diphtheria, tetanus and infantile paralysis are near non-existent thanks to vaccines,” by sharing this happening a caution arises in the readers minds allowing them to ponder the fact that if everyone was immunised these horrid diseases could be eradicated.…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This kind of immunization resistance is a result of the increased concern of possible negative vaccine side effects, which has been supported by anti-vaccine activists like Jenny McCarthy, who have made a career of playing into the publics fear. This study decided to use a similar strategy and use social marketing as a way to address common concerns, encourage vaccine immunization, and to help rebuild the public’s trust in the medical community. Opel, Diekema, Lee, and Marcuse explain that “In 2004, 93% of pediatricians reported that there was at least one parental refusal of a recommended vaccine in the last year, and a recent analysis of data from the 2004 National Immunization Survey found that 28% of parents were unsure about, delayed, or refused vaccines” (2009, p. 433). These statistics are undoubtedly attributed to the increased media attention gained by the anti-vaccine movement and proves that a new strategy is needed to promote behavioral change in the…

    • 1600 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Haugen, David and Musser, Sussan. "Requiring Mandatory Vaccination Is Dangerous." Opposing Viewpoints. Epidemics. Detroit: Greenhaven Press. (Reprinted from Protest over Mandatory Flu Shots for Preschoolers, Associated Press, 2008) Retrieved from http://ic.galegroup.com.prox.miracosta.edu/ Web.16 Sept. 2012.…

    • 2276 Words
    • 66 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Quote from The Age of American Unreason, page 219-220: “The first and most fundamental warning sign [of junk thought] is an inability to distinguish between coincidence and causation—a basic requirement for scientific literacy.” “During the past twenty-five years, there appears to have been a significant increase in the incidence of autism in children around the world. Whatever the reason for the rise in reported cases of autism, it has coincided with an increase in the number of recommended child immunizations. Anti-vaccination groups have focused on a relatively new triple vaccine, introduced in 1987, that immunizes children against measles, mumps and rubella.”…

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This article discusses the controversy of vaccines in American society. From the source of the ideas that caused the issues to the discredit of the person who “poisoned the well”, this article was very thorough. Ms. Lemmons has experience as a freelance writer on well documented topics and has provided her work to several well known publishers. This article was intended for the educated person exploring the rumors of vaccinations benefit being outweighed by the risk. The author is very neutral in her writing. I appreciate her stance and use of fact to support her claims. Stating only the fact that can be documented…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Herd immunity protects people with “many medical conditions, especially those which compromise the immune system” because “in a population of vaccinated people, infectious but preventable diseases have trouble spreading even to the immunocompromised” (“The Anti-Vaccine Movement”). While herd immunity is of critical importance to those with weakened immune systems, many Anti-Vax parents fail to realize that the health of their children is also dependent on herd immunity. A recent study estimates that “if current vaccination rates were to dip to just 98 percent of where they are now, one child in seven would be vulnerable to measles” (“Anti-Vaxxers Are Destroying”). With the estimated rate of measles increasing that significantly, there comes a point where one wonders how far Anti-Vax parents will go before they begin to see the trail of destruction they are leaving. Recently, in America, “whooping cough… hit its highest rate of infection in 50 years,” and “over 100,000 illnesses and over 1,000 deaths” were “associated with the anti-vaccine movement” (“The Anti-Vaccine Movement”). When more and more parents stop vaccinating, they endanger not only the health of their child but also the health of those who cannot be…

    • 967 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    People are current taking action against vaccinations and joining the anti-vaccination movement. Although research proves anti-immunization increases disease rates, parents stand firm in their believe that their children should not be vaccinated. This paper briefly discusses the reasoning behind their notion and the substantial fact about vaccinations. It then provides facts behind their judgment and consequences of…

    • 58 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Certain things that we encounter in life, have hidden dangers, while others only look scary at first glance and turn out to be quite positive. It is because of these types of things that many people become confused when it comes to making life altering decisions, such as being vaccinated. While many think of vaccines as harmful and dangerous, they are in fact safe and essential for stopping the spread of life threatening diseases, and therefore should be mandatory.…

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Largent addresses how the amount of trust the public places on researchers and program runners in the vaccine industry determines the success of immunizing children (136). Largent comments on the previously mentioned Jenny McCarthy, famous for her time as a comedian and model, whose advocacy of the anti-vaccination movement has “Solidified her position in the community of parents of autistic children, and further publicized her assertion that vaccines are one of the principal causes of autism,” (145). Although she is not medically qualified to speak on the topic, she is trusted and influential enough to spread the fear of vaccinations to parents all over America. Furthermore McCarthy, just as countless other authoritative figures in the media, blatantly disregarding the reliable scientific data proving her assertions incorrect (147). Adam Burgess compares the concept of McCarthyism, action of accusing someone or something without any evidence, to the behavior of figures in media such as Jenny McCarthy, as an “alarmist authority encouraging mass anxiety,” (334). Celebrities' influence dominates discourse online as well. While the internet's ability to spread information faster than anything else has always worried scientists, several analyzes show that despite the abundance of…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It's time to stop that stigma.”, Elizabeth Picciuto argues that opposition to vaccines is placing people at risk over the baseless fear that it could cause autism. Picciuto states that if a link between autism and vaccines existed, then vaccine opponents are arguing death is preferable to contracting autism (par. 4). She goes on to contend that, “Having autism is not a fate worse than death, and it is grossly offensive for anti-vaxxers to suggest it is” (par. 7). Picciuto also goes on to relate how her own son has autism and even though it is a struggle at times she probably would not risk having him unvaccinated even if she believed vaccines might have caused it (par. 10). Picciuto’s article on vaccines is a very opinionated piece written for an online news site. Although there are several facts brought into the article she does not cite the source of this information causing it to lack credibility. This article relies heavily on personal narratives to attempt to sway people to its point of view. Throughout the article Picciuto’s bias is on display as it is clear that she takes offense to those who disagree with her point of view. Although this article brings up some interesting arguments it is very weak on…

    • 673 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When it comes to vaccinations, there are many different opinions on immunizing a child, especially when that child’s parent has a strong like or dislike towards vaccinating. Immunizations have been around for at least a thousand years and as technology advances more, there are new vaccines being designed to help protect our children from contracting contagious and sometimes deadly diseases, such as Bordetella pertussis, polio, and even influenza. For decades, all 50 states have required that parents vaccinate their children against various diseases, including polio and measles, as a prerequisite to enrolling them in public schools (Ciolli, 2008). Enrollment in public school requires up to date vaccinations in order to protect the children and even the adults from contracting and spreading a disease, possibly causing an epidemic. Although all public schools require immunizations, there are still children in the schools whose religion exempts the use of vaccinations. The goal of this paper is to further explain…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The general public needs to be aware of radical political ideologies that oppose vaccinations without clinical studies or proof of the dangers of vaccination. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services wants to inform you of the clinical trails and the content of vaccines, which will dispel any subjective arguments against the vaccination process. The citizen must be aware of the dangers of subjective or misinformed political ideology that strays from scientific fact and clinical studies that are available to the general public in reference to vaccination.…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The fight against vaccines has become controversial however arguments against mass immunization should be evaluated so that a good understanding of this controversy can be had. There are three main arguments against the mass immunization of children and babies. Firstly, It is argued that vaccinations can have harmful side effects on children. Secondly, it is argued that laws requiring mandatory vaccinations infringe upon an individual’s liberty and freedom of choice; and finally, mass immunizations a law, violates religious freedom. According to Omer et al (2009) approximately 69% of parents are more concerned that vaccines could cause harm to the health of their young children than they are with the other issues. The CDC does, in fact, publish that vaccines may have side effects for example a reaction to the varicella vaccine can range from a rash to a severe infection (CDC, 2010). No specific evidence exist, however, to support the claim that vaccines predispose children to other disease such as type 1…

    • 440 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Vaccinations Mandatory

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Since vaccination decisions not only affect the infant or child, but also the community, these decisions cannot be treated as individual ones. At the point where individual decisions might harm the community, the government and public health professionals should also be involved. At the same time, the procedure of vaccination should be more open, and health professionals should carefully study genetic history and reactions of kids before vaccinating them. The controversy on vaccinations significantly influenced means of delivering scientific conclusions to the…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Melnick, M. ( 2011, February) The Dangers of the Antivaccine Movement. (Conversation with Dr. Paul Offit, chief of the Division of Infectious Diseases and the director of the Vaccine Education Centre at the Children 's Hospital of Philadelphia.) Time Magazine…

    • 1807 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics