The Role Of Dee In Alice Walker's Everyday Use
While reading the short story "Everyday Use" written by Alice Walker, shallow and selfish come to mind as the story describes the oldest sister, Dee. Critics will argue on how selfish she really is though. According to Nancy Tuten, author of "Alice Walker's Everyday Use," Dee, the oldest sister, has grown accustom to getting her way and not sure how to act when she is told NO. Where Susan Farrell says in her article, "Fight vs. Flight: A Re-evaluation of Dee in Alice Walker's Everyday use," Dee is not as selfish as most people believe. Susan Farrell still says that Dee is selfish, but to a point, the rest is her view of her heritage and new way of copping with the oppressed society that they live in. "Clearly, Dee privileges language
over silence," (Nancy Tuten). This is shown by how she tries to educate her younger sister, Maggie, and her mother, known only as Mama. Yet according to Nancy Tuten, Dee's knowledge gave her the power to educate her family, but instead it is used to separate herself from them, the uneducated ones. Where Dee used this to "shove us away like dimwits," (Walker). Susan Farrell will state that Dee's intentions are in the right place and she is just trying to educate her family. Farrell says that remembering that Mama is telling this story and her views on her daughter's intentions could be off a little. Meaning that Dee was trying to educate her family and keep them from being oppressed by the system. One must keep in mind that this story is told by Mama and because of that she is the one with the last word, having control over the story. We really do not know what Dee's feelings and thoughts are toward her family; we just have to take Mama's word for it. While Susan Farrell mentions that while we read about her mothers daydream involving Johnny Carson and hear how Mama thinks Dee would like her family to look like and act. We have to keep in mind that we truly do not know if this is how Dee would like the family to be, or if this is how Mama thinks Dee would like the family to be. Nancy Tuten will say that Mama secretly has distaste for her daughter Dee and there for has this Johnny Carson flashback. This flashback is really just a way for her to dream of what it would take for her oldest daughter, Dee, to respect her. Toward the end of the story, Mama tells Dee something that she has never said to her before, NO. Once again the two critics are split on why Mama had said this to her oldest daughter. Susan Farrell will tell you that when Mama took the quilts from Dee, Mama is in fact really acting like Dee would in then same situation. As in, not backing down and standing up for what she believes in. On the other hand, Nancy Tuten will say that Mama is acting on Maggie's feelings by telling Dee that she can not take the quilts; almost like Mama was responding to Maggie's nonverbal messages. When reading this short story, you must always keep in mind that the mother is the one that is doing most of the talking. We are really only getting Mama's thoughts and her thoughts alone. Still, no matter how you read this story, Dee still ends up being the selfish one.
over silence," (Nancy Tuten). This is shown by how she tries to educate her younger sister, Maggie, and her mother, known only as Mama. Yet according to Nancy Tuten, Dee's knowledge gave her the power to educate her family, but instead it is used to separate herself from them, the uneducated ones. Where Dee used this to "shove us away like dimwits," (Walker). Susan Farrell will state that Dee's intentions are in the right place and she is just trying to educate her family. Farrell says that remembering that Mama is telling this story and her views on her daughter's intentions could be off a little. Meaning that Dee was trying to educate her family and keep them from being oppressed by the system. One must keep in mind that this story is told by Mama and because of that she is the one with the last word, having control over the story. We really do not know what Dee's feelings and thoughts are toward her family; we just have to take Mama's word for it. While Susan Farrell mentions that while we read about her mothers daydream involving Johnny Carson and hear how Mama thinks Dee would like her family to look like and act. We have to keep in mind that we truly do not know if this is how Dee would like the family to be, or if this is how Mama thinks Dee would like the family to be. Nancy Tuten will say that Mama secretly has distaste for her daughter Dee and there for has this Johnny Carson flashback. This flashback is really just a way for her to dream of what it would take for her oldest daughter, Dee, to respect her. Toward the end of the story, Mama tells Dee something that she has never said to her before, NO. Once again the two critics are split on why Mama had said this to her oldest daughter. Susan Farrell will tell you that when Mama took the quilts from Dee, Mama is in fact really acting like Dee would in then same situation. As in, not backing down and standing up for what she believes in. On the other hand, Nancy Tuten will say that Mama is acting on Maggie's feelings by telling Dee that she can not take the quilts; almost like Mama was responding to Maggie's nonverbal messages. When reading this short story, you must always keep in mind that the mother is the one that is doing most of the talking. We are really only getting Mama's thoughts and her thoughts alone. Still, no matter how you read this story, Dee still ends up being the selfish one.