Preview

The Politics Of The Natural, By Noel Sturgeon

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1067 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Politics Of The Natural, By Noel Sturgeon
When I think of the word natural, my mind escapes to a serene wooded place, rife with life and fauna. I use the term to define ideas and concepts as predetermined, or in a state of purity. Author and teacher Noel Sturgeon argues in her essay “The Politics of the Natural in U.S. History and Popular Culture” that nature is a word teeming with social and political quandaries that have led people to misuse the term, often to the advantage of white males and other powerful groups throughout history. Sturgeon expertly dissects the word “nature” from a variety of angles by examining the political, cultural, and sociological impact the word has made through its misuse throughout the years. Although I largely agree with her position, I find some of …show more content…
Their meaning is fluid and has a very different connotation from one person to the next. Sturgeon relates this concept back to human-nature being “understandings of human evolution, inherent human capacities for violence and sex, and differences among humans – have often been used to naturalize and therefore justify social inequalities” (710). She elaborates by showing the reader how these troupes of human-nature are just cultural stereotypes perpetuated by a sort of complacency shared by most people. People often accept these biases because they’ve come to accept them as the norm, and therefore natural. She continues her dissection by next looking at nature from the perspective of its use in popular culture, paying close attention to how nature is used in advertising. Using several ads from many popular publications and consumer products, Sturgeon offers the reader insight on how “Men’s nature is to control nature, while women’s nature is to be nature” (John Berger [1972, 47] Sturgeon 722). She concludes by reaffirming her point that nature is a convoluted term riddled with social prejudices and inborn malice which perpetuate ideas such as cultural stereotypes, sexism, and social

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Connected within this repressive system, Hogan’s work critically explores the destruction and exploitation of the environment. Broad in scope when confronting the topic, she gives the reader a strong sense of the issues faced in regard to the natural world. Providing clarity to Hogan’s worldview, she juxtaposes that which troubles her against what she views as the correct way to be in the world. She is sharply critical of Western values for covering “the American continent with a view of the natural world that did not accept the Earth was alive and that all species were sentient.” Within the dominant view, the destruction of life is inherent.…

    • 582 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Never has a man left the embrace of nature once he found himself enamored by it; this infatuation is found in both John Muir’s and Aldo Leopold’s writing, a sense of wanting to protect this deity they call Mother Nature, a moral and ethical responsibility which every human being has to this Mother. Both John Muir and Aldo Leopold recount their almost romantic encounter with Mother Nature in their books Our National Parks and A Sand County Almanac, respectively. However, in both books it is notable that each man carries instilled in the very fiber of their being a sense of dissatisfaction toward the process of mechanization and industrialization; processes which unfortunately…

    • 1225 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    "Changes in the Land" by William Cronon offers countless intimate observations and gatherings regarding the ecology of New England and the encounters between the colonists and the native americans. Cronon interprets and analyzes the different happenings in New England's plant and animal environments that occurred with the shift from Indian to European dominance. As the distant world and inhabitants of Europe were introduced to North America's ecosystem, the boundaries between the two were blurred. Cronon uses an arsenal of evidence to discuss the circumstances that brought upon drastic ecological consequences following European contact with New England. Cronon made use of reports and records in addition to scientific data as evidence for his arguments. Court records, town hall records, descriptions by travelers, surveyor records, etc. proved invaluable to Cronon's arguments. Europeans saw the land from an economic standpoint and tended to focus upon "merchantable commodities", ignoring economically insignificant aspects of nature. Cronon stated that the environment the Europeans first encountered in New England stunned them. Early descriptions were restricted to the coastline, but the accounts all agreed on the astounding level of animal and plant life in New England. The european settlers were not used to so much untamed land, as landscape for hunting in England was reserved to large landowners and the Crown. Heavy forests covered the New England terrain, which was also new to the settlers, as England had exhausted most of its timber as fuel. European settlers were struck by the absence of domesticated animals, which played a vital role in European agriculture. The European settlers and the Indians had different values on life and had differing opinions on how they should use the land around them. According to Cronon, "Many…

    • 813 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sarah Jacquette Ray’s concept of “The Ecological Other” can be used to describes the relationship between the environment and the type of bodies classified as “ideal” or “other” by a society. Similarly, the article “What it means to Rewild,” by Patrick J. Kiger plays on this concept of “The Ecological Other” by examining how “Rewilders” believe that modern civilization has psychologically and physically harmed the connection people have with mother nature and therefore, made them unfit to coexist in a modern society. Another way to look at the “Rewilding” phenomena is by considering that many “nature based” arguments can be used to implement specific social programs that are designed to control or discriminate against certain groups of people. For instance, Sarah Jacquette Ray contends that environmental ideologies have directly contributed to the subjugation of impaired, immigrant and Native Indian people. Moreover, white environmental justice ecocritics have often racialize the wilderness narrative by ignoring the fact that non-whites also lived and reflected upon the same landscapes through writing.…

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When reflecting on the past image of his generation's childhood, Louv aspires to truly slow his readers down and to fully grab their attention. "We were fascinated with roadkill, and we counted cows and horses and coyotes and shaving-cream signs, " he recalls. Louv deliberately establishes these images in his readers' heads, in a succession-like manner. To his audience, these pictures pass through the mind as he lists them simultaneously, almost as if we are driving by this sequence of events, while looking out the window of a car. By doing this, Louv hopes to define and give life to specific instances of the respect for nature that we once had. By focusing on memories, he shows us the current state of our nation: we have forsaken the natural world as a source of subtle but long-lasting inspiration for, electric stimulation of our…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Human nature is a vexing issue: some argue that we are born as blank slates and our 
natures are defined by upbringing, experience, culture and the ideas of our time. Others 
believe that human nature is innate and pre-destined, regardless of time and…

    • 323 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his critique, “The Trouble with Wilderness or Getting Back to the Wrong Nature,” William Cronon argues against the romantic conceptualization of nature that a great portion of the environmentalist movement has embraced. Subsequently, Cronon revokes the Romantic and even quasi-religious notion that wilderness spaces are separate from those inhabited by man. He argues that by eliminating the divide in perception between the human constructs of the natural world and the civilized world, man will be encouraged to take more responsibility for his actions that negatively impact the environment. In prefacing his conclusion, he writes, “Home, after all, is the place where finally we make our living. It is the place for which we take responsibility,…

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    William Cronon Dualism

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages

    William Cronon’s (year?) article on the wilderness as a “cultural creation” is part of the human construct of natural landscapes. This human construct is part of the two dualistic ideals of historical interstation of the wilderness that North Americans perceive as part of this tradition. For instance, Cronon (year?) defines (1) the “sublime” vision of nature as a beautiful artistic image of the pristine wilderness as a type of sanctuary or Garden of Eden in the 19th century, yet it also defines the dualistic countermand of (2) nature as a dangerous wilderness in the American frontier: “The “delicious paradise” of John Milton’s Eden was surrounded by a “steep wilderness, whose hairy sides/ Access denied” to all who sought entry” (Cronon, year?, p.71). ). This dualistic perspective of Nature defines human beings as controlling or occupying natural spaces, such as Eden, or being victims of the hostility and danger of…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Muir and Abbey

    • 1014 Words
    • 3 Pages

    It is difficult to find writers more passionate about the natural environment than John Muir and Edward Abbey. Both Muir in a section from his book A Thousand-Mile Walk to the Gulf and Abbey in a chapter titled Polemic: Industrial Tourism and the National Parks channel anger and frustration at the environmental policies of their time into literature that argues fervently for preservation of national parks and other areas of wilderness. In Hetch Hetchy Valley, Muir reverently describes in vivid detail the beautiful landscape of a river valley in Yosemite called the Hetch Hetchy Valley, condemning anyone who supports a government plan to dam the Hetch Hetchy River and flood the valley. In a famous quote Muir says, “no holier temple has ever been consecrated by the heart of man” (Muir 112). Abbey employs a highly sarcastic and satirical tone to outline the consequences of further expansion of roads and highways into national parks. He aims to incite anger with sharp language and insults to draw the reader in emotionally. “This is a courageous view, admirable in its simplicity and power… It is also quite insane” (Abbey 422). Both pieces easily stand alone, but when looked at together they suggest even more strongly that it is deceptive and dishonest to advertise industrialization of wilderness as any kind of favorable progress for society. This “progress” does not actually benefit anyone. Those who proclaim this as their reason for supporting industrial development are more likely motivated by the short-term economic benefits they will receive.…

    • 1014 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    There has been a longstanding debate over the appropriate way to understand the relationship of Native Americans with the environment and the ecologically noble Indian stereotype that has followed them throughout history. This essay examines the fundamentally Eurocentric attitudes that this very debate entails, thereby rendering any possible conclusions drawn to be meaningless due to its lack of understanding of the basic cultural structure it seeks to define. Because of the radically different way Native Americans conceptualize the universe and nature, attempting to place them on our constructed spectrum of environmentalism is a meaningless endeavor. If the term “environmentalism” itself is examined, it becomes clear that it is by definition…

    • 2461 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Comparing Henry David Thoreau and Herman Melville's Writings Henry David Thoreau and Herman Melville focused their writings on how man was affected by nature. They translated their philosophies though both the portrayal of their protagonist and their own self exploration. In Moby Dick, Melville writes about Ahab's physical and metaphysical struggle over the great white whale, Moby Dick, symbolic of man's struggle against the overwhelming forces of nature. Ahab's quest is reported and experienced through the eyes of Ishmael.…

    • 1726 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Noel Steurgeon Nature

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the article The Politics of the Natural in U.S. History and Popular Culture, Noel Sturgeon showed many examples of how she thinks nature and culture intersect. One of the examples she talks about is, “Are wilderness areas necessary for preserving “wild nature”? Or are they managed and commodified leisure resources in which “wild nature” has to be controlled?” I have confidence that this sentence means that nature can sometimes be controlled by culture, where it maybe should not be. Another example from Sturgeon of culture and nature intersecting is in a paragraph about human rights. Sturgeon explained that back when almost nobody had rights, it was because it was “natural”. More specifically, “...were “discovering” a host of “natural” differences that proved the superiority of white European men...” She also explained why she believes it should be separate, in the essay she states, “New genetic,…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Defining nature comes only from a personal experience, a description of the emotional effect you feel. Nature is a part of the world we can enjoy, not because of the changing times, but because it's in real form. Although, it's very difficult to define nature, you have to fully understand the relationship between present-day technology and nature by experiencing the outdoors one-on-one. Even if you walk out into your backyard, take a deep breathe, and soak up the free air; you still get a rush of excitement and energy. The feeling received from nature should be personal, sitting on a park bench alone in the park listening the ducks flap around is a personal experience. In the Age of Missing Information, Bill McKibben helps us realize what we are missing. When he talks about nature he never exaggerates, he doesn't throw out a catchy slogan to grab our attention. He simply speaks of nature in its purest form. Nature is a feeling, an emotion shared personally; however, there are many changes that begin to strip us of what we know as our lush environment.…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nature vs Nurture

    • 529 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Nature is considered your genetic characteristics thatwere given to you at the time of conception. There are strong beliefs that “if mama does it, you will do it”. The individuals that truly believe this ideado tend to follow the footsteps of their parents. Individuals that are not strong enough to surpass their environment willalways fall into this category of prejudice from the environment. “Traditionally, genetics characteristics are considered stable and uncontrollable” (Jayaratne, et al., 2009, p.25). That is saying that a person can’t control the turn out of their life because it has been etched in stoned and there is nothing they can do about it.…

    • 529 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gender roles, or stereotypes, have formed a central part of humanity since the beginning of human existence. It assists…

    • 7986 Words
    • 32 Pages
    Powerful Essays