Preview

This Is What It Means To Say Phoenix Analysis

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
962 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
This Is What It Means To Say Phoenix Analysis
Otherness in a nutshell is a feeling like one does not fit in for any number of reasons. Race, gender, sexuality, religion and appearance are just a few of the reasons. This is felt throughout life from childhood to adulthood. When you are in school it may be something as silly as your brand of shoes, you may not have the cool ones because your parents cannot afford them, so you get made fun of. Then here you are as an adult and it may be the car you drive or neighborhood you live in that gets you ostracized from your peers. The slight differences in people, as small as they seem, have separated people since the start of mankind. Otherness has led to seclusion, inequality and even hate. I chose to read Sherman Alexie’s piece titled “This Is What It Means to Say …show more content…
Victor, who is broke, needs to find a way to
Phoenix, Arizona to claim some money and a pickup truck. After failing to come up with all the money, Victor runs into the town loony Thomas Build-a-Fire. Thomas was a childhood friend of
Victor, but Thomas’s story telling put a rift in their relationship. Thomas agrees to give Victor the money only if he takes him along. The two then fly to Phoenix and exchange stories of their youth and put the past behind them. Alexie puts otherness front and center in his short story. Alexie, I feel wrote this piece as an outlet to discuss how he has felt othered by society, mainly with being Native American. There are many levels of otherness, the first being that Victor and Thomas are Native Americans who throughout American history have suffered at the hand of our government. The otherness they feel is because of the oppression and segregation of the Native American people by our country.
This is made obvious when they are celebrating the 4th of July as children and question why they are celebrating. They realize that they too are Americans but feel neglected and forgotten by

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    3- Victor remembers having good times with his father, talking about great indians, and white unfairness that later turn into getting slapped and beat.…

    • 250 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A minority is often repressed by the majority, which in many American cases is the Anglo Saxon. The minorities often grow tired of being treated as lesser than humans and take matters into their own hands. Identical to the Chicano’s background, the white American tried to “Americanize” the children and kill their culture (Skousen, 1). Similar to El Plan de Atzlan, the Native Americans advocated “strong identity,” “culture acceptance” and “legacy” amongst other things (Skousen, 3). The Natives took pride in their oral narratives, past and present tribal culture, and their ability to bridge cultures.…

    • 95 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Alexie was given many opportunities yet what he did with them was unexpected. "Most lived up to those expectations inside the classrooms but subverted them on the outside" As Indians; others saw little in them soon they began to feel the same way about their selves. Acting uneducated as if no knowledge was ever known in front of an non-Indian teacher. What people thought was soon becoming a reality. "We were expected to fail in the non-Indian world." Yet Alexie was raised reading books, every kind imaginable. He thought to fail never phased him, he aimed toward success. Really it was him verses the world; people wanted him to be stupid. Except every chance he got, he took to prove them wrong. "I was trying to save my life." Being separated by ethnicity made it hard to learn. Taking things into his own hands, he taught himself how to read, how to understand the meaning of words. If he didn't nobody else would. He showed that if one Indian could do it, why not others as well. As a Result it gave the opportunities to make a difference in the…

    • 458 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Smoke signals

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages

    After Victor hears about his dad’s death he decides to go to Phoenix to get his dad’s remains. But he don’t have enough money so Thomas offers him help in one condition that he will be allowed to go with him too. This way Thomas helps him with the money for the travel and they head towards phoenix by the bus. One thing I noticed about Victor was the he shows he is tough through out the movie and he has a belief that if he has to get respected by the white people, he has to be serious and be a warrior which he tells Thomas to do too. When they reach to phoenix, the lady named Suzy gives the remains of Victor’s dad and tells him what kind of good man his father was even though at that stage victor still has the same impression he…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although it seems as though he likes Thomas by the end of the story, Victor in fact still harbors certain feelings of dislike and contempt towards Thomas. Almost at the finish of the story “This is What it Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona”, Sherman Alexie portrays Victor as being kind and friendly to Thomas. Victor feels the urge that he owes something to Thomas and ends up offering to Mr. Builds-the-Fire the precious ash remains of his recently deceased father. As kind as he was to do that, Victor immediately afterwards talks to Thomas in an underlying mean way. Thomas graciously turns down Victor’s offer, and in the process relates a simile comparing Victor’s father to a salmon. Although throughout the story Victor seems appreciative of Thomas’…

    • 346 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I was certain about Thomas’s friendship up until he said he was making a deal with Victor’s dad to watch over Victor. He said he came with Victor because of his father. Is this mean without the father, the friendship was long dismantled? I don’t think so. The father’s death reunite the strong friendship that was originally there even though they both cannot go back to their “original” friendship stage. I think they cannot go back to the original stage because Thomas is still holding onto his tribal tradition and telling stories, which no one understands and Victor is more modernize. However, I’ve concluded that after the trip to Arizona, their friendship rekindle because Victor feels gratitude toward Thomas and even gives some of his father’s ashes to Thomas. Victor also agreed to stop and listen to Thomas’ story when he encounters such…

    • 348 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The term Belonging can be defined as a sense of identity found through the process of feeling accepted or understood.Whilst not belonging can be defined as the feeling of being disconnected and isolated.…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fistfight In Heaven

    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Victor almost seems to admire Thomas, because Thomas doesn’t care what other people think about him. Although Victor wants to escape from the standards of the white people, he still conforms to their culture because he is afraid of ridicule. However, Thomas doesn’t let other peoples’ opinions affect him, and Victor is jealous of his nonchalant attitude towards other people. “Everyone has dreams about flying. Thomas flew,” (70). Thomas has confidence in himself, which is something that most everyone else in the reservation seems to lack. When Victor sees Thomas’s confidence, he begins avoiding Thomas, perhaps because of jealousy, or possibly because he is afraid of what other people might think about Victor if they see him with Thomas. When Thomas and Victor are returning to Spokane Reservation in “This is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona,” Thomas says, “I know you aren’t going to treat me any differently than before. Your friends would give me too much shit about it,” (74). Victor is too caught up in the modern world to possibly understand the importance of Thomas’s stories, and Thomas understands Victor’s limitations. However, at the end of “This is What it Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona,” Victor agrees to listen to one of Thomas’s stories just once. This symbolizes Victor’s step backwards towards the traditions and stories of Native Americans in the…

    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Zora Neale Conference

    • 298 Words
    • 1 Page

    Segregation occurs due to many different reasons and is most strongly felt within social and…

    • 298 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    An individual’s interaction with others and the world around them can enrich or limit their experience of belonging.…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The theme of a story is woven all the way through the story, and the characters' actions, interactions, and motivations. This is all reflected in the friendship between Victor and Thomas and the heritage between modern man and tradition Native Americans. Thomas proposes to lend Victor the money he needed after only receiving 100 dollars from the Indian counsel due to lack of funds. That money that Thomas gave Victor was a mark of true friendship. He gave it without expecting anything in return except to be part of the trip to Phoenix. Even thought they have not been friends since they were teenagers, their journey to Arizona helps Victor realize Thomas would later reveal in the story, the reason for him giving Victor the money was that he had given his word to Victor’s father that he would “watch out” for him. Thomas was being a true friend as he had always done such as the incident with the wasp nest when Thomas saved Victor. However, in the end Victor knows that he and Thomas will not be friends after the trip because of how other people perceive Thomas. At the end of the story Victor r54offers half of his father’s ashes to show Thomas that he is grateful for Thomas’…

    • 477 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Smoke Signals

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The relationship between Victor and Thomas in the movie Smoke Signals is what gives the stories that Sherman Alexie weave they're meaning. As the story goes on so does the relationship from acquaintances, to veritable enemies, to close friends. This shifting in association gives the movie a very heartwarming effect. It showed that these young Indian boys overcame the obstacles that had separated them, and while doing this became close friends. In the opening scene we are exposed to how Thomas' family becomes indebted to Victor's. Victor’s father rescued Thomas from the burning building that killed his parents. We are not made aware of the fact that Victor's father had in fact started the fire as well. Leaving this detail unknown until the end of the movie allows everyone the chance to come to their own conclusions about Victor's father, before his personality is really showed by his neighbor. During the movie, Thomas tried to befriend Victor. The other children consider Thomas a "dork" and Victor did not speak to him very much. The scene after Victor's father left, where Victor beats Thomas into oblivion for making a rude remark about Victor's dad and the scene on the basketball court shows us this feeling of annoyance that Victor holds about Thomas. For unknown reasons, however, Thomas continued to try to befriend Victor. Thomas…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The body of the monsters companion is found and Victor is accused of a murder and is taken from the boat. Now the creator is being portrayed as a monster to society just like the monster he created. As the court is discussing Victors’ punishment a few witnesses said they saw him at the time of the murder so the court had to release him. After Victors risk of death due to the monster, he goes home to with his father. The monster then realizes the he will not be getting his companion like he wanted and like he was promised. The monster feels betrayed and abandoned again by his creator. He gets very angry at the situation and turns on Victor telling him that he shouldn’t have done that and that he will be back on his wedding night. The monster then plans on taking away Victors love and companionship like Victor has taken away…

    • 1493 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A True Betrayal of Nature

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages

    those that are closest in Victor's life in a form of retaliation for Victor's creation of a…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Since the arrival of the Europeans in 1492 the Native American has systematically been dehumanized, decivilized and redefined into terms that typify a subordinate or minority role, restricted life opportunities persist today as a result.…

    • 3494 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays