Preview

To Kill a Mockingbird vs Scottsboro Trial

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
375 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
To Kill a Mockingbird vs Scottsboro Trial
Tom Robinson vs Scottsboro Boys
The book To Kill a Mockingbird symbolizes how a community of decent human beings can be corrupted by simple commonplace stereotypes within society, the Scottsboro trial is a real life example of how even in the 20th century individuals were scapegoats of this malicious prejudice. This type of prejudice united the most ignorant Americans into the absurd trail of thought that African Americans were, in some way, inferior to even the most uneducated Caucasian due to the diversity of their customs and/or skin color. The Tom Robinson case within this novel is a fantastic literary device written to stoke the reader’s curiosity and explore the many similarities and differences of these two trials.
Undoubtedly these two trials have many similarities despite one of the trials being mainly a focal point for achievement in the literary world. An identical example between these trials are the historical culture in abundance with many of the families included in the trial, an example being the Ewells compare to be utterly consistent with the two young prosecutors in the way they live their life. Another of these many similarities includes the bizarre assumption by the jury that the accused were already virtually guilty before the trial had even begun due to the mainstream’s coarse view of African Americans and how African Americans are nothing better than a common house animal, punished at the dominant being’s will. This point is shown, beyond doubt, when one of the women prosecuting the Scottsboro Boys, Ruby Bates admits that neither herself nor her friend Victoria Price were every raped in anyway by any of the nine accused African Americans. Even after this incriminating confession, the series of trials continue .
Although even with these similarities, the two trials are not perfectly identical and do have many variations between the two. One of these variations include the lawyers assigned in each case to represent the defendants.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Tom Robinson was a civilized man who was trying to get home from work one day,and Mayella Ewell ruined that for him. In the unfair case of Tom Robinson he was accused of raping a girl he never found interest in.The case had a ruling set before it even started,because he was a black man. There was so much evidence that Mayella wasn't raped by Tom Robinson,some of the evidence were Tom's physical handicap from a cotton gin as well as his left arm being twelve inches shorter than his right and was not able to use his left arm.His color works againt him,the jury decides to believe mayella instead of Tom. Therefore, he was convicted and sent to jail.…

    • 255 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    There was no evidence to prove the women’s stories that the black men had actually raped them. In Tom Robinson’s trial it was pointed out that Mayella Ewell had bruises around her neck showing that someone had deliberately attempted to strangle her with BOTH hands. Mayella classified that she was beaten by Tom Robinson but she was not one hundred percent assured that it was really Mr. Robinson. Tom Robinson was then questioned about his left arm. He informed the court room that when he was younger he got in an accident that prevented any use of his arm. Even that evidence proving that he was immobile in his left arm still did not fluctuate the jury’s opinion on the verdict. The Scottsboro trial also had no evidence that the women had been raped. There were no traces of forced rape or bruises on either one of the girls. In addition, the trials were also unfair. They were biased because of failure to take in fact the defendants input of what had actually happened. There was virtually no evidence. The evidence they had was immaterial. This was in fact of the Great Depression, the Jim Crow laws, segregation, and racism toward the African American men. These factors all contributed to a one-sided trial resulting in the death of the…

    • 1168 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A. Thesis: American history was infinitely changed by the Scottsboro Boys case. Through this case, the country’s faulty judicial system was exposed, along with its civil and ethnic defects.…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “When individuals change, society will change. And when society changes, the whole world will change…” is a quote from Sathya Sai Baba which explains the impact society has on people. Society plays a huge role in who you are, what you do and it shapes who you are as a person. Mayella Ewell from To Kill a Mockingbird and Ruby Bates from the Scottsboro Trials as victims and accusers are examples of how society shapes you and influences what you do. Society shaped Ruby and Mayella in both similar and different ways.…

    • 434 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Tom Robinson’s trial was probably one of the most nail biting trials ever and it all took play place in Maycomb County in southern Alabama.This trial occurred in August 26,1935 but the crime took place at the Ewells home on November 21,1934,which also means it was during The Great Depression.It all started when Mayella had accused Tom Robinson of allegedly raping and beating her,when in trial she said “-he chunked me on the floor and’ choked me and took advantage of me”(TKAM).During this trial many things occurred from the defendant’s lawyer “Atticus” kids who gaped through the whole trial to Mr.Gilmer,the accuser’s lawyer,impertinent attitude towards Tom Robinson.…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I tend to my garden as I watch several cars drive along my street back to their homes. Tom Robinson’s trial must be over. Before the trial even started, I predicted that the verdict would be guilty. When I saw Jem, Scout, and Dill arrive back at their house with long faces, my prediction was confirmed. It is still upsetting for me to hear that another innocent black man’s life was ruined because of the way white people treat them. I did not attend the trial; I do not wish to see an innocent person on trial for their life. I take off my gardening gloves and head inside. As I wash my hands, I see the children looking very upset and confused. I decide to make them chocolate cakes to help to cheer them up. They must be extremely confused and disappointed about the verdict of the trial. They are too young to completely understand our unfair society.…

    • 281 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The train stopped in a town called Paint Rock where the nine boys were put into jail. The boys were about to be charged with assault, but two women were discovered hiding on the train. The women, Victoria Price and her accomplice, Ruby Bates, were riding as hobos on the train and decided to testify against the boys to cover up the crime they committed (Wormser). The mirroring of these events suggest that Lee was influenced by real world incidences she grew up hearing about. In the Scottsboro Trials, Ruby Bates and Victoria Price went to see a doctor, and semen was found in both girls. They did not seem to be injured and were very calm after being allegedly raped. The semen was non-motile which was strange because they were just raped by many boys. During the trials, Ruby Bates said that her and Victoria spent the night with their boyfriends the night before the train ride (Salter). There was no credible evidence against the boys, barely anything to go off of. This did not seem to matter in the 1930s. There is a similar situation in the novel. In To Kill a Mockingbird, Mayella Ewell claims that she has been raped by Tom Robinson (Lee 180). Her father, Bob Ewell, called the sheriff after he saw what…

    • 1053 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Scottsboro trials occurred in the 1930s and had nine African American boys aging from thirteen to seventeen and they were accused of raping two girls on a train. Eight of the nine boys were sentenced to death and one of them was too young for the death penalty so he was sentenced to life in prison. There was a lot of evidence that pointed to them being innocent. Like the two girls were examined by a doctor and he found no evidence of rape, but he was not called to court, but he told a lot of people. Also they found out the girls were prostitutes and they were crossing a border illegally so they covered it up saying they were raped. Later on, during the case one of the girls admitted that she was never raped. Also the boys were not in the same train cart as the girls (Johnson). The Scottsboro trials are a lot like Tom Robinson’s trial in To Kill a Mockingbird. The cases are a lot alike, because they both took place during the Great Depression and they both are rape cases. Also the towns took the white person’s side instead of the African Americans sides (Johnson). That is why the Scottsboro trials are like the trials in To Kill a…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tom Robinson’s case in To Kill A Mockingbird resembles many Civil Rights Cases, specifically in the case of Powell vs. Alabama. In Powell vs. Alabama, several young white men…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In a time of prejudice and segregation, the words of blacks are not trusted when they contradict the words of even white criminals. When prejudice clouds the mind, then the truth cannot prevail. After being discovered on a train with nine colored boys, Victoria Price and Ruby Bates accuse the nine boys of raping them. The two women are criminals, untrusted by society, but the moment they accuse those nine boys of attacking them, society takes the side of the whites, because the nine boys are of color and because “what was presumed to be the black man's insatiable sexual appetite for white women had struck fear in the hearts of Southern whites” (Scottsboro Boys: An American Tragedy). This goes to show that prejudice takes priority when it came…

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the paper directed towards African American called The AfroAmerican, described the event very differently. “Death sentences imposed upon seven youths at Scottsboro, Alabama, for the alleged criminal assault of the two white women were set aside by the Supreme Court.” The talked about the boys as “innocent until proven guilty” rather than how the newspaper for the white people focused on saying the boys were guilty. The AfroAmerican also focused on the condition of the boys and the status of their trials. Differently from the other two newspapers, the Communist paper, Young Worker, portrayed the boys as unquestionably innocent, as the title of the article was “Nine Innocent Scottsboro Boys.”…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    TKAM Final Essay Juliana To Kill a Mockingbird is a controversial subject to many people. Some of the subject in it are racism, prejudice, sexual assault, and abuse. Overall, the main part that would definitely cause controversy over this book is the trial. Throughout this part of the book, Harper Lee paints a different image than that of what we usually know about the judicial system. Now, we think that the judicial system is fair, that there is no prejudice, and that you won’t be judged for something that you may not have done.…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Scottsboro Trial

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages

    It is shocking how a country has the audacity to proclaim an innocent person guilty while knowing the truth. People are so suddenly blinded by their biased opinions and can’t seem to accept the truth. This is shown in the The Scottsboro Trials, which was a series of trials that involved nine Negro boys that were accused of raping two white women. The trial was actually a false allegation, of which the two white women were at fault. Furthermore, in the book To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee, the character Tom Robinson had a case that was very similar. Tom was accused of raping a white woman, but he was falsely accused as well. Both cases have many things alike.…

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Subsequent to the verdict of the trial, the white people started exiting. Atticus was in a desperate attempt to reassure Tom there would be an appeal. Tom pinioned to security guards was taken away. Leaving Atticus to muster up his belongings. All whilst the coloured people stayed put. As Atticus started down the aisle Reverend Sykes alerted Scout to join the rest of the balcony in standing up. This was a revolutionary moment in the book because it demonstrates the immense amount of respect and gratitude the coloured people have for Atticus despite the result. It goes further because of how highly segregated the two communities were.…

    • 107 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    To kill a mockingbird

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Of all the destructive powers humans possess, none ruin others lives and destroy our humanity like racism does. Racism is the worst kind of prejudice in our society, and as illustrated in “To Kill a Mockingbird” by what befalls upon Tom Robinson; it can ruin people’s lives. An unnecessary evil, it brings down misery in some way to all who harbour or are victim to it. The most apparent victim of racism was Tom Robinson himself. Falsely accused of raping Mayella Ewell, by her father Bob Ewell, Tom was brought before a prejudiced, white jury for trial. Despite convincing evidence that proved Tom Robinson was innocent, the prejudiced views of the white jury caused them to prove him guilty. It is unfair that prejudices based on a person’s skin colour should wreak such havoc on their lives, and yet it was once commonplace as shown in TKAM.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays