Preview

The Irony of McCarthy's Use of Title in All the Pretty Horses

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1839 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Irony of McCarthy's Use of Title in All the Pretty Horses
"The Irony of McCarthy 's Use of Title"
In the novel All the Pretty Horses by Cormac McCarthy, the author shows how important the roles of the horses are in the story and how they relate to John Grady, the protagonist of the novel. The horse has played an important role in the development of America. It has been a form of transportation, easy muscle, and companionship. In the Wild West, it was an essential resource for a cowboy to do his daily chores. McCarthy describes horses as spiritual and as resembling the human soul; meaning that horses came in many different forms. Horses are pretty, ugly, wild, tame, etc. in the story, they have so many different descriptions and different types of personality that they appear to resemble humans. In the story, John Grady is able to communicate with horses beyond a level normal people could. He could look into a horse 's eyes and be able to see into its heart; because of this distinct relationship Grady is able to compare the world of horses to the world of humans. Throughout the novel, he learns that what he thinks of men and about his romantic idea of living in the world is completely false and wrong. Therefore, McCarthy 's title shows that life can be full of change; and, at times, it can be cruel and ironic. Because of this, McCarthy 's title shows how much a perspective can change when a man goes on an adventure and experiences things he did not experience before. Meaning that, McCarthy wanted readers to think before they read the book that life is pretty and easy, but after they read the book he wants the readers to know that life is not always how it seems.
John is a cowboy and as with all cowboys, their lives all revolve around the horse. While he is at home at his grandfather 's ranch, he basically spends all his time training and breaking horses. His whole life revolves around the knowledge of horses and he does not interact with many people causing him to not know about the true side of humans and



Cited: McCarthy, Cormac. All the Pretty Horses. New York: Vintage Books, 1992.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    John's personality is also completely different. He is entirely confident in himself (sometimes appearing arrogant) but believes he is right all of the time. This is one of the factors why the townspeople look up to him. But also one of the reasons the townspeople turned against him so fast when he admitted to adultery.…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The main person responsible for blocking John from becoming purposeful is his own son Johnny. Johnny doesn't talk with his dad, therefore, making him feel isolated from his son since he knows nothing about him. Whenever Johnny's dad tries to become functional with Johnny, Johnny makes his dad feel stupid for trying. Some more specific examples of this is when dad saw Johnny on the street, Johnny barely managed a wave. Also, when his dad went to see his son play games in the schoolyard, Johnny bluntly ignored his dad. Johnny is the main reason that John is not succeeding in becoming useful. However, the other members of the family also help Johnny in his evil deeds.…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cormac McCarthy gives his story All the Pretty Horses an unique organization. The book only has four chapters within, yet each chapter is lengthy. There are also very few flashbacks in this story. This flashback was needed, however, to show how things did not change after John Grady Cole’s grandfather died. “On the wall opposite above the sideboard was an oilpainting of horses. . . . his grandfather looked up from his plate at the painting,” shows the painting being there while his grandfather was alive and is stirs up John Grady’s memory of it. There was also one dream sequence in the novel. “That night he dreamt of horses in a field on a high plain . . . they ran in that resonance which is the world itself and which cannot be spoken but only praised,” implies how the horses are wild and…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    He had a tough time finding acceptance in the native boys, so much of his time was spent by himself. He has a close relationship with Linda, and feels protective of her around other men.…

    • 3612 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the novel All the Pretty Horses by Cormac McCarthy society is based on its economic constitution, common ideologies and social class structure. During the colonial era, the west was viewed as a place of opportunity filled with riches and prolific western civilization dating back to the late 1800’s.But as the years progressed, a shift in economic stability was underway as once wealthy westerners lost their profits and struggled to maintain their ranches. The ranch at which John Grady Cole resided waned in profits and became a financial burden, so Cole’s mother sold the ranch to lift that burden and because of this, Cole leaves Texas to embark on his new adventure to get away from the economical dilemma. Economics plays a main…

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Langdon's Childhood

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages

    So the story started when John was born, which was in 1741.The original state he was born in was New Hampshire, in the city of Portsmouth. His father was a farmer, which meant that his father worked hard for his son to have a better life than him. John family was in emigrated family and a very large family. During his childhood the education stuffed he was learning were pretty tough. He went to a Grammar school, which was not far from where he lived. Later on when he was a teenagers…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The last two paragraphs of All The Pretty Horses tie up most of the imagery, metaphors, and themes that he uses throughout the book. He fills the novel with insightful imagery to make us feel like you are there. We think it is both challenging and captivating. He uses a sunset to make things come to an end. McCarthy uses a sunset in the beginning of the novel and at the end. It’s used in the beginning of the book for his grandfather’s death and in the end for the novel ending.…

    • 596 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Within the novel All The Pretty Horses, Cormac McCarthy attempts to associate the appeal of the Wild West in comparison to its reality. A prevalent idea that concludes the book on a slightly somber note appears in the form of John Grady’s character going into the western plains. As the narrative comes to a close, it is the diction and imagery that ultimately show how John Grady lets the story end with his departure into his life as a cowboy, having completely bended into this unique lifestyle and having lost a piece of himself along with it.…

    • 768 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In both tales, the main characters interact with other cultures but, in very different ways. The typical American Western highlights a cowboy who is superior to other cultures. The romanticized American cowboy has no respect for any culture other than his own. Ethan shows this disrespect and hate early in the film by shooting the eyes out of a dead Native American so that he will have to wander between the worlds of life and death, never able to go to the heavens. Ethan hunts and slaughters many "savage" and "evil" Native Americans throughout the film. "The Searchers" romanticizes the American West myth of the righteous cowboy. All the Pretty Horses challenges this role of the American cowboy with the novel's main character: John Grady Cole. John Grady is not in search of bloodshed. Instead, John Grady is looking for a life that vanishes with the turn of the twentieth century. He is looking for a life of ranching, horses, and peacefulness. John Grady contradicts the romanticized "racist" cowboy, by valuing justice, responsibility, and loyalty. Cole treats other cultures with respect and trust. John meets the Hector family and comes to befriend them. In contrast to Ethan's treatment of the Native Americans, John Grady Cole treats the Hector family as equals, despite the difference in cultural backgrounds. Conflicting with the romanticized American cowboy, Cole treats other cultures with acceptance. When…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    John, who is Nanabush, enters the Anishnawbe community as a representation of disorder and chaos. Initially, the only relationship that John has within the community is with Lillian. Maggie asks John how he knows her mother and he informs her that he knew her from “A long time ago.” Maggie then questions him saying “You’re younger than me. This doesn’t make any sense” to which John replies “Yeah, I know. Isn’t it great? Who needs sense!” (Taylor 89). A lack of sense implies a lack of order and therefore promotes chaos and John's remark that the state of lacking sense is “great” situates his character as one that is comfortable and fimiliar with chaos. The various names of John are a depiction of the disorder he wishes to establish (examples of his stated names are ‘Tanner,’ ‘Richardson,’ ‘Prestor,’ ‘Clayton,’ ‘Matas,’ ‘Frum,’ ‘Savage,’ and ‘Smith’ (Austen)). By continually altering his name, John is able to create multiple reference points for his character which only furthers his ambiguity and chaotic nature. Another example of John's promotion of chaos occurs when he lies about the history of Natives in the museum (Taylor 240-41). By lying about the Native history, John is furthering the distance that exists between Natives and their oppressors which creates turmoil, thus causing a chaos of historical accuracy for the Anishnawbe community. Throughout the course of the novel, Virgil places importance and wonders about the significance of petroglyphs. Eventually, John tells Virgil that the drawings are not symbols or markings, to which Virgil exclaims that “they’re all nothing…

    • 423 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    John starts to open up to the group when he reveals his life at home with an abusive father who once burned a cigar on his arm for a simple mistake. But, after Andy’s character calls him out as a liar who is making up the story as part of his charade, he once again shuts everyone down but not before showing the cigar burn he received from his father. During the course of the movie, while harassing Claire for…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A story is comprised of literary elements and literary devices. The basic literary elements of a story are setting, character, conflict, point of view, plot and theme. A story must have all these elements in order to become a fully developed story. Aside from these elements, writers often use literary devices to enhance the story, perhaps making the story more popular. Irony, a statement meaning the opposite of what is written literally when taken in context is one of the popular literary devices used. R. H. Lawrence also uses various ironies in his short story, Rocking-Horse Winner. Consequently, the various ironies in the story Rocking-House Winner effectively help to enhance the story by further developing the literary elements.…

    • 909 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    John is rather a cold character showing no understanding or even wanting to understand his wife’s illness. He does not see it even as an illness but rather as her needing to pull herself together. He is almost fearful of any mention of mental illness and when she suggests her body is well but not her mind he gives her “a stern reproachful look” and describes it as a “false and foolish fancy”.…

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    From Alice Walker’s story, she recounts her experience watching Blue’s life. She recalls the feeling she had when she looked into the horse’s eyes. She described the feeling as one of horrible loneliness, which was shocking to her. Even a simple animal can convey so much emotion. She remembers when a new horse appeared on the property and Blue was happy. Time went by and the two horses became very close, and Blue’s new friend was eventually pregnant. Blue was content and happy, probably the happiest he has ever been; the look in his eyes conveyed the “this is itness”. As soon as this happened, the new pregnant horse was whisked away, it was all just for mating purposes. Blue was devastated, he thrashed around, and the author compares him to a person, filled with inconsolable grief. These people did not have the intent to provide this animal with companionship, they only wanted to breed another horse and conducted it in a purely business-like manner. They didn’t take into account the animal’s emotional wellbeing. Because from a business perspective, why should we care so much for a dispensable tool? The author draws a lot of parallels between animals and slaves,…

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Whether people would like to admit it or not, everyone does things that do not always make sense. For instance, many people talk to inanimate objects when they do not work the way they are supposed to work. Even though people know that no decipherable response will come from them, pets and other animals are also often the recipients of other such one-sided conversations. In addition to simply talking to animals, many people give animals human characteristics such as emotions and thoughts, perhaps to help them feel less alone in the world. In “Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening,” the speaker gives his horse thoughts and emotions, like any ordinary person would in his position, perhaps to show that he is feeling lonely and left out of the world. The poet of “Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening,” Robert Frost, uses literary devices such as the personification of a horse to draw attention to common yet significant ideas.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics