Evaluate a type of model used in science and its uses and limitations.
A model is a three-dimensional representation of a person or thing or of a proposed structure, typically on a smaller scale than the original. Scientists use models to present patterns they observe in the world. Models may be actual physical constructions of mental images; they can also be mathematical models, for example the model of a structure of an atom or graphing a wave. There are many uses and limitations of using models in science.
The Plum Pudding Model is an atom model proposed by J.J Thomson, the physicist who discovered the electron. In Thomson's "Plum Pudding Model" each atom was a sphere filled with a positively charged fluid. The fluid was called the "pudding." Scattered in this fluid were electrons known as the "plums." The radius of the model was 10-10 meters. Thomson suggested that the positive fluid held the negative charges, the electrons, in the atom because of electrical forces.
Thomson’s “Plum Pudding Model is used in science, because it was the first model utilising electrons. He and his fellow scientists knew that electrons were negatively charged, but they couldn't immediately explain why, then, most atoms carried a neutral charge. This caused further research of the features of the atom.
Thomson’s “Plum Pudding Model” brought along several benefits. J.J Thomson was the first person to suggest the theory of the atom containing positive and negative particles, and demonstrated the latter which he called electrons. He experimented with cathode ray tubes to show how electron beams were deflected by magnetic forces. He also showed the hydrogen atom has one electron. His atomic theory identified that electrons inside an atom could show, meaning that atoms were not invisible.
Although there are benefits of Thomson’s “Plum Pudding Model”, there are also limitations. Since the weight of an electron is about a thousandth part of a hydrogen atom, it would mean that a single atom, especially of the heavier elements, would contain many thousand electrons. But J.J. Thomson himself found that the number of electrons in an atom cannot be greatly different from the atomic weight. According to this model, hydrogen can give rise to only one spectral line, contrary to the observed fact of several lines. This model could not explain the large angle scattering of alpha particles by thin metal foils.
Using a cathode ray scope, Thomson determined that all matter, whatever its source, contains particles of the same kind that are much less massive than the atoms of which they form a part. They are now called electrons, although he originally called them corpuscles. His discovery was the result of an attempt to solve a long-standing controversy regarding the nature of cathode rays. Thomson may be described as "the man who split the atom" for the first time. Therefore it’s safe to say that Thomson’s “Plum Pudding Model”, has served its purpose and contributed greatly to our understanding.
Although Thompson’s “Plum Pudding Model” was disproved, his model and experiments were important stepping stones in atomic research. For his efforts, J.J. Thomson was awarded the 1906 Nobel Prize in Physics.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
A new atomic theory, in which all atoms of the same element are identical to one another and equal in mass, was proposed by the scientist Dalton. Although the theory had its flaws and was simple, it was revolutionary. Scientists became able to study the actual structure and mass of atoms after the discovery of radioactivity. Soon, isotopes were discovered, as atoms of the same element which have been built up to have different masses.…
- 1323 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Although Joseph John (J.J.) Thomson (1856 - 1940) was mainly a physicist, his discoveries are closely connected to the chemical community. Thomson used Crookes high vacuum cathode ray tube in his discovery of electrons. He found the green beam produced by the cathode ray tube was a completely negatively charged material. Experimenting with different electrically charged plates and magnets in the cathode ray tube and observing the deflection of the rays he had enough evidence to say that particles smaller than atoms existed. By doing this experiment multiple times he compiled enough data to conclude that the mass of one of these particles, which he called an electron, was lighter than an atom of hydrogen by around 2,000 times. He also found the ratio of charge to mass (e/m) would be the same for any electron.…
- 534 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Models are conceptual constructs that aspire to represent real things or processes that to a large extent are hidden for the senses and to the ordinary experience. Models have a role to describe, represent, explain, and ‘translate’ the world.…
- 440 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
(McPhee, 2010) The scientists of the 19th centuries renewed their interest in the Atomic Theory •John Dalton suggested that all matter was composed of small particles - atoms, each element had a different atom and a different atomic weight, theorized that atoms could not be created or destroyed in chemical reactions (1804) •In his attempt to classify the elements by principles, Dmitri Mendeleev arranged the elements by their atomic weight, discovering the existence of periodicity of the atoms (1869) •J.J. Thomson discovered electrons through his cathode ray experiment and proved that atoms were divisible(1897) (McPhee, 2010), ("A brief history," 2005) 20th century concepts and discoveries •Earnest Rutherford discovered that there was a small, dense positively charged nucleus, predicted the existence of neutrons, stated that electrons move rapidly in the empty space around the nucleus (1909-11) •In continuation of his experiments J.J. Thompson determined that all particles had charges that were multiples of the same number •In 1913 Robert Millikan accurately determined the mass of election…
- 809 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Six scientists were chosen to see which one had made the greatest contribution to our current understanding of the atom’s structure. Our knowledge of an atom’s appearance and structure have evolved from years and years of development and contribution from many different scientists. Scientist Ernest Rutherford had been the best contributor to the understanding of the atomic structure. Why Rutherford was chosen is because his work had information on protons, neutrons, and electrons, the main components that make up the atom, showed what the atom looks like when the three are put together, and had also been the discoverer of the nucleus which is the one of them most important parts of the atom’s structure.…
- 793 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
They discovered that those cathode rays were a stream of negatively charged particles which they called electrons. The exact value of the negative charge was not known (was it 2-, 3-, 9-, 1-?).…
- 5272 Words
- 22 Pages
Better Essays -
8. In 1897, J. J. Thomson made a discovery that proved the first part of Dalton’s atomic theory was correct. True…
- 466 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Dalton atomic model is the simplest model. Atoms only described as a very small ball but massive. This model is still not familiar with the charge within the atom.…
- 1125 Words
- 5 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In 1897, a British physicist named J. J. Thomson discovered electrons through his cathode ray experiment. Thomson made the cathode ray by firing electrical currents through glass pipes filled with low-density gas. Thomson measured the ratio as always the same, regardless of what elemental gas was in the…
- 363 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Earnest Rutherford preformed en experiment later that proved an idea of Dalton's wrong. With his gold foil experiment, Rutherford found atoms to be consisted of at least two smaller parts, unlike Dalton's idea that atoms are indivisible. He established that an atom includes a tiny, positively charge nucleus, which is surrounded by electrons.…
- 272 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Although John Dalton was the scientist to discover the first scientific theory of an atom, J.J Thomson was next to research the atom. While evaluating Daltons work, he found that atoms are not indivisible. He experimented and found that when the atom is excited by an electrical current it causes the atom to break apart into two parts. Then to further explain his findings, Thomson created a model which was called the Plum-pudding atom. In the model the “plums” are the negatively charged electrons, while the “pudding” is the mass of positive…
- 762 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Henry Gwyn Jeffrey’s Moseley: worked with Ernest Rutherford experimented with 38 metals, he found that the positive charge of each element nucleus increased by one from element to element as they were arranged in mendeleevs periodic table, lead to modern definition of atomic number (# of protons in atoms nucleus) and the recognition the atomic number was basis of organization of periodic table.…
- 2160 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
historical development: Democritus; Aristotle; Dalton (postulates, law of definite proportions, law of multiple proportions, atomic model); J.J. Thompson (atomic model and electron discovery); Rutherford (atomic model and gold foil experiment); Bohr’s atomic model and origin of discontinuous energy levels; Heisenberg and electron cloud’s model; Schrodinger and wave functions…
- 456 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In 1913, a Danish physicist named Niels Bohr put Rutherford's findings together with the observed spectra to come up with a new model of the atom in a real leap of intuition. I believe that the Bohr’s model of atom explains well about the atomic theory, because in his experiments it is shown and explained the structure of an atom. His famous suggestion is about that the electrons orbit around the nucleus of an atom. Bohr experimented with atomic spectrum that proved his suggestion.…
- 377 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In the years before Ernest Rutherford and his associates, Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden, did the Gold Foil experiment, scientists explained the structure of the atom using the Plum Pudding Model. The Plum Pudding model stated that the atom was solid and only had protons and electrons mixed together in a single piece of matter. In 1906, Rutherford, Geiger, and Marsdon decided to test the Plum Pudding model by firing alpha particles at a piece of gold foil. Their results would revolutionize the model of atomic structure to one that is similar than the model used today. By examining the Gold Foil Experiment one can…
- 1497 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays