Chapter five was a situation with David, Sophie and Alan. David and Sophie were together until Alan arrived. Alan glanced at the sandy ground while looking at Sophie's footprints that included an extra toe on each foot (p.44). David flung himself on Alan angrily from asking all the stupid questions about Sophie's foot. To the naked eye this exemplifies bad behavior towards David for fighting with Alan. However, David obviously could not bear to see Sophie treated and humiliated like a deviant because of her feet. David surprisingly did a good deep for Sophie because David distracted Alan while Sophie could get away unknown from Alan. However before Sophie left she hit Alan with a stone. "I hit him"(Sophie 45). Therefore, again the situation turns into a bad one, but maybe Sophie was trying to save David from getting beat up. This particular situation tells the reader that to the naked eye its bad behavior going towards David and Sophie, but what it really tells us is that it's a good one because of the good deeds towards helping each other.
Chapter seven was a situation with Harriet needing a certificate of normalcy (p.73) because her child was a deviant. "Harriet! Are you going to tell me that you have not a certificate?"(David's mother 70). The only way that she could obtain that certificate was if she switched her baby with a non-devant, like her sister Emily. "It would only be for a day or two, just while I could get a certificate"(Aunt Harriet 71). Aunt Harriet's proposal was denied. Nobody in the house would support Harriet. They all said that they were ashamed of her. "You have the effrontery to bring your monster into my house?"(70). Even though Harriet's plan was not considered appropriate, the thought of her just trying to save her baby is considered good behavior. Harriet obviously cared a lot about her baby to go through all the trouble to get the certificate. Harriet committed good deeds just so she can keep her baby, even if it took her evil plan to action.
The next mourning, Harriet was found dead next to a river with her baby. Nobody knows how she died but maybe she killed herself. "When I saw her, I wanted to kill myself"(70). Also, Harriet had good reason to kill herself because her whole family turned against her. Nobody was supporting her, so Harriet left crying and the thought of killing herself was obviously a thought roaming in her mind. When she wanted to borrow the baby and fraudulently obtain a certificate, it was not a very honest way to do so. When reading about Harriet's proposal to borrow the baby, you immediately think that she isn't a very honest person. However thinking about the reasons for her evil plan was considered good because all she wanted was to keep her baby knowing she had a normal non-deviant one. David's mother had good reasons for yelling and denying Harriet's evil plan. "I would like to know why you have come here, why did you bring it here"(70). Nevertheless she wasn't being far. She was a part of family and didn't help or support her one bit during the discussion the family had. She could have at least helped her by thinking of another solution, or actually supporting her to her original plan, which might have not been elegant considering it was against the law.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Linda Brent in Harriet Jacobs story face challenges with her children, leaving them behind in fear that he Mr Flint would sell them, but wanting to get away from the harsh treatment that she received from him. Even after she left , he search high and low for her, and threatened her grandmother of selling the children. It bother her that Mr.Flint put her children and brother in jail, she thought about returning, but was advise not too. Linda wanted the best for her children, she want them to learn to read and write another suffer as she did under her master. Even after Linda, fled north, she stay in touch with her daughter. I do not think that it set well with her that her son betrayed as a white man to get work and stay free.…
- 141 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The lessons are learned through the tragic and meaningful events that represent the ups and downs in life. For example, Wang Lung and his land teaches determination can lead to success, O-Lan strangling her daughter teaches that being able to move on is important, and the flood teaches that you should be able to deal with uncontrollable tragedies. Because of Pearl S. Buck’s ability to make The Good Earth so relatable to the readers, the lessons in the novel are easier for the readers to learn. Finally, no matter who the reader is, they will be able to relate to The Good Earth, because of the many similarities they can find between their life and the characters lives in the…
- 526 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
There are a few patterns that I noticed in the Chrysalids the one that really jumped out at me was the idea of “normal” the entire story is based around the idea of “normal” and gods image. It's repeated all throughout the book, Sophie gets her foot stuck in the rocks she doesn’t want her shoe to be removed because she fears David will think of her having six toes as something abnormal, in Davids house where there are no paintings on the walls instead phrases from the bible about gods divine image and if any one deviates from them they are to be known as Satin spawn, and how civilization is divided, people of gods image live a good life protected from people with deviations who live as out casts…
- 387 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Within a few pages of the buldingsroman novel ‘The Chrysalids’, written by John Wyndham in 1955, a number of significant issues and ideas are introduced. Set in a post-apocalyptic world, Wyndham captures the fears and pessimism of Cold War Europe and explores how such fear and rigid principles can lead to destruction. Utilizing archetypal characters and techniques such as irony, Wyndham incorporates numerous issues and ideas within his dystopian and myopic world that are relevant to the rest of the text.…
- 1235 Words
- 4 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Aunt Harriet had produced a deviant baby. She loved the child and could not stand the thought of it being taken away and sent to the fringe. She went to her sister, Davids’ mother, and asked if she could change babies for one or two days. Her intentions were to get a certificate to prove she has a real baby.…
- 568 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
However, even though he does not agree, other people in Waknuk would like to rid the society of deviations. Such a fact us relevant when Alan Ervin notices the six digit footprint down by the stream. David shows great bravery by fighting with Alan, allowing Sophie to escape. Even after David returned home, and the adults had learned about Sophie, David remained brave and did not cry as his father whipped him.…
- 357 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Both she and her family are forced to flee. They are captured and banished to the Fringes. David finds it difficult to reconcile the laws of his society with his own conscience. This problem is intensified when he sees his aunt driven to suicide because she has given birth to a deviant baby.…
- 4964 Words
- 20 Pages
Good Essays -
The Chrysalids, John Wyndham is a science fiction novel about people who can communicate with their minds. This essay with prove that the book has both hopeful and pessimistic view on humanity. The books has very inhuman laws and has inhabitable lands, but also has a hopeful future.…
- 366 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
When people are forced to hold certain beliefs which they do not agree with, they often end up becoming hypocrites. Such is the case in The Chrysalids by John Wyndham; the citizens of the book's setting, Waknuk, are forced to believe that any being which is not completely normal is a mutant, and should be removed from society. These stern beliefs force several citizens to become hypocrites.…
- 780 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout her confinement to the yellow nursery, the narrator began to realize how wrong her perception of her husband John was. She initially thought that John was helping her treat her depression. However, she now understood that her husband was neglecting her in the room, and only created the impression of helping her, while in reality, he is doing nothing. Gilman writes, “He asked me all sorts of questions, too, and pretended to be very loving and kind. As if I couldn’t see through him” (25). The narrator reveals her husband to be hypocritical, pretending to be a husband while actually leaving her alone. This makes him seem selfish and disrespectful towards his wife. As a husband, he should have made his wife feel as comfortable as possible during her supposed “treatment.” Instead, he treats her as a confused person with little worth. This action makes him look more like a prison guard instead of a caring husband. The narrator, however, was finally able to see through her husband’s deceptions. By saying that “As if I couldn’t see through him,” she understood that her husband is not treating her as she is supposed to. According to traditional gender expectations, a wife is supposed to follow everything her husband’s orders,…
- 1386 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The many points of view we receive, helps us, as readers, to not judge a specific character by their actions, but the story as a whole. In all three works there is a define line that shows the turning point of despair and struggle to surviving and achieving survival, then victory over fear and the socially acceptable behavior. In Wonder and Shingaling we see how one small act of kindness that August received affected the life of Charlotte who was not focused on the boy drama. However, as the acts of kindness picked up for August and his life began to change so did the life of Charlotte as well as everyone else. Coincidently, in The Julian Chapter, as the acts of kindness picked up the more Julian’s life began to fall apart. This goes to show how one small act of kindness in middle school was the key to surviving and achieving change over the once socially accepted…
- 1098 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
d.ii. Miss Susan’s sister came to teach Harriet to care for the child and clean…
- 579 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In the beginning of this movie, Harriet the Spy, 11-year-old Harriet has parents that are quite of the "authoritarian" style of parenting. This means that they expect their children to follow the strict rules established by the parents. Failure to follow such rules usually results in punishment. Authoritarian parents fail to explain the reasoning behind these rules. If asked to explain, the parent might simply reply, "Because I said so." These parents have high demands, but are not responsive to their children. These parents are obedience- and status-oriented, and expect their orders to be obeyed without explanation.…
- 519 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
After that accident the master sent her to be a house nurse for her his wife and was left to take care of their baby and do random household tasks. The master’s wife ended up beating her because she did not know how to clean properly. She also was beat whenever the baby started crying she was left to tend to the baby all-night and learned to always keep an eye on the baby. One day when Harriet was working in the kitchen she saw sugar and never knew what it tasted like so she stole a piece and the wife caught her. Fore this purpose, the wife did not want her anymore so Harriet was sent to the field to work with the men.…
- 2510 Words
- 11 Pages
Better Essays -
Sophie and Elly have been best friends for years. Sophie is the bossy one who is always telling Elly what to do, she has often threatened to stop talking to Elly if she doesn’t do what Sophie says. Elly’s mother never really liked Sophie. Elly must have had a low self-esteem in a while, because she has developed anorexia. In the beginning of the story Elly is hostile towards Sophie. She doesn’t want to admit to her best friend that she has an illness, probably because she is embarrassed and feels like a failure. Sophie is nervous about her friend from the beginning of the text, but also a bit annoyed about how Elly pronounces words and sentences. I think Sophie is embarrassed for not doing something before and that comes out in her annoyance, because she is mad at herself. In my opinion Sophie is right trying to help her friend, but I think she should have done something about it before it got out of hand. I think Elly has felt inferior to Sophie because Sophie is the boss in their relationship, and that she has felt neglected because she has lived in the shadow of Sophie. But now, when Elly has got an illness she will get the attention that Sophie used to get and…
- 638 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays