Kunal Kishan
English III
Mrs. Goins
October 15 2010
Diversity
How can two fictional characters a century apart influence people today? In The Scarlet Letter, written by Nathaniel Hawthorne, the reader goes back into Boston Massachusetts around the late 1840’s and experiences the Puritan life. In Chocolat, written by Joanne Harris, you are placed in the middle of France around the 1960’s during lent. Both of these stories have similar women characters in them. In the communities that they live in, the town’s people have a problem with them. Both Hester and Vianne have committed sins and must find a way to live with their own guilt and the judgmental opinions of the people. Although Hester is in Scarlet Letter and Vianne is in Chocolat, they both show determination to live their lives and not let what other people think is right bother them. Everybody may have a different opinion on what they think is right, but they do not necessarily have the right to pass judgment on others. In the Scarlet Letter, the main character Hester has committed a sin. She has had sex with another man besides her husband and now has produced a child out of wedlock. The town is ashamed to have someone like this in there community. The puritan life is to be pure and without sin. Hester’s punishment is three months in jail and sitting on the scaffold to be humiliated. She has to live in a little shack in the middle of nowhere with her daughter Rose. For Hester’s income she sews gloves, mittens, and scarves. The town
Kishan 2 looks at her as if she has three eyes. Hester is not bothered by this at all. She looks at it as a new way of life. She has accepted her sin and now is going on with her own business. “Shame, Despair, Solitude! These had been her teachers and the made her strong.”
When Hester is asked if she regrets it, she says no because she is human and everyone makes mistakes. The town is being very hypocritical toward Hester and her daughter. Instead of shunning them, they need to open up and let them their there community. If they are trying to live their life for God, they need to learn to forgive and accept Hester’s mistakes. Hester would not be as strong as she is if it was not for the sin she committed. Hester deals with her sin by being strong and as helpful as she can. She has a true heart that the people cannot seem to see because they are blinded by their judgmental minds and hears. In Chocolaat, Vianne is what any reader would call a static character. She is a mother of a child who is born out of wedlock, also. Vianne moves from town to town across France. With her she carry’s a pot of her dead mother’s ashes. She feels like there is no need to stay in one place for too long. When Vianne arrives in a small French village, she uses her gift to open up a chocolate store during lent, a time to give up your self-pleasing desires like chocolate. When the town’s Count sees this, he is disturbed and goes to talk to her. Vianne tells him in there discussion that she intends to open her store and does not want to attend their church. The Count is angry with her decision and decides to leave. The Count starts telling people that they need to avoid her shop because she is un-Godly, due to having a child out of wedlock, and is opening up a chocolate store during lent. When all of the town’s people hear this, they are scared to go into her
Kishan 3 shop because they are afraid of what people will think about them. There are a few people in town that are not bothered at all by the Count’s warnings and don’t care what the town thinks of them. Vianne is a character that is going to go on with her business and not let anybody stop her. Vianne just wants to make others happy with her chocolate treats. But happiness is hard to find in this small town. She says, “Happiness is a simple as a glass of chocolate or tortuous as the heart; bitter, sweet, alive.” She and Hester are very much alike when it comes to dealing with the town not accepting them. Hester and Vianne are both types of women that can be strong and independent. They live there lives as they please. With-out even realizing it, they have turned the towns they live in into a better place. Vianne shows the people that not everyone who does not attend church is evil, and also that you have to have an open heart to everyone, because you never know what they are going through. When Vianne shows her true inner character, people start to see that she is not a bad person after all. Her reaction to the town hating her is to continue to be good and kind. This shows the town that they need to be more open hearted and do the Godly thing and accept different outsiders. In Hester’s situation, the crime that she has committed puts a scurrilous taste in everyone’s mouth. Committing adultery is a horrible crime among the Puritans. The town’s women want Hester to be killed and fell that her punishment is too light. Hester has to deal with wearing an A on her chest for the rest of her life. She shows the town that mistakes can happen and that she is going to be able to deal with it. Her strength and ability to never lose hope, shows her good character. The town needs to not be so hypercritical because the Bible says that everyone sins and that all sins are the same in Gods’ eyes. Kishan 4 Ultimately, the common thread between these two stories and characters is an affect of sin on a person’s life. Everyone makes mistakes and commits sin. Both Hester and Vianne sin and find themselves to be the focus of an entire town’s judgmental wrath. Bother towns are made up of people who are supposed to be Godly people. But instead of offering these women compassion and forgiveness, they shun them and treat them badly. People do not have the authority to pass judgment on others. Only God can be judge of our sins People have to play for forgiveness from God, not other people. Hester and Vianne show that a person has to be strong and determined when faces with adversity. Everyone can find themselves in a similar situation to these characters and can learn from their determination.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
This is another example of Hester’s defiance and strength. When the author refers to the towns people as “her” townspeople it’s showing that even though these onlookers are scorning her, she somehow still has power over them.…
- 1624 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
English Protestants created a large group of people in the 16th and 17th centuries called the Puritans. These people advocated strict religious discipline along with a strong beliefs and worshipping. The Scarlet Letter reflected on Puritan Society in several ways, from religion to discipline and punishment. Religion seemed to control everyone, the reverend was the person that everyone looked up to, and the community, as a whole, believed in fate and destiny. Puritan relationships were very restricted, therefore making adultery a terrible sin in the eyes of the community. In the 17th century, Boston was extremely strict and the laws were strongly enforced, making Hester’s sin a great example of the consequences the Puritans suffered. Public displays of punishment were used to both teach the criminal a lesson and to show the other members of the community that what was done shouldn’t be repeated.…
- 2549 Words
- 11 Pages
Good Essays -
This quote describes a major part of Hester’s character. She is realizing that she has to except her punishment and rise above it. She will have to go on with her live enduring the stares and laughs, but she is going to accept the struggle and live her life.…
- 1122 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Hester’s view on the situation is she thinks because Roger Chilingworth had not stayed with her and traveled to America with her she was lonely and had an affair with Arthur Dimmesdale. This affair had lead to the birth of Pearl, a young and beautiful baby. Although Pearl was a living example of my wrong doings she is my most…
- 535 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
As well as most of her emotions and thoughts. The author acts in favor of Hester by placing a character in the crowd. Whom silently fights for her through her compassion. Although this, a reader can feel benevolence and empathize towards Hester and her situation. Not in the sense of committing adultery or sins; but because she must learn to forgive those who have betrayed her. An obvious situation in life that many can feel compassion towards her for. As I’ve stated earlier in the paragraph the author has made Hester a third person omniscient character. Allowing the reader into Hester’s thoughts and motives for her actions. As a sympathetic reader you feel bad for Hester and her situation. Although she has clearly sinned, she has in a sense payed her dues and has redeemed herself from her actions. As a reader you find it unfair of what she must go through for others to find justice that again cannot be found unless there is forgiveness. Why must hester and her child suffer just for the town people’s…
- 754 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The Puritan Era was the most religious time in American history; committing any sin was seen as an act of rebellion. In that time the sin of adultery was taken very literally to an extent where the women were forced to wear the letter “A” across their bosom to show the people of the town what they had committed. In The Scarlet Letter, Hester Prynne’s sin results in such a punishment, but as the reader gets deeper into the book, a prominent and more profound understanding of Hester can be reached. It is through her struggles that Hawthorne gets across his primary themes. Hawthorne illustrates his theme through Hester's struggles that becoming an outcast can help one achieve a profound grasp of who they truly…
- 697 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
When The Scarlet Letter was written the Author, Nathaniel Hawthorne, discovered many ideas and facts about the Puritan community. Knowing this Nathaniel Hawthorne wrote about how women in the 17th century lived and how strict the society's rules can be, one major rule that was followed strictly phonate was “Actions spoke louder than words, so actions had to be constantly controlled.” (nd.edu). When the book begins it starts with introducing Hester and how she has done this huge violation according to the bible, maybe even causing the death penalty upon herself. As The Scarlet Letter goes through the timeline of how she is isolated and is shunned from the society; eventually, Hester slowly becomes part of the society by being the pure character she really was. This lets her take off the scarlet “A” and change the meaning of Adultery to the meaning of Able. Hawthorne decribes the climax of Hester’s story by expressing, “The letter was the symbol of her calling. such helpfulness…
- 674 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Hester Prynne herself occasionally allows herself to stumble, permitting her faith to diminish is magnitude. Her dwindling hope has caused her to become "a bare and harsh outline" of her former self (149). Yet, in a revelation to her of the importance…
- 430 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In the beginning Hester is in jail, dealing with the fact she committed adultery, and as such is a sinner and as punishment…
- 745 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The Scarlet Letter is a novel written by Nathaniel Hawthorne. This essay discusses how Hester is a victim of her social pressure. She was punished for something she did to achieve her dream of having someone that loves her. Hester committed adultery with minister Dimmesdale and had a child with him, Pearl. Her punishment was to stand on the scaffold with her child and wear the letter A on her breast as a sign of her “crime”. Due to the strictures of the puritan society, Hester Prynne suffers from public shaming. She almost lost her only child, and was not able to openly love who she wanted.…
- 812 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne and The Awakening by Kate Chopin both strongly embody the way women were treated before women’s rights became less restricted to cooking, cleaning, and parenting. Hester Prynne and Edna Pontellier are both upper class women that cheated on their husbands. Although their situations were distinctly different, they relate to each other in several ways. Hester in the seventeenth-century and Edna in the nineteenth are great examples of the good and bad consequences of doing what you desire or what you think is right. These two women seem to have a lot in common, like how they feel towards their lovers; however, they differ in their feelings towards their children and they both have…
- 1295 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Hester was forced to confess her sin to the world, unlike her counterpart Dimmesdale. She was forced to be truthful and accept the punishment and stigma; “Thus the young and pure would be taught to look at her, with the scarlet letter flaming on her breast,—at her, the child of honorable parents,—at her, the mother of a babe, that would hereafter be a woman, —at her, who had once been innocent, —as the figure, the body, the reality of sin” (chapter 5, page 54), This quote demonstrates how the Puritan Community placed all of the blame and burden of the sin of adultery on Hester. She was forced to accept all of the shame that…
- 2044 Words
- 9 Pages
Good Essays -
“Whose is the greater guilt therein when either’s conduct may dismay: she who sins and takes the pay, or he who pays her for her sin?” (Cruz 296). In the 1600’s, when a woman commits adultery and brings shame upon her husband she is often put to death as punishment. However, in Hester Prynne’s case she is shamed with a scarlet letter and excluded from society. In the novel written by Nathaniel Hawthorne, The Scarlet Letter, Hester is forced to wear a Scarlet Letter “A” upon be bosom for the rest of her life. Yet, why is one person punished when the act of adultery must be committed by two? Hester’s partner in the sin committed, Mr. Dimmesdale, even though he was not revealed until the end of the story, would not have faced a punishment so severe.…
- 1027 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The same can be said of the sick, poor, and elderly people whom Hester helps because they are the unwanted members of society, just like her. However, their sins are not things that they did, but rather misfortunes that had happened to them, and therefore society will not assist them with their needs. Hester helps these people because she understands them and therefore has empathy for them. Even as she is giving them food, clothing, and financial aid, they mock her and spit on her, but she still helps them, like a true martyr. Soon, it becomes difficult for the townspeople to hate her because she does kind deeds and exemplifies the message of Christianity, but they still want to hate her because of the badge that she wears. For the Puritans, it is easier to find a scapegoat than to acknowledge your own sins, but Hester shows them through her actions that it is sometimes easier to love than to…
- 345 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
passed judgment on Hester and her sin is laid bare to the reader's opened eye.…
- 659 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays