Preview

The Pros And Cons Of The French Revolution

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
763 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Pros And Cons Of The French Revolution
Contrary to Rousseau’s belief that the monarch should not have the power to veto, this provision of the current constitution (the Constitution of 1791) would empower the monarch to veto legislation for up to five years. This provides one essential check on the immense and wrong power of the National Assembly because it has too much power, with no other institutions to check that power. The National Assembly’s conception of power will ultimately lead to the ruin and devastation of France, largely through the lack of leadership, skill, direction, and foresight of the members of the National Assembly. The king needs to maintain his monarchical powers and rights, while the National Assembly needs to have serious checks on their powers before the …show more content…
Burke toys with the idea presented by revolutionaries that the French population has declined and will continue to decline with a monarch in power. He quickly demolishes this claim by stating, “That talk of the failure of the king and the monarchy is exaggerated, as evidenced by the growth in the French population from 18 million in 1700 to about 25 million now” (9). In addition to fighting claims about the population due to a monarchist leader, Burke also says that the nobility are not the “greedy despots; many of them are brilliant statesmen, scientists, musicians, and artists” (9). Revolutionaries are infuriated by the distinction of the nobility, not the wealth of them as many come off as a “mere work of …show more content…
Along with this, the power of the National Assembly needs to be weakened and the maintenance of social order and rights to property shall be guaranteed with this revision of the constitution. As Burke states in his Reflections, “the National Assembly has no fundamental law, no strict convention, no respected usage to restrain it” (151). Burke claims that rather than focusing on being obliged to conform a fixed constitution, “they have a power to make a constitution which shall conform to their designs” and not the people’s designs (151). Not only does Burke attack the lack of fortitude within the National Assembly, he also believes it is the source of the calamity of the French Revolution as he claims “this fond election of evil, would appear perfectly unaccountable if we did not consider the composition of the National Assembly” (152). Rather than having ill-suited people in the National Assembly, the government should be filled with men of talent and virtue and a king who maintains his monarchical power and the right to veto

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The time for a new government came about in times of fear, many men such as William Livingston wondered “if the republic could even survive another decade” for Henry Knox made an excellent point in declaring “Our present federal government is a name, a shadow, without power, or effect”. Meantime the relationship between the states was poor and there was an uncertainty if they would even remain united what with the debts, the economic turmoil, and the slow realization that without England they had no protection from the outside world. The question on everyone’s mind was, is there anything that can be done to save their country? 55 delegates gathered in hopes of answering this question with a brilliant solution of their own.…

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A newly developed constitution brought upon adverse opinions as to its “new republic form being as enshrined” as well as it being a “danger”. Both oppositional and approval views were discussed within Madison Federalist No. 10 and Patrick Henry’s Speech against Ratification.…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this essay, I will be analysing the strengths of the British constitution and comparing it to a codified constitution, I will also discuss its weaknesses and whether ‘extremely strong’ is an exaggeration and it lacks the qualities of a reliable constitution.…

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sandefur calls for people to take back over the government but at the same time brings in the complexities that is our nation by explaining how the United States is not a democracy and should never be one. He explains, that people need to take charge and become involved and educate themselves. He see the passage of Anti- gun laws and other bills as a growing disconnect between the politicians and the people as well as a direct attack on the Constitution. The author argues that the best option to fix this is in the Declaration of Independence and the natural rights that it professes that informed its drafting and approval. “The Declaration. . . must guide our understanding of our political and legal institutions” (p. 2). It is in this document and the…

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The American Revolution had a very big impact on the lives of millions at the time and history. It was a separation of the original 13 colonies from the British Empire. After years of the colonies trying to gain representatives in Parliament, they had enough. However the Revolution was not started because of one single thing that bothered the colonists. It was more like dominos which made one thing lead to another. The Colonists were able to defeat the British despite many disadvantages, due to the assistance from the French, better knowledge of the land and their determination of the soldiers.…

    • 241 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    SOCIAL: Transcript of The Lasting Social Effects of the French Revolution as evide The Lasting Social Effects of the French Revolution as evident in Mid 19th-Century France Bryttan, Mary, Daniel Social Structure before the French Revolution Large class differences between the rich and the poor French leaders were known to be very extravagant and constantly found themselves in debt The French Revolution Abolished the feudal system and monarchy of France Peasants burned and pillaged many places Mass murder of nobles and noble sympathizers Long Lasting Effects Changed the social structure beginning with the feudal system and monarchy Bourgeois and land owning classes emerged as dominant classes Caused widespread reform in other monarchies Gave…

    • 297 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Charles A. Beard’s article, “Framing the Constitution,” he suggested that there is a dichotomy between the values of the Constitution and those of the Declaration of Independence, who believed that the Constitution was a document that was only created to protect the framers’ wealth. He articulated that the reason rich framers wanted to protect against majority rule was to prevent the majority from overthrowing the rich. His purpose was to examine the circumstances and conflicting goals and ideals of the time, and how they were resolved and agreed upon in the Constitution. His analysis was very persuasive, as it effectively argued that importance of the circumstances at hand, as well as comprehensive, in that in articulates the issues and solutions of the time.…

    • 261 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    How were the Americans able to win in the American Revolution? There were many disadvantages for the American yet they were able to win many victories. The Americans were also able to have advantages over the British . The American’s achieved victory over the British because of their familiarity with the geography, they were allies with European nations and their ability to unify.…

    • 392 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Historians have debated the powers of the king and parliament for centuries, and the events that molded the power balance between the two institutions. This power balance had been changed to a large extent by the end of the seventeenth century from what it had been at the beginning; as power and control slipped out of the monarchy’s grasp and into parliament’s hands. For could James the 1st have ever imagined that in a few years time his son would be beheaded on the charge of treason, and the monarchy itself would be abolished? Could William the 3rd have contemplated having the power to command a standing army, and conducting a foreign policy independent of Parliament? No one can deny the political changes of this era, however, what can be argued is what form this change took; an evolution or a revolution?…

    • 823 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    By 1775 the American people were getting fed up with the British continuing to raise and impose taxes on the colonists. As tensions grew, the two sides started to engage in real warfare. Once the fighting ceased and the Americans had gained independence, citizens would question how revolutionary the war actually was. The American Revolution was in fact revolutionary because the battles and treaties between the two nations led to the American people getting their independence as well as inspiring another revolution.…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    America is a young country in 1787. They have just won the war for their independence and are now under the new rule of the Articles of Confederation. This government is put in place to ensure that no one leader will have too much power. The newly formed nation still has the undesirable taste of monarchy in their mouth and are hesitant to enact some sort of executive power. The Articles rely on the committee’s to take care of that missing executive branch. Committee’s prove as weak during the period after the war as they did during war itself. The legislature and committee’s lack to enact major neccesties of a government proved it was time for a change. The authors make sure to point out the flaws of the articles of confederation.…

    • 1964 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Canadian Party Discipline

    • 3485 Words
    • 14 Pages

    Mahler, Gregory. “Congress and the House of Commons: Legislative Behavior and Legislative Roles in Two Democracies.” Ed. C. Soe. Annual Editions; Comparative Politics, 02/03. 20th edition. Guilford, CN: McGraw-Hill, 2002: 74–78…

    • 3485 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Evelina!” I’ve broken something again. Master Jefferson has been spotted in the distance, and the entirety of the household of Monticello is in a frenzy. Everyone around me is rushing to get the house ready, and to make Master Jefferson’s room adequate for his anticipated return. As I seize a broom to sweep up the remnants of the jug I dropped, I think about what news he might bring of the newly proposed Constitution. In truth I am unsure about whether this constitution will help anything. On one hand, unification of the states would make this land stronger as a nation and more organized, but with the proposed president in place, it seems as if we are leaning more towards our monarchical roots. Without a bill of rights, our individual rights are threatened, but they did say that the Constitution could be…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The National Constituent Assembly originated from the National Assembly, and its purpose was to write a constitution that would create a new France, one that was based on equality, liberty and fraternity - a nation governed by the people, and for the people - where men are born and remain equal in rights. It was essentially dominated by members of the Bourgeoisie, as well as some Nobles and Clergymen, but it did not effectively represent the whole of France. The National Constituent Assembly set up a militia type force, called the National Guard, to protect themselves and their ideas, from those who were counter-revolutionary. It was led by Marquis De LaFayatte, a member of the second Estate, who was also an influential voice in the Constituent Assembly. The Assembly did not want to create a Republic, it wanted to create a…

    • 1583 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    mljnp;k knkm.

    • 5862 Words
    • 20 Pages

    Pages 8-11 debate criticisms of the constitution and the impossibility of radical reform of the constitution. It is probable that these sections are not central to exam questions asked – which tend to centre on flexibility – but at least the general arguments should be known.…

    • 5862 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Powerful Essays