Preview

The Dangers Of Police Discretion

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
492 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Dangers Of Police Discretion
Police discretion essentially alludes to the decision-making power/choice that is afforded to police in terms of the handling of a given situation; the fewer rules given to officers and the more individual power they wield, the greater the discretion. Alternately, with more rules placed on officers concerning the ways in which they should conduct themselves/police business, the lower the level of discretion.
In many ways, police discretion is very important; every day, officers are faced with situations of varying danger and complexity. No situation is ever exactly the same; even routine traffic stops are ever changing because of different citizens of the public that officers encounter, all of which could pose possible danger to law enforcement
…show more content…
Many factors contribute to police discretionary behavior, including situational (e.g. race of suspect) , organizational (e.g. police departments/their varying rules and expectations), and environmental characteristics (e.g. racial or socioeconomic composition of given neighborhood or area patrolled by police), in addition to characteristics of the individual officer (such as personal beliefs/morals). All of these factors combined leave far too much availability for unfair treatment of civilians, as all officers, and areas across the country in which they patrol, are different; one officer could have bias against a certain groups of civilians that could sway his/her discretion; different officers could exercise varying levels of harshness in arrests/traffic stops if the option was available to them (ie: a citizen could receive a warning from one officer, while another (for committing the same offense) could be fined, arrested, etc). High levels of police discretion leaves far too much power to an individual officer and his or her own personal beliefs, which should not have any place in a person’s working environment that pertains to the policing of peoples of varied race, gender, religion, etc. For this reason, in addition to factors listed above that influence the behavior of police discretion, I believe that officers should exercise limited discretion to avoid (to the greatest extent possible) any/all bias in the treatment of American

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    The ethical or unethical use of force is determined by the community, society, or a judge and jury. Police officers that misuse their authority never seem to consider that nowadays the citizens in American society frequently utilize their electrical devices to record the unnecessary deadly force by police officers on minorities. Such misuse of authority against minorities seems to bringabout unconstructive results and grave concerns about the police officers that misuse their authority, and how it strongly appears that they are not held accountable for the unwarranted fatalshootings of minority individuals. The cause and effects of such unwarranted shooting appears toof had a negative impact on…

    • 1205 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    When police officers are not punished for behaving inappropriately, the criminal justice system ignores an unnecessary lapse in its operation. Not every case handled by law enforcement will be cut and dry. Many factors contribute to unique situations that require equally unique solutions. Cases like those of Michael Brown and Eric Garner speak to that. However, when an officer meant to uphold the law and act in good faith engages in misconduct, it is only logical that they be disciplined for their actions. Additionally, measures must be taken to hold law enforcement accountable for their actions. It is crucial for law enforcement to maintain a good relationship with their communities. A skewed power dynamic can only lead to issues.…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the early hours of March 3, 1991, a police chase in Los Angeles ended in an incident that would become synonymous with police brutality: the beating of a young man named Rodney King by members of the Los Angeles Police Department. An amateur video, televised nationwide, showed King lying on the ground while three officers kicked him and struck him repeatedly with their nightsticks. No one who viewed that beating will ever forget its viciousness. The Rodney King incident projected the brutal reality of police abuse into living rooms across the nation, and for a while, the problem was front page news. Political leaders condemned police use of excessive force and appointed special commissions to investigate incidents of brutality. The media covered the issue extensively, calling particular attention to the fact that police abuse was not evenly…

    • 422 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As of now, the current system is experiencing an overflow of cases from felonies and misdemeanors which already takes days even months to resolved. And so the use of police discretion helps the court system trust the police department to use all their resources and good judgment to stop or continue a criminal process. Police discretion is not supposed to be use recklessly it should only be use on certain situations with good reasons. When the police officer uses discretion takes into consideration standards like profession, legal, social and moral norms as well as offender’s age, race, economic status, gender. Besides giving them a warning for their offence they will offer lectures depending on the severity of the crime.…

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Ever wonder if police officers know what its like to be a citizen under jurisdiction, with the same sense of distrust and sense of unfaithfulness in the individuals who are supposed to protect? People must also realize that citizens will never know what it is like to be police officers. They take too much crap from people who don't appreciate their services. Police officers also have their personal lives to worry about. That is stress that a lot can't understand, let alone coupe with. There are a lot of officers that take their authority to a whole new level. These officers offer their lives in protection of its citizens, not just for a check, but also for a change. Bad apples spoil the bunch, yes, but can society blame and stereotype every officer of the law because of these people? Why do people run from the cops? The same reason people stick up their middle fingers when they confront us in the streets when they aren't looking, distrust. The Tim Thomas case, along with the mishaps of the Amadou Diallo situation are perfect examples of racial profiling. Is it right to do so? Some say that racial profiling helps the crime rate go down, while others strongly disagree. Rodney King exposed how corrupt the Los Angeles Police Department was, while the Rampart case proves that the Department still has made little to no progress. One still has to understand the police officers perspectives on how difficult this job really is.…

    • 1284 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is not an absolute to every situation every time. There are different people involved in different locations with different attitudes. Some officers believe that politicians enact laws to make symbolic statements and that they do not desire full enforcement of the laws. Age, race, income, attitude toward the officer, gender, and income status are all factors of how police respond to a situation. Police are more likely to use more force against African Americans and they are less likely to take a juvenile complaint as serious as an adult. Discretion is used at all levels of the criminal justice system. The police, lawyers, courts, individuals, and corrections all have instances such as deciding minor differences in matters such as a routine pull over for the police, whether to take a case or not for lawyers, whether to break the law or not for citizens, and for judges how long of a sentence should be handed down. Discretion being defined as the ability or power to decide responsibly or the freedom to act or judge on ones own, in this instance still according to the law and regardless of ones own prejudices. Police are the largest and most visible segment of the criminal justice system. Many decisions a policeman or women make is at his or her own discretion. Police have a wide range of discretion in their multiple daily duties. Discretion can be seen when an officer decides whether to pull a car over, question some…

    • 477 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Police Discretion

    • 538 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Police discretion is issued to officers for the purpose of maintaining a just society. Discretion is defined the ability to form decisions based on their own judgment. These decisions are concluded through copious reasons such an officer’s experience or through their own individual backgrounds. Police discretion has the ability to dismiss minor crimes, yet laws exist where discretion is invalid and officers must accomplish whatever means legally to punish the criminal.…

    • 538 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Samuel Walker (1993) asserts the problem is not with the use of discretion, but the misuse of discretion in the Criminal Justice System. According to Walker (1993) “The Criminal Justice System is nothing more than the sum total of a series of discretionary decisions by innumerable officials.” (Walker 1993 p.4) Charles Klahm and Rob Tillyer (2015) explains that “Exposure, activity, and performance independently impact the likelihood of the officer initiating discretionary.”(Charles Klahm and Rob Tillyer, 2015 348). The assumption is police officers who are routinely exposed to diversity among age, race, gender, and criminal or noncriminal individuals effect the police use of discretion. The activities that police officers partake in is another factor that shapes the police use of discretion. The suggestion is that police officer's past behavior will reflect their future behavior in other words. Similar to activity, performance looks at police officers past performance. The assertion is that police officers who perform discretionary searches where contraband was founded were more likely to continue using discretion when conducting…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Patrol officers use discretion each and every time while on shift. They will respond to a variety of calls and have to make a decision on scene whether to charge a subject or arrest them. Patrol officers also work traffic and enforce moving violations and equipment violations. Try to imagine if officers did not have discretion and had to fully enforce the law each time a violation occurred. This would have a negative impact on community relations and would also completely saturate our court systems that struggle already with caseloads. However, discretion allows the officer to make a judgment in the field based on the totality of the circumstances to decide which offenders should be tried through the criminal justice system and which should…

    • 380 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Police officers in the United States and around the world have an extremely hard job both physically and mentally. Police discretion is a tool that officers use every day on their jobs (Odom 2009). It is a decision making process where the officer deduces from the situation and observation the best solution. For example, an officer pulls over a driver for running a red light. The officer must decide whether or not to issue the driver a citation. If the officer feels the driver isn’t intoxicated, or a danger to others, the officer may let the driver go with just a warning. The officer might pull over another car for the same thing, but issue the citation because the driver was a danger to other drivers on the road.…

    • 576 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Police Officer Discretion

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Police officers have a large amount of discretion. This stage of the crime is the most influential to a case. What a police officer decides to charge an individual for and whether or not they charge them at all can completely affect how a case is carried out. For example, let’s say that and individual was going 10 miles per hour over the speed limit and a police officer pulled them over for it. The individual breaking the law was speeding because a loved one was in the hospital. It is now the officer’s decision to either hold this person responsible and give them a ticket or let them off with a warning because of the…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the wake of unjust police brutality occurring throughout the United States, racial profiling has transpired into an even larger issue than previously perceived. It has led to the targeting of specific minority groups in order to counter terrorism and danger. One can easily manage to see why racial profiling is utilized. Many argue that the police may appear racist when making charges, but are actually being objective. Others believe that all information available in a case is necessary to come to a conclusion and unusual activity is most often associated with particular ethnic backgrounds. Lastly, some feel as though law enforcement officials have the mental capacity to exercise their own professional judgment. These arguments appear valid,…

    • 216 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Police Discretion

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In most situations that police officers have to deal with, they are given a certain degree of discretion to decide not only when to use force, but also about which type of force to use. No matter what the situation is or what it seems to be at the moment, it requires the officer on the scene to analyze that particular situation and apply his or her training and moral values when choosing how to react. Police officers and law enforcement personnel hold the lives of each and every individual that they come into contact with in their power every day.…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Excessive Force Essay

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Recently there have been a number of cases that involve the U.S policing force using excessive force. This has caused an uproar in many communities concerning the lack of equality among all races. Police have to use a certain amount of force to overcome a suspect, but the recent deaths caused by the hands of the police have fueled a heated debate among Americans. In America, black males are generally perceived to be more aggressive and dangerous than the average white male. Police are trained to assess the level of threat. This racial bias can affect the way a police officer might think. Making the situation seem “reasonable” on one hand and “unreasonable” on the other. There has been a rift between policing…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Police Discretion

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Looking at the criminal justice system as a whole, I find that the police officers are the ones who exercise the most discretion. They maintain the ability to enforce the law at anytime and anywhere, in uniform and out of uniform. For example, they are the ones who make the decisions regarding who they will pull over and who they will arrest. They must make a discretionary decision on what to do about a crime in progress if, for instance, they are out of uniform shopping with their family. There can be quite a number of important decisions facing them everyday, especially if they are not in their uniforms.…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays