To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Community service and pursuits such as charity work are praiseworthy and important ventures. There are both benefits for the individuals who are helped as well as for the volunteers. However, the issue of obligatory community service raises questions as to the extent of the advantages it would provide.
If a high school student had to undertake an unpaid position working for a charity, then there may well be a certain amount of resentment on behalf of the student due to the lack of choice and the sacrifices they would have to make in terms of their free time. This could lead to the opposite effect of the program’s intention; to teach teenagers valuable life lessons, such as respect and empathy for others. Conversely, a compulsory volunteering project could have a positive effect on high school pupils as it would become a commonplace and expected situation. As these teenagers grow up, the attributes that they gain from community services could help to shape a better, more caring society.
The opportunity to understand hard work, self-discipline and the duty of care that all individuals have is clearly of educational benefit. However these qualities could also be learned from paid work. Many students at high school have to maintain a part-time job in order to support their families or save for their future. Compulsory community service would severely disrupt the requirements of these students and be incompatible with their lives and schedules.
To exploit the various advantages that community service offers, it should be available in schools but not be obligatory. If improving the area by picking up litter, for example, was rewarded and respected by institutions, then teenagers would be more likely to happily engage in such activities. In a similar way, if schools were able to provide charitable pursuits that matched an individual's future aspirations, then this would be a better path to follow.
In conclusion, I am convinced that offering well-respected and useful opportunities to do community service to high school students is far more beneficial than forced participation.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
First, working for community service hours builds character and responsibility. People who make up community service hours are either to lazy or do not want to work unless they are paid. Working for your hours teaches work ethic and that work hours do not always need to be paid.…
- 304 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In “Serve Or Fail,” Dave Eggers argues that "colleges should consider instituting a service requirement for graduation.” He claims that 4 years college are too long, student usually waste many time, and to be volunteer is a good idea to kill time better than killing time on the meaningless activity like football. Furthermore, he states giving a opportunity to college student to service is a chance to let the kid meet society earlier. He introduced a bill like more than 90000 students at 14 state run universities required to them to have 25 hour community service in one year that can create more than two million volunteer in one year, and it can provide benefit from getting involved. In addition, the author argue that the service requirement…
- 270 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
At the start of high school, I learned that all students at my school were expected to perform sixty hours of community service before graduating. I hoped that my time would be well used, and that I could create a noticeable difference in someone else's life.…
- 594 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Overall, community service is paying back to people and animals that are in need. That is why it is necessary for the people that are able to participate do. Not only should people do it because they have to, they should want to. I have learned this personally through my community service experiences. By participating in community service it has allowed me to change as a person and look at life differently. In the beginning I was not enthusiastic about volunteering, but afterwards it made me feel good about myself. There are many benefits of volunteering like, doing helpful things of your interest, interacting with family and friends, and receiving more knowledge about things you didn’t know. There are many aspects of community service that are not blatantly shown.…
- 1014 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In the article it says “negates the spirit of volunteering itself.” With this it causes students to feel like it’s almost a “bad” thing because they see it as a job that has to be done instead of actually learning how to give back to the community because you desire to do it. Volunteering would come off as “forced work” to students as well as mandatory everyday work. When students have so much going on it’s almost impossible to keep up with community service and other activities going on in their life.…
- 524 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
However, according to Sally Brown, volunteering brings these groups together and unites communities through bonding and “mutual understanding” (qtd. in Dykhuis 16). In fact, Pappas states that many youth volunteers get started in service work through church or school. Consequently, these closely knit programs encourage friendship and address areas of each community’s concern (Dykhuis 16). This allows communities to come together through a similar cause whether that be “illiteracy, teen pregnancy, high crime rates, or drug abuse” (Spiegel and Safrit 14). Due to the different opportunities for community service, volunteers are able to understand the barriers between affluent and limited resource areas and use their knowledge of these barriers for further personal and communal…
- 1335 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Volunteers find a sense of self worth, empathy, gratitude, and responsibility. Personally, helping the community and providing a service to the community allows for a boost in confidence. Our world is often corrupt and unjust, but by twisting balloons and face painting, I learned that regardless of age, the youth of today can make major impacts on society, one smile at a time, even if it is just for a slight…
- 985 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Community service means much more to me than completing hours for a class or for a more appealing résumé. It builds character, leadership, and integrity. It transforms regular humans in to leaders and more passionate citizens. Community service also stands as a foundation builder to become a more…
- 1306 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Schools require all students to perform community service. They shouldn’t do community service more like job shadowing. Do job shadowing instead. They might want know more about a job they want to do in the future. Have try the job or shadow someone else doing the job…
- 228 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Moreover, community services can help for your future. Some students may even be interested in a career through doing the jobs. A few months ago, my friends and I went to do the volunteer that helped the campaign team to canvass. During the campaign, we had to distribute flyers and sort different flyers into envelopes. We encouraged them to join the campaign and hope that they can vote for our team, Progressive Conservative. While in the canvassing, we had to communicate with people. It demonstrates excellent organization, communication and good team spirit. People can use previous experiences in the future as they have obtained on the job. Therefore, there are many knowledge can be learnt from doing the community services.…
- 471 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Thesis Statement: High school students should have to take part in community service, also known as service learning, so they learn to appreciate what they have more and learn something new along the way.…
- 495 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
People get involved in community service for a variety of reasons. For example, there are many who suffer from starvation and need someone willing to make sure they receive the necessary nutritional values. There are elderly people in this world who are looking for someone to talk to, and someone to comfort them. There are many people in the world seeking a friend and others who are searching for guidance or a mentor in life. Many people choose to give back to their community in different ways. Some choose a public service; others join organizations or even create a club or organization geared towards a specific task. This semester I have decided to volunteer my services by giving my time.…
- 483 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Students shouldn’t be required to perform seventy five hours of community service. This is because the work wouldn’t be done well if the students were forced. Also time would be taken away from clubs, sports, social life and school work. Then again it will make the town look better.…
- 356 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Should high school students do community service to graduate. In the article “volunteering to graduate: Do we need more requirements?” By Miriam Dodge explains why doing community service should be required to graduate. Some schools think that doing community service should be required in order to graduate from high school, but what they don’t know, is that a higher percent of students won't graduate.…
- 191 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Does mandatory volunteering differ from “slavery”? According to this project, a student has to spend his or her particular time to service for community for free in order to graduate from the university. It is fact that in some countries (United States of America, Canada) mandatory volunteering is still used, and in their experience, it works effectively. They say that mandatory volunteering not only develops some skills, but also teaches the future life to the student and it is a kind of preparation for them. In my opinion, they can find more useful and interesting thing than mandatory volunteering in order to graduate from the university, and it should not be required.…
- 503 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays