Preview

To What Extent Does The Homosexual Subtext Add To The Comedic Value In The Importance Of Being Earnest

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1495 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
To What Extent Does The Homosexual Subtext Add To The Comedic Value In The Importance Of Being Earnest
To what extent does the homosexual subtext add to the comedic value in The Importance of being Earnest
‘The Importance of being Earnest’ is an accomplished parody of the conventions of comedy, containing the main attributes of a comedy of manners. It is easy to view simply as a frivolous farce, laced with witty dialogue, contrived situations and sarcasm. However, upon closer look, Wilde uses his protagonists and the situations caused in the play to target many of the hypocrisies that Victorian society created. Exposing manners, false sincerity and how marriage is little but a social tool, all add to the comedic value of the play, thus considering the play an iridescent filament of fantasy. However, when decoded further, references to the Victorian homosexual underworld are revealed, opening the comedic value up to a whole new audience. I believe that Wilde’s subtle, yet frequent use of homosexual subtext throughout the play adds another layer of meaning to the comedy.

The title of the play is a double entendre, as the pun depends on the adjective ‘Earnest’ meaning sincere and honest, as well as the name ‘Earnest’. However, as the word ‘earnest’ was also gay code for homosexual, Wilde converts it from a double entendre to a triple one. Decoding the play along these lines thus opens up delicious new comic meanings, as one begins to spot and search for double entendres throughout the play. From the butler’s sly admission that ‘there are no cucumbers to be found in the market “even for ready money”, to the statement that Algernon’s luggage includes a particularly large lunchbox, as the central premise of the plots are men emerging from a closet life what more can one say? New hints and meanings thus occur frequently, such as Wilde’s use of conventional comic conventions of dual identities, so historically prevalent in drama stemming from ancient Greece and Rome.
Dual identities is a theme laced throughout the play, exploring what it means to have a dual identity.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Small details are all too often overlooked, called either insignificant or irrelevant, they are rarely given the attention they deserve. In Oscar Wilde’s “The Importance of Being Earnest” we see cleverly hidden details within the drama that, while serve significant roles, people may see as inhibitors to understanding the play. Cigarette cases and tea parties are two of the many details within the story that have background meanings; their most prominent purpose being to emphasize the importance of propriety within their era, however they also play substitute roles in accentuating character themes and building dramatic irony. The link between these two particulars can be stated as turning points within the novel that increase both tension, and…

    • 150 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Oscar Wilde is known as a comedic playwright to much of the world, although his plays address issues with contemporary society in a nonchalant way by turning these issues into a joke. In The Importance Of Being Earnest Wilde uses irony and mockery to ridicule the narcissistic attitude of the victorian aristocracy as well as to expose their hypocrisy, ridiculous social norms, and their sheer stupidity that results in a myriad of silly and funny situations.…

    • 201 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    When dealing with Lady Bracknell it is important to realise that her intellectually farcical dialogue makes her character the quintessence of the book’s title; she creates ‘trivial comedy’ yet is one of the ‘serious people’. From this simple observation we can infer that Wilde wants us to watch Lady Bracknell as she represent the book as a while in character form. An example of her character’s nature is when she makes a remark about the ‘unfashionable’ side of the street upon which Mr Worthing lives. She then says that they can change ‘both’ the fashion and the side. Upon the surface Lady Bracknell takes something as trivial as which side of the street he lives on and talks about it in such a serious tone that it creates humour. This also displays her use of witty dialogue as her quick yet humours reply helps Wilde to create a base for much of the fast paced intellectually comedy in the rest of the play. Therefore this analysis shows that she does create comedy via her use of tone and amusing dialogue. However, on a deeper level, the nonsensical dialogue takes away from the character’s realism. Then she is creating comedy exempt from the context of the play as people laugh at her unrealistic nature suggesting that she doesn’t create comedy within the play. A similar comment about Bunbury making up his mind ‘whether he will live or die’ can be analysed in the same way but it also provides yet another layer. It…

    • 1400 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    While reading Oscar Wilde’s story “The Importance of Being Earnest” I can see that the play is about a debate of pleasant and unpleasant marriage. Wilde explores sincerity in his play by really gearing the play around the word “earnest”. In the play both women wanted to marry a person named “earnest” because they thought that it actually meant to be sincere, responsible, and earnest. The play presents many scenes of sincerity versus hypocrisy. For example, when Lady Bracknell asks Jack about Cecily with the intention to judge her as a wife for Algernon, while Lady Bracknell notices Cecily after she found out about her money. But, also the men characters play having a double life or secret life. Both men Jack and Algernon make up a fake…

    • 187 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Through the play, “we are made to share Wilde’s view of the ludicrous and sinister realities behind the fashionable façade of an over-civilized society where nothing serious is considered serious and nothing trivial trivial” (Reinert 17). In the interactions between people who subscribe to Victorianism, such as Gwendolen and Cecily, the trivial matter of addressing each other while having a conversation is turned into a manner of enormous social importance. In contrast, in the interactions between people who subscribe to Bunburyism, or the total rejection of Victorianism, matters as serious as pretending to have a dead brother Ernest or sick friend Bunbury are treated lightly. Gwendolen and Cecily’s Victorianism leads them to become enraged at each other without reason, while Jack and Algernon’s Bunburyism very nearly leads to their mutual loss of the women whom they love. In this way, Wilde shows that moral ideals should lie in the middle between Bunburyism and Victorianism because of the consequences of taking both ideas of extremes (Reinert 18). Jack sums up the moral best in the last line of the play when he proclaims that he has “now realized the vital Importance of Being Earnest” (Earnest 313). Through this play, Wilde states that the key to success is to simply behave without thought for social…

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    "The tone says life is fun. The undertone suggests life is a catastrophe. " How far do you agree with this model of comedy in relation for The Importance of Being Earnest?- Edward Braddock. The Importance of Being Earnest has been described in many ways, some believing that its dialogue is "wittily allusive and understated rather than downright comic" , whereas others believe it is simply a narrative driven by Wilde's deep roots in the Aestheticism movement. Despite the play being a comedy where the status quo remains when the curtain falls, the jovial and fun tones the play appears to have are paralleled by dark undertones- some more subtle than others.…

    • 1579 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    When viewing the film it made Wilde’s play come to life and it was enjoyable to watch. Parker put a lot of his own twists to the play and added scenes. As a viewer you would not notice the scenes because they were blended in so well. You would have to have read the book and physically compare the film and the play to notice. In Act III, in the play, Gwendolen and Cecily are eating muffins by the window watching Algernon and Jack, at this point he was Earnest. Gwendolen is persuading Cecily to get the boys attention, but the men then look and notice the women staring at them. Gwendolen switches attitudes and states, “They’re looking at us. What effrontery!” After this scene, Algernon and Jack…

    • 657 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Victorian society, the male role would be to rule, protect and provide for his family. Men were always making the political decisions and women had the job of wife, mother and domestic manager. When married, it was men who owned all properties of the women, and she must be faithful to her husband. Divorce led to shame only on females and loss of the right to see their children. In this patriarchal society, men were clearly dominant over women, however, this is not entirely the case in ‘The Importance of Being Earnest’. The play portrays particular female characters in very different and unexpected manners, some less favourable than others.…

    • 1509 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Importance of Being Earnest’ is used to represent a contradictory and hypocritical society. Oscar Wilde uses the text to reflect his own experience with an ignorant society; Oliver Parker does not replicate this in the 2002 film version of ‘The Importance of Being Earnest’ as he does not have the emotional influences that Wilde had. Therefore Parker does not produce an accurate representation of Wilde’s play; he only provides a comical historical representation of the milieu for a modern audience. The director and writer both explore the themes of marriage, morality and gender equality however their interpretation and manifestation of the themes differ.…

    • 1346 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The play “The Importance of Being Earnest,” is one of the most perfect examples of satire in our culture. Although it is set in England, it makes fun of the upper class. The play uses dramatic irony to show how Oscar Wilde sees the upper class as too formal and snobbish. It is dramatic irony because the characters in the play obviously think that they are high class with their multiple houses and butlers even though the author thinks that the upper class is too snobbish.…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the play, Wilde achieves most of his humour through the wonderfully satiric characters, however in the film Parker represents them as being far more farcical. Throughout the Wilde’s play Algernon, Jack, Gwendolen, Cecily and Lady Bracknell all speak quite candidly of their thoughts and views of society. Although they do not realise it, their views do not grant them any merit, and only exemplify their flaws. Algernon’s opinion that “it is awfully hard work doing nothing” followed by “however, I don’t mind hard work where there is no definite object of any kind” is an example of how he has no concept of what “hard work” is, yet he believes that he does, and the audience laughs at the satire of it. In Parker’s film, while some of these lines remain the same, the satire in them is overshadowed by their farcical nature. Cecily’s vivid daydreams where Algernon is dressed as a knight in shining armour, Gwendolen’s tattoo of the name ‘Ernest’ on her backside and Algernon and Jack’s duet of ‘Lady Come Down’ are the scenes the audience remembers most, and sadly none of them are in the original. Because Wilde’s satire relies on the characters behaving with dignity, scenes like these in Parker’s film destroy all sense of dignity in these characters, and consequently there is no longer any satire. The loss of satire not only lowers the standard of comedy, but it also means that Wilde’s…

    • 1427 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Importance of Being Earnest was Oscar’s fourth comedy, and it was to be his last and most outstanding play. ‘The Trivial Comedy for Serious People‘ (in earlier drafts, ‘serious comedy for trivial people’) was first produced by George Alexander at the St James’s Theatre on 14th February 1895 in London. The play was reduced from four to three acts (Raby 161-163).…

    • 2157 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Victorian era was a time of smugness and pomposity for the newly rich generation who quickly rose in class during and after the industrial revolution. Nothing was as it seemed in this day when earnestness was allegedly the most prized attribute a man could possess. In Oscar Wilde’s classical satire, “The Importance of Being Earnest,” every character embodies the ideas and values of this “earnest” age.…

    • 1060 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Chasuble, D.D.: Mr. H. H. Vincent. Merriman: Mr. Frank Dyall. Lane: Mr. F. Kinsey Peile. Lady Bracknell:…

    • 24391 Words
    • 98 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Essay Plan 1

    • 1236 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Throughout the duration of the play, “The Importance of being Earnest” by Oscar Wilde, conflict is a running theme which sparks a certain amount of comedy, however, it is debatable matter on weather conflict is the only source of comedy in the play. It becomes apparent throughout the play that conflict usually comes about in result of differences views on a matter, which is relevant to the play in the way in which few of the characters agree with each other’s opinions and reasoning. Furthermore, the comedy in the play tends to be soft, yet result in an overreaction on the characters behalf, further adding to the comical side of the play and the light heartedness of it all, yet it becomes questionable into weather comedy is caused by conflict, or weather conflict is presented during comedy, yet comedy is caused by the dramatic irony of the play. This further adds towards the reasoning into why “The importance of being Earnest” is recognisably one of the most noted comedies written.…

    • 1236 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays