Preview

The Nhl's Concussion Quandary Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1050 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Nhl's Concussion Quandary Analysis
The Globe and Mail’s editorial, “The NHL’s Concussion Quandary”(2015), speaks out regarding the level of long-term harm professional hockey players are enduring due to the lack of guidelines when it comes to concussion protocol. Coming from a hockey family, with professional connections, one must consider what goes on between the players, trainers, coaches, general managers, and everyday fans being the issue not the regulations of the league. “The NHL’s Concussion Quandary” is finding players returning to the game too soon a pressing problem, what the outside eye doesn’t see is the player “sucking it up” to receive their pay check and bonuses. Although their main talent lies on the ice, professional hockey players have skill when it comes to …show more content…
The Globe pressed the question “But if the sport became soccer on ice, would that really be so bad?” The answer is yes, it would be terrible, hockey is popular because of its rough, gritty demeanor. The Globe and Mail also debated “The streamlined, beautiful game exhibited at the Olympics every four years proves that a purer version of the sport can exist, once the will to adapt is there.” This sophisticated play comes from bigger consequences, yes, but also from the pressure of representing your country in positive light. Hockey player’s in the NHL however play for themselves, their club, and in present day most importantly, their fans. Fans want to see huge hits, fights and goals - in reality the spectators are who pays the players therefore players must preform to their liking. Discussed was the fact that professional sports do remake themselves to eliminate harmful parts of the game, an example used in the editorial regarding hockey is the banning of spearing, but players still spear which proves adding rules don’t fix everything. Players want to impress their teammates, coaches and fans, sacrificing their own well being to do

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    My case study was the concussion crisis in the NFL. I believe the ethical moment was when Mike Webster died and it was discovered the he had CTE. At this moment when the connection between football the CTE was first proposed, that was the moment that action needed to be taken. Due to the NFL taking a defensive or denial approach many more players suffered and feared of having or possibly having CTE. I believe I would have made a public statement, the reason for the NFL to not make an official release was money driven. While it would have been difficult, a pay check and reputation is not worth more than a person’s…

    • 115 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    At this point in time, there is not enough evidence to answer the question of how successful the NFL concussion protocol is. The statistics regarding concussion incidences in the NFL provides outsiders with inconsistent data. There is no clear pattern of steady increasing or decreasing rates over the course of multiple seasons. These results seemed to support the evidence that not all concussion present the same way. This variation in clinical presentation might be an explanation as for why some seasons had a drop in concussion rates. Even though a player might not show drastic signs of a concussion such as loss of consciousness or changes in gait, it should not be assumed that the player has not sustained an…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Frontline’s League of Denial explains how the glorification of violence plays a role in head injuries in the NFL. The National Football League’s chronic brain injury rates are increasing very quickly, causing the league to increase protocol to provide better protection for the players. It is hard to find a football player today whose body hasn’t paid a very high price; the love of the game may be destroying the brains of NFL players.…

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The N.F.L created the head, neck, and spine committee with the intention of diagnosing, preventing, and treating any N.F.L football player that sustains an injury, including concussions. However, concussions remain a major issue happening in the football world and players continue to remain affected by them. In fact during the 2015 pre and regular season games, 271 players sustained concussions, making it a 31.6 increase from 2014 (Breslow). This set of statistics proves that the concussion crisis continues to increase because each year more players continue to become affected by concussions. Furthermore, it tells people that concussions don’t only happen in regular games, but during pre season games as well. In addition concussions regularly occur in highschool and little league football. As a matter of fact, around 47% of concussions occur in high school students (Sports). Which represents one of the highest percentages among other high school sports. This again proves that concussions do not only happen in the major leagues. The N.F.L also plays a major rule in these outside leagues. The New York Times stated, “the league’s public position could influence other levels of football because many college, high school and youth leagues take their cues…

    • 1944 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The purpose of this study was to determine the knowledge and opinions on concussions of high school coaches from a geographi- cally large yet rural state in the northern Rocky Mountains of the United States. Few medical issues in sport are more important, or have had as much publicity recently, as concussions. The exposure gleaned from tragic health issues among professional athletes post- concussion has motivated college and professional sport agencies to modify and enact strict guidelines in the diagnosis and treatment of suspected concussions. Yet underdiagnosis and mistreatment by some (former University of Michigan coach in 2014) highlight the need for continued education and enforcement of the current guide- lines. Obviously, when a head…

    • 182 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Many sports can cause concussions, which can be changed by getting better equipment and adding other sports that won’t be as dangerous. Even though the sports are dangerous getting better equipment can help make the sports less dangerous. If the better equipment would too…

    • 284 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Every year on Boxing Day, the World Juniors tournament for players under 20 begins. The NHL stars of tomorrow compete for their country on the sweaters as well as to create a name for themselves. This generates an intense, excellent quality of hockey which fans love every single year. The one main difference between the World Juniors and the NHL is that fighting is illegal in the World Juniors tournament. There are people who believe that without fighting the game would suffer due to a lack of sportsmanship. Shawn Horcoff, current Dallas Stars centre-man, expresses his feeling toward the issue if fighting was removed from the game: "I think there would be a lot more guys running around, a lot more high sticks, a lot more hits from behind."(Whyno). Horcoff is not alone in believing this; actually, 98% of NHL players in 2011 supported to keep the game how it is, fighting included (Whyno). On the contrary, another highly supported hockey event is the Olympics. NHL superstars get a chance to earn a gold medal only once every four years. A gold medal in the Olympics is considered by many, even current NHL players, to be a greater feat than winning the Stanley Cup. Along with the World Juniors, fighting is also illegal in the Olympics. As far as the quality of hockey being displayed on the Olympic stage, it is second to none. Olympic athletes are not looking to…

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    By clearing the players return to action, it helps ensure that the player has fully recovered from the injury. However, 33% of high school athletes who sustain a sports concussion report two or more in the same year (Sports). This means that even though the committee passed the “concussion protocol”, the players are still receiving concussions more often than they should if they used the protocol. It also shows that not only do the players receive one concussion, but two in the same year. Despite placing the protocol into action, many football players continue playing even though they sustained…

    • 1908 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Every sport has its own unique signature that separates it from the rest of the sports world. Baseball has the homerun, basketball has the slam-dunk, golf has the hole in one, and football has the touchdown. But, perhaps the sport with the most distinguished and unique signature is hockey and its fights. However, hockey officials and executives are trying to eliminate the games most distinctive aspect. Yet, because of the recent decline in the amount of fighting in the National Hockey League (NHL) and since a ban on fighting in the NHL could jeopardize the popularity of the sport, eliminating fighting from games may not be necessary. Over recent years, the amount of fighting in NHL games has been on the decline and the role of the one time "enforcer" has changed dramatically. Also, hockey fights bring in much needed revenue for professional teams in way of television, attendance, and concessions. The NHL deeply needs to look at what effect removing fighting would cause in the long term.…

    • 1431 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Violence In Hockey Essay

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Hockey is long stood for being a game where pushing and shoving and even a fight breaking out is highly likely to happen. Some people claim that if the rules of hockey took away violence, then it wouldn’t really be hockey. Though controversial, the same thoughts are considered for other games like lacrosse and football. That being said, there are traditions per se associated with sports, and violence is one that is linked with hockey. Although unfortunate, violence is a reality that tends to be the nature of…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Contact sports today such as hockey are very fast paced, and dangerous. Due to the high level of contact in the game of hockey, injuries such as the concussion have become more common. Due to the injury, the National Hockey league has made various changes in rules and which has impacted the way the game is played. As both a player and a fan of the sport, I disagree with the alterations that have been made. In my argument, I intend to show organizations such as the National Hockey League that the injuries come from the players and that the added rules are lowering the enjoyment of the game. The NHL has no doubt increased the safety of players. However, numerous players and fans feel as if the enjoyment of the game has decreased. The big hits and fighting are what…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Exploratory essay

    • 1915 Words
    • 5 Pages

    March 5th, 2004, the Ottawa Senators and Philadelphia Flyers had what people regard as one of the best fights in NHL history. The fight resulted in a bench-clearing brawl resulting in 20 players getting ejected as well as 419 penalty minutes given out. The fighting aspect of hockey has been around since the early 1800’s and it has played a monumental role in shaping the game of hockey into what it has become today. Top sports news broadcasts such as ESPN, Bleacher Report, and Sports Illustrated often compose many polls and surveys asking the public how fighting in hockey is beneficial as well as detrimental to one of America’s oldest sports.…

    • 1915 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Concussions In Ice Hockey

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The two sports are both at high risk of injury. They are both high contact sports they call for heavy padding and a lot of protection. The game of ice hockey is especially strenuous on someone's head. The most recent and accurate study on concussions in the NHL was done in seven seasons over 1997-2004. This study showed that 559 players had gotten a concussion during regular season games over seven seasons(Concussions Statistics Tallied in Study of NHL).…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are several conflicts that may arise during all sports. From the little league, all the way up to the professional league, there is always going to be conflict, some bigger than others. As the book The Joy of Conflict Resolution by Gary Harper states, “…conflict is a part of life”. Every day people are challenged with new or reappearing conflict, some can be resolved, some are still in the process of trying to be resolved, and others ignore it and hold onto a grudge. A major conflict arising today is about football players and concussions. The game is constantly changing, forming faster, stronger, and all-around better athletes than ever before. This means the players are taking more traumatic blows to head than ever before. As a result,…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    People know what mostly causes the concussions, aggressive, high impactful sports such as football, hockey, basketball, baseball and soccer. Scientists are working to make these sports safe, adding more padded helmets and certain rule restrictions against head to head contact. The rules will add a positive spin to these sports, because every time you break a rule you will get a very expensive fine.” Keith McCants, the fourth pick of the 1990 NFL draft, screened Will Smith’s movie “Concussion” and told The MMQB: ”We were paid to give concussions. If we knew that we were killing people, I would have never put on the jersey”(Retired…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays