Preview

The Portman Hotel Case Study

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1260 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Portman Hotel Case Study
The Portman Hotel Company was a relatively small hotel with only 348 rooms and 21 floors located in San Francisco’s booming hotel district. It was influenced with Asian philosophy of services, to provide high quality hospitality to its guest at affordable rates. On paper, the hotel sounded like a great success, one that would definitely flourish amongst the competition. However, even with this philosophy, there were numerous problems that plagued the Portman Hotel. A few examples of these problems are the common mistake of fundamental attribution error (FAE), expectancy theory, as well as operant conditional theory. This essay will explain how these three things can potentially bring down an entire company very quickly.
First we will look at FAE and how it relates to the Portman Hotel. To find an example of FAE located in The Portman Hotel case, we must first define what FAE exactly is. Fundamental Attribution Error is the tendency to over-value dispositional or personality-based explanations for the observed behaviors of others while under-valuing situational explanations for those behaviors. It is typically most visible when people explain the behavior to others. Essentially, what FAE suggests, is that we, as human beings, tend to be too judgmental of others without actually seeing that there might be external factors causing that individuals behavior. Now that we have defined exactly what FAE is, we can begin to identify an example of this contained within the case. One great example of this common error in action involves the personal valet’s (PVs) of the company and Spencer Scott. Scott criticizes the PVs for always taking on additional tasks and pursuing new needs and even states that they want to do everything, which causes them to suffer short attention spans. He is so focused on the PVs being a group of freethinkers that he has failed to remember his companies purpose, which is to cater to every desire the hotel guests might have. He has

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    This appeal was presented to the Florida court by Cordelia Shipman and her husband A. K. Shipman from Miami against the Peacock hotel represented by Coral Peacock and her daughter Cecil A. Peacock from Miami as well. The appeal was from a final decree of foreclosure of the purchase-money mortgage. The Shipmans made a contract with Ms. Peacock, an inexperienced in business widow, and her daughter, a minor, for the sale of the Hotel with the premises of the women continuing the payment for the hotel mortgage after the sale was completed.…

    • 889 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Fundamental Attribution Error (FAE) principle states that man tends to ignore outside pressure and factors when judging the behavior of others. This means that people believe that a certain action or behavior was a cause of an internal motive rather than some influence from external pressure. In simple words, the FAE describes the inability to step inside other people’s shoes.…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Over a period of years, Guam has experienced a boost to its tourism industry. The year 1967 was the beginning of that upward trend. that includes support from the United States. However, the decline of the Japanese economy in the 1900’s and onward severely damaged the economy of Guam. How many of us can attest to looking up a product or service online, seeing its respective pictures, only to find out that the actual product is dissimilar to the original picture? The excess room inventory in the hotel industry paired with the decline in the general tourism of Guam could only lead to failure. In other words, supply greatly outnumbered demand. Additionally, applying a “Me-too” approach to hotel operations in such conditions can have limited success. Research has shown that piggy backing on others in the industry can often lead to failure, because companies employing this tactic rarely see the need to differentiate with a product or service. It can be assumed that a “me too” company’s sole intention is to capitalize on the success of another company and the upward trend of a fad. McKenzie clearly observed and often commented on the issues he saw, like the unkempt meeting room and aged furniture. This brings out another aspect of a “me too” company in that usually those who employ this tactic place reinvestment in a lower priority. Could the Regal Carnation benefit from a shift in focus? We find that the use of our gut when making decisions can have a positive effect. In contrast, the McKenzie’s failed to follow their gut…

    • 3074 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    This paper will discuss the pros and cons of the Rosewood Hotels moving from individual brands to a corporate brand. It will look at the history of Rosewood hotels, how they got to where they are, their customer base, and where they want to go. It will look at the concept of customer lifetime value as it relates to the Rosewood Hotel customer, then make a recommendation for or against tying its corporate Rosewood brand to all of its present and future hotels.…

    • 1089 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sweet Dreams Inn

    • 515 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Although Mr. Phan’s objective was not communicated officially, he did seem to have one in mind when he bought the 60-room hotel. He is concerned because after two years of owning the business his occupancy rate is not where he believes it should be. After the first year the occupancy stabilized at 55% of capacity, but it has remained below the 68% industry average ever since. Discussion of this concern leads one to believe that his objective was by year two to be maintaining an occupancy of at least 68%. This objective can be classified as such because it is:…

    • 515 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Amber Inn & Suites, Inc., formed in 1979, operates 200 Amber Inn properties and 50 Amber Inn & Suites properties located in 10 states throughout the Rocky Mountain and western states. On Average, each location has approximately 120 individual guest and suite-style rooms. Under a new president and CEO, the goal is for Amber Inn & Suites to reach profitability within two years after five consecutive years of unprofitability. This company is positioned as a limited-service hotel which does not have the amenities such as a restaurant, lounge, or meeting rooms. This type of hotel is classified under a midscale hotel with food and beverage, such as Holiday Inn and Ramada Inn.…

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    | 2. Be able to complete and use business documents for internal and external communication in an organisation…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Receivables: Meriwether has a fair amount of receivables. It will be up to the Board of officially write off unrecoverable receivables.…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Joie de Vivre is a hotel management group that is located in San Francisco that was founded in 1987 by Chip Conley. He liked commercial real estate but did not like doing the transaction part of it. He stated to Travel Weekly the branding strategy for Joie de Vivre. In article he said that they know California better than anyone, approximately 40 percent of consumers are from California. He knows that his company comes up with unique hotels, with own personality. It has managed to grow to 36 boutique hotel properties. It became the second largest in 2010.…

    • 1120 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Portman Hotel

    • 1707 Words
    • 7 Pages

    First, we will take a look at fundamental attribution error (FAE). From our discussion in class this condition, based on attribution theory, involves the tendency of human beings to attribute too much personal/internal factors in analyzing a particular situation where, in fact, environmental/external forces are more at work. In essence, what FAE suggests is that we, as human beings, tend to be too judgmental of others based on what sort of person they are with a general disregard for outside, situational forces beyond their control. So how does this relate to The Portman Hotel personnel dilemma and what can we do to resolve it? One great example of this error in action involves the disdain Spencer Scott, the director of guest room services, has towards the PVs. He criticizes them for always taking on additional tasks and pursuing new needs. He goes on by saying that they want to do everything and, therefore, suffer from short attention spans. Case in point, this is exactly what FAE is warning us about. Scott has forgotten that the hotel's core, the essence of their differentiation from other luxury hotels, is the undivided service they provide to their patrons/guests. He is so intent on blaming the PVs for being a group of self-serving, liberal, free-thinkers that he has lost sight of…

    • 1707 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    From the description of the case study, it seems that the reason lead the Portman Hotel to this terrible situation was that their HR policies were inconsistent with its strategies. The Portman Hotel's philosophy is that if they want their customers treated better, they must treat each other better. They also think the Portman Hotel is a place where they can make their employees feel satisfied with their jobs. Their jobs will be fun and they will fulfill their expectations. The employees will have the best work experiences. Besides, the Portman Hotel expects to be the best employer in San Francisco. They are willing to show their trust and pride in their employees. That's why the hotel considered their "associates" of the highest potential, and, thus, they could retrain associates rather than reprimand them. In addition, they wanted to help employees gain growth in both associates' personalities and their professionalities.…

    • 2286 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Astor Lodge & Suites, Inc. is a hotel chain founded in 1979. The company operates 200 Astor Lodge properties and 50 Astor Lodge & Suites properties with locations in 10 western and Rocky Mountain states. The company focus on the business travelers as their target market, and try to provide clean and comfortable rooms at reasonable price for all customers. The company’s executives decided to position Astor Lodge & Suites, Inc. as a limited-service hotel, which places the company between midscale hotels with food and beverage and economy hotels. According to the company’s service mission and positioning, Astor Lodge & Suites, Inc. wants to provide services in convenient locations that avoided urban or downtown area, but locates on premium sites…

    • 316 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Fundamental Attribution Error(FAE) is when people do not factor in the person and the situation of what is happening (Stangor, Jhangiani & Tarry, 2014). The Department of Motor Vehicles(DMV) is the first case where I had observed the Fundamental Attribution Error. During this time, one of the workers was angry and acting mean from when it had looked like there was a sheet of paperwork missing from the stack. The paper in question had stuck to the paper in front of it due to how new the paper was when paperwork was printed. A dispositional cause, is that this woman was mean since she did not see the paper that was in the stack. A situational cause, is that she had a bad morning where her car would not start and was late for work. At that…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In order to achieve a new level of service among American luxury hotels, the Portman hotel introduced an innovative concept called 5-star team plan. When the plan was implemented, the hotel started facing many issues. The current paper presents various challenges faced by the Portman Hotel and the possible solutions that can resolve the problems in improving the business. This paper introduces three theories namely Fundamental Attribution Error, Expectancy Theory, Operant Conditional Theory in identifying the problems that fall into one of these categories.…

    • 1915 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Supply Chain note

    • 635 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The case study describes an experience of Dinsmore’s friend coming to visit the Flagship hotel, where Dinsmore took over the manager position. This guest focused on analyzing how does the hotel look from the outside and how does the actual business run inside Flagship by the request of Dinsmore. The experience was a nightmare to the guest. All the employees made mistakes from the moment the guest walked in to the hotel and walk out, plus they showed the careless attitude and lack of career professional. More importantly, Dinsmore- the one who asked for the investigation seemed to ignore all the feedbacks and the horrible service quality that his hotel is providing. Dinsmore blamed the low income of Flagship only on the restaurants but reality is the opposite…

    • 635 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays