Preview

The Company Man Ellen Goodman Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
616 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Company Man Ellen Goodman Analysis
Work Replacement Needed
“He worked himself to death, finally and precisely, at 3:00 a.m. Sunday morning.” The promise of reward for all the hard work and extra hours is wasted on a shortened life barely lived. Every day turned into a blur, barely distinguished from the next. In “The Company Man” by Ellen Goodman, she used a variety of rhetorical devices to tell how she feels Phil, and other working class Americans, work too hard and end up sacrificing their lives, hobbies, and families for a chance at success and how the ideology of big companies ruin the lives of their own.
Goodman utilized numerical diction throughout the story. Goodman demonstrated numerical diction with a phrase like “fifty-one years old,” and that he worked “six days a week,” on a “four-day week.” Goodman did this to convey how Phil’s life was all facts and statistics with little meaning outside of work. All aspects of his life were considered work, even “ a monthly golf game,” was an obligation that needed to be accomplished. He cared so much about his job and getting things done that he took for granted the simple things that should have brought love and happiness into his life. The numbers were the motivation and key principles in his life rather than his family, friends and
…show more content…
He strived to be and work like “the Important People,” even though Phil was “one of six vice-presidents,” who could possibly be “moved to the top spot.” The author did this to show how little he meant to the company and how easily forgotten and replaceable he was. Phil’s “dearly beloved” children were like him to the company, easily dismissed and forgotten. Goodman never addressed Phil’s children by name only things like “eldest” and “the boy.” The author used the generic terms of the children to demonstrate that the ideology of the company had made him think his work and the amount of hours he put in were more important than his

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    To find a job today requires thinking outside the box and being creative, like finding a unicorn. People become more desperate to find work in today’s economy, making it a job itself to make sure the bills are paid on time. The difficulty of finding a nice paying job isn’t the only thing that’s changed though. The hierarchy of the work environment is something that has also gone under some improvements, especially for those who work under their own roof. People are clinging to their work because the economy today is giving them no alternative, causing a lack in social interaction with the people they care about and changing the way family values portrayed. Richard Sennett’s article “No Long Term: New Work and the Corrosion of Character” uses two people, Enrico and his son Rico, to convey that idea. Because of the rapidly changing economy today, a job becomes scarcer and causes a lack of interaction and hierarchy within family households along with businesses.…

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Later, the author uses anecdotes of Phil’s family and details about his personal life to show how much time he spent at work and how it affected his family, furthering Goodman’s resentment toward Phil and what he represents. “A company friend said, ‘I know how much you will miss him.’ And she [Phil’s wife] answered, ‘I already have.’” Because Phil was rarely at home and spent most of his time at the…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The importance of working and family is always facing one another. Working parents tend to spend less quality time with their children because of work demand. In modern America there’s more responsibilities that have to be taken cared of. Now, there is no time to time to waste. Gopnik worries about his daughter’s imaginary friend by writing, “I was concerned, though, that Charlie Ravioli might also be the sign of some “trauma,” some loneliness in Olivia’s life reflected in imaginary form” (154). Olivia who is just a three-year-old child is seeing the effects of capitalism. Her older brother is busy with his activities and her parents are busy with work. Olivia’s mimicking of her mother created this imaginary friend called Charlie Ravioli. She would constantly hear her mother talk on the phone with friends about work and Olivia would mimic that. Her imaginary friend who is too busy to play with her bounces between work and meeting, leaving no time to play with Olivia Gopnik. Mr. Ravioli’s character is a suggestion to the busyness she sees in her daily life. Therefore, Olivia is just creating and mimicking everything that she sees. The way Olivia rushes when she speaks on the phone is learnt from her mother. Parents take up a huge role in their children. Likewise, Hochschild argues how children as creating a similar lifestyle as their parents. She writes, “In other families, parents seemed to encourage children to develop schedules parallel to and as their own” (190). Due to the increase of the working demand, parents are trying to make their children’s schedules similar to theirs. Parents are constantly lacking time and cannot do certain activities with their children, by having parallel schedules everyone will be able to enjoy time together. Creating a parallel schedule is going to keep children busy as well. Eventually they will develop a similar lifestyle…

    • 1748 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Phil’s relationship with his family is another place where Goodman uses rhetorical devices to place heavy fault on him. The image created as she writes about his eldest son “researching his father” by scouring the neighborhood talks of the distance in their relationship. Their family dynamic is obviously strangly skewed from what would normally be expected in a household. Seeing as the children’s relationship with their mother is intact, Goodman must be trying to communicate with the audience that Phil is to be held accountable. Another image of Phil’s faults are created as Goodman talks about the dynamic within Phil’s marriage, stating that his wife stopped believing she was more important than his work years ago, “when the children were small.”…

    • 241 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Andresky Fraser Summary

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The article by Jill Andresky Fraser talks about the problems faced by people who are working in corporate America. She frames the problem by talking to people who are living a comfortable life and are working hard in their jobs and discussing their work and life. The article exposes the life of employees of large corporations who are ideal employees and are doing the best they can, but are constantly stressed and feel the tension of their jobs seeping into their life. They have to constantly work and hardly get any time when they can relax and not think about their work. The article describes the kind of life the well paid employees of large corporations live, how they are treated by their companies, and how the companies see them.…

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Work is defined as a job or activity that one does regularly in order to earn money, yet the concept of work seems to be a controversial topic many argue about. Those who do work are often happy with their job but there are also those who are dissatisfied. Perhaps this controversy is due to Social Darwinism, also known as the survival of the fittest, by brainwashing society to believe that success is being superior to others. This mutual theme of Social Darwinism is presented amongst the poems Night Waitress by Lynda Hull, Singapore by Mary Oliver, and Hard Work by Stephen Dunn. The biggest dispute is if people are working to survive or working to be…

    • 118 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Andrew carnegie

    • 1840 Words
    • 5 Pages

    According to Carnegie, the Industrial Age of the U.S. was witness to a great divide in humanity. American Business was able to grow by more than 400 percent between 1860 and 1900 alone. Similarly the nation’s wealth capitalized from 16 billion to 18 billion in this short time. As a product of the Laissez Faire ideology (little to no government regulation in the market), monopolies were allowed to emerge. John D. Rockefeller, J.P. Morgan, and Andrew Carnegie became large public figures from their mastery of Big Business and the economy. However, while the economy and business prospered, many common workers suffered from 10 hour workdays for six days a week, low wages of one dollar and fifty cents per hour, abhorred working conditions, and sometimes serious injuries causing death: on average, 35,000 deaths and 500,000 injuries per year, as reported by Claver.gprep.org in 1890. Carnegie viewed the poor conditions and long hours as a negative aspect of the Gilded Age but argues that the conditions are not purposeful, but a product of the Gilded Age that “forces employers in the strictest economies” to cut back on safety…

    • 1840 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Rhetorical Essay

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Ellen Goodman’s attitude toward Phil in “The Company Man” seems to be frustration and disappointment. She explains how Phil, the main subject practically worked himself to death. He was a “workaholic,” meaning he put his work above anything and anyone, even his wife and children. This explains Goodman’s disappointment towards Phil because he let work take over his life and force him to push away his loved ones and close family members. The author expresses frustration by writing in the passage that Phil let work cause him to work himself to death finally and precisely. The obituary said that he had died from coronary thrombosis, which is a blockage of the flow of blood to the heart, caused by a blood clot in a coronary artery. Everyone who was close to him knew that instantly because of their knowing of Phil personally. Phil was a fifty one year old vice president who never stopped working, even on his off days. On the day he died, that Sunday was supposed to be his off day but he was still working. Goodman uses description to describe and explain how Phil worked himself to death. She stated that he was vice president at his company, he had no outside extracurricular interests, and how he worked like the Important People. Goodman also uses contrast and comparison to explain her attitude toward Phil as a working man. She compares Phil to his friends and acquaintances by stating that after Phil died, his friends and close ones began to think for five or ten minutes about how they were living their lives. They may have been going at the same rate as Phil, so after they seen him put to death by working, they began to think about how much they work and how they can avoid dying due to work. Goodman also uses…

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The American labor force of the late 1800s and early 1900s was weak, uneducated, and forever trapped by the low-pay and harsh conditions of work and life; there was virtually no way out, as explained in Thomas O’Donnell’s Testimony. Everyone was caught in a rut, starving and poor; hoping for a better future, yet knowing that nothing else awaited them. “How could [they] go…walk?” (O’Donnell 31).…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the play “ Death of a Salesman” by Arthur Miller, presents a common view of the American dream. The main character, Willy Loman, struggles to become a successful salesman; he’s trying to make himself feel better by lie to his family and himself. He holds onto a strong belief in the American dream.Willy cannot face the reality and begins to daydream how to success. Although he gets fired by his boss, Willy never seems to give up on his dream, and refuse to accept a job that Howard offered to him in order to retain his pride. In this play, Miller creates a character in Willy, whose determination, belief, and dreaming illustrate the person within a capitalistic society.…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the piece, Goodman reveals details about Phil’s life in a clinical manner to reveal her heartfelt indifference towards him. When the wife answers with “I already have” to how much she will miss her husband in lines 39 to 41, her answer shows the brutal truth in their almost nonexistent marriage, in which she had long given up on loving him. Goodman also provides details about Phil’s relationship with his children in lines 45 to 56, who “had nothing…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The laboring class argues that work conditions were horrible; they were unsanitary, overbearing, exhausting, and the list continues. While this argument holds true, it cannot be denied that if more money had been spent on salaries and the beautification of the working environment, the manufacturers would have had no wealth to redistribute to philanthropist purposes. If Rockefeller had not “stolen” from his workers, who then would have contributed to the University of Chicago’s educational and enlightenment funds? If Carnegie had not donated his funds to the creation and prosperity of Carnegie University, how then would the University’s present day achievements have come alive? The fact of…

    • 475 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The implications of the work ethic Sheehy describes for the future of Americans business are tomorrow’s leaders of America are ones that feel that you must claw your way to the top. They show characteristics of someone who would step on anyone or do anything to get what they want. It shows implications of a lot of ill will being performed in the future and how the structure of business competition may be a bit more competitive in the future.…

    • 977 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Bibliography: * Impoco J. “Dying to work” U.S. News and World Report 110.10 (1991): 24.…

    • 1941 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the play The Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller, an event which influenced me to think differently about the dangers of a materialistic and consumerist society was the suicide of Willy. A critique, Nas Mulhasas wrote, “Miller alludes ‘American dream’, which is an effect of capitalism and consumerism, through the depiction of the protagonist Willy... and moves further to criticize these ideas by showing tragic end of Willy Loman.” Throughout the play, the reader can see how Willy’s need for materialistic riches leads to his mental and physical undoing. The want for riches caused him to focus on the wrong things in life, and eventually led to him wasting away his entire life, in hope of becoming richer and more…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays