Authors
Abstract
The growth of university-industry research relationships in biotechnology has raised questions concerning their effects, both positive and negative, on universities. A survey of over 1200 faculty members at 40 major universities in the United States reveals that biotechnology researchers with industrial support publish at higher rates, patent more frequently, participate in more administrative and professional activities and earn more than colleagues without such support. At the same time, faculty with industry funds are much more likely than other biotechnology faculty to report that their research has resulted in trade secrets and that commercial considerations have influenced their choice of research projects. Although the data do not establish a causal connection between industrial support and these faculty behaviors, our findings strongly suggest that university-industry research relationships have both benefits and risks for academic institutions. The challenge for universities is to find ways to manage these relationships that will preserve the benefits while minimizing the risks.
Industrial support of university research in biotechnology
A 1984 study of biotechnology companies reveals that nearly one-half of all such firms fund research in universities. Industry may support as much as one-quarter of all biotechnology research in institutions of higher education. These investments seem to be yielding substantial benefits to involved firms. Per dollar invested, university research is generating more patent applications than is other company research. Research relationships do pose some risks to traditional university values such as openness of communication among scholars. These risks may be greater in relationships involving small firms. The data also reveal that government is now, and seems likely to remain, the principal source of support for university research in biotechnology.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Berman uses the 'institutional framework’ to answer the questions- “why university patenting increased in the first place” and “what else besides the Bayh-Dole Act caused university…
- 646 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The Council of Canadian Academies published a study analyzing the strengths and weaknesses of the Canadian research and the innovation in its business sector. This editorial piece critically describes the purpose, approach and findings of the report. It then focuses on the details of three aspects; weak Canadian business research and development, the firm-centric model in an innovation ecosystem and the key trends that will drive sciences and technology policy in and business innovation the future. Finally it will assess the proposed recommendations as compared to what science and technology theory has suggested.…
- 1233 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Casas, R..; Etzkowitiz and Carvalho de Mello, J. (2005): Knowledge for Innovation: New Directions for Latin American University-Industry-Government Interactions. New York:…
- 6485 Words
- 26 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Young argue in this journal the situation of university investigation and its different facets. Since 1950s, university research is facing many changes. Some changes are positive, like the expansion of population going to university, but others are negative, like the interference of governments and industry. The view of the author of what a university should be is that of teachers and students engaged, mainly, in knowledge that will profit society not only with a short economic gain. History probes that since the beginning there have been forces trying to affect the outcomes of university research. Before it was religion, but now is the industry who wants to put its influence in universities. Things started to change in university research after the World War II. Research funds were no more available through departmental resources, but through governments and industry. In this context, the report of Bush stated that the government should provide support for research, but also that scientist should freely investigate. At the end of the last century, many countries had granting councils. This model supposed more money for research, but also prioritized scientific research over art or social sciences. As the needs of universities increased, more detached were administrators from faculty, and more open were researchers to be transformed in entrepreneurs. In Canada, after an agreement, universities are increasing their commercialization in a way that makes Young wonder if this will be considered for tenure as much as teaching and researching. With this situation, some faculty members are more open to become entrepreneurs. This is putting in risk the nature of universities and the future of academic medicine. For example, in mild to moderate depression, both drugs and psychotherapy weight the same, but because of the push and the funds of pharmaceutical companies, there are more research centred in drugs. This situation could bring great misrepresentation in the areas…
- 438 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The president of Mountain Home University has been asked by her board of trustees to set up a mechanism for the commercialization of technology developed at the university. Such a mechanism is typically called a…
- 1911 Words
- 8 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Slaughter, S. & Rhoades, G. (2004). Academic capitalism and the new economy:Markets, state, and higher education: John Hopkins Univ Pr.…
- 5279 Words
- 22 Pages
Best Essays -
University Research - more than $500 million per year in sponsored research at Florida universities…
- 926 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
References: Dean, CC 1997, ‘The Principles of Scientific Management by Frederick W. Taylor: the private printing’, Journal of Management History, vol 3, issue 1, pp. 18-30.…
- 1489 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Schilling, M. A. (2011). Chapter Nine Protecting Innovation. In Strategic Management Of Technology Innovation, Third Edition (pp. 184-205). New York: The McGraw-Hill Companies Inc.…
- 1824 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Biotechnology has been the source of lots of controversy. There are those that love Biotechnology and dream of all the great things it could bring to mankind. There are also those who see it as threat to mankind, something that could possibly overthrow our current society. James Watson, who along with Francis Crick discovered the double helix structure of DNA, exerts that this controversy is not deserved. He believes that it is pertinent for our future, that it could benefit mankind. Francis Fukuyama, a professor at John Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies and author of the influential best seller Our Posthuman Future, insists that “… our compulsion to control and manipulate natural processes, including the human genome, will ultimately undermine nature itself (Fukuyama 668).” This viewpoint is concerned with conserving mankind as it is. There must be a place in between, a stance that both sides agree on.…
- 1076 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
It discusses the decentralized system of post-secondary education between provinces and its connection to how federal tax dollars for post-secondary will be spent, but also the structure of their post-secondary system itself. This article overall focuses on academic capitalism and presents data on post-secondary expenditures, contrasts provincial and federal policies, resource allocation, and revenue generation. It discusses policy initiatives that have actually increased Canadian academic capitalism, some which are very obviously entrepreneurial, even more so than that of the United States. This article was done in order to re-assess a previous paper done on the matter, and has brought forth the evidence that Canada has shifted to a structure of academic capitalism due the decreased public funding and increased private funding – public meaning from the provincial or federal level, and private from an institutional, tuition, and industrial level. Metcalfe’s paper discusses at length the Canadian Foundation for Innovation; the CFI is to be understood as an intermediating organization which is situated between government, academia, and industry . The CFI promotes the “institutionalization of entrepreneurial behaviour” within post-secondary education by requiring government funded research grants to be matched by industry. They are essentially increasing the ties between institutions and the private…
- 1896 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
After reviewing the proposed study, “The Value of Research”, presented by Mr. X, a graduate student at Auburn University, I have granted permission for the study to be conducted at School Name.…
- 457 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
innovation, Norman Matloff, a professor of computer science at the University of California, Davis, states “a commission appointed by the other top U.S. science agency, the National Institutes of Health, found that a severe oversupply has created a brutal job market for those who pursue doctorates in science research” (Matloff, par. 11). He stands against those claiming that there would be a labor shortage in the STEM job market.…
- 3276 Words
- 14 Pages
Best Essays -
Research Development differs significantly from university “development” (institutional “fundraising” or “advancement”) in that RD is not aimed at attracting contributions or donations. Rather, RD strengthens research programs and proposals to make them more competitive for extramural contracts and grants from federal and state agencies, and grant-making foundations that…
- 1228 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Brainard Jefferey; Anne M. Borrego, 2003. Academic pork barrel tops $2-billion for first time. The Chronicle of Higher Education.…
- 688 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays