Preview

The Man He Killed Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
868 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Man He Killed Analysis
War is not only causes physical injuries, but emotional ones as well. Throughout history, soldiers returning from war have acquired emotional damage after enduring to the harsh conditions of combat. They suffer from illnesses such as PTSD or Post Traumatic Stress disorder, a disorder in which traumatizing experiences from the past still affect an individual to which they are unlike themselves anymore. Along with PTSD they suffer from moral injury, the pain that results from damage to a person's moral foundation. In All Quiet on The Western Front By Erich Maria Remarque and Thomas Hardy's’ “The Man He Killed” characters struggles with the emotional effects of war. Despite the internal struggle faced by Paul and the speaker from the poem, both …show more content…
After ending Gérard Duval's life in the trench, Paul feels guilty of taking another man's life. He struggles to cope with his moral injury as he feels he did not need to kill the man. Paul believes that Gerard Duval poses no threat to him as Gerald is already helpless and dying. Paul states that he “would give much if he would stay alive”, and “each word [he] translate pierces [him] like a shot in the chest” (Remarque 221 and 225). Paul wishes that he could have taken back what he had done and allow the man to die on his own. Paul faces the reality of war, as his own hands become a weapon. Similarly, the speaker in “The Man He Killed” struggles with internal conflict after killing an enemy in combat. The speaker tries to reason with himself in hopes of justifying his actions. He momentarily forgets why he shot the man, but then states “I shot him dead because- / because he was my foe” (Hardy 9-10). The speaker pauses based on the repetition of “because” to indicate his confusion as to why he shot the man in the first place. The speaker continues on, not putting much thought towards the topic. Both Paul and the speaker battle a similar internal conflict, a conflict that every soldier has to deal

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Paul is forced to stab an enemy soldier named Gerard Duval and then watch him die right next to him in a ditch during battle, the force of the stabbing shows animal like instinct (self preservation)…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The negative effects of World War 1 are endless. Despite some of the positive outcomes, the book focuses on the main points of how the soldiers felt emotionally, physically, and mentally. When reading the book, All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque, one can further understand the true sadness, physical pain, and mental exhaustion that the German soldiers actually went through. This changes our perspective about the war because we can oversee our American bias and understand the pain on both sides. When Paul says, “We were all at once terribly alone; and alone we must see it through,” it shows how although there were hundreds of thousands of soldiers fighting together, the pain and the suffering was…

    • 1049 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the story All Quiet On The Western Front, the author Erich Maria Remarque uses the motif of blood and death to display a theme of withering innocence, and how soldiers had to witness horrible events through humanity’s downfall. Erich uses animals to show crude human nature, the story describes to us how “the belly of one horse is ripped open, the guts trail out. He becomes tangled in them and falls, then he stands up again” (63 Remarque). This passage of gruesome death shows decaying innocence by humans forcing innocent creatures of the land, to fight for their own selfish needs and ways. Throughout the story, Paul is thrown again and again into life or death situations, “I grab for my gas-mask.…

    • 245 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Remarque tells of the dehumanizing effects that are perceived in ‘All Quiet on the Western Front’. When the young soldiers arrive at the frontline its nothing to what was anticipated as they had “just begun to love the world and being in it, but we had to shoot at it.” Remarque’s characterisation of Paul is naive and inexperienced as he only just begins to grasp the understanding, through torment and fatality, that they didn’t “believe in those things anymore; we believe in war” their new objective was to survive. Trained to disregard their conscience and distancing themselves from their own emotions, taught to let go of their former lifestyle. “Keep things at arm’s length” was their innovative technique in being able to endure the horrors of war. The audience is alarmed by the lack of emotion deemed by the young soldiers through Paul’s metaphoric language that “we have become wild beasts” enlightening context to the overall traumatic experiences that were inflicted. Remarque continues to portray the emotional state in a distant tone that “we are dead” convincing the audience they are completely detached…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As the novel's narrator and protagonist, Paul is the central figure in All Quiet on the Western Front and serves as the mouthpiece for Remarque's meditations about war. Throughout the novel, Paul's inner personality is contrasted with the way the war forces him to act and feel. His memories of the time before the war show that he was once a very different man from the despairing soldier who now narrates the novel. Paul is a compassionate and sensitive young man; before the war, he loved his family and wrote poetry. Because of the horror of the war and the anxiety it induces, Paul, like other soldiers, learns to disconnect his mind from his feelings, keeping his emotions at bay in order to preserve his sanity and survive. As a result, the compassionate young man becomes unable to mourn his dead comrades, unable to feel at home among his family, unable to express his feelings about the war or even talk about his experiences, unable to remember the past fully, and unable to conceive of a future without war. He also becomes a "human animal," capable of relying on animal instinct to kill and survive in battle. But because Paul is extremely sensitive, he is somewhat less able than many of the other soldiers to detach himself completely from his feelings, and there are several moments in the book (Kemmerich's death, Kat's death, the time that he spends with his ill mother) when he feels himself pulled down by emotion. These surging feelings indicate the extent to which war has programmed Paul to cut himself off from feeling, as when he says, with devastating understatement, "Parting from my friend Albert Kropp was very hard.…

    • 3207 Words
    • 92 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the story “The Man Killed” By Tim O’Brien, the narrator stares in silence at the man he has just murdered. He imagines all sorts of things and describes every part of him, from the blood running out of his wounds to his dainty long fingers. He, then starts telling us about his life and visualizes his past, present and future. The narrator envisions this man of My Khe as a scholar, not a fighter; he believes he is someone who went to war only to fulfill his patriotic duty. During this whole time, O’Brien never really speaks, and the silent is broken by two of O’Brien’s fellow soldiers. First Azar speaks, his apathetic ways are much too cruel, since he compares the soldier to shredded cereal, this also shows he feels pleasure from the man’s death. The second voice is from Kiowa, who in fact sympathizes wit O’Brien but still urges him to move on and tries to make him see that the young soldier’s death was necessary, because if he hadn’t killed him, O’Brien would have been the one…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    During tough and trying times, when people’s spirits are suppressed or crushed, the things which usually help alleviate the low emotions tend to be attention from concerned people and their understanding, friendship, compassion, and love. War, revolutions, and political conflicts are just some of the most depressing moments the world experiences every now and then. During these moments, what the world needs the most is sincere compassion and care. War can also be considered as one of the most emotionally high moments when people are filled with negative feelings such as fear, angst, and/or grief. This could be one reason why a lot of people who have lived through a war have also been inspired to express their shattered spirits and frightful experiences in battle through writing or literature. In turn, this literature inspires the readers as they read what the author has gone through. The German poet, novelist, and common foot soldier Erich…

    • 2167 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Erich Maria Remarque’s novel, All Quiet on the Western Front, Paul Bäumer and his generation feel separated from the rest of the world. These boys’ lives were drastically changed by the war, and “even though they may have escaped its shells, they were destroyed by the war,” (Remarque Epigraph) describing that even though they survived the war physically,they were mentally destroyed by the dangers and chaos of war. Paul expresses that “he has been crushed without knowing it” and “does not belong anymore, it is a foreign world” (Remarque 168). The generation of men who fought in the war are “pushed aside,” (Remarque 249) as an unpleasant reminder of a war that society would like to disregard. After surviving such dreadful…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many men were destroyed by the war mentally. The Soldiers that survived the war and came home almost all had PTSD and were mentally ill from what they had seen or experienced. (Chapter 5, pg.87) "The war has ruined us for everything” This quote means that what they have seen and done in the war has transformed them into only being able to think of and understand the life of war. War becomes what they live and breath and cannot comprehend with other jobs that do not relate to war and the horrifying killing that they were trained to do. Paul was destroyed by the war when he was in a shelling whole and an enemy jumped into it with him and Paul stabbed…

    • 808 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “This book is to be neither an accusation nor a confession, and least of all an adventure, for death is not an adventure to those who stand face to face with it. It will try simply to tell of a generation of men who, even though they may have escaped shells, were destroyed by the war” (Epigraph). In All Quiet on the Western Front, there are many themes present throughout the text. The most important of which, being the psychological effects that the war has on the soldiers. Out of all of the men fighting throughout the war and those who physically survived in the end, they were destroyed mentally from their experiences. This theme occurs throughout the war on many soldiers and has an even larger impact on nineteen-year-old Paul Baumer in chapter…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “There was never a good war or a bad peace.” War, conflict between nations or fellow citizens with the use of arms. War is the most powerful threat we have on earth today. War can accomplish a variety of things in a variety of ways but for the soldiers they are stuck with an experience unlike any other known to the everyday man, stuck with memories and images of what it's like to be hunted by another man. Different people take different things away from war and are affected in different ways, but a change after a war is inevitable and for the vast majority it is difficult to recall his experiences of war yet they are prominently printed into their minds torturing them mentally for the remainder of their lives. This is evidently shown throughout the novel “The Things They Carried” which depicts the impact of the war in many forms, the suicide of an ex-soldier upon his return home; the lessening sanity of a medic as the constant death surrounds him; the trauma and guilt of all the soldiers after seeing their friends die, and feeling as if they could have saved them; and the deaths of the soldiers all of these offsets to their actions and personalities stem from immense difficult for soldiers to recall his experiences of war.…

    • 1577 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    War is portrayed as just an armed state of conflict habitually, but that does not begin to cover the depths of it.War tears at an individual, whether you are a soldier fighting for your nation or daughter waiting for her father to return home unscathed. Additionally, it comes with the heavy price. Through the words of Jose Narosky, "In war, there are no unwounded soldiers." Every man or woman receives some type of damage. People are broken down by their surroundings and left emotionally and mentally paralyzed. Piece by piece a person is plagued by war's appalling actions. It is a very cruel reality but an accurate one.No matter what war is transpiring, this same outcome is precise.The World War 1 based novel, All Quiet on the Western Front, by Erich Maria Marque examines the…

    • 1795 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After the slaughter of Gerard Duval, Paul’s conscience seemed to have completely drained and the murder has changed him emotionally, but he is later supplied with sympathy. When Paul was ordered to observe furtively upon the position and movement of his belligerent enemy, but Paul departs in trepidation and was suddenly surprised when an unknown being crawls into Paul’s shell hole; as a result, Paul continuously stabs the unknown being. As Paul remains in the shell hole with the soldier, he experiences, “This dying man has time with him, he has an invisible dagger which he stabs [Paul]: Time and time” (221). After Paul had stabbed the French soldier with an actual weapon, a human that Paul should conceive as an “abstraction” suffering, fills…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Remarque's use of realism shows how the themes of dehumanization and destruction correlate to each other. During one of the skirmishes in the front, Paul sees a an enemy soldier staring at him and says that, "the head rises up, a hand, a movement, and my hand-grenade flies through the air and into him" (113). Remarque's detached writing describes how Paul is indifferent to the man's death. It is human nature to feel one's emotions stirring when they are in the act of killing; however, Remarque made no reference to Paul's emotions and merely stated that the grenade "flies through the air" and kills the man. Along with the fact that not much is said about this man's death, it is implied by this style of writing that Paul killed this man for no other reason than to…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Dead Man Walking Analysis

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages

    As Poncelet's execution approaches closer and closer, his character is seen speciously unpredictable, harboring questions about the rightness of what they were doing to him. In one minute, we hear him requesting a lie identifier test to tell his mom that he is pure, in an alternate we see him enraged playing the victimized person, accusing the legislature and drugs. Poncelet never comprehended that he has robbed the Percys and the Delacroixs so much, providing them only distress and ache. They are never going to see their kids again, never going to hold them, to adore them, to giggle with them. Portraying the families of both the killer and his two victimized people. The scene in which Sister Helen visits Mr. Delacroix after he has criticized her for not doing as such, as the scene closes, the camera gradually moves back, uncovering a serene and still living room. This shot alone consummately recommends the shattering toll a murder takes on a…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays