This, I believe is how Hester dealt with her guilt and how Arthur ultimately died. Hester's sin was public while Arthur's was private. In Hester's case, the shame was only momentary. While it never truly went away, overtime the shame, guilt, and sin were all pushed onto the back burner and stayed there only occasionally resurfacing. Even though Hester had her ever constant reminders of the letter A and the child that came from the sin, she still managed to stay strong and rebel against the intended meaning of the letter A; Changing it from Adulterer to Able. One could argue that it is only a matter of personality. Hester was brave and strong while Dimmesdale was cowardly and weak. Hester, it seems, was able to deal with the guilt, while Arthur was self-loathing and continued to carve or brand his own letter A into his skin. In my opinion, you can see it both ways. Yes Dimmesdale is self-loathing, weak, and cowardice, and that might just be his personality, although the private guilt may be responsible for all of his horrible traits. You could also argue that his personality is what caused his private suffering. Had he revealed that he was the man that sinned with Hester, he may not have basically killed himself in the end. His personality however prohibits him from making that leap and admitting to the public that he was Pearl's father and Hester's fellow
This, I believe is how Hester dealt with her guilt and how Arthur ultimately died. Hester's sin was public while Arthur's was private. In Hester's case, the shame was only momentary. While it never truly went away, overtime the shame, guilt, and sin were all pushed onto the back burner and stayed there only occasionally resurfacing. Even though Hester had her ever constant reminders of the letter A and the child that came from the sin, she still managed to stay strong and rebel against the intended meaning of the letter A; Changing it from Adulterer to Able. One could argue that it is only a matter of personality. Hester was brave and strong while Dimmesdale was cowardly and weak. Hester, it seems, was able to deal with the guilt, while Arthur was self-loathing and continued to carve or brand his own letter A into his skin. In my opinion, you can see it both ways. Yes Dimmesdale is self-loathing, weak, and cowardice, and that might just be his personality, although the private guilt may be responsible for all of his horrible traits. You could also argue that his personality is what caused his private suffering. Had he revealed that he was the man that sinned with Hester, he may not have basically killed himself in the end. His personality however prohibits him from making that leap and admitting to the public that he was Pearl's father and Hester's fellow