Charlotte believed that The Tenant of Wildfell Hall and “the choice of subject was an entire mistake” (page 304, Wuthering Heights). Charlotte then goes on to say that Anne had pure motives but the subject matter was too crude. Charlotte believed that Anne “hated her work, but would pursue it” (page 305, Wuthering Heights). Charlotte made these claims after Anne's death so Anne was unable to defend these claims. However, in the preface for the second edition of The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, she says that she wanted to write the truth. The truth is so rarely the safest option, the truth is hard to pursue. As Anne put it, “to represent a bad thing in its least offensive light...is the most agreeable course...but is it the most honest or the safest? Is it better to reveal the snares and pitfalls of life to the young...or to cover them with branches and flowers” (page 4, The Tenant of Wildfell Hall)? Anne had to make a choice as she was writing a difficult subject matter. She had a choice between the honest or the safe path. Anne chose to write the truth, even if it was scandalous. Anne would rather show people the hard aspects of life than to hide the challenges with a beautiful life so that it would be a surprise to whomever walks on it. Charlotte was attempting to protect her sisters name, to defend her, even though it was by denying something her sister worked so hard on. This novel was seen as something that was wicked, so wicked in fact that Anne had to defend how proud she was of her work and the light it shed on a shocking
Charlotte believed that The Tenant of Wildfell Hall and “the choice of subject was an entire mistake” (page 304, Wuthering Heights). Charlotte then goes on to say that Anne had pure motives but the subject matter was too crude. Charlotte believed that Anne “hated her work, but would pursue it” (page 305, Wuthering Heights). Charlotte made these claims after Anne's death so Anne was unable to defend these claims. However, in the preface for the second edition of The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, she says that she wanted to write the truth. The truth is so rarely the safest option, the truth is hard to pursue. As Anne put it, “to represent a bad thing in its least offensive light...is the most agreeable course...but is it the most honest or the safest? Is it better to reveal the snares and pitfalls of life to the young...or to cover them with branches and flowers” (page 4, The Tenant of Wildfell Hall)? Anne had to make a choice as she was writing a difficult subject matter. She had a choice between the honest or the safe path. Anne chose to write the truth, even if it was scandalous. Anne would rather show people the hard aspects of life than to hide the challenges with a beautiful life so that it would be a surprise to whomever walks on it. Charlotte was attempting to protect her sisters name, to defend her, even though it was by denying something her sister worked so hard on. This novel was seen as something that was wicked, so wicked in fact that Anne had to defend how proud she was of her work and the light it shed on a shocking