Paragraph on Tyack and Cuban’s Ideas
By
Joanie Rice
Joanie.rice@waldenu.edu
Student ID# A00109444
School: Richard W. Riley College of Education and Leadership
Program: PhD in Education
Specialization: Learning, Instruction, and Innovation
Instructor: Dr. Gaddy
Walden University
September 25, 2013
Your Name: Joanie Rice__________________________________________
Module 2, Assignment 1: Key Ideas of Tyack and Cuban
In your own words, summarize each chapter in Tyack and Cuban’s Tinkering Toward Utopia. Write one sentence for each chapter in your own words. Do not include any quotations.
Prologue: Learning from the Past
Reformers today need to focus on ways to help teachers improve instruction from the inside out.
Chapter 1: Progress or Regress?
Progress or regress, we are still left with the problem of those who live in poverty.
Chapter 2: Policy Cycles and Institutional Trends
Changes in schools do show some cycles, but most of the messages remain the same.
Chapter 3: How Schools Change Reforms
If teachers would be more involved while collaborating and sharing information there could be more effective school reform.
Chapter 4: Why the Grammar of Schooling Persists
The Grammar of schooling provided a stable structure for a vast number of people.
Chapter 5: Reinventing Schooling
Reinventing schooling is correcting and continuing what is best about our present system.
Epilogue: Looking toward the Future
Education is a process of recycling democracy to create a healthy common good in society.
Tyack and Cuban’s “grand theory” or “big idea”:
Education can change society.
Read your summary sentences carefully. Write one succinct paragraph sharing what Tyack and Cuban’s main ideas are regarding the assumptions and purposes of public education, the politicization of public education, and the interaction of social change and school reform. You will demonstrate that you have been a critical reader as you capture the essence of Tyack and Cuban’s ideas during this period of their writing.
Tyack and Cuban felt that one of the purposes of education was to change society. Their thoughts are that changes in schools show cycles based on trends, but messages remain the same. Reformers today need to focus on ways to help teachers improve instruction from the inside out. Education is a process of recycling democracy to create a healthy common good in society.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Currently, several teachers in an elementary school are ineffectively teaching curriculum concepts they are required to teach. In return, students are confused, frustrated, and falling behind. When students are confused by what their teacher is trying to teach them, they become frustrated. When they become frustrated, they give up and end up not learning what the teacher wanted them to learn. This in turn causes them to make bad grades and fall behind grade level expectations.…
- 1381 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Teachers should be able to inspire students, make them apply what they learn and most importantly, make students want to learn. Sometimes it can be beneficial for teachers to work together to help each other with student specific ideas. “Teachers at Donaldson Elementary School in our district were reluctant to spend large chunks of their early-out times in meetings supposedly intended to promote ‘continuous improvement.’ But when they began to see collective progress, a direct result of their focused collaboration, the meetings became more meaningful. A good example is what happened in 2nd grade writing: students’ difficulty in writing in writing descriptive settings. After the team brainstormed, a team member proposed having student’s first draw then describe in writing the setting they imagined for their stories. The number of students able to write high-quality descriptions went from just a few to almost the entire 2nd grade class” (Schmoker 11) Like previously noted, many previous reforms have been solely based on curriculum and not enough attention is put on teachers. “The central-concern is for the teachers to become better equipped to know what new strategies to adopt and how to adopt them.” (Caine and Caine 187) This quote originates from a brain based approach, and this and many other…
- 3020 Words
- 13 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Education has always been a basic human right, across every society around the world. We have always needed to disseminate information and teach people about different skills in order to perpetuate our societies, as they cannot function if people will never go beyond the basics and specialize. However, it is also because of education that we become more holistic people, taking in new ideas and thinking about them, allowing us to develop ourselves as an individual. This is why education is important in creating informed citizens within our own societies, creating our individual “voice” and instigate change within our societies. James Baldwin’s article “A Talk to Teachers” stresses this, as he discusses that education is important in the…
- 1192 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Great principals also play a part in helping teachers become successful as part of a strong, well-supported instructional team. Mulford (2003) suggested that top-performing teachers can make a remarkable difference in the achievement of students. Students who are assigned to top-performing teachers every year experience a higher rate of achievement than those that do not. In the last ten years the federal government has developed ways to make sure that there are effective teacher in every classroom, and an efficient school leader on each campus. Each instructor and administrator will have access to on-going training support that they may need to be successful (Mulford, 2003).…
- 1452 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Educators want to improve the work they do for students, their families, and the community. Whether its instruction, school climate, leadership, family engagement, or any of the other issues schools face on a daily basis, all educators need tools to help them improve their actions and methods. (Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development, 2012)…
- 555 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Time and time again, Hollywood has presented the power and influence a good teacher can have on the lives of young students. Most of us have had an influential teacher at least once in our lives. Imagine what we could have become if all our teachers had been willing to pull extra weight to help us achieve our full potential. In today's society, the public school system for K-12 is failing. America has become in the lowest percentile in the world for math and science. How can this be in a country with so many freedoms and advantages? Perhaps one of the largest factors in the failing school system is the lack of good teachers. At the head of this crashing train is tenure. We need to rid public school systems of tenure, implement more aggressive evaluation processes for educators, and reward or discipline teachers according to their achievements in the classroom. America's public school system would be better off eliminating tenure and implementing a two tier system based on teacher merit.…
- 2419 Words
- 10 Pages
Best Essays -
teachers can make a huge difference with giving correct expectations to the class along with the student. As teachers we must remember to model and be the example for the students if you put them in a group to work join a group with them and then the students will see you doing it is well and then they know the correct behavior. I don't want to be the teacher who gives an assignment and then retracts back at the desk filling out grades I want to be involved and relate to the students and work with them.…
- 628 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
As a result many politicians found themselves called upon to "fix the schools" and "restore their greatness," triggering a 15-year period of reform. Although most experts believe further reforms are warranted, the agreement ends there. Some want to toughen curriculum requirements and increase teachers' salaries to attract more competent teachers, while others think the answer lies in tackling issues such as poor parenting and poverty, which they believe are the main impediments to progress in education. Still…
- 2963 Words
- 12 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In today’s school system where ‘no child is left behind’; the teacher is set up for failure. Combined with achieving metrics on standard testing scores; these extrinsic motivators seem to be the only thing presented to teachers today. They are expected to be high quality teachers who are able to inspire, mentor, design and align lessons, differentiate instruction, craft assessments, analyze data, grade homework, connect with parents, enforce discipline, promote fitness, cultivate a love of learning, write individualized education programs, and so on . Look at what we are expecting of our teachers today, and how we are trying to motivate them. The joy of teaching students to make their own decisions and succeed in life seems to be gone.…
- 400 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Therefore, school reform is the best way to go. School reform could unlock new ways to teach students. No more lectures and each student could connect in their own way. This doesn’t mean this change has to happen all at once. We could start slow with getting rid of standardised testing for example. Just something small to ease the blow. So in conclusion the american school system needs reform, students are unhappy, they are over stressed and students that learn a different way, even a little bit different, are left behind in the dust and fall behind. School reform needs to happen. The curriculum isn't useful, kids are being left behind and no one does anything about it. It's just…
- 859 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Many students feel that teacher’s effort aren’t enough. Junior Collin Phillips says he wishes teachers would “communicate more to keep the classes consistent, and make sure that students are learning effectively and equally in each…
- 707 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
at the reform movement, however, one must first look at the so called problem of…
- 1157 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Teachers can gauge where their students are at and provide the supports needed to push their students to where they need to be both academically and…
- 714 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Education empowers individuals to contribute to society, fulfil their personal talents, fulfil their civic responsibilities and carry tradition forward (Trilling and Hood, 2001:9).…
- 3987 Words
- 13 Pages
Powerful Essays -
With more teachers per students in classrooms, there would be more individual help and attention for each student. If students were getting more individual attention, help and guidance, the success rate of students would be much higher. This would eliminate the need for government wide testing and rules such as the No Child Left Behind Act. It would also decrease the pressure and strain put on teachers. A lot of teachers don’t like federal education involvement. Not because it holds them to a standard, but because a lot of teachers feel these rules hold them to the wrong…
- 900 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays