Preview

The Skeptical Subjectivist Perspective

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
853 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Skeptical Subjectivist Perspective
The Skeptical Subjectivist Perspective Many Christians adopt a rigid transcendentalist view on morals. However, compared to the other views, subjectivist and objective relativist, they tend to be closed and unobservant. Paul Kurtz, author of Science and Ethics, attacks this view by demeaning the close-minded, faith-based approach on morals (p. 13). While Christians should retain their biblical, faith-based perspective, Kurtz has a point when he suggests for us to be more open to observations made in science when tackling issues on morals in our daily life. Throughout my reading, I have concluded that, as Christians, adapting a skeptical transcendentalist perspective is important because it allows an objective approach to morals, does not set “artificial limits” to arguments, and allows one to include an opponent in a loving, Christ-like manner. Securing a skeptical transcendentalist perspective is key in allowing oneself to make evidence-based assessments on ethical issues. Morals and ethical issues can be solved more peacefully by seeking evidence that may explain a transcendentalist viewpoint. When it comes to moral issues such as abortion, Christians are quick to rigidly say, “It is murder, and God says not to murder.” However, Kurtz considers this a value that is not “influenced by cognition and informed by rational inquiry and scientific evidence (p. 20).” A good example of this is found in embryonic engineering (p. 59). Christians are highly opposed to the fact that an embryo in a petri dish is not life (p. 60). They say that since conception, a zygote is life. However, according to science, it does not fit within the requirements for life (p. 62). Arthur Caplan, who was interviewed in Science and Ethics, says, “The religious view that holds that all embryos are persons, or even potential persons, does not square with the facts (p. 61).” Caplan further explains that scientific reasoning is hindered by the Christians unbending absolution on not

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    This paper will delve into Christians Anthropological Dualism and Materialism/Physicalism, finding the positive and negative aspects of both viewpoints. Christian Dualism is the true anthropological viewpoint available, and this paper will bring out the common pitfalls of materialism. This subject is important in today’s society because many atheists do not believe in life after death, affirming that there is nothing in the world apart from the physical body despite the abundance of evidence present. Materialism, while it does have some advantages, is clearly inferior to Dualism, specifically Christian Dualism, as the most plausible explanation for the current state of the humans. While Materialism is embraced by much of the scientific and academic community of this world, Christian Dualism is the more correct view on anthropological dualism, and if this is correct, it has life changing implications for humans living today.…

    • 1018 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The sufficiency of her evidence cannot be doubted when bombarded with example after example. One of her key arguments is that although human embryos have moral value, they cannot be granted full moral status like humans. This is due to the fact that they do not have “beliefs, desires, goals and projects” (Steinbock 130). In an example, she compares embryos to comatose patients. She argues that embryos have no nervous system, thus they can’t desire anything nor experience anything, including death. Meanwhile, comatose patients have goals and desires present inside them, including their desire to live. This makes perfect sense. She uses an accurate, relevant and easily understood example to distinguish embryos from humans which shows why it isn’t morally wrong to kill an embryo for research although it is wrong to kill a human. What the author implies is also relevant to all embryos. Furthermore, Steinbock emphasizes that due to this absence of “interests”, embryos merit respect, but not Kantian respect like humans do because it should only be applied to people with interests. In another example, she establishes what kind of respect they deserve by comparing the use of human embryos for research to the use of corpses in medical school for learning. Just like cadavers are respected for…

    • 1391 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Yearley, Lee H. “Selves, Virtues, Odd Genres, and Alien Guides: An Approach to Religious Ethics”.…

    • 1938 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The debate over whether abortion should be legal and to what point in the pregnancy it should be allowed has polarized many societies. Many religious preach that at the moment of conception, the new life is human and possesses a soul. Therefore, abortion is murder. Other, less extreme views, suggest the life is not human until there is a recognizable "completion of form." A third view proposes we have an obligation to create a good life for all children already born before we bring more unwanted children into the world.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thomas Aquinas liked this idea and introduced the idea of God. If God created the world ex nihilo ‘out of nothing’ God is the author of the natural world, and the world is as he intended it to be. This made it compatible with Christianity. The imago dei (ideal plan for humans) exists within the divine mind before creation, meaning that things are planned. So when this idea is applied to embryology people who follow natural moral law argue that it doesn’t fit with Gods plan. That and embryo once fertilized should reach its end goal, which is becoming a human and any act that prevents that, is morally wrong.…

    • 528 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Pro-Life

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Schwarzwalder, Rob. "The Best Pro-Life Arguments for Secular Audiences." Family Research Council. Web. 22 May 2013. <http://www.frc.org/>.…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    By the educational research state Growing concern about a shrinking cultural consensus on values, coupled with religious pluralization and the realization that schooling is not, and cannot be, value-neutral, have led to proposals to teach ethics in schools, interpreted as a contribution of the discipline of philosophy to the common curriculum. To the extent that this approach is seen to hinge on the alleged autonomy of ethics, it has the potential to indoctrinate the contestable view that rationality is the prime motivator of moral commitment. A case is made for regarding philosophical ethics and religious (or world-view) studies not as alternative avenues to values education but each as a core curriculum priority, different but complementary to the other in its content. (Hill, 2014) there for as Wilkens writes in his book Christian worldview are valid tools to bring to the table in evaluating our moral bases. At the same time, it employs the usual means of critiquing ethical theory—logical consistency, possibility of universalization, consequences and the like.…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Moral skeptics may have moral beliefs that they perceive to be true, yet not justified, but have not made substantive arguments for why they think so. As such, critics…

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pro Life Paper

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Abortion is arguably one of the most controversial issues discussed in the world today as the laws and ideas of right or wrong are argued by just about everyone. Many believe abortion should be considered murder and that you are taking the life of an innocent human being. Others believe that it is up to the mother, and in many cases that of the father as well, to make that decision. In this paper I will argue the secular view of the pro-life argument.…

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Abortion: Moral Issues

    • 1004 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Some critics believe that abortion is a woman’s choice; others believe that termination of a life even before it is born is still murder. I highly doubt that pro-choice advocates would support their stance if they too believed that abortion was murder, so how then can they justify their pro-choice affiliation? The true question to be asked is when does life actually begin? There would be no questions asked if someone could prove the point at which life begins. However there is a grey area, we do not know when “life” begins. Some believe at conception, others at heartbeat, and others at brain waves. No one can say for sure, I however prefer the stance of “better safe than sorry” when it comes to another possible humans life. The moral issue is determined by one’s belief of the beginning of life, is it murder or is it really just an optional part of a woman’s body that can be removed, like a skin tag. Currently in the United States 1.3 million babies are aborted every year. The leading reasons for abortion today are inadequate funding and lack of readiness for responsibility. These reasons are completely ridiculous when looking at abortion from the pro-life framework of thinking, if it is a human life, then it is murder to abort the baby and therefore no reason for termination can be justified. (Word count: 230)…

    • 1004 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In-vitro fertilization (known as IVF) is a process whereby the sperm of a man and the egg of a woman are united outside the womb. The embryo is then implanted in the womb of the prospective mother. Moral issues over the process have sometimes clouded the desirability of the procedure. Some Christians object to IVF because they feel it prevents couples from adopting. Other Christians feel that embryos developed during IVF but later left to perish essentially constitutes murder. By addressing these two objections, I hope to provide validation that IVF should be considered a morally permissible form of assisted reproduction for Christian families.…

    • 2478 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Christian Psychology

    • 1284 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The knowledge of Christian beliefs makes a PhD researcher’s worldview be determined by the scripture and not the biological, psychological or social behaviors people manifest. Therefore, Christianity helps a PhD researcher researching on psychological issues to understand that secular approaches to psychological cases can only be effective in eradicating the symptoms of a psychological problem and not the problem itself (Zickar, 2013). The Christian belief that people should be able to come out of sin and understand the reasons why they should stay away from is an important thing psychologists should incorporate into their work. When this happens, it becomes possible that the PhD researches target more the psychological problems and not the symptoms of the problem in their researches. Moreover, the Christian beliefs will ensure that the researchers endeavor to use their work to help society lead healthy and holy lives that makes people stay away from pain (Haeney, 2014). Nevertheless, the Christian worldview and approaches to psychological issues should not obscure the secular approaches. The most important thing a researcher has to do is to have the two worldviews and incorporate them well to…

    • 1284 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Religion is a big factor in the opposition of stem cell research as some religions such as the Catholic Church go against any form of prevention of life (Surve, 2009). Embryonic usage for research should not be denied based on views considering it to be unethical because most fertilised eggs are lost due to natural causes where implantation does not occur (Rettner, 2014). This leads to the conclusion that not all fertilised embryos have the potential to form into human beings. This proves that they cannot be considered as a human being unless it is implanted in the human uterus and its cells have started specialising to form its nervous system and organs. Embryos at early phases should therefore be considered as a mass of cells with the potential to become a life and if not, then they should be considered to be cells with the potential to contribute to…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Human pain and suffering,” (Presbyterian Church, United States) shows a very mixed and peaceful view of an issue that, on the contrary, sets many aflame. A distasteful blessing to most, stem cells taken from aborted fetuses in order to conduct forward-moving health research, causes ethical chaos between those of 21st century science and those of impenetrable morality. The pros of this research factually out-weigh the cons created by humanity’s biased principals, but these ethical principals endowed to society upon generations will always argue what is “truly right.”…

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    ABORTION

    • 3257 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Every day 115,000 pregnancies are aborted around the world.[1] Is this wrong or is it right? Should it be legal, or illegal? Abortion is a complex and complicated issue that has been the subject of debate for decades, but perhaps it’s not as complex and complicated as it really seems to be. When we use instrumental agents of logic, science, morality and theology, it is possible to sort through the complexity and find simplicity in the argument. It is my hope that in using these tools, you will see the reality behind this long standing debate, and agree as a final cause, that the only moral, ethical and logical side to maintain in this great debate is the Pro-Life position.…

    • 3257 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays