Preview

The Trolley Problem

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
452 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Trolley Problem
Shiaa K
PHIL 1020: Ethics

Paper #1
Supposing I observed a runaway train at the rail-yard and if it continues hurtling in the direction it is going, it will kill five people. Luckily for me, I’m standing next to a power switch and if I pull the lever of the switch, the train will divert into a different track. However, there is one person working on this track and if I pull the switch, that rail worker will die. Here’s what I would do. I would in fact pull the lever of the switch to spare the lives of the five people working in the rail-yard. The reason to that is even though it is not my obligation and my right to be a “hero” and the fact that I wasn’t given permission to do what I just did, the fact is five lives are greater than one. There are a lot of scenario’s that could happen if I did or didn’t pull the switch. One of the scenario’s is that I could ask myself “How would I warn the six workers that a runaway train has escaped and is in full pursuit of damaging property or damaging the lives of the six workers all together working”? “Would yelling from the top of my lungs be as effective as going into a building owned by the rail yard hysterically yelling out for help that I spotted a runaway train in full speed? The logic may be the person I’m yelling out for help to may think I’m crazy and delusional or he may follow me out to the rail yard to physically show him what I saw. Regardless of the logic and scenario, had I not pulled the switch to divert the train, I probably would have lived with guilt and regret not saving anyone’s lives that was at stake, especially the one person that was working on the track of where I diverted the train to go to after I pulled the switch.
In a separate scenario, a train is rapidly bearing down on five rail workers. However, I’m standing on a bridge under which the train will pass. I could very well stop the train by dropping a heavy weight onto the tracks in front of the oncoming train. As it happens, I’m standing

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    In 1890, the Brooklyn Trolley Dodgers professionals’ baseball team joined the National League. Over the following years, the Dodgers would have considerable difficulty competing with the other baseball themes in the New York City area. Those teams, principal among them the New York Yankees, were much better financed and generally stocked with players of higher caliber. In 1958, after nearly seven decades of mostly frustration on and off the baseball field, the Dodgers shocked the sports world by moving to Los Angeles. Walter O’Malley, the flamboyant owner of the Dodgers, saw an opportunity to introduce professional baseball to the rapidly growing population of the West Coast. More important, O’Malley saw an opportunity…

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The first article was about the Trolley Dodgers. In 1890, they joined the National League. Unfortunately, for them they did not have the finances to compete with teams like the New York Yankees. The Dodgers’ losing went on for about 70 years. As a result, they moved to Los Angeles in 1958; what we know today as the Los Angeles Dodgers. In 1997, the team was sold for 350 million dollars to Rupert Murdoch. In the closeout interview by Peter O’Malley (the former owner), he was grateful for all the employees that worked for him, especially Edward Campos. Little did O’Malley know Campos was committing significant fraud.…

    • 298 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is always an inevitable contradiction between the value of lives and the cost of saving it, and indeed many Americans prefer to being more concerned about the latter, mostly because they get used to compare other people as threats, not as partners. In the article, Ryan utilizes the controversial incident about the suicide attempt in Bay Bridge that resulted in a 13 1/2 hour traffic jam. Confronting the severe traffic congestion and financial losses, some people firmly hold their opinion that saving a person's life is the most moral obligation for everyone. "You do whatever it takes for however long it takes to prevent the suicide"(par 3). Nevertheless, there are more people still ceaselessly complained that relevant authority must remove the jumper as soon as possible principally for the sake of their convenience. "The resistant jumper might be hurt or even fail to his death in the process, but since he put himself in such a dangerous position, he is ultimately responsible for the result"(par 4). Furthermore, in order to insist the seriousness of the cost, they further to recognize themselves as "hostages" and the jumper who actually felt desperate to death as a "narcissist who wants to be the center of attention"(par 4). Yet it appeared that rather than trying to alleviate the intense controversy, the people seemed committing to fanning it. Unarguably, getting stuck in freeway, many…

    • 655 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    There is a runaway trolley barreling down the railway tracks. Ahead on the tracks there are five people tied up and unable to move. The trolley is headed straight for them. You are some distance off the tracks on a footbridge standing next to a very large or fat man; we will call him the portly fella. You can push the man off the bridge, and his body will fall onto the tracks and stop the trolley from killing the five people, but will kill the portly fella. You have two options: (1) Do nothing and let the trolley kill the five people. (2) Push the man onto the tracks, where it is likely to kill the one person. What would you do in this situation? Push the portly fella, or just watch as the five people on the tracks reach their own demise.…

    • 1959 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Help! Help! I’m dying..!” Those were the last words Kitty Genovese had said before meeting her demise. In the reading titled “Why Don’t People Help in a Crisis” by John Darley and Bibb Latane, they claim that all witnesses in a situation are indifferent. One of their examples include the famous murder of Kitty Genovese in which thirty-eight witnesses looked at the scene more than once and did nothing about it. “They continued to stare out their windows, caught, fascinated, distressed, unwilling to act but unable to turn away,” says Darley and Latane. Even though people may disagree and say, “Well, if I was a witness I would have done something about the situation,” they can’t deny the fact that Darley and Latane made a very valid point about bystanders. Darley and Latane state that we tend to follow the crowd. The thirty-eight witnesses of the Kitty Genovese case attests to this.…

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    trolley problem

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In this essay will be discussing the trolley problem devised by Philippa Foot, and exploring different aspects of utilitarianism in relation the situation. The trolley problem is as follows ‘A train is hurtling down a track and you see that it is going to hit a group of 5 people and will certainly kill them all. However you are standing on a bridge over the line next to a fat man and you are sure that if you pushed him onto the line his bulk would be sufficient to stop the train before it hit the group of people, would you push him?’.…

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Railroad Crossing Essay

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages

    I did not realize railroad crossings where such a big problem or hazard, but after reading the articles and watching the videos, I understand just how highly dangerous they can be. It is very important that I understand the problems associated with railroad crossings because trains can very easily destroy a car because of their weight and speed. It surprises me that some people make some of the mistakes that lead to injury and death around train tracks, but they do, so I need to learn how to avoid these mistakes. According to the driving handbook, getting injured or killed at a railroad crossing can be avoided by slowing down and paying attention when you come to a railroad crossing. In addition, you should never pass another car at or close to a railroad crossing or…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Obligate Bystanders Essay

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages

    When comparing the statutory language of the two different statutes similarities jump out at the reader, mainly you are only required to assist in the situation if your involvement does not put you in harm's way as well. I feel this is a key feature in any duty to rescue statute since the goal of these statutes is to allay some of the dangers that others face, meaning legislators do not want others to put themselves in harm’s way in an attempt to rescue someone else. It is counter-intuitive, considering the result is now two people in life-threatening situations. Vermont’s duty to rescue statute poses greater demands on the bystander than the Massachusetts statute does. Vermont’s statute suggests the direct intervention of the bystander to try and diffuse the situation, whereas Massachusetts indicates that the minimal action the bystander must take is alert the proper authorities to handle the situation. I feel that requiring citizens to directly intervene could be problematic. In theory a bystander could in fact not know how to handle any situation that could occur or provide life-saving aid, consequently, the Massachusetts statute seems to ask a more reasonable amount of action from the…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    lanes Trains and Hamburger Meals Thesis Statement: I am convinced an iPod, children’s picture book, and a Big Mac hold the future’s key to preserving the history of the world as we currently know it. Access to an iPod will give insight into both humans’ technological achievements and culture. The current generation iPod demonstrates our ability to consolidate multiple devices into one.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The most important thing of being a bystander is making sure your safe. Safety come first while you're attempting to help. Safety goes along with the idea of making sure you stay from anything that could accuse you. Doing the right thing along with protecting yourself is a way to not get you accused and not put yourself in…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    By these actions, you will be ready and confident when the call comes to you to save a life, whether that victim is someone you love and a part of your family, or you are saving a complete stranger.…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    You are in a life-or-death situation with your friend, but only one person has a chance of surviving the situation, what will you do in that situation? Would you sacrifice yourself for your friend or would you let your friend die? Consequently, should people be held accountable if they were in a life-or-death situation, they should be held accountable for their actions. Therefore, people that have a lack of judgment, will suffer from survivor guilt, and don’t want to pay the cost of rescues should be held accountable for their actions.…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This article talks about how the bystander effect works and how it affects people in certain situations. The bystander effect happens when a person sees an emergency situation and does nothing, thinking someone else will help. In experiments done by John Darley and Bibb Latane, when a room that contained one subject and two calm non subjects, as smoke filled the room “only 10% left to get help” (Burkley). To avoid the bystander effect a bystander must recognize the diffusion of responsibility. Diffusion of responsibility makes the witnesses believe they are partially responsible for helping and not full responsible. To combat this, a witness must realize their first instinct “will be to deny responsibility for helping the victim” and the bystander…

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    It is difficult, if not impossible, to maneuver through life being oblivious to reality. This must leave a person unprepared for potential risks or obstacles that occur without any notice. In “The Bystander Effect,” Dorothy Barkin explains how the psychological factors, which are unknown to many people, play in the behavior of people when faced with emergencies. The two main factors that should be addressed are level of ambiguity and moral diffusion. In Martin Gansburg’s essay “Thirty-Eight Who Saw Murder Didn't Call the Police,” he gives an account of a senseless death that could have been avoided if any one person had simply made a call from the safety of their apartment. Gansburg’s point is clear that people need to be more concerned and involved with their environment and those with whom they share their environment. In the article, “Five Charged in Gang Rape of Girl, 7, in NJ Apartment,” co-authors Angela Delli Santi and Beth Defalco stress how critical it is for citizens to overcome their fear of retaliation so they can have a positive impact on their safety and that of their neighbors. Education is an important tool for improving individual and public reaction to emergencies or crisis.…

    • 1460 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bystander Effect Analysis

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Bystander effect is real, and it is still present in the modern society. A mock experiment in a YouTube clip “Bystander Effects” posted in 2009 highlights the reality of this situation. The narrator introduces the clip saying that one may think that in case of an emergency and surrounded by people, he or she is likely to get immediate attention. However, this is not the case as the film present a character named Peter who is acting to demonstrate the Bystander Effect in Liverpool Street London. Peter acts demonstrating someone who is in immense pain while clenching to his stomach. He calls out, “Help! Help! Somebody help me (YouTube min 1.05).” Several people pass by all taking notice of him and taking no action. He lies there for over 20 minutes with over thirty people bypassing him without offering any assistance. Shortly, another actor, Ruth takes over Peter’s place. She is lying still, and it takes close to 4 minutes before someone helps her. This is a clear indication of bystander effects in our current society with everyone conforming to the majority phrase, “I do not want to get involved.”…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays