Throughout the proceedings of this case, the defense has proven that not only was the prosecution’s case mainly based on the testimony of Ms. Shirley Thompson, but they were unable to find substantial evidence to determine whether their act of sexual intercourse was consensual or not. During the prosecution’s examinations, Ralph Thompson and Detective Rich were unable to…
In the early 1980’s in a small Podunk town of Ada, Oklahoma, a young woman named Debra Sue Carter, was savagely raped and killed in her own apartment after work at the local cocktail bar. Quickly, the town drunk was arrested in relation to the rape and murder with nothing more than a single “eyewitness” that placed him at the woman’s job that night. Many regulars to the bar said that “they would know if Ron Williamson was at the Coach Light and he wasn’t there.” They, in fact, named another man: Glenn Gore, the prosecution's main witness. Gore was also the man that Debbie’s friend said that she was afraid of and he was supposedly at Debbie’s apartment the night of the murder, according to the friend who received a phone call that night from Debbie. Gore was also seen being pushed away by the victim at the victim’s car the same night as the murder.…
What were the names of the accusers? The names of the accusers were Ruby Bates and Victoria Price.…
Katherine Watkins was raped by John Long as she claimed under oath. Her story is confirmed by Humphrey Smith, whose deposition is in agreement with Katherine’s accusation. Humphrey had nothing to gain from defending Katherine’s story, which would warrant his story as true. In contrast, the other witnesses probably hated the white Quakers and would have delighted to see Katherine convicted and shame brought on the Quaker community. These other witness accounts from John Aust, William Harding, Mary Winter, and Lambert Tye are all part of a made up story to protect John Long and attack the Quakers. Each of these people, being black slaves, probably hated the white quakers and wanted to destroy and embarrass Katherine. The risks Katherine…
The first witness for the case was a woman named Caroline Haspers who lived in the same apartment building as Mary. She recalled on January 30th that Mary looked distraught and that her daughter was not with her. She also provided information that was not relevant to the charges saying that, “I always thought Ms. Barnett was a disgrace—I mean, she didn’t have a husband.” Given that she did not…
There was widespread outrage over the verdict, and Ruby Bates traveled the country with some of the Scottsboro Boys', giving speeches vindicating the young men. Then, on June 22, 1933, Judge Horton made a stunning announcement: Evidence that made clear Bate's wasn't raped on the train. Horton set aside the jury verdict and ordered a new trial. It was not until years later that he revealed why: One of the doctors who examined the women pulled Horton aside to say that he couldn't find signs a rape had occured, but was afraid to testify to it on the…
Tom Robinson’s trial was probably one of the most nail biting trials ever and it all took play place in Maycomb County in southern Alabama.This trial occurred in August 26,1935 but the crime took place at the Ewells home on November 21,1934,which also means it was during The Great Depression.It all started when Mayella had accused Tom Robinson of allegedly raping and beating her,when in trial she said “-he chunked me on the floor and’ choked me and took advantage of me”(TKAM).During this trial many things occurred from the defendant’s lawyer “Atticus” kids who gaped through the whole trial to Mr.Gilmer,the accuser’s lawyer,impertinent attitude towards Tom Robinson.…
The day of Tom Robinson's trial was hot, damp, and uncomfortable. The seats were hard and painful to sit on. But it still seemed as if everyone in Maycomb was packed into the courthouse. There was a separation of the court, the blacks sat on one side and the whites on the other. Sheriff Heck Tate was the first witness. He testified that he had found Mayella at her home. He described her awful conditions; her head was full of blood, she had bruises on her arms and neck, and her right eye was black and blue. She claimed to have been beaten and raped by Tom Robinson. Sheriff Tate also added that he realized that a left-handed person had attacked Mayella because her wounds were on her right side.…
The train stopped in a town called Paint Rock where the nine boys were put into jail. The boys were about to be charged with assault, but two women were discovered hiding on the train. The women, Victoria Price and her accomplice, Ruby Bates, were riding as hobos on the train and decided to testify against the boys to cover up the crime they committed (Wormser). The mirroring of these events suggest that Lee was influenced by real world incidences she grew up hearing about. In the Scottsboro Trials, Ruby Bates and Victoria Price went to see a doctor, and semen was found in both girls. They did not seem to be injured and were very calm after being allegedly raped. The semen was non-motile which was strange because they were just raped by many boys. During the trials, Ruby Bates said that her and Victoria spent the night with their boyfriends the night before the train ride (Salter). There was no credible evidence against the boys, barely anything to go off of. This did not seem to matter in the 1930s. There is a similar situation in the novel. In To Kill a Mockingbird, Mayella Ewell claims that she has been raped by Tom Robinson (Lee 180). Her father, Bob Ewell, called the sheriff after he saw what…
In the early to mid-1900’s Americans were cruel to African-Americans through racism, segregation, and inequality. The Scottsboro Trials took place in the 1930’s and consisted of nine ‘colored’ men accused of raping two white women on a train. Of course, since life wasn’t exactly fair for everyone during this time, the trials resulted in biased results. Plus, the jury selected, was made up entirely of white men who were clearly in favor of the two white women. The Scottsboro Boys’ Trials eventually shaped the way for the direction in which discrimination in the United States progressed over time.…
Remember the segregation of blacks. Well did you ever wonder what happened to them if they committed or got accused of a crime. There were many cases but there is one case in particular that I am going to be talking about. The Scottsboro case had the most impact on the black community.…
The Lizzie Borden case has mystified and fascinated those interested in crime forover on hundred years. Very few cases in American history have attracted as much attention as the hatchet murders of Andrew J. Borden and his wife, Abby Borden. The bloodiness of the acts in an otherwise respectable late nineteenth century domestic setting is startling. Along with the gruesome nature of the crimes is the unexpected character of the accused, not a hatchet-wielding maniac, but a church-going, Sunday-school-teaching, respectable, spinster-…
In recent cases such as Treyvon Martin, it is evident that justice is being denied to innocent black men, an issue that has raised awareness for far to long. To Kill a Mockingbird, by Nelle Harper Lee, was written in 1960. In this novel, the man falsely accused of raping a white woman has no hope. In the 1930's Scottsboro boys trials, which took place just decades before the novel was written, a group of black men were also falsely accused of raping white women. Although there have been many great movements to promote equality and integration since the 1900s, the bias nature towards African-American men remains.…
In this trial, nine African American teenagers were unjustly accused of raping two white women on a train. Even though the evidence clearly showed otherwise, they were still convicted again and again by the many juries that they faced because of their skin color, showing once more the power of Jim Crow Racism. During the multiple trials that this case spanned, there were many individuals who showed courage. One such person was, ironically enough, Ruby Bates, one of the women that had accused the boys of raping her. Aside from adding to the fact that the teenagers were innocent, Ruby’s recantation of her story was also, on her part, a courageous one.…
Miss Ewell did something that in our society is unspeakable: she is white, and she tempted a Negro. The defendant is not guilty, but someone in this courtroom is. I have nothing but pity in my heart for the chief witness for the state, but my pity does not extend so far as to her putting a man's life at stake. She knew full well the enormity of her offense, but because her desires were stronger than the code she was breaking, she persisted. The state of Alabama has relied solely upon the testimony of two witnesses who's evidence has not only been called into serious question, but has been flatly contradicted by the defendant.…