Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

The Socius and the Neighbor Research

Better Essays
2072 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Socius and the Neighbor Research
The true meaning of SOCIUS and the NEIGHBOR
We've discussed these in our Philosophy class and I enjoyed it since it is one of the way to be "FULLY HUMAN" or a better person in order to achieve our goals in life.

Probably, you'll find these words in English dictionary. FYI, you can't find the word SOCIUS and the they defined NEIGHBOR as a person who live next to your house; I think this is the meaning ofNEIGHBORHOOD not NEIGHBOR.

What do you mean by the SOCIUS and the NEIGHBOR?

A French philosopher best known for combiningphenomenological description with hermeneuticinterpretation named Paul Ricœur clarified those two things.

According to him, Socius is the human relationship that you have with an organized group or the person that you can encounter through his/her social function. On the other hand,Neighbor is the personal way that you can encounter another as a person, the interpersonal, with varying degrees of intimacy.

So, in other words, being a SOCIUS has a social function and NEIGHBOR is the real attitude of a person and has no social function.

Paul Ricoeur also said that there is no Sociology of the Neighbor. Since the Science of the neighbor is thwarted by the praxis(deeds) of the neighbor. Which means, one does not have a neighbor: "I make myself someone's neighbor".
Though, these two are complete opposite they can be as ONE to help us to be "FULLY HUMAN". These two are the two faces of the same charity(PAUL RICOUER).
UHmmm..Why did he said so?
Two faces of the same charity because they have different approaches. The neighbor is whom we knew to be the primary mover of such charity, we thought that they are the only one who is capable or who possessed this deed. But we also have to consider that the socius also had their own face of charity and we can see this through their institutions. The neighbor works their charity in a direct manner, through a man-to-man relationship with others; while the socius was in an indirect manner. They can be of the same charity when they work at the same time. Charity must come hand in hand with justice.
A reflection on The Socius and the Neighbor by Paul Ricœur
This reflection talks mainly about the insight presented by Paul Ricœur in his article the Socius and the Neighbor, “..the depth of human relationships often appears only through the failures within the social realm: there is a technocratic or an institutional slumber, in the sense in which Kant spoke of a dogmatic slumber, from which man is awakened only when he is socially stripped, be it by war, revolution, or great historical disasters.” The discussion talks about the observed pattern appearing and recurring in human history which could be explained by the statement Ricœur has made. In the midst of disasters, be it war, revolution, or tragedies, the depth of human relationships are seen and emphasized; in a way, he is moved and awakened. There is a certain tendency in a human person where he defies his social function and moves toward becoming available for another whenever there is a drive pushing him to do so. Thus, from taking the role of the socius, he becomes someone's neighbor.

Along with the civilization of mankind was the emergence of human relationships. These relationships may start coldly and purely functional between two Neanderthals seeking to survive, but would eventually grow into a partnership and interdependence on each other. The concept of these relationships could have originated from one common goal which is to survive, which would then evolve into something much deeper as eras go by. Thus, relationships as such may be classified according to how deep the individual goes relating with another. The evolution and progress of human society has resulted into innovations in day to day activities. In the hope of improving lives, man finds himself in the midst of a reality where everything is seemingly complex and has highly evolved. Man gained new and specific roles. Institutions and organizations were founded. Environment has changed and new challenges and demands spring up keeping human brains thinking and asking. With the appearance of new roles come new interactions between human encounters. Compared to eras ago, communication, generally, interactions among people today are made easier and faster. Transactions and tasks are accomplished more efficiently because of technological advancements. Thus lots of activities may be inserted into anyone’s schedule, making a lot of people “busier”. Each one has his own business and each one has his own role to play. With these, it is normal for anyone to be absorbed in his role and concentrate with his job. Doing otherwise may result into chaos and disorder in systems and institutions, giving a chance for failures to spring up in the social realm. These are inevitable, however, but should be solved right away for man to achieve a specific task. Solutions to failures are attended to by “troubleshooters”. They are the ones who fix errors and try to make everything back to normal. Since disorders stop a certain system from functioning, there is an event of halt. Events unplanned happen during the break in the system. The worker encounters the troubleshooter as the troubleshooter helps the worker. A certain degree of uniqueness and importance is seen in this situation because it is unlike any normal day in the worker’s life where he does his monotonous job. In the instance, the worker is given the chance to deal and encounter the troubleshooter. The worker gives importance to the troubleshooter because of the help he has given in fixing the errors in the system. Without the failure, the importance of the troubleshooter would not be realized. The idea of somebody who would get out of the way to help a person would then not be made real. The relationship of the worker to the troubleshooter may in a way be deeper as compared to the relationships dealt by the worker in chiefly doing his job – the encounter he has with co-workers or clients. Going deeper into our analysis, deep relationships are not those which are purely functional. They are something beyond that. Examples of such relationships are mother-daughter relationships, relationship as lovers, relationship as best friends, etc. Persons involved in these relationships are accountable to each other. Using the example of the relationship of lovers, the other would not be called a lover without the presence of the other lover. Connections and relationships such as these are hard to break and difficult to forget. Unlike those relationships which are generally functional, like worker to worker relationships, the other worker may go on to find his place and role even in the absence of another worker. But it is important to note that deep relationships are the results of the failures in the social realm. Assuming that everybody could just go on living to do purely functional stuffs, there is no need for the longing of deep human relationships to be filled because it does not exist in the first place. For instance, if a child could grow fully and strongly without a mother figure, then that is a manifestation that human relationships need not be deep enough. In other words, if love is not needed, we could just go on doing functional tasks. Even in the presence of families and friends, interactions among them may sometimes become functional. Only in the presence of trials and problems may their love and compassion be witnessed. During these events can their availability be seen as to what they can offer, how much weight can they carry, and how much farther they can carry it for the other who is in need. In times like these can we see how love of the neighbor is much more profound than that of functional ties. Seeing how love can be abstract could we also see how it is concretized. We might want to wonder how society came to be what it is now. Somehow, man has an end point in mind when he thought of continuous innovation, series of experiments and research studies. Man wanted to make life as easy as possible where it is better everyday and everything is comfortable and manageable. Somehow, we could infer that in people’s being absorbed to tasks and work, they are showing their love to everyone who benefits from their work and efforts. This is how they love a multitude. Somehow, the love is not shown anymore and is not manifested because it is the task which they are focusing about and not the beneficiaries. Thus, exists an institutional slumber where people tend to forget the essence of human relationships over human roles and tasks. This love however is awakened by disasters and unfortunate events that happen. In a way, people are shaken and stirred to think about what is left after disasters occur. They tend to realize what it is that matters most, not their jobs nor their social roles, but their relationships to other people. That is why in calamities, heroes appear, compassion is shown, and people suddenly become available for other people they don’t even know. It is important to note the significant realizations acquired from Ricœur's statement. Man has always tried to make things better for him and his society. It is also in this way that man's concern and love for another is shown. However, man gets quite absorbed in his role. The tendency to become functional sets in. In his functionality can we see man's skills and abilities. He is highly honored and respected whenever he discovers or invents something, or finds a solution for a global problem. However, man's subjectivity and ability to love is shown strikingly when he is socially stripped. More than that, the love he gives is given much value. Somehow, his being human is much more appreciated in this context of facing challenges, problems and being pushed in the idea of sacrifice. Man could either offer his availability to another or be the one who accepts help from another. This implies that in being socially involved, man is able to fill in a certain level of need in another person. For man, therefore, to be truly human, he needs to exercise his talents and abilities without disregarding the love he could give to another. In the imperfect world, people could not afford to be purely functional. Man is above animals. There is more to just survival. Because of the imperfect world and society, the acts of love and compassion are even magnified. It is then that together we strive to improve everything, and in improving everything, the tendency to be functional shows up, leading us to be surprised by historical tragedies driving the cycle of love and functionality.

Paul Ricoeur’s “The Socius and the Neighbor” (“Le ‘Socius’ et le Prochain”) is my favorite Ricoeur essay. The beauty of the essay derives from the exquisite fitness of its theme to Ricoeur’s interests and talents; the bridging of two seemingly incommensurate discourses (theology and sociology) through a close interpretation of a beautiful New Testament text (the parable of the Good Samaritan). What results is an interpretive tour de force. Ricoeur’s eloquence flows from the sheer power and precision of his thought, and this eloquence is nowhere in better evidence. Ricoeur’s purpose in this essay is to find a productive link between the institutions of social justice and the charity of the individual. How does one make a sociological inquiry into the injunction to love thy neighbor? How can one bring dispassionate observation to the imperative to love thy neighbor? There seems to be an unbridgeable chasm in the deficiencies of each, the cold bureaucracy of the anonymous governmental agency and the sheer insufficiency of the individual act of charity. To begin, Ricoeur uses the parable of the good Samaritan (Luke 10: 25-37) to show how “a behavior in the first person” defies social categories. The ensuing reflection sharpens the antinomy he creates at the outset (“There is no sociology of the neighbor.”) before resolving the antimony in favor of a necessary collaboration between institutional stability and acts of personal affirmation. Ricoeur, Paul. “Le ‘Socius’ et le Prochain.” Christianisme Social 68:7-9, July/Sept. 1960. 462-474.“The Socius and the Neighbor.” History and Truth. Trans. Charles A. Kelbley. Northwestern UP, 2006. 98-109.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    2. Analyze the difference between Charity and unselfishness? Do you agree with Screwtape in his belief that unselfishness can have harmful effects?…

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    I came across this documentary on PBS titled “A League of Denial” (http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/film/league-of-denial/). This documentary explores the unreported and hidden concussion related injuries in the NFL. “A League of Denial” piques my interest. It begs the question why were these injuries hidden; who knew, why they did nothing, and how could the players do nothing? Of course, one obvious answer is money, but I would like to analyze how sports tend to perpetuate this machismo persona.…

    • 1690 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    woman in the catcher

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages

    their motives in collecting money as pure, whilst he condemns his mother’s charity works as…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Clotfelter, C.T. and T. Ehrlich., Eds. Philanthropy and the Nonprofit Sector in a Changing America.…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Application Assignment 1

    • 3999 Words
    • 16 Pages

    The term social location refers to where you are located in society. It includes not only physical places, but also personal characteristics. Our social location is central to our relationships with others. Sociologists have documented that social location influences almost all aspects of our lives. (Henslin, 2011)…

    • 3999 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Definitions For Ethics GCSE

    • 2503 Words
    • 11 Pages

    One way in which Animals are used for medical research= Test safety of other products One way in which a Christian might support a charity = With money by donating 10% to the church which will then raise funds for a specific charity. One way in which Christians might put charity into practice = By committing themselves to voluntary work.…

    • 2503 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    SOCIOLOGY 1001A

    • 4922 Words
    • 22 Pages

    Helps us assess opportunities and constraints in our own lives and the lives of others…

    • 4922 Words
    • 22 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Charity is the kindly or sympathetic disposition to aid the needy as a result of deep feeling or understanding. Charity exists in many different forms. It can be seen in the forms of helping the poor, those who have disabilities, and efforts for a cure to disease. People often neglect charity from their daily lives, but there is always someone in need. There is no financial gain; instead, a feeling of self-worth and respect is produced. Timothy…

    • 3248 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    6 august, 1945 America had attacked Hiroshima, Japan with nuclear bomb named little boy. Nuclear bomb has taken around 10000 lives in the provenience of explosion. Three days later again an attack had occurred with the same type of the bomb named fat man in Nagasaki. The intensity of the bomb was 12500 TNT and it had caused around 4000 degree Celsius. It was enough to vaporize the flesh and bones of humans. It was a nightmare for the people of Japan.…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his book and short article The Life You Can Save is almost all uncontroversial, yet, while Singer’s ability at glorifying ones self is marvelously hitched to well worthy causes. But certainly his objective of the book was not to make others feel guilty, rather, to get individuals to donate and give more than usual, also being if it is not as much as they can. And unlike come areas of the government, Singer does not believe in supporting a local…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Human Observation Project

    • 2537 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Burlingame, Dwight F. "Altruism and Philanthropy: Definitional Issues." Essays on Philanthropy 10. Indianapolis: Center on Philanthropy at Indiana University, 1993.…

    • 2537 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Soc Theory Paper

    • 405 Words
    • 2 Pages

    ‘it is always the doctors patient’ This paper will be discussing the struggle of allied health practitioners to achieve professional status. This health issue can be discussed under many different sociological theories however Feminism in particular sociological/ Marxist feminism with touching on post modern feminism also, shows great understanding around the health issues and gives an understanding of the way of health and health care in Australia. It explains how medical dominance in this field overrights the Allied health professional through subordination the allied health professionals being under direct authority of doctors in the hospital system in particular. Feminism also shows that in this field Allied health practioners are predominantly woman and medical professionals hold a patriarchy over allied health and the sexual division of the two. Finally closing point of how many womens health issues in past and present are again predominantly male.…

    • 405 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In this brief essay I will be discussing two main ideas: Social location’s role to sociology and the concepts of sociology being relevant to my life.…

    • 460 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Often, the philanthropist doesn’t make the decision to give until there is a building to put “her”name on or another naming opportunity to establish recognition in perpetuity. The decision could often be based on the admiration of others or a deep sense of self satisfaction. This is because philanthropy is not altruistic. Rather, it is the confluence of altruism with egoism. Philanthropy is where selflessness and self-centeredness meet.…

    • 2888 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Society – This is known sociologically as a group of people related to each other through persistent relations (usually sharing the same geographical location) Society has norms which is expected behaviour of each individual, thus it is an important factor in your activities and friend choice. It must be societally acceptable else you may be labelled deviant.…

    • 344 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays