Preview

The Cambridge Illustrated History Of China Chapter Analysis

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1499 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Cambridge Illustrated History Of China Chapter Analysis
The Chapter 9 of The Cambridge Illustrated History of China narrates the history of Qing Dynasty from 1644 to 1900. The most impressing part is that the author, Patricia B. Ebrey, stresses the role of common people in the development of the history. However, there is the Orientalism within the narrative to some extent. The narratives of Meng Sen, Hsü Chung-yueh, and Jonathan D. Spence will be used to compare with Ebrey’s narrative to demonstrate the arguments.

The strength of Ebrey’s narrative of Qing is that common people are narrated and analyzed to reconstruct the history and reflect the background of the time from them, but not only the macro history narrative about the whole dynasty affairs in this chapter.

Ebrey dedicates a significant
…show more content…
For example, Meng, a Chinese historian, suggests that Qing’s success owed to three measures: the claim of rescuing people from suffering, the abolition of surtaxes, and the inheritance of Ming government institutions. Similarly, Spence, an American historian, also states that the adaptation to China is one of the reasons for Manchu’s success, besides the other two factors: Manchu’s capable leaders and the good cooperation with Han people. In brief, these two historians believe that one of the reasons of Qing’s success is that Manchus inherited the legacy of Ming. On the contrary, Ebrey argues that the fact that Manchus are not Chinese makes contribution to the success of Qing. In another word, Ebrey implies that the Chinese institutions and culture were disadvantaged, and defects were developing within it since that …show more content…
Meng describes two of the causes of Opium War are British’s demand of an entrepot like Macau to Portugal, and the heavy expropriation of tariff from Canton system. Hsü Chung-yueh argues that the discrepant understandings of international relations, trade and jurisprudence led to the inevitable conflicts between China and Britain. Therefore, the Opium war is inevitable. Spence’s statement that there are several accounts for the outbreak of the Opium War: the chaos had appeared within the China society; more and more people were addicted to Opium; the antipathy of Chinese for foreign culture and people; foreigners refused to accept Chinese laws; the changes of international trade; the western scholars did not admire China anymore, and the problem of Canton System. It can be clearly seen that Meng’s explanations for the reason of outbreak of the Opium War are established on Britain’s commercial interests and demands. Though Hsu and Spence’s arguments are also involved in the differences between China and Britain, they offer other causes and do not give the judgment of superiority or inferiority between the west and the east world. By contrast, it seems that there are signs that Ebrey’s narratives show the superiority of Europe and the stress of the differences between China and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Discontent is building against executive bonuses of more than 1 billion euros ($1.33 billion) at Anheuser-Busch InBev triggered when the brewer cut its huge debt two years ahead of target. This 2008 exceptional option grant was set to vest if the group's net debt to core EBITDA profit ratio fell below 2.5 times before the end of 2013. The actual debt ratio fell to 2.26 times by the end of 2011 which is 2 years early. This bonus issue annoyed the group managers and office staff who are seeking for work security guarantees according to union officials while Brito, the CEO of AB-InBev appeared to have security up to 2019 when his options fully vest. This annoyed both the white collars and blue collars…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    7. What was the attitude of China’s Qing dynasty leadership toward modern, industrialized societies?( see pgs. 570-571).…

    • 440 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ebrey stated. “When the ruler looks as lofty and firm as a mountain peak and as pure, bright, and illuminating as the sun and moon, the people will admire and respect him.” The quote is showing and saying that Taizong believed that when a ruler or leader shows the respect and admiration for his people, the people will show the same back to him. Emperor taizong showed this throughout his ruling, he obviously was the most successful ruler throughout this dynasty. Emperor Sui thought his government should be ran the exact opposite from emperor Taizong. Obviously here Taizong had the upperhand. In conclusion Emperor Taizong and Emperor Sui Yangdi had very different views on how a government should be handled and ran.all of his problems. Although this was proved to be wrong because in 617, when he was almost captured by enemy forces and after that rebellions broke out throughout the town and reeked havic on people. He believed that a government should be ran with violence, but on the other hand Emperor Taizong believed that a government ran without violence and corruption. This obviously was the right answer because he was able to extend the empire to the largest it ever was. Both of these emperors had a very different perspective on how their government should…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    DBQ: Opium in China

    • 1735 Words
    • 5 Pages

    While most of the Western Hemisphere was undergoing drastic advancements, such as former colonies gaining their independence and transforming into more modernized nations, a lot of mishaps were occurring in the Eastern Hemisphere—China, specifically—a nation that was notorious for its isolation from foreign influences. European nations began to greedily eye China’s abundance of desirable resources, such as tea, porcelain, and silk. However, China had very little need or desire for European goods. In an attempt to resolve the trade imbalance Britain began importing opium into China, which would prove to be disastrous for the Chinese population. The dispute over the importation of the drug eventually led to the Opium War, beginning in 1839.…

    • 1735 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The British eventually wanted ALL of China’s resources and land, which led to Britain trading opium with China, which then led to Chinese citizens being addicted to the drug. As a result, China was basically forced into trading with Britain in order to keep…

    • 149 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    A British imperialist may have justified the export of opium into China in defiance of the wishes of the Chinese government by claiming that there was a market for it since, even though it was illegal, there were still people buying it. They would have said whatever they could to justify it because all the cared about was the economic gain for their own country, rather than the toll it took on the Chinese. They would not have cared about the wishes of the Chinese government because they would have claimed that if they really did not want opium imported than they would have to do a better job at eliminating the demand in their country rather than taking it out on the suppliers. 4. The fact that the British government was willing to go to war over opium exports shows that the motives behind British imperialism are purely for the economic benefit of the British regardless of death it could cause.…

    • 1437 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The view of England on China and vice versa has changed completely since the first time a British emissary came into contact with China. In the beginning the relationship between the two countries were quite sincere. Lord MacCartney, a British emissary to the Chinese imperial court, commented that China was the “true representation of the highest pitch of human greatness and felicity” (3). Likewise, a British cartoonist depicts Lord MacCartney “kneeling before Chinese court” (2), hinting that the English looked at the Chinese from a positive point of view. Moving forward half a century, the replacement of silver with opium as an export to China despite the fact that the English understand “the harm caused by opium” (4), shows England’s contempt for the Chinese, opposite of what happened previously. In addition, it shows England’s focus on commercialism, as it was easier to produce opium in India than mine silver in general, as was previously done. Soon after the fact that the English had subjugated the Chinese becomes clear.. This can see seen from Lord Palmerston, a British Foreign secretary, and his letter to the Chinese government in 1840. His letter explains how the “Queen desires that Her Subjects who may go into Foreign Countries should obey the Laws of those Countries” (5), but at the same time “cannot permit that Her…

    • 755 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    20 years after the Opium Wars, China faced intermittent periods of conflict against the Western powers. According to the Chinese, the first Opium…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Opium War Analysis

    • 1984 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Travis Hanes and Frank Sanello recounts the history of the Opium War through both the Chinese and the British perspectives. Its purpose is to give both sides of the story to better inform the reader of the Opium Wars causes, conflicts, and effects, while also presenting the information in an interesting way intended to captivate the reader. Because the source presents the view of each side the information is balanced and lets the reader decide what they make of both arguments. The value of this source is that it does examine both perspectives and it includes, not only stories and text but also illustrations of graphs and charts to aid understanding. The source has the limitation of its length, being very long and it covers information outside of the scope of this paper. Both of the authors are Americans that created this source many years after the event, so it is a secondary source that has an inherent underlying western inclination, though the images were obtained by primary…

    • 1984 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    The Terracotta Army is a life-size clay army (Hardy 13) built as, the 1st Emperor of China, Qin Shi Huang’s tomb (Hardy 10). It includes over 8000 soldiers, 130 chariots, 520 horses, and 150 cavalry horses (Terracotta) because the Emperor wanted to have them just in case he wanted company in the after-life (Roach). In this amazing life-size army there were three pits filled with soldiers, chariots, horses, and even a officer’s command station (Terracotta). No one knows how long it actually took to build, but it must have taken a long time because it took 7000 craftsman to build this colossal clay army, and it didn 't even get finished! These astonishing soldiers were not only made of clay, but the army received its name by...…

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the book Herodotus and Sima Qian (2010), Thomas R. Martin contests of the Greek Historian and the Chinese Historian Sima Qian. Martin displays that though the historians’ politics, cultures, and time periods were different, both historians had the innate desire to record their subjective view of history as objectively as possible. Though they were not the first writers of ancient Greece and China, their books and their historical innovations shaped and changed how the past was depicted from their culture and on.…

    • 1967 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The great rebellions that happened during the 19th century in the Qing dynasty, proved to be costly. Notably the biggest and most dangerous of the rebellions was the Taiping Rebellion. The Taiping Rebellion was so widespread, that the Qing considered it to be more pressing than the second opium war against the Europeans. The Taiping Rebellion had taken over 20 million Chinese lives over the course of the rebellion. Why did the Taiping Rebellion and other Rebellions during the middle of the 19th century happened? The rebellions throughout Chinese history usually happen with events that causes impoverishment to the peasant classes; For example, the Yangtze river flooded much farm land throughout the heart of China and elsewhere, it was drought (Green). Another reason to why the Taiping and other rebellions were so successful was due to the immense weakening of the scholar-officials and their corruption. A lot of these rebellions got so big because the scholar-officials were failing to report it – much like the earlier and later opium wars during the 18th century – to save their lives (Green). Lastly, these rebellions saw much reform in the Qing's military structure, such as, Chinese officials being able to raise armies without a Manchu present. This essay looks at…

    • 552 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Qing Dynasty

    • 1832 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Nevertheless, despite the unequal treaty signed along with a series of other obligations and negativities on the defeat, the Opium war indeed opened the door of modern Chinese history, and is beneficial to China’s development from a different perspective. While the improvement in technology had largely improved people’s lives in Europe and spread the idea of liberty to the general population, China had yet to accept the trends of revolutions. Even though the majority of the reasons of Qing’s collapse are related to internal factors, the external forces helped stimulate the internal forces and push the country forward. Moreover, the break-out of the Opium War fostered the growth of emerging merchant class in China, which also set the foundation of self-strengthening and reform movements in later Qing. As five ports were forced to open in China after the Opium War, the foreign trade and other merchant activities became increasingly prosperous, especially in Canton and Shanghai. As China’s door was gradually opened after the Opium War, foreign technology, and more importantly, foreign ideas of democracy and liberty started to take roots in the land of China. As more and more young scholars became educated on the foreign ideas or were even sent abroad to study, further rebellions, reforms and revolutions have yet to take place. Therefore, the Opium War well…

    • 1832 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Great Britain made no attempt to hide her aggressiveness when it came to total exploitation of her colonies. This seems most evident in the smuggling of opium into China. Until the 1820’s the favor had remained with the Chinese in regard to trade, for they had little to gain from European countries. But when England began the smuggling of opium, grown in the English colony of India, this was dramatically reversed.1…

    • 1850 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    [Type the abstract of the document here. The abstract is typically a short summary of the contents of the document. Type the abstract of the document here. The abstract is typically a short summary of the contents of the document.]…

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays