Preview

The Inaccurate Portrayal Of The Characters Of Miranda And Hamilton

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
564 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Inaccurate Portrayal Of The Characters Of Miranda And Hamilton
Have you ever heard a story from a hip hop point of view? “Hamilton” by Lin-Manuel Miranda is about Alexander Hamilton’s life and the role he played in the American Revolution and how he impacted the American people through music and how his life was and how he grew. Miranda accurately portrays history within Hamilton through historical facts and inaccurately through making it modern. These choices in portrayal impact the reader or listener’s understanding of the characters, time period, or musical by making it modern and not as realistic for the time. Lin-Manuel Miranda makes an accurate portrayal of the characters by giving most of them the right historical background for them and the events they go through but he inaccurately portrays the characters by making them modern and over exaggerating the drama and what they have to do in life. …show more content…
In “Satisfied” Eliza says “I’m a girl in a world in which/ My only job is to marry rich/ My father has no sons so I’m the one/ Who has to social climb for one..” This proves that she gave up Hamilton for Eliza but it wasn't accurate.In this quote it says that she has no brothers but that is inaccurate because she does have brothers to take up the job socially but she still gives up Hamilton for Eliza even if it wasn't for the same reasons. Lin-Manuel Miranda accurately portrayed the time period of the Revolutionary War by capturing the energy and mood of the time and staying true. He inaccurately portrayed it by condensing the time periods and made it more modern for the time period. For example, Washington says that Jefferson resigned, but

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Lin-Manuel Miranda’s newest Broadway musical Hamilton, that made it’s big break last year, 2015, is taking America's youth by storm. Hamilton is a hip-hop/rap musical about one of America's lesser known founding fathers and the first Secretary of Treasury Alexander Hamilton, or as he is more commonly known, the face off of the $10 bill. It illustrates major events in Hamilton's life along with the details in his wife’s, children's, friends, and enemies lives, from his birth to his death. The musical features 49 songs written by Manuel, the most known being My Shot, Aaron Burr, Sir and Alexander Hamilton. The musical teaches students about the revolutionary war and the time period. This isn’t Miranda's first Broadway musical, as his production,…

    • 211 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Lin-Manuel Miranda has performed in many shows and productions. Soon after college he wrote a musical called In The Heights. Later on this became a broadway production in which he starred. He has also worked on countless other productions such as West Side Story and Bring It On the Musical. That's not all though! He has also performed in TV shows and movies. Some examples of this are, Modern Family, How I Met Your Mother, and The Odd Life Of Timothy Green. In addition, he also wrote and performed in the now well known broadway musical Hamilton. Hamilton is all about the life of one of the great founding fathers of America, Alexander Hamilton. It has become a very popular musical across the country. Lastly, he wrote all of the music…

    • 168 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The very first conversation they exchanged to each other was otherwise the most insulting argument two people of the opposite genders could ever hold. Angelica had stormed in one day, ranting in Hamilton's defence and her view point about the current social status for women, while Jefferson, being too ignorant and filled with pride, lamely shrugged her off. Soon, swears, insults and disagreements flew in the air and Thomas, for a moment, had actually thought he had finally found a person equally as annoying as Hamilton, if not, maybe even more! During the heat of the dispute, Jefferson could not lie though. Angelica's beliefs and opinions held strong with her and she seemed to have a mind he didn't usually see in women. It all ended once James Madison broke the two up and Angelica left furious, swearing on her dear soul she would never come back to see him, and back then, Jefferson was thankful to that.…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I learned a lot from Darcy, Sarah, and Miranda's miscue analysis. I really like how the teacher just didn't bring up the student's weaknesses but also her strengths. That can really boost a student's self confident level if they are struggling with a subject. From this section I hope to remember that the quantity of easy and interesting reading that the student's pick will help them become successful readers. By having the student's self select their own reading material will help them make meaning out of the text. Another thing I hope to remember from this section is that students who overuse phonics need to come up with another word when struggling that sounds like a real word that makes sense. Students can also say "blank" when struggling…

    • 174 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The reason I was able to see the impact they had on our country is because John E. Ferling, the author, described the hardships and successes of each person in great detail starting from the very beginning and continuing on all the way to the very end of their lives. John E. Ferling approached this book with a higher opinion of Jefferson, but gained greater appreciation for Hamilton towards the end. I enjoyed learning more about the forming of our nation and the lives of some of our founding fathers. I am inclined to learn more about the characters in the book because the play, ‘Hamilton’ on Broadway is something I’ve wanted to see for a while. I’m interested to see how similar and accurate the play is compared to the book. This author’s writing style is something I enjoyed reading, but I don’t think reading another one of his books is something I’d take part in. My recommendation for this book would be to read it for school and other educational purposes, but only read it for pleasure if you thoroughly enjoy…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “In the Heights” was his first musical to reach Broadway. The musical was about a young man, played by Lin, growing up as a teenager in the rough parts of Puerto Rico. He had used a lot of his grandmother’s stories to really get a connection with what Puerto Rico had been like. After “In the Heights” Lin was hired to help write the score for the Broadway musical “Bring it On”. While on vacation from writing, Lin decided to pick up the book Alexander Hamilton by Ron Chernow, and started reading. Automatically Lin compared to hard life of Alexander Hamilton to the struggles he often heard in hip hop or rap songs. After this he decided that he would write a modern, hip hop, musical about Hamilton’s life. It took him over one year to write the first song and another year for the second. Finally, after six years of work he was finished writing “Hamilton”. “Hamilton” alone was awarded eleven Tony awards that Lin could add to his four other Tonys from “In the…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    As the number one fan of the musical “Hamilton”, I was immediately drawn to Washington & Hamilton: The Alliance That Forged America by Stephen F Knott and Tony Williams. I have always been interested in the relationship between George Washington and Alexander Hamilton, but have heard little about it prior to this book. I was really pulled into this book when I read the second paragraph of the introduction, “But one of the more important founding collaborations has been overlooked by readers: the unlikely partnership of George Washington and Alexander Hamilton” (pg XI). This sentence leads to the main point, which examines the odd yet critical alliance between Washington and Hamilton.…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hamilton believed that the upper-class ought to have a stake in the government, as they did during Shay’s Rebellion. “Give therefore to the first class a distinct, permanent share in the government…as they cannot receive any advantage by a change, they therefore will ever maintain good government.” Hamilton would have argued that the elite legislature in Massachusetts was in fact acting in the best interest of the state as they “cannot receive any advantage,” and as such there was no need to rebel. Hamilton’s trust in the upper-class, and general distrust of the mass of the people, meant that he would have certainly been opposed to the…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On December 14, 1780 Hamilton married Elizabeth Schuyler, the daughter of General Phillip Schuyler, at Schuyler Mansion in Albany, New York. A year after Hamilton’s marriage, he quit aide-de-camp, served in the Continental Congress, and shared his opinions about the weakness of the national government (The Famous People, “Alexander Hamilton”). Hamilton decided to convince Congress they needed a strong central government and many people opposed his ideas of a strong central government because they were worried that the central government may have too much…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Miranda is “Eve of an enchanted Paradise” (Works of W. Shakespeare vol 16), the meaning of innocence, beauty and simplicity. As soon as she meets Ferdinand, she is ready “to place her life, her love, her service beneath his feet” (Works of Shakespeare vol 16), which is opposed to what Fowles’ Miranda is doing. Though both are well educated, beautiful, they have different meanings of what life is about and what they should do in order to achieve fulfilment. Contrary to the cultural background, Fowles’s Miranda is a survivor, a woman who once being captured, learns to love life, while Shakespeare’s Miranda is fragile, always protected by the hardships of life by her loving father. Both Mirandas are imprisoned in a virtual cell, derived their…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hamilton understood that a strong central government would be needed to keep the fledgling country alive. In order to keep a strong government that understood the problems at hand, it needed to be run by first class, educated men. Hamilton also makes a good point in saying that, though Jeffersonians thought the rich would corrupt the government in order to profit for themselves, the rich had nothing to gain as they were already at the top of the social ladder. Whiele Hamilton was a realist, Jefferson was a romantic. He lagged…

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    They connected immediately and their relationship grew quickly. By December of that year they were married and had a short honeymoon in Eliza’s hometown. Eliza was described by Martha Washington, her close friend throughout their husbands political careers, as “my ideal of a true woman.” She was also a member of New York’s most high profile families, the daughter of Philip Schuyler. They were one of the richest families in the area so with this marriage, Hamilton earned some financial gain. After their honeymoon, Alexander returned to the war. In July of 1781, George Washington finally granted Hamilton the command and glory he craved.(Magnet) Hamilton organized the Battle of Yorktown which was the last big battle of the revolutionary war. His tactics took less poise and more blood. The British surrendered on October 19th, 1781 although they did not leave New York for another two…

    • 1587 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hamilton is an incredibly popular, highly awarded musical and its had this much success for a reason. Not only is it an incredibly well written piece of work, it deals with so many issues in today’s world. But it does this through the lens of a historical story. By addressing how the world looks now by observing how the world looked then we can see how far society has come and also see how far it still needs to go. This play address politics, race, and culture, and it works to advance society by uniting historically white dominated theater with the culturally diverse hip hop and rap genres of music.…

    • 511 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    An enrolled into King’s College (Modern Day Columbia University). Though Hamilton was sent to New York for academic purposes, with a evolution brewing Hamilton found himself more interested in politics. In 1774 Hamilton wrote his first political letter. This letter was pro-patriot and was against the British loyalists(“Alexander Hamilton Biography”). Hamilton left King’s College before graduating to join the patriot army. In 1775 he joined the New York Artillery Company and fought in the battles of Long Island, White Plains, and Trenton. In 1777 he fought in the battles of Brandywine Creek, Germantown, and Princeton.He was promoted to lieutenant colonel of the continental army in 1780. Later that year on December 14th Hamilton would marry Elizabeth (Eliza or Betsy) Schuyler at the Schuyler Mansion (“Eliza Schuyler Hamilton: Alexander Hamilton’s Beloved Wife”). He had only met Eliza a few months prior. Eliza Schuler was the daughter of the wealthy general Philip Schuyler. Her sibling include Angelica, Margarita, Philip, and John. In the eyes of many of the townspeople, they were the perfect couple. Sometime during this Alexander was promoted to being aide-de-camp to George Washington. While Hamilton was working his desk job he meant John Laurens, a patriot from South Carolina. John was an abolitionist just like Hamilton, they became great friends fast. Hamilton also met Marie-Joseph Paul Yves Roch Gilbert du Motier de…

    • 1897 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Musical theater has never truly been a diverse enterprise. Before Miranda wrote his shows, diversity had never been prevalent and styles of music in theater had never featured rap so heavily. Miranda was the first to reach out to different cultures and create stories that shadowed around true experiences immigrants to America have. Racial tension has been running high this past decade. Media, Police, and Politics have all played a major role in the raising of racial tension. Discrimination that has always been underlying in the media and the clear lack of diversity in the televised and produced world was becoming imminent to many. These people chose to stand up for their beliefs and thus an era of racial violence began in America. Most who played any kind of role in the creation of the government were white and male. Regardless, Miranda chose to retell the story of Alexander Hamilton involving women, people of various races, and sexual orientations. He introduces diversity never seen before into the media. Miranda is redefining the rules of…

    • 636 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays