Preview

The Pros And Cons Of Foster Care

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1956 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Pros And Cons Of Foster Care
“More than half a million children are in foster care in the United States today—roughly double the number who were in foster care in the mid-1980s, according to the Child Welfare League of America (Nakyanzi).” Kids being placed into foster care are kids who have been abused and neglected by their own loved ones, and instead of helping the kids mend the broken family, they pull them apart by sending the kids to foster home after foster home. Foster care was meant to help and protect kids from abuse and neglect that they were receiving at home; however, there are problems with the foster care system. With these problems foster kids often struggle with learning to be independent and some children even face mental and physical problems. Past studies …show more content…
Even though the system has an overwhelming number of children they lack the number of foster parents that volunteer. Pennsylvania has about 9,000 homes but 20,000 children in the foster care system; Oklahoma contains only about 4,669 foster homes but have 8,865 children that are in foster care (“Shortage of foster parents”). This difference in numbers is obviously concerning to those in the foster system trying to find places to put the children so that they are away from thoses who were neglecting or abusing them. This lack of foster parents is not only concerning but dangerous towards the children. During one of Illinois tragedies, after they abandoned family preservation, they ran out of places to put the children, “So they were jammed into a hideous shelter, then overflowed into offices.” Another Tragedie that had happened in New york, after they also abandoned family preservation, They had brought in too many children and “thousands of children were forced to sleep, often on chairs and floors, in violence-plagued, emergency makeshift shelter created from city offices, a four-year old foster child was beaten and starved to death in a foster home” (National Coalition of Child Protection Reform). Foster care is supposed to further help the children and find them a better place to be instead of being at their abusive or neglecting home; however, …show more content…
From 17,000 in 1998 to almost 30,000 in 2009, the number of young adults aging out of the foster system has exponentially increased over the years (Atwood). All these older teens without a place to call home and a family to return to because the foster care took them away, yet these numbers would stop increasing if family preservation would take over foster care. The foster care system does not prepare the young teens about being independent like living at home would tech them; in fact, most of the young adult homeless population is caused by the foster care system (Older Teens Cycle Out). Young adults who come out of foster care are used to having money given to them due to the fact that states provided money to support them while in foster care; however, now that they no longer have that money, they have to find a job. Studies in the past have shown that one of five young adults who aged out of foster care will become homeless within two years of leaving foster care. This statistic is most likely because these young adults are “shut out of jobs for lack of training, priced out of housing for lack of jobs, they also lack family support that can bridge the tough times” (Older Teens Cycle Out). The lack of family can

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Introduction In the book America, by E.R. Frank, presents a personal narrative of a man’s journey through the foster care system, and how it affected his mental health. The author’s major premise is to highlight the disparities in the foster care system and how those disparities affect the children’s mental health and future outcomes. The author’s point of view is to offer sympathy and empathy to the families involved and offer opportunities for advocacy and awareness. The author’s point of view is transferred into the content of the book to contribute to further learning and advocacy for change.…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Morgan Simpson Transition

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The advocacy project Morgan Simpson and I completed took a closer look at the transitory period foster youth face when they age out of the foster care system. Upon their eighteenth birthday, unless they sign a Continuing Residential Support (CARS) Agreement or join the LINKS program, foster youth are considered legal adults no longer under the care of the State. This means that all the services they were receiving—housing, medical, mental health, et cetera—cease. For the majority of the adolescents in a permanent family, the transition from childhood to adulthood is a gradual process comprised of stages of increasing responsibility and autonomy. Foster youth are not granted that luxury; their…

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Though the system has its pros, it also has his cons but there are solutions being made to solve some of these foster care problems. Caseworkers having too many children to keep a record of, children’s placement being moved around too much, and even bad experiences with the system, in general, are all problems being faced in foster care. Some things are being done to help make things easier for both the child and caseworkers’ side of the problems. There are new apps being made to help caseworkers keep track of their weekly or monthly visits. Also, reducing placement moves that have been associated with bad outcomes make the job of the caseworkers easier and help the children in the system as well.…

    • 906 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Many women that get unexpectedly pregnant and cannot care for a child want to find a home for their unborn where they will be taken care of. However, in some cases this can mean the child goes into foster care, orphanages, or up for adoption. This can be very beneficial for some children as they have someone that can take care of them, but on average each year “almost 270,000 youth ‘age out’ of foster care without the emotional and financial support necessary to succeed” and some children are in the system for three years or longer living in up to three different households (Carter). This puts thousands of children out into the adult world with little to no guidance and complete independence which many are not ready for. Places like orphanages or foster homes only keep children until they are adopted, reunited with their old family, or turn eighteen and are put into the real world to be an “adult”.…

    • 1644 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The foster care system in New York City is deeply flawed. Sixty-four percent of foster care children are impoverished in their adult lives, 50% of girls are pregnant within 12-18 months of aging out of the system, and 80% of all inmates on death row grew up in the foster care system. Foster care children should not have to fight against these statistics. The Felix Organization is providing solutions, through Camp Felix, Beyond Camp, the Felix Friendship Circle, and the Secret Santa Gift Exchange. Camp Felix, their largest program, is a four week long summer camp for children in foster care.…

    • 373 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Reports on employment suggest that on average only one-third to one-half of youth out of substitute care are employed, but they do not identify full time vs. part time employment.” (3) With that being said, Foster youth do not earn enough to rake them out of poverty. “On average, former foster care earned $8000 compared to a national average of $18,300.” (3) Financial independence is often unattainable for forth kids. Some challenge facing employment assistance programs for foster youth is the availability of alternative sources of employment services. A large majority of youth receiving several types of employment assistance.…

    • 880 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Definition: Foster care is defined as care for delinquents or neglected children usually in an institution or substitute home. Children in our foster care system receive long lasting effects of abuse and neglect but in some cases the foster care system has been proven to minimize the negative results of inappropriate use of child care.…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    While in foster care, nearly half of the children live in institutions or group homes rather than a private home. When these children age out of the system they usually become homeless (Beam, 2013). Unfortunately, while in foster care, children face daily struggles and are normally “worse off”. Many of them act out during…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the U.S., there are two hundred fifty thousand children that are in foster care every year (Moe, 177-192). Foster care is placing a child or children in the temporary care of a family care (Foster Care & Adoption). Children who goes through abusive or negative families had to move to in foster care because of situation. Children that were just born have to be taken away from their mothers because of the drugs she was on, or the abuse in the homes. A family that can’t provide for the child, the state will take away also. Some children are given up to foster care because that not the kind of baby they want in the family or the family just know they real can’t provide for the child. Children who are home alone and start a big problem in…

    • 1711 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    There are over 400,000 kids in the foster care system and with this many people in foster care it is easy for individuals to get lost. Josh, a former foster kid, once said, “A typical birthday was one of the saddest times in foster care, at times someone would say ‘Happy Birthday, Josh,’ but usually the day was silent. I would feel worthless, like no one valued my life” (Time for a Reform). Many foster kids don 't feel appreciated or valued because people don 't even care about them enough to find out the most basic things about them like their birthdays. Saving kids from bad situations is very good thing, but only if the system places them somewhere that they can heal from their past experiences. Many foster kids get rescued from bad circumstances like abuse only to be placed with foster parents who are also abusive. The system bounces foster kids around from house to house until they “age out”, and unfortunately the system has a poor success rate for them. Less than half of them go on to live happy lives. On average, 56% of foster kids end up unemployed once they age out, 27% of emancipated foster boys end up in prison, and 30% of emancipated foster girls end up with early pregnancy (The Twenty Five Project). A foster kid’s time in the system affects them for the rest of their lives. A child’s character and personality truly develops in their childhood and teen years; so, if your childhood and teen years are terrible, it will affect you for the rest of your life. Kids are forever changed by the system and it is very unlikely for them to ever reach their full…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    As a result of parents making a bad decision, which harms their child, “the children who need temporary and permanent families are all ages, races and ethnicities” (“Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) Foster Care and Adoption”). The foster system has a wide range of minors, which “include teenagers, toddlers, infants, children with special behavioral and medical needs and sibling groups” (“Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) Foster Care and Adoption”). Teenagers have a harder time being placed with foster families than toddlers and infants. Teenagers end up getting placed in a group home where they are not being shown the love and affection they deserve. It is true that caring for a teenager in foster care is difficult, considering that they are…

    • 195 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When children who fall under the “special needs,” and cannot find a stable home, can suffer from long-time mental, behavioral, and/or physical health problems. Teenagers who cannot find a stable home and family are more likely to suffer from depression, withdrawal behaviors, somatic behaviors, and anxiety. Close to 27 percent, or 3 in 10, of teenagers ages 11 to 18, had behavioral problems that resulted in some form of clinical assistance. Young adolescents and teenagers are more likely to internalize mental health problems after they are placed into foster care system (Woods, Farineau, & McWey, 2013; Walsh & Mattingly, 2011). With the situations many children who were removed dealt with, mental health issues are something many foster families will have to consider when taking on teenagers and children with mental and physical…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Being foster parents is known as being “stand-in” parents, the children are thought to not have all the love that most children have in life (Unrau 1260). Foster care settings include, but are not limited to, “nonrelative foster family homes, relative foster homes, group homes, emergency shelters, residential facilities, and pre-adoptive homes” (Curtis 3). Foster placements are monitored until the birth family can provide appropriate care or the rights of the birth parents are terminated and the child is adopted (Unrau 1260). Most children in foster care have no say in their placements and therefore can be placed and moved to different placements as many times as the state chooses. Simone de Beauvior believes that “the child’s situation is characterized by his finding himself cast into a universe which he has not helped to establish, which has been fashioned without him, and which appears to him as an absolute to which he can only submit” (69). This explains why so many foster parents are able to abuse and neglect…

    • 2568 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    It limits a form of childcare that is proven to be effective and beneficial. The reasons and history behind the government’s biased view of these facilities is still unclear. Orphanages offer many disadvantaged children distinct advantages over foster care, some of which are structure, stability, and a sense of permanence. Children’s homes permit siblings to stay together, afford children a chance to develop moral and religious values, encourage a sense of responsibility and work ethic, as well as much needed education and job-related skills. There is great potential for orphanages to meet the needs of the many children who currently languish for years in the modern foster care system. It is time for policymakers to recognize the distinct advantages institutional care can provide.…

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For example, a study conducted by the Pew Charitable Trusts of foster youths who age of foster care showed that fifty percent didn’t have a high school degree, and less than three percent went on to graduate college (Smith). Andrew Setterholm, writer for the Post Bulletin, talks about how the placement of children into foster homes causes trauma in the child’s life, resulting in mental health effects (Setterholm), and Sarah Geenan states students who are placed in multiple foster homes end up transferring to multiple schools (Geenan and Powers). Without direct adult support caused by this unstable environment, achieving higher grades is difficult and many youths end up not living up to their potential in school- resulting in many foster youths having a delay in gaining or never gaining at all necessary social skills and are thus blocked from receiving a higher education and a better chance of having a secure job. (Smith). James Koppel, Minnesota state commissioner for child and family services, states that “We cannot let our foster care system fail the very children that we have chosen to take out of homes due to maltreatment. We cannot fail those children in our foster care system”…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics