The courts serve as the venue where disputes are then settled and justice is administered. In Australian courts the adversarial system of trial is used to determine guilt, this is two sides, one representing the accused the other the state, debate over the guilt of the accused; this is mediated by a neutral third party, the judge or magistrate. Guilt is determined by the judge, magistrate or a jury. Punishment for the accused if found guilty is determined by the judge or magistrate.
Discuss the use of the adversary system as a means of achieving justice.
The adversarial system is a system where two parties, one representing the accused the other the state or the plaintiff, argue the over the guilt of the accused whilst being mediated buy a neutral third party, a judge or magistrate, in many cases a jury is required to determine guilt, in minor matters guilt is determined by a magistrate, or in the high court a panel of judges determines guilt. Some of the merits of this system is as follows, the adversarial system promotes vigorous examination and debate of all evidence and testimonies presented before the court this is an almost guaranteed way of discovering the truth of evidence.
Examine the role of legal representation in the criminal trial
They must also act in accordance with their client’s instructions and maintain client confidentiality. The defense lawyer’s role is to present evidence and argument to the court in support of the defense case both at first instance and on appeal. Usually solicitors appear primarily in Local Court proceedings, although barristers can and do as well. Barristers, as specialist advocates, appear for the defense in more complex and serious criminal matters in the District Court, Supreme Court, Court of Criminal Appeal and High Court.
Assess the use of defenses to criminal charges in achieving justice.
The use of defenses as a means of achieving justice is a good way to uphold justice for the accused if the accused committed the offence as a means of self-defense, or was under duress to do so or if the accused was mentally unable to discern that whatever he/she was doing at the time was morally or legally wrong. Though these defenses often do not excuse the committing of the crime fully they can still either downgrade the charge or achieve a significant reduction in penalty, defenses are a way to achieve justice for the accused.
Discuss factors that affect sentencing decisions, including the purposes of punishment and the role of the victim.
The factors affecting sentencing decisions include the victim’s impact statement. A Victim Impact Statement is used by the court before an offender is sentenced to help the judge or magistrate understand the impact of a crime on the victim. The variety of purposes for punishment can demand very different sentencing decisions for example if the objective of sentencing is rehabilitation, the punishment will be less severe than that for retribution or incapacitation.
Evaluate the effectiveness of different types of penalties, including diversionary programs.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Most common forms of ADR which are available are – Negotiation (It is a simple procedure in which parties involved in dispute discuss with each other to reach a voluntary settlement.),Mediation (In this method, the parties use a mediator to propose a settlement of their dispute), Arbitration ( In it, the parties chooses a third party to hear evidence and testimony and then decide the dispute), Mini-trial (In it, lawyers from both parties present their case to representatives of each party so that parties can know strengths and weaknesses of their cases.), Fact-finding(the parties employs a neutral third party who act as fact-finder for the investigation of case and the information investigated by Fact-finder can be used in negotiating settlement.), Using a Judicial Referee (With the parties agreement, the court may appoint a judicial referee to conduct a private trial and give a judgment and their decisions stand as judgments of the court). (Cheeseman,…
- 781 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
First I will start off with the one who has all the authority, the judge. The judge is the one who makes all the rules. Next is the prosecuting attorney. The prosecuting attorney may also be known as the district attorney, state’s attorney, county attorney, commonwealth attorney or solicitor. The prosecuting attorneys duty is to conduct criminal proceedings on the behalf of the state or the people against those accused. The three main roles of the prosecutor are investigating crimes, to decide whether or not to instigate legal proceedings and to appear in court. All of the duties of a prosecutor may become too much for one person to handle so they supervise a staff of assistant district attorneys who do most of the work in the courtroom. The prosecuting attorney determines which cases to pursue by the amount of evidence that they gather. If the attorney cannot find enough evidence to get a conviction then they may make the decision to drop the case. Next is the defense attorney. The defense attorney is the one who represents the one being accused of a crime. Public defenders also represents those accused of crimes, however they are state employed lawyers.…
- 337 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Their main goal is to obtain the complete dismissal of the charges brought against their client or obtain a not guilty ruling by the jury of their peers or the judge. The criminal justice system is a 3 part system which includes the judge and jury, the prosecutor, and the defence lawyer. Each part of the system is there in order to prevent abuse of power, and make sure each person receives a fair and equal trial. If the accused did not have a defense attorney they would have noone to fight for them and their rights, this would cause the system to be even more corrupt and unbalanced, as every person presented to the court would already be guilty because they have no one to show the contradicting evidence in their…
- 413 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The prosecutor has a very important role as a member of the courtroom workgroup. The prosecutor may also be known as the district attorney, states attorney, or the commonwealth attorney (Schmalleger, 2011). The prosecutor is responsible for making and presenting the case of the state against the accused. In their own way the prosecutor speaks on behalf of the people, for the law or laws broken by the defendant. The…
- 1183 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Barristers are lawyers who argue a clients case where as Solicitors prepare paper work and usually handle civil cases which includes divorces, wills for husband and wife, suing someone and offering no win no fee personal injury claims, they sit and work in the lower courts which are the magistrate’s courts and county courts.…
- 967 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
There are different models of criminal courts that help society understand how they should work. These models consist of the adversarial and consensual models. The most familiar model is the adversarial model. This is also called the combat model. “In this model, the prosecutor and defense attorney ‘fight it out’ by vigorously contesting the evidence before a judge acting as a neutral referee over the proceedings” (Steven Barkan, Law and Society: An Introduction, 279-280. Pearson Education, Inc. 2009). In most cases, a consensual model is used. This can be done by a good deal of cooperation with the prosecution and the defense. “Fighting it out” is a way to slow down processing of a case, especially when the main goal is to get through most cases as quickly as possible. According to Law and Society, “the adversarial model largely operates for only…
- 1694 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
They advise the clients of their rights, explains what can happen for each step of the criminal procedure and help ensure their client’s rights are not violated. The defense attorney must be knowledgeable and competent through all phases while failure in this can have disastrous consequences for the attorney and the defendant. The attorney will help with plea bargains arrangements, decide what is going to be the best course of action to defend the charges or help negotiate a guilty plea punishment. The defense attorney’s position does not end with the completion of the criminal trial. They will also be needed for the trial’s punishment phase, and any appeals process or parole hearings. The attorney must be able to develop a meaningful relationship with the client in order to provide the proper defense counsel. The Sixth Amendment guarantees the “effective assistance of counsel” for criminal defendants.…
- 933 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
A defense attorney is the advocator to the accused. In his defense, the attorney will advise him or her as well as to make sure their rights are not violated. According to the American Bar Association they must also give quality representation, and not misinterpret any facts or laws to the court or to the accused. Andrew Cohen from “Why Defense Attorneys Matter” explains that even though the accused is unpopular, or despised they need to have representation for our Constitutional principles to succeed. We must try to hold the police and prosecutors accountable, defense attorneys can be related to the Bill of Rights because, the Bill of Rights was designed as a counterbalance to the enumerated power of the government that was listed in the…
- 770 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
There are many parts to the duties of the defense attorney. While representing the accused throughout the case, they may engage in diverse…
- 445 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The United State’s Criminal Justice system allows people to be put to a fair trial within a court of law. This means that everyone has the right to be tried for the crimes that he or she is being charged with and has the right to an unbiased trial. Though everyone has this right, many people do not know how the trial process works, or do not know what the courtroom personnel do. The purpose of this paper is to explain how the major personnel of the courtroom work and the rolls and responsibilities of each person.…
- 1288 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Within the walls of any courtroom exemplified is the adversarial system of the United States of America between prosecutors and attorneys. In a logical sense, both roles and responsibilities are somewhat similar but contrasting.…
- 316 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
A lawyer may refer not only to law but to other considerations such as moral, economic, social and political factors that may be relevant to the client's situation. The lawyer may give more than purely technical legal advice in relevance to the client's situation.…
- 952 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The court system was formed to separate the innocent from the guilty when a disparity has surfaced or developed. In the criminal justice system everyone is entitled to a fair and unbiased trial. We will be identifying and describing the distinguishing features of the major court system ranging from state level, superior court and federal district court through the U.S. Supreme Court. Second we will discuss the key players, jurisdiction rules, and interpretation on issues and the effect of evolving technologies on the court proceeding at all levels in the court system.…
- 1224 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Jane Addams (September 6, 1860 - May 21, 1935) was a pioneer settlement social worker, public philosopher, sociologist, author, and leader in women's suffrage and world peace. In an era when presidents such as Theodore Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilsonidentified themselves as reformers and social activists, Adams was one of the most prominent[1] reformers of the Progressive Era. She helped turn the US to issues of concern to mothers, such as the needs of children, public health, and world peace. She said that if women were to be responsible for cleaning up their communities and making them better places to live, they needed the vote to be effective in doing so. Addams became a role model for middle-class women who volunteered to uplift their communities. She is increasingly being recognized as a member of the American pragmatist school of philosophy.[2] In 1931 she became the first American woman to be awarded the Nobel Peace Prize and is recognized as the "father" of the social work profession in the United States.…
- 4683 Words
- 19 Pages
Better Essays -
A defense attorney can either be hired by the client, or the courts can appoint one to the accused. Prosecutors are there to represent the people and that…
- 1422 Words
- 4 Pages
Powerful Essays