Preview

The Book Thief Essay

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1489 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Book Thief Essay
1

Ethics, Person and Society

The Book Thief by Markus Zusak

A01330075

2
The Holocaust have been analyzed over and over again by many scholars, because of the cruelty and lack of empathy that several people showed towards the
Jewish people during this time. Because of this, many works, both fictional and nonfictional, have been created on the subject. The Book Thief is a novel that shows the dilemma that some Germans went through during World War II: to hide a Jew and risk your life and your family’s, or to turn him in and obey the authorities1. However, such predicament should not exist, people must have the priority of defending a human life, especially if the social moral code does not provide the same rights to everyone, including the integrity and protection of all its individuals.
The novel I picked to scrutinize is The Book Thief. This book is narrated by Death and tells the story of Liesel Meminger. She is a nine year old German girl who was given up by her mother to live with Hans and Rosa Hubermann in Molching in 1939, before
World War II. Hans previously made a promise with a man who saved his life. That man is a Jew named Max Vandenberg and Hans agrees to hide him in his basement due to the persecution. Hans publicly gave bread to an old man who was Jew, and because he did it, Hans was sent into the military. When this was happening, the police made an investigation to Hans; after this, they found out about Max. Because of this, Max had to leave to a concentration. Finally, Liesel and Max survived the war and Hans and his family died because of a bomb on the street.
The situation described previously will be analyzed, firstly quoting Kant. Kant supports the statement of disobeying the rules when they affect people, as shown in his categorical imperative. The first maxim states that “people should choose their “codes of

1

The web page www.yadvashem.org lists the nations that helped hiding Jewish people during the



References:  Markus Zusak (2007)  Shmoop Editorial Team (2008) Shmoop University, Inc. Retrieved on September 14th, 2013 from www.shmoop.com.  Hariman, Robert (2003)  James Bentley(1984)  Victoria Barnett (1992)  Wolfgang Gerlach (2000) Jackson, J. (1965). Structural characteristics of norms: Current studies in social psychology  Mitcham, Carl (2005)

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    ‘The Book Thief’, written by Markus Zusak is a novel set in Nazi Germany that demonstrates the hardships, danger and threatening experiences faced by the German families and Jews during that time in comparison to the rewards obtained due to such experiences and how they compare in relation to each other. Liesel Meminger, the main character experiences death and loss for the first time when her father is ‘taken away’ as an alleged communist. These experiences become more common as Liesel, with ‘One eye open, one still in a dream’ witnesses her brother Werner’s death on a train to Molching. Liesel’s mother cannot financially support and provide for her and therefor makes the difficult decision to place Liesel into the care of Rosa and Hans Huberman. Liesel’s initial reluctance to accept her new home is stimulated by the reoccurring nightmares which she endures. ‘She would wake up swimming in her…

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Liesel Part 2 Summary

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages

    He is greeted by Hans. The narrator explains that Hans was friends with Max’s father, Erik, in the war. It is because of Erik that Hans did not die in the war’ Hans promised Erik wife a favor, anytime, because her husband saved his life. His favor would now be keeping Max safe.The story flashes back again, to tell us about Max. Like Liesel he was one to fight other children. One of his many opponents, Walter, he became very close with. Walter shows to his house one night to help Max escape. He quickly says goodbye to his mother and family and is taken to a storeroom to hide. He will live there for the next 2 years. It is Walter who gives him Mein Kampf and the identity to go to Molching. In present time, Rosa feeds him pea soup and gives him the bed that was meant for Liesel’s brother. Hans takes Liesel down to the basement to explain their predicament to her. He tells Liesel not to tell anyone or they will all be taken away and will never see each other again. The family slowly becomes used to having Max around and accommodating him the best they can; they let him sleep by the fire when winter comes, they give him a mattress, and they give him more than scraps for food, though food is tight for them already. Liesel and Max bond over nightmares; they both have them routinely. Come her birthday, Max fails to give her a gift and bans her from the basement for a week. After the week, he presents her with a handmade book, The Standover Man, about all the people in his…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There were many things that happened in the 1940’s, during World War 2 there were many round ups for the Jews. One of these round ups was called The Ve’lodrome d’Hiver Roundup. This was one of the first round ups Hitler started. Hitler was the dictator of Germany. Many people didn’t like the Jews for lots of different reasons.…

    • 1477 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Germany had lost the war and people were looking for a way to relieve them of the humiliation that they felt. The German Christians were wanting to use the story…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Clara Kramer Essay

    • 360 Words
    • 2 Pages

    On September 1st 1939, the Nazis had invaded Poland. The life of the 15 year old girl, Clara Kramer, wasn't ever bound to be the same again. Clara Kramer was a typical Polish teenager from a small town named Zolkiew where thousands of Jews resided. At the sudden uproar of World War II. Clara and her family decided it was a good idea to go into hiding. They were taken in by a family called the Becks, a Volksdeutsche (ethnically German) family from their town. Mrs. Beck was a Catholic woman who worked as Clara's family's housekeeper. Mr. Beck was known to be an alcoholic and a prominent anti-Semite. When Mr. Beck heard the news of how Jews were being slaughtered and sent into camps, Beck sheltered the Kramers and two other Jewish family…

    • 360 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is 1918, Liesel Meminger, a nine-year-old girl living in Germany during World War II. Undergoing many troubles Liesel’s experiences are narrated by Death, who describes both the beauty and destruction of life in this era. Liesel avoids the mayor's house at all costs because she suspects that the mayor's wife saw her steal the book from the bonfire. However, Liesel’s mother is working under the mayor, she has to pick up and deliver laundry everyday. The mayor’s wife has invited her to her library every time Liesel comes to pick up laundry. One day the mayor fires Liesel’s mother and that began the mischief of Liesel and…

    • 109 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Both Hans and Max must live their lives knowing what their choices have resulted, but their actions differ. Hans pushes on living by giving back to others who desperately need it, feeling that being kind will help alleviate some of the sadness and weight he carries, whereas Max’s yearning to survive helps him to prevail, even with the odds against him, although unlike Hans, he lives bitterly and with deep resentment towards…

    • 459 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Essay On The Book Thief

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Her brother died halfway the trip and had to be buried somewhere nearby the railroad; that’s when Liesel stole the first book about how to dig a proper grave and when death and Liesel took a first glimpse of each other. After all the commotion, Liesel and her mother got to the designated train station and greeted her mother goodbye to never see again and head towards her new Mama and Papa on a new street; Himmel (Heaven) Street. There she meets her new best friend Rudy, a lemon haired boy that loved Liesel within at first sight; a new home and family for her, new surroundings with new people to like or dislike.…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Plot * Liesel, her mother and her brother Werner are all travelling on a train, to greet Werner’s and Liesels foster parents. * Liesel, illiterate has a dream o Adolf Hitler and speaks to him in broken German. * As she is half awake, Liesels brother dies, and there were two Nazi soldiers who argue on weather they leave the body there or take it with them. * Both Liesel and her mother are traumatized by his sudden death and 2 days later he is buried. * After the ceremony finishes Liesel digs at his grave but is dragged away by her mother, but before getting on another train Liesel steals a book she is unable to even read the title of. * She is taken to a place in Munich called Himmel -"Heaven" to meet Rosa and Hans Hubermann, her foster parents. * She refuses to meet or get out of the car with her suitcase that only contains her clothes and the book she stole from her brother’s gravesite. * The only person that manages to get her out of the care is her foster father. * Liesel feels abandoned by her mother, but understands that it’s better for her to live there and be protected from the poverty; she also learns that her father was a communist, but she doesn’t yet know the meaning of that word. * Liesels foster mother acts harshly upon her and calls her a "pig girl" when she refuses to bathe, but claims to loves her. * Her foster father, Hans develops a closer relationship with her and teaches her how to roll cigarettes. she starts calling them "mama" and "papa" * Liesel got terrible nightmares about her brother the first few months and was accompanied by Hans, who she kept the book hidden from. * She kept the book as a symbol reminding her the last time she saw her brother, and the last time she saw her mother. * Liesel is put in school but has to stay with a much younger grade, just learning the alphabet. When she turns ten she joins the Hitler Youth. * Liesel makes a friend names Rudy who…

    • 1453 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Liesel also feels abandoned when Max Vandenburg, a Jew, comes to hide in the Hubermann 's basement, but falls ill after Liesel brings snow into the basement on Christmas Eve. She starts reading for him and giving him gifts everyday. "She gave The Dream Carrier to Max as if words alone could nourish him" (Zusak 328). Liesel 's recovery from her abandonment stemmed from Hans teaching her to read. Words were what had kept Liesel connected to her mother and brother and now they kept her tied to Max.This connection supresses her guilt and fear of losing him. One can see Liesel 's courage and her ability…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hermann is a young German soldier in the Tsar's army who dreams of becoming a member of the Russian elite. After an evening at a friend's, he learns the story of an old countess who is known to hold an invincible secret at playing cards. This Countess resides with her niece, Lisa. Hermann decides to manipulate Lisa and allows her to fall in love with him so that he may be introduced to the Countess. Once introduced, Hermann basically threats the Countess to reveal her secret. Not much time afterwards, the Countess appears in one of Hermann's dream and reveals to him a winning card combination on the one condition that he marry Lisa. After becoming very happy Hermann decides to reject Lisa and use her secret to become rich. But little does he know what is going to happen.…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Book Theif

    • 6546 Words
    • 27 Pages

    3. What tragedy struck Liesel’s family while on board the train? Liesel’s brother, Werner died on their way to Molching.…

    • 6546 Words
    • 27 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Sunflower - Response

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Placing a Jew in this anguished position further victimizes him or her. This, in my reading, was the final sin of the dying Nazi."…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hiding was one of the ways the “outsiders” tried to protect themselves Gestapo and Nazi’s. Say you know where your Jewish…

    • 511 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Liesel is given up by her mother to Hans and Rosa Hubermann, a married German couple. Along the way to the Hubermanns, Liesel younger brother dies. Hans is a humorous old man that brought joy and comfort to Liesel. Rosa is a mean lady that is very strict and blunt. Hans taught Liesel how to read and Liesel in return fell in love with books. The first book Liesel learned to read was a book that she stole from a gravedigger from her brother's funeral. Liesel became friends with her neighbor named Rudy who fell in love with her. During a book burning ceremony, Liesel realized her parents were victimized for being communists. After the burning, Liesel was then spotted by the mayor's wife stealing a book. Owing a favor to his father, Hans agrees to take in Max who is a Jew and hides him in his basement. Despite the age difference, Max and Liesel became close friends. A neighboring friend of Hans, who is a Jew, is approached by the Nazis and Hans decides to defend him. In the process, Hans's name was taken down for trying to help the Jew. Unfortunately, Max has to leave the Hubermann's house for the reason that they were now in danger because of Han's decision. During an unannounced air raid, Liesel was fortunately writing a story in her basement. While she fell asleep in her basement, her neighborhood was being bombed and everyone on her block including Hans, Rosa, and Rudy was killed. Liesel is the only survivor and goes on to live a long successful…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays