Preview

Trust In Julius Caesar

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
712 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Trust In Julius Caesar
Luis Sanchez
2nd
The fundamentals of marriage have been seen throughout history with the golden “rule” always being trust, in some cases trust must be earned by persuasion. In a story that completely negates the meaning of trust such as Julius Caesar, it is still has a constant presence. The idea of trust is shown in a momentous scene with the character Portia attempting to persuade Brutus that he can entrust her, this point in the book can relate to a logos or pathos emotion. In Act II of Julius Caesar, Portia uses emotional and logical appeal to convince Brutus that she is not only worthy, but as his wife, obligated to be informed of what is troubling him. Portia uses logical appeal at a heated point in the argument, to try and convince
…show more content…
She introduces this point with the lines, “I grant I am a women, but withal / A women that Lord Brutus took to wife” (II.I.315-316). Portia acknowledges she is being taken for granted and seen as “no stronger than my sex.” These few lines set up a dramatic moment in which Portia stabs her thigh, which in turn set Brutus off. Portia has throughout the brief moment in the confrontation tried to prove her reliable stature and also his agreement within marriage to let her into his personal …show more content…
She immensely shows this when she bluntly tells Brutus, “Within the bond of marriage… / Is it expected that I know no secrets / That pertain to you”(II.I.331-3330)? She questions why within their marriage there is no trust and questions the purpose of their “vows of love”. All the emotion Portia expresses at this point in the scene is pouring out of her as she is in a position where, because of the loss of communication, she is not informed and not understanding of the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Plutarch’s classic literatures, Plutarch gives us his view of women and the roles they played back in his time. He illustrates how caring and encouraging, how determined, powerful and manipulative women can be. But this is only relative to the roles that women play in their personal and social life. The first example of how Cornelia is illustrated as a caring mother, the read says she take “upon herself all the care of the household and the education of her children.” Also, Plutarch illustrates how women are encouraging is in “Life of Tiberius Gracchus”, there is one scene where the Roman citizens suggests that Tiberius’ mother, Cornelia, encouraged him to fulfill his civic duty. First of all, Cornelia’s role is to be Tiberius’ mother so we can only assume that she said this out of being a mother. I think what Plutarch is trying to imply is that women who were mothers supported their children dearly. Next, my example of how a Plutarch illustrates women being determined to get what they want is in Plutarch’s “Life of Marcus Brutus” and “Life of Antony”. In “Life of Marcus Brutus”, when Brutus’ wife Porcia asks what Brutus is up to, he does not tell her because of the importance of secrecy. Porcia then to gain Brutus’ trust, maimed herself to prove that Brutus could trust her. In this example here, Plutarch exemplifies the willingness and determination of women in love/ wife. He shows how women are attached to their husbands and how women can be strong to stand up for themselves. Also, towards the end of the story, when Porcia learns of Brutus’ death, she takes her own life by eating live coals. I think what Plutarch is trying to say is that women take their husbands very seriously and when a couple is married, maybe marriage links their lives together and deaths. In my third example, Plutarch shows how powerful and manipulative a woman can be. My example lies in the story “Life of Antony”, Cleopatra; the queen of Egypt manipulates Antony to fight war…

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The play Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare revolves around how power manifests in different characters. The most obvious being Caesar, whose power inevitably led to his downfall. Through his development of the characters Cassius, Brutus, Anthony, Shakespeare reveals that the nature of power compels people to act more toward their own gain.…

    • 154 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Portia feels as if she is Brutus’s “harlot” [prostitute] and not his wife. She believes that as a married couple they should not keep secrets from each other. “Within the bond of marriage, tell me, Brutus, Is it accepted I should know no secrets? That appertains to you? To keep with you at meals, comfort your bed, and talk to you sometimes?” (II.ii.275-276, 302-307). During the time of Julius Caesar women have an utterly different view compared to men in the society. They are just there to take care of their husbands, look after kids, clean the house, and do chores while the men are out fighting battles. Women are not taken seriously just because of their sex. Generally speaking, women are just powerless figures. Portia reasons Brutus should treat her with more respect and to treat her as a wife. Since Brutus does not tell her what is happening with his life she feels that he is solely excluding her from his life. Portia contemplates they…

    • 687 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Rome during them time of Julius Caesar, a persons uprightness was measured by how well he/she conformed to four basic virtues.…

    • 321 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Julius caesar

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Act 1 of Julius Caesar begins on the streets of ancient Rome during the high holiday of Lupercal. Citizens all over Rome are not only celebrating the holiday, but also celebrating Caesar’s return from Egypt. While celebrating with his fellow Romans, Caesar gets an oracular warning from a soothsayer who tells him to “Beware of the ides of March”. As Caesar is celebrating his return and impending crowning, Cassius is plotting to murder Caesar because he’s jealous and feels that Caesar is no better than him, so why should he get the crown while he has nothing. Cassius’s first step in the plot against Caesar is to try to sway Brutus away from Caesar and onto the conspirator side. He does this by playing on Brutus’s rectitude and saying that Caesar has no honor, and that when he becomes dictator he will ruin Rome. After meeting with Cassius, Brutus is still not entirely convinced about whether or not to join the conspiracy. He is conflicted (torn) by his loyalty to Caesar and the future of Rome with Caesar’s growing power. Knowing that he must do the right thing, Brutus acts prudently and informs Cassius that he will weigh his options. Cassius knows that Brutus has not been swayed to his side, so he plans to send Brutus forged letters from the people of Rome that state their love and respect for Brutus in hopes that this will show him that Caesar is not the only one loved and respected by the people.…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Julius Caesar Legacy

    • 1558 Words
    • 7 Pages

    With hearing the constant news of politics and the presidential race for the oval office, United States citizens are in the process of choosing a presidential candidate with the best leadership qualities. The choice of the next President will impact not only the political and economic future of the United States, but more importantly, the rest of the world. A strong leader may be able to keep peace and prevent war. However, the inability of the United Nations to keep rogue nations, like Iran and North Korea, from destabilizing their neighbors will fall on the leadership of the new President and the arbitration of Congress. To find the unique leadership qualities that have had such a long term impact on societies, a study…

    • 1558 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Did Brutus Love Portia

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Need a claim In ancient Rome, marriage was less about love, and more about the need for a pretty possession to call a wife. However, Brutus’s relationship with his wife, Portia, was not like this. Brutus truly loved his wife as an equal.…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The exposition of Julius Caesar, Shakespeare immediately presents the ideals that underpin the differing views of Caesar’s rising power through his two protagonists, Brutus and Cassius. Both characters posses different interpretations on Caesar’s reign on Rome, one being loyal to Rome and a love and respect for Caesar “I love him well” but the other being a spiteful and vitriolic towards a “feeble old tyrant.” This highlights the notion of Cassius’s selfish prejudice towards his own contentment, which is only shown behind closed doors. Brutus on the other hand is victim to Cassius’ vitriol and becomes the pawn as he is manipulated “poor Brutus, with himself at war,” Brutus is troubled emotionally, torn by his patriotism and his respect for Caesar, above all he has an undying love for Rome, “Brutus had rather be a villager than to repute himself a son of Rome.” It is this love for Rome that causes such internal turmoil for Brutus, through Shakespeare’s use of juxtaposition of characters, he is able to highlight to the audience, the lengths that man will go to in order to…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout Julius Caesar, Portia is trustworthy, loyal, and observant. She uses these characteristics wisely in order to persuade Brutus to tell her his worries.…

    • 300 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This reason isn’t that strong of an example, but it shows that if Brutus stayed to to Caesar he wouldn’t have such bad fortune. “If this were true then should I know this secret I grant I am a women, but with all a women that Lord Brutus took a wife.” Portia is trying to tell Brutus that he should say his secret because he chose her as a wife, he can trust her. Brutus thinks he is keeping her safe, but really she just wants to know. Portia thinks he is being pompous and wants to defend his honor in the conspiracy and not look like a coward if he tells Portia and she tries to change his…

    • 604 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Portia was worried about the change of Brutus’s behavior because he was acting different. She was concerned and desperate to know what Brutus was going through. Calpurnia was worried about Julius Caesar because she having having bad dreams and thoughts that something bad was going to happen to Caesar if he went to the Capitol. Both Portia and Calpurnia confronted their husbands and receive different reactions.…

    • 176 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Julius Caesar

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages

    1.Several individuals tried to warn Caesar. List three of them and explain Shakespeare's purpose in the warnings.…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Relationships between characters play a great part in Julius Caesar, the Shakespearean tragedy about the scheming of Caesar's death, which then are shown to affect all aspects of Roman life. Some relationships show the concealed discord between characters, some show the conniving spirit of those who desire power, while others show how some hearts are devoted entirely to the greater good of the republic. The dialogue between Brutus and Portia, along with that of Calphurnia and Caesar, plays a significant role in the development of the plot. Portia is a symbol of Brutus's private life, a representative of correct intuition and morality, just as Calphurnia is for Caesar, but they differ in several ways, including each wife's fears and concerns, each husband's response to the pleas of each wife, the final outcome of the exchange, and both couples' dramatic function in development of the play.…

    • 2381 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Portia and Brutus

    • 330 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In our scene Portia presents the classic wife, worrying for her husband’s health of body and of mind. This is the first and only time that Portia is seen in Julius Ceasar. This is pretty important, because it doesn’t allow our view of her to change, therefore, everything she says can be taken at face value. We first hear of her saying “Brutus, my lord!” Which shows the interesting factor of subservience of women, in Ancient Roman times. Portia, in her next line, which is basically a monologue, proceeds to ask Brutus what is wrong with him. “Make me acquainted with your cause of grief.” This extremely long monologue is a good way of showing Shakespeare’s “above the iceberg” writing style. She is somewhat offended that Brutus seems to have put her off in the past couple of days when she asked what was troubling him. “And when I ask’d you what the matter was,” … “But, with an angry wafture of your hand, gave me sign to leave you, so I did.” Cleary she is mad that she isn’t being told of Brutus’s problem. Like any wife, when she feels that she isn’t being kept fully in the flow of things, she brings up the marriage thing. “Within the bond of marriage, Brutus, tell me.” Then naturally if she doesn’t get what she wants she gets all offended. “Portia is Brutus’s harlot, not his wife.” She also shows that she is very devoted to Brutus by stabbing her thigh and not getting any treatment to show that she could keep a secret. “Giving myself a voluntary wound. Here, in the thigh: can I bear that with patience.” Overall I have a positive view of Portia. She is a devoted wife, who expects to be included in her partners life, like any good spouse. Plus she proves that she can hold Brutus’s secrets with the thigh thing. Unfortunately, we hear about her killing herself later in the…

    • 330 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Portia; Heroin of Venice

    • 1437 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Portia is a strong heroine in a play filled with, confused, selfish, niave men. It may seem that she is a controlling female who uses her power to get her way in the world, but she is given a bad rap. Sure she's a bit controlling but how can we blame her, that's how she was brought up, it's part of her upbringing. It's easy to accuse her of prying into her newly husbands life or taking control over something that wasn't any of her concern, but it's possible that like many other heroes and heroines it was done out of love and not an insane need for control. Portia often gets criticized for being strong, independent and assertive but she is being judged on the main fact that she is a woman. Portia isn't abiding by the assumed gender roles of that time and because of this she is turned into a feminist.…

    • 1437 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays