Preview

The Trotula Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
574 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Trotula Analysis
If we are to think of The Trotula as a bridge spanning two different worlds of medicine and academics, from east to west, we must think of the Galenic and Hippocratic traditions as the eastern end of the bridge, the foundation on which twelfth century medicine was built. Even with Galenic and Hippocratic tradition as the foundation for The Trotula, even they had to begin somewhere. Their foundation consisted of the natural philosophy teachings of Aristotle, and while his teachings are fascinating and vastly important, I cannot do Aristotle justice in this piece. Although Hippocrates was the first to introduce the idea of the four humours, Galen expanded on it drastically, writing the treatise On the Natural Faculties where he discussed the transformation of nutrition from the form it was consumed in, to elements that could be used by the human body. These ideas of balancing the humours form the basis of many of the remedies contained within the Trotula.
Galen refers to Nature, the creator of human anatomy, as female. Conversely, in the introduction to the Trotula credits God with the creation of
…show more content…
Indeed, in the first section of The Trotula, Book on the Conditions of Women (also referred to as the Trotula major), the author ends his introduction. This is the first example of the bridge, of the Trotula bringing together old and new. Galen and Hippocrates were natives of Greece, not so far removed from Salerno in Italy, although it would take the involvement of the Arabs for their teachings to reach that seat of medical knowledge. Remedies from these traditions come together with remedies from the Middle East, also brought over by the Arabs. This incorporation of medical techniques, as well as herbs from beyond familiar borders, also illustrates the increased sharing of knowledge between cultures, even before universities rose as the chief centers of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Zucconi points to the following medical payri to further understand the concept of medicine and religion. She uses the eleven medical papyri: Kahun, Ramesseum, Edwin Smith, Ebers, Berlin, Hearst, London, Chester Beatty, Carlsberg, Brooklyn, and the London-Leiden as a comparison to show a relationship between medicine and religion. Of the ones given, the Edwin smith papyrus describes surgical diagnosis and treatments while the Ebers papyrus describes the physiology of the body. They highlight the…

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Socrates Dbq Analysis

    • 81 Words
    • 1 Page

    In the department of medicine, Hippocrates dramatically changed the games for the development of medicine (Document 8). It is undeniable and perhaps it is safe to say that all western thoughts that applied philosophy can trace its origin back to the Greek thinkers like Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle who brought in the Greek rational thinkings. The questions that were once brought in by the great philosophers are still being discussed in multiple courses such as religion and political issues (Document 3,4).…

    • 81 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The most advanced nation in healthcare or medicine in the ancient eras was Egypt. There were four main reasons for that, first they trader with other nations ners them which let to large variety of spices that could…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ideas about health of the body completely shaped the treatment of patients by physicians and the general maintenance of health by people. Each and every practice was based on beliefs about how the body worked, and each prescribed or suggested treatment was explained in relation to how the body worked. Interestingly, although many today would glance at the beliefs about health and the body in ancient Greece, and dismiss them, upon careful examination, many treatments and ideas were not entirely invalid. In ancient Greek, the body was a temple of the soul and intellect, therefore care of the body was of utmost importance. To fully understand this, one must understand how the ancient Greeks viewed the body, and how they believed bodily functions…

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    19th Century Dbq

    • 1376 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Before the progression of the 19th century people generally believed that practicing medicine was revolved around the belief in the four humors which consisted of black, yellow, blood and pleam. It was believed that if an imbalance of any of these bile’s were to occur, that diseases were sure to stem from them. Practices like bloodletting and exorcisms were performed to combat these imbalances. Although there was no real proof of these four biles or their connections with diseases, doctors continued their search the fact that doctors could do relatively little to treat disease during that time meant that they were not always…

    • 1376 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Claudius Galen's theories of arteries carrying blood instead of air and illness was caused by an imbalance in the body pushed the practice of medicine. Many students took anatomy and surgery classes of University of Paris (Giblin 44). They dissected bodies and for the first time medical textbooks were printed in English, French, and Italian rather than Latin (44). This allowed medical research and information to be available to the average…

    • 1080 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    If these humors were imbalanced, a person would become ill. To make him or her feel better, you must balance the humors (Brinkley, 2004). According to Rorke, “one must sweeten acids, purify the stomach, and rid impurities by bleeding and purging” or by using leeches to increase blood production, to balance these again. Most doctors actually let patients bleed out, because their “humors” were not balanced, whereas midwives prescribed laxatives to remove bile. Furthermore, Boerhaave believed that a “fever was the body’s attempt to keep from dying,” even though we now know that it is actually the body’s response to killing whatever is making the body sick. Although this sounds absurd when considering our knowledge with today’s medicine, many doctors and midwives used this theory to aid the ill and actually succeeded in some…

    • 1489 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    After religious prohibitions on human dissections and surgical operations were weakened, many discoveries and experiments were made. (WB Encyclopedia 60) The surgeon, teacher, and brilliant anatomist Andreas Versalius was the founder of modern medicine. Before his time, Renaissance doctors continued to follow the methods of the ancient Greeks. They relied mostly on the works and discoveries of Galen, a Greek physician of the 2nd Century AD. He based most of his conclusions about human anatomy from dissections on Barbary Apes. As a student attending the University of Padua, Versalius made his own ideas of the human anatomy. He conducted and performed dozens of dissections, as well as collecting bones from the graveyards, public gallows, and mortuaries. This experience made his ideas and conclusions even more accurate.…

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Explain why effective communication is important in developing positive relationships with children, young people and adults:…

    • 386 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Anatomy of the Future

    • 454 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I have researched the philosophy of my predecessor, Galen. Galen made great strides in the observation of the human anatomy. My research in contrast to Galen has confirmed his theory of the four humours, and how each of these four humours relate to three principal points of the body: head (phlegm), heart (blood), liver (black bile), and gallbladder (yellow bile). I have a great advantage in comparison to Galen 's research because of my dissection of the human cadavers. I have found that humans do not share the same anatomy as apes. Galen was not provided with the opportunity to prove this theory. Galen 's theory of bloodletting led me to write a pamphlet that confirmed his theory but also supports my knowledge of the blood system. This pamphlet shows clearly how anatomical dissection can be used to test speculation and it underlines the importance of the structure of the human body in medicine. Bloodletting has become a popular treatment for a variety of illnesses. Because of this popular pamphlet, a Paduan Judge has invested in my…

    • 454 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The 17th Century took place from 1601-1700, and was a time of great advancements in both science and philosophy. In the area of scientific achievements, medicine in particular experienced a number of important breakthroughs. During this time, the theories created by Galen, a Greek Physician, in 140 AD were still believed by doctors. His theory stated that four humors, or fluids, determined your personality, ruled your body and how you reacted to diseases. For example; if you had a phlegm humor, then you would be cold, and as a result have a calm personality.…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ancient Egyptians exploration of medicine, and the different methods in which they used made them greatly advanced in the field of medicine compared to that of other Ancient Civilizations. It is stated, “If one had to be ill in ancient times, the best place to do so would probably have been Egypt. Not that an Egyptian's chances of survival would have been significantly better than those of his foreign contemporaries, but at least he had the satisfaction of being treated by physicians whose art was renowned all over the ancient world” (Unknown,1). Ancient Egypt was highly advanced in medicine and would be the best place for someone who was plagued with a disease or an illness to go. As previously mentioned, they used different methods and constantly tried to improve upon the techniques in which they used. Even when faced with an illness in which they could not define or describe, the doctors and healers tried their very best to treat their patients.…

    • 275 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    "According to this theory, the human body had four humors: yellow bile, which was hot and dry; blood, which was hot and moist; black bile, which was cold and dry; and phlegm, which was cold and moist." (Corzine 59) These four humors were also linked with the four elements of the earth: fire, air, earth, and water. If someone was deeply ill, physicians believed that the humors in the body were imbalanced. If the humors were balanced, then the person would be perfectly healthy. Certain emotions were also used to distinguish people who had an excess of a certain humor. "An individual's temperament was determined by the predominance of one or more of the humors." (60) For example, for a person who had too much blood, they tended to act happily. If they were dull, they'd have too much phlegm and if they had too much black bile, physicians would "prescribe a hot and wet medicament." (Bruccoli 440) However, physicians often used Phlebotomy to cure these humor imbalances in a person but instead of curing, they were killing them…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Euthanasia Essay

    • 1122 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Shapiro, Joseph P. "Expanding a right to die."U.S. News & World Report. April 15, 1996, Pg. 63.…

    • 1122 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In document three, al-Razi wrote a medical reference encyclopedia, it desribed the influence of Islamic books he wrote on European medicine. The book states “When Europeans learned that Muslims had preserved imppratant medical texts, they wanted to translate the texts into Latin. In the 11th century scholars traveled to libraries in places such as Toledo, Spain… where they began translating, but only after they learned to read Arabic. Through this process, Europen medical schools gained access to vital reference sources”. The Europeans gained most of their knowledge of medicine from Muslims. In document four, Al- Khwarizmi, a mathematician studied Indian sources. It says “He wrote a textbook in the 800s about al-jabr (algebra)”. The textbook was later translated and passed down and used for many years throughout Europe. In document five, “Muslim scholars made advancements in trigonometry, astronomy, and mapmaking”. Muslims made different advancements in those given areas. In…

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays