Let me start this debate by defining the key terms of the definition. By "tv" I mean an electronic device that allows the broadcasting of audio and visual content to a mass audience; in this debate, also all the programs shown on this device, either through regular channels or on cable, at any time of day or night. By "negative effect" I mean has many harmful effects, which outweigh whatever good effects there may be, so the net result of tv is bad. And by "society" I mean all tv viewers, as well as all citizens in countries with tv, but with special emphasis on the youth.
I in the Affirmative believe that tv is doing much more harm to our society than good, and I will prove that to you in this debate.
I will prove this by focusing on 2 key arguments: tv has unacceptable levels of sex and violence that cause harm to viewers, and is a significant tool of rampant commercialization, which victimizes its viewers.
As the 1st round for the Affirmative, I will focus on how tv has unacceptable levels of sex and violence, while in my 2nd round I will discuss how it is a tool of rampant commercialization.
I believe that tv causes harm to viewers because of its increasingly suggestive sexual and violent content. The viewing public, especially the youth, are susceptible to messages being shown on tv, and this kind of content is extremely damaging for our youth, in particular. According to Changingchannels.org, more than a thousand studies have shown the same thing: "media violence makes our kids more aggressive, less patient, and more fearful of the world around them."
I can see that tv encourages young viewers to commit acts of violence. In 1 study done at Pennsylvania State University in 1972, about 100 preschool children were observed both before and after watching tv; some watched cartoons that had a lot of aggressive and violent acts in them, and others watched shows that didn't have any kind of violence. The researchers noticed real differences between the kids who watched the violent shows and those who watched nonviolent ones. "Children who watch the violent shows, even 'just funny' cartoons, were more likely to hit out at their playmates, argue, disobey class rules, leave tasks unfinished, and were less willing to wait for things than those who watched the nonviolent programs." says Aletha Huston-Stein, Ph.D., now at the University of Kansas.
This is unacceptable because we are struggling to build a more peaceful society, and the media, especially television, is only aggravating a difficult situation. Studies by George Gerbner, Ph.D., at the University of Pennsylvania, have shown that children's TV shows contain about 20 violent acts each hour and also that children who watch a lot of television are more likely to think that the world is a mean and dangerous place.
Tv also encourages young viewers to have sex outside of marriage, and this has led to many social problems. The Kaiser Family Foundation(2001) has reported that 80% of the content presented on soap operas is sexual in nature. Bryant and Rockwell's study found that teens that had been exposed to a highly sexual TV drama rated descriptions of casual sex encounters less negatively than teens that had received no sexual content exposure. Brown and Newcomer found that students who think tv accurately portrays sex were more likely to be dissatisfied with their first experience with intercourse. This means that our children are being encouraged to view pre-marital sex as both natural and desirable, and that their expectations for sex are unrealistic.
Furthermore, according to Changingchannels.org, tv desensitizes viewers to the evil nature of pre-marital sex and unprovoked violence, encouraging young viewers to find them acceptable and normal in society. The University of Michigan Institute for Social Research found that "Televised violence suggests to young children that aggression is appropriate in some situations, especially when it's used by charismatic heroes... It also erodes a natural aversion to violence." The same study found that children who watched violent tv programming." ... were also more likely than other study participants in the previous 12 months to have shoved somebody in anger; punched, beaten or choked an adult, or committed a crime or a moving traffic violation." The University of California at Santa Barbara, on the other hand, says "In one study of soap operas, there was only one representation of a married couple engaging in sex for every 24 portrayals of unmarried characters performing sexual acts." It cites another study which finds that "The bulk of the sexual action and language occurs between unmarried characters... unmarried heterosexual characters engage in sexual intercourse 4 to 8 times as much as married characters." Several studies, including those by Brown and Newcomer in 1991, link increased exposure to the mass media with dissatisfaction with virginity among teenagers. There are many other studies that show a similar effect. Wingood's study of black women aged 14 to 18 revealed that adolescents who see X-rated movies have less favorable attitudes toward condom use than other teens.
All of this is conclusive proof that tv leads to greater violence and pre-marital sex in society, and this is leading to further erosion in the values of our youth that will cause greater social problems for society in the future. If we truly want to build a more mature, responsible society, we must provide our youth with messages that affirm this kind of maturity and responsibility. Showing unacceptable levels of sex and violence on tv will only harm our efforts to improve society in the long-run.
I urge you to agree with the Affirmative, and to let this motion fall, for children's sakes, and the and the future of our society.
Thank you.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
How Does Television Violence Affect Children's Behavior Does television promote violence and crime among children? Although most people look at television as an entertaining and educational way to spend time, some people think there is too much violence in television and that is influencing our young into becoming aggressive in nature and to tolerate violence.…
- 549 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Cited: Oppenheim, Mike. "Tv Isn 't Violent Enough." Ainsworth, Alan. 75 Arguments: An anthology. 2006. 137-141. Print.…
- 777 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Television is just another part of technology keeping us from viewing the world and living our lives as we should. Instead of coming out of our house and taking on any challenge the world might have for us, we easily give up to our laziness, which quickly makes us grab the bag of chips, the soda, and sit down. Even though I am one of the many people who just loves to have the remote by their side, I strongly believe that television is nothing but detrimental to our society.…
- 623 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
When Television is being debated whether it is good or bad, I think that it should be taking into consideration just as any other subject we talk about when past/present is involved, and that consideration is “Evolution-Things forever evolving or changing”. Take for insistence the way countries would defend their land. In the 1700s militaries fought with swords, in the…
- 1014 Words
- 5 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
There has been much research into the negative effects of television. Television has been linked to aggressive behavior for over fifty years. In the 1960s, Albert Bandura did experiments to test the effects of televised violence on children’s behavior. In these experiments, children imitated adults’ violent treatment of an inflatable clown after watching it happen on film (Bandura, Ross & Ross, 1961, 1963).…
- 367 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Television is not the basic programs that were aired even a decade ago. There are now programs called reality television. Maryann Haggerty quoted, “In the blink of an eye, it seems, reality television has become a certifiable global pop-culture phenomenon.” There are currently over 200 reality television shows broadcasting all over the world. Any given subject can be found on television. You can watch a program from cooking, to life of a teen mother. With all the hours spent on watching such shows, I feel television has corrupted the world. Television is causing people to become, overweight; teens are using television as role models, and the world is using television for instant gratification.…
- 1784 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
While many people feel that television is a source of evil, and some people feel that it is a source of good, in my opinion it can be used for both good and bad. Sure, television can ruin and brainwash our youth, but there's a lot that they wouldn't learn without it. It is said that TV can mess with your eyes too. That may be, but we have advanced medical sciences for that. Let’s jump into it!…
- 902 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Plus, television has provided a forum for politics, allowing republicans, democrats, and independents to voice their opinions on the state of our country and how to manage it. Television has always been criticized for promoting violence, sex, teen pregnancy, and our country’s growing obesity problem, but television has also been a way of bringing this country together and giving Americans the ability to open our minds to social and cultural changes like the civil rights movement and to draw strength from tragedy like the Kennedy Assassination or the Space shuttle Challenger explosion (Media and Culture Ch.…
- 739 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
I agree that television shows influences our behaviors even without our knowledge of it. Although television seems like a great thing to have, it has many drawbacks. Television can have negative impacts on people, especially kids. People learn new skills by observing, then utilizing it, such as when we were kids and learn to walk by seeing our family walking around or learning a new subject in school. Therefore, when watching television it may influence our fundamental social dispositions; no matter if it is good or bad. Almost ninety nice percent of households possess one television. Television is today’s source of news, stories, legends, and characters from previous centuries; the reason why it is so influential. However, only “0.7 percent is used for public service announcements and news”(Sex, violence, profanity...). The other 97.3 % consists of television shows with violence, crime, advertisements and mainstream blandness. Many studies and research has been done to demonstrate that heavy television viewing may lead to serious health consequences. Television is great for entertainment but has grown into a major problem.…
- 1300 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
If we look closely at the most recent tragedies such as the September 11, New York, or the January 24, Hazmeih, tragedy it is clear that the people behind both tragic incidents (though they are not related) were influenced by TV. Such incidents could , by all means, have occurred in a Hollywood movie but they weren't movies they were real live T.V. What has television really done to our lives? It has corrupted the heads of people and taught them all the means of killing and getting away with…
- 481 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
2. Federman, J. (Ed. 1998). Executive Summary National Television Violence Study, Volume 3, Santa Barbara, CA: Center for Communication and Social Policy, University of California, Santa Barbara.…
- 1007 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Media violence has always been a big topic in America. The debate has never been decided upon. There are multiple studies that say that it does promote violence while others say that it is completely unrelated. Media violence is a form of entertainment that parents believe can effect their children negatively. Even though it is fake in the movies many people believe that children will believe it is cool and want to follow the example. They believe that children will not be able to distinguish between reality and the media. Even though no direct correlation has been made between the two most parents believe that it does but in reality they just do not want their children subjected to violent material. The media has become more daring with the material that they put on television. Over the decades the envelope on what is acceptable has been pushed to the point where there is almost nothing censored and everything is acceptable. Even though there is more violence on TV there is still no clear answer to rather it has promoted violence in children.…
- 1523 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Violence on television is a very controversial topic in today’s society. Many people have different views and opinions of how it effects today’s youth, and authors have written article after article pleading their points. Two similar articles with very different points pertaining this in depth subject are, written by Alice Langholt, “Positive Effects of Television on Kids”, and , written by American Psychological Association, “Childhood Exposure to Media Violence Predicts Young Adult Aggressive Behavior, According to a New 15- Year Study.” The article written by the American Psychological Association is by far the more analytical and statistically filled paper.…
- 588 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Young people and children learn from both experience and role models. When young people see violence on television, they have a difficult time deciding between what is real and what is make believe, and they often try to copy what they are seeing. Many young people are influenced by violence in TV and the media which can then shape their inappropriate behaviour. This is very dangerous TV viewing.…
- 781 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Television viewing is a major activity and influence on children and adolescents. People complain that certain TV shows are having negative effects on their children. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry (AACAP) both feel that TV does influence the behavior of children as young as one year old. From their studies, the AACAP states, “Children who view shows in which violence is very realistic, frequently repeated or unpunished, are more likely to imitate what they see” (as cited in Wilcox, 2004) This speaks to the impressionable mindsets of young children, who are still learning control of their minds and bodies, and are likely to mimic what they see, as it seems quite normal to them. Everything that children see or hear in the media early on in their lives affects them in some way. Violence, sexuality, race and gender stereotypes, drug and alcohol abuse are common themes of television programs. The Academy of Pediatrics says “More than one thousand scientific studies and reviews conclude that significant exposure to media violence increases the risk of aggressive behavior…
- 1359 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays