The Scarlet Ibis And My Brother's Keeper By Jay Bennet

The short stories “The Scarlet Ibis” by James Hurst and “My Brother’s Keeper” by Jay Bennet are both realistic examples of family dynamics and how they can affect the way siblings treat each other. “The Scarlet Ibis” demonstrates how older siblings tend to feel the need to assist or help their younger siblings in things they cannot do, often leaving the younger siblings codependent on the older siblings for everything. In comparison, “My Brother’s Keeper” demonstrates how trauma can lead to siblings leaching to each other and becoming reliant, more often one more than the other. Even when two people are not siblings but are close, one person can become codependent on the other, Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck is the prime example of this.
In "The Scarlet Ibis," the author highlights the responsibility that older siblings can feel for their younger siblings. Throughout the story, Doodle is depicted as being completely dependent on his brother, requiring constant attention and companionship. Brother recognizes that this will likely be a lifelong relationship, stating, "Doodle was my brother and he was going to cling to me forever no matter what I did" (Hurst 171). While Brother cares deeply for Doodle, he also feels frustrated by this constant need for his company, which prevents him from pursuing his interests. This story offers a poignant reminder of how younger siblings can become attached to their older siblings, and how this can be both a blessing and a challenge for the older sibling. In comparison to "The Scarlet Ibis," "My Brother's Keeper" demonstrates the responsibilities that exist in family dynamics. Jamie and Ted, two brothers who lost their parents when they were young, are the focus of the story. Jamie, the younger brother, has taken on all of Ted's obligations since then. I'm your kid
Ted's lawyer puts Jamie in a difficult position by asking him to lie in court to help his brother or tell the truth and ruin his brother's career. When Jamie seeks advice from his Uncle Harry, he realizes that Ted is solely dependent on him for support. Harry tells Jamie, "I reached out to him, but he turned away from me and went to you... and all the while you stood there, holding him, your face tight and silent. Like you were a big man, sheltering him" (Bennet 29). This story realistically portrays how siblings often rely on each other in real life, leaving one sibling to deal with all of their other siblings' problems while also taking on their responsibilities. Of Mice of Men illustrates responsibility throughout the story by showcasing the dynamic between George and Lenny. George takes on the “parent” role in Lenny’s life, looking after him and tending to his needs. Anytime Lenny causes trouble, it is up to Georges to find a way for the both of them to get out of trouble. For example, when Lenny spots something pretty, it is in his nature to touch it. It doesn't matter what it is, he just needs to touch