On April 16, 2007, almost exactly 8 years after the horrible assault of gunfire and bombs that left many students and one teacher dead at Columbine High School in Littleton, Colorado, another deadly assault took place at Virginia Tech University. The aftermath of the Virginia Tech horror was even more gruesome than Columbine. Including the gunman who took his own life, a total of 33 people died—making it the worst school shooting in America’s history. (Media effects research : A basic overview :Glenn G. Sparks)
The national discussion that followed both the Columbine and Virginia Tech incidents had some striking similarities. After Columbine, a persistent theme was sounded over and over again: The mass media must share a significant part of the blame for this incident and others like it. President Clinton called on the producers of mass media messages to reduce gratuitous violence. The clear implication of Clinton’s rhetoric was that exposure to violent entertainment images increased the probability of this type of violent behaviour. Similarly, after Virginia Tech, it took only hours before the media devoted intense coverage to the possibility that the perpetrator of the shootings had been influenced by playing a violent video game. The prominent TV psychologist Dr. Phil McGraw appeared on CNN’s Larry King Live and said: “We’re going to have to start … recognizing that the mass murderers of tomorrow are the children of today that are being programmed with this massive [media] violence overdose.” (Media effects research : A basic overview :Glenn G. Sparks)
The media landscape is ever changing, with new technologies resulting in greater interactivity on smaller, graphically superior, and computationally more powerful devices. These new technologies are tremendous resources for learning and knowledge acquisition at a rate unparalleled in the past. Unlike traditional media (such as broadcast TV), these new technologies, in combination with an Internet connection, give children and adolescents new ways of playing games as well as access to more diverse forms of visually stimulating content than ever before (Donnerstein, 2011). Access to such content has many benefits, but it also carries risks. Youth can now download, view, play, and listen to violent material any time of day or night, often from the privacy of their own rooms, and with little supervision from their parents. With new technologies, the opportunities for viewing violent content, which was once relegated to more public spaces (such as the neighborhood, the movie theater, or the living room), have become increasingly private. For other media contents unrelated to violence, it is widely accepted that what people see in the virtual reality of the media has an effect on their behavior in the real world(Media Violence Commission, International Society for Research on Aggression).
By watching aggression, children learn how to be aggressive in new ways and they also draw conclusions about whether being aggressive to others will bring them rewards (Huesmann and Eron, 1986). Those children who see TV characters getting what they want by hitting are more likely to strike out themselves in imitation. Even if the TV character has a so-called good reason for acting violently (as when a police officer is shown shooting down a criminal to protect others), this does not make young children less likely to imitate the aggressive act than when there is no good reason for the violence (Liss, Reinhardt and Fredriksen, 1983).
Besides making children more likely to act aggressively, violence on media may have other harmful effects. First, it may lead children to accept more aggressive behaviour in others (Drabman and Thomas, 1974). Second, it may make children more fearful as they come to believe that violence is as common in the real world as it is on media (Bryant, Careth and Brown, 1981).
Other problems arise with viewing given that a child‘s cognitive development has not yet matured in order for him or her to completely understand, dissect and analyse all of the messages being thrown at him or her by the media. According to Potter (2008) a lack of cognitive development can be a barrier to appropriate emotional reactions to media messages (p. 58). “Until children have developed many knowledge structures, they don‘t have many perspectives from which to view the world” (p. 61).
Violence is one of many messages disseminated through the sensation of television, which plays an active role in entertaining and impacting the lives of today‘s youth. Because of its prevalence, violence on media has grown to be a controversial issue on which several studies have been conducted since the 1950s. Based on his research, Gerbner asserts that growing up in a mediated violence-laden culture breeds aggressiveness in some and desensitization, insecurity, mistrust, and anger in most (Brittany T. Rawlings, August 2011) . While debate ensues over potential long and short-term effects of media, children are often at the forefront as a special group that needs protection from the risks of any negative media effects (Potter, 2008, p. 62).
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The documentary “Bowling for Columbine” is an award-winning documentary directed by well-known filmmaker Michael Moore. The film won an Academy Award for Best Documentary Feature, as well as an Independent Spirit Award, a Cesar Award and many others. This bold movie criticizes America’s large number of gun related deaths annually compared to other countries around the world. He discusses why America seems to have such a problem with violence and how it has led to tragedy’s involving firearms like the imfamous shooting at Columbine high school in Columbine, Colorado. Since the Columbine shooting in 1999 there have been other school shootings that seem to closely resemble it, such as the 2007 Virginia Tech shooting and the recent 2012 Sandy Hook…
- 686 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In Bowling for Columbine, Michael Moore’s documentary film he proposes that the availability of guns is directly influencing the increasing gun related incidents that are taking place in the U.S. Furthermore, he points out that the media is manipulating these killings to create a culture of fear. Moore uses narrative elements and film language to persuade us to embrace his proposal while being entertained.…
- 758 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Following the massacre of Columbine High School, Colorado, controversial filmmaker Michael Moore, ventured into creating the societal criticism documentary that explored gun violence throughout the United States. The documentary Bowling for Columbine (2002), directed, produced, and written by Moore, deconstructs the events of this massacre, other school shooting, American gun culture, media coverage of such events, paranoia, racism, and poverty and several other subjects through the use of documentary techniques in order to achieve a clear understanding of these issues that underpin his documentary. The main issue being is to search for the answer to why gun violence represents such a great portion in the United States.…
- 865 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The Academy Award winning documentary film “Bowling for Columbine” by Director Michael Moore attempts to find a reason for the Columbine High School, Colorado shootings and leads to an investigation into gun laws and gun violence. Through a series of interviews, stunts, cartoons, commentary and media pieces, we are left at the end of a blunt and revealing journey wanting the answers to the various moral and ethical questions raised. Moore travels across America and Canada to get a broad pool of opinion and not only takes the trip to find a reason for the gun violence in the first place, but he takes the long road by not blaming the usual suspects (video games, angry music, and a bloody history as a nation) and investigating other investigations. Moore reveals disturbing and frightening truths about the US’s gun possession statistics and gun related death figures. Moore shows his skill as a filmmaker in “Columbine” in his ability to keep the audience, not only attentive, but entertained also. Although the film is based around the tragic Columbine Massacre, Moore makes the best of a bad situation and tries (when appropriate) to make the film humorous and light hearted.…
- 2360 Words
- 10 Pages
Better Essays -
When a school shooting is vaguely talked about through much of media, it is thought the reason for the shooting is because of violent video games, TV, and even music. However, an abundance…
- 2032 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
“In ten years after Columbine, more than eighty shootings took place in the United States.” (Cullen 348) The Principal of Columbine High School, Mr. D, made himself available to every principal who made it through the shootings to talk. Although these calls were hard sometimes, nothing compared to an email he got from a student that was obsessed with Columbine from North Carolina. The email said, “In a few hours you will probably hear about a school shooting in North Carolina. I am responsible for it. I remember Columbine. It is time the world remembered it. I am sorry. Goodbye.” (Columbine 348) When Mr. D realized he got this email, it was too late. The student drove by his school while firing off eight shots, injured two people and killed his father. School shooting was a fear that was now expanded all throughout the world. Another school shooting that was a real eye opener was at Virginia Tech by Seung-Hui Cho. “Seung-Hui Cho killed thirty-two people, plus himself, and injured seventeen.” (Cullen 348) Cho didn’t seem to relish his massacre like Eric and Dylan did, he had psychosis and didn’t even seem…
- 457 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
We will discuss what happened in this incident that disrupted the nation. In The Social Science Journal, “The Columbine High School Massacre and criminal justice system response: An exploratory case study” Matt DeLisi discuses about the horrible incident in Columbine High School when two students open fire on campuses killing 23 students and later committed suicide within a 4hour rampage. During the four hour incident witnesses mentioned that gunmen targeted student-athletes, students in Christian organization groups, and ethnic minorities. It was later discovered that the gunmen were infatuated with right-wing and Nazism ideologies and had planned the massacre for over a year (Matt DeLisi, 2002). Many questioned if there were any warning signs that could have been seen before the incident happened. A Documentary by Zero Hour on a YouTube channel gave us an insight on the lives of the two gunman. An analyzation of one of the teens and his distension of risk factors that were involved priere to the…
- 1753 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
On the noon of April 20th, 1999 America’s deadliest school shooting had just ended with the suicide of its two gunmen. Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold had just murdered twelve students, one teacher, and injured twenty-one since they began their shooting spree forty minutes earlier in the city of Littleton, Colorado. The media coverage of the Columbine High School massacre made this event have a tremendous impact on the people of the United States, inducing fear of all outcasts in schools, and creating an insatiable thirst for answers. Soon, there was a large amount of misinformation, but it took years before people knew why it happened. The events leading to the Columbine High School massacre have become important clues to look for in order to…
- 2099 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Due to this fact, the connection between violence and aggression is self-evident, and the continual stream of violence through these forms of media do not help the matter in any regard. This is supported by Nancy C. Cornwell’s statement that “research supports a correlation between media violence and aggression.” Media can send many messages to those who are exposed to it, but this statement suggests that a less than savory ideal may be sent to younger audiences who happen to be exposed to it. As is evidenced by the fact that this influence from a form of media can be found in many cases where someone from a younger audience took the ideals portrayed too far. This is shown to be fact instead of speculation due to copycat crimes that can lead to devastating reenactments of fictionalized drama and horror being implemented in reality. There are many examples that support this statement like this given statement from Cornwell’s article “violence in Media,” “The numerous anecdotal examples of copycat rapes, suicides and violent crime, closely mimicking television drama, movie scenes and provocative song lyrics” (Cornwell). With the added perspective derived from this statement supplied by Cornwell, these ideas show the realistic evidence supplied by the facts given, which garners a far more vast well of knowledge, that leads to the…
- 1590 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
In Violent Media is Good for Kids, Gerard Jones argues that violent forms of media in our pop culture can be used as a means of helping kids cope with rage. Throughout his essay, Jones promotes the idea that kids should use “creative violence” as a tool to transfer their negative emotions rather than acting out on them (197). Although Jones points out valid arguments to defend violence in media, he fails give a clear definition to determine what constitutes it. Thus, he excludes all other forms of media violence such as gaming, movies, television shows, etc. that dominate our current world. Jones’ argument is based mostly on Marvel Comics with superheroes acting out their “violence” to perceived injustices. His lack of sources makes him lose credibility and ineffectively persuade his readers, especially parents, to use media violence as a form of creativity to diminish any negative behaviors.…
- 801 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Her team examines databases containing information on high-profile mass killings and school shootings in the United States and attempt to determine if these tragedies inspire similar events in the near future. Her group has determined that these events have in fact shown a pattern they call “contagion”, which is when patterns of many events are bunched in time, rather than occurring randomly in time. The period of contagion Tower’s research has uncovered spans the thirteen days after the initial event, providing data that twenty to thirty percent of copycat killings occur during this time period (Long, 2015, p. 11). A similar phenomenon has shown itself in research about highly publicized suicides and copycat events. While suicides and mass shootings are not technically the same event, people’s response to them seems to be similar, providing a starting point for scientists trying to find a copycat link with mass murderers and the media. A total of 293 findings from 42 studies showed that the effect of a highly broadcasted entertainment or celebrity suicide showed results where a copycat was 14.3 times more likely to occur. Often the greatest reduction in copycats from these studies came from simply reducing the sheer quantity of the news on the suicide as opposed to reducing the perceived quality of the news…
- 1293 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
This was yet another story in which the media could seek their teeth in and blame it on video games. To this day it is still not proven that these two students were influenced by video games. After the shootings the police found the journals of the two perpetrators and found out that the result of the shooting was due to them being social outcasts and bullying form the other students. Even with these hard facts pointing towards different influences leading to the columbine shooting the news and congress still blame video games and wish to ban them from people’s homes. According to a small article on the “American Psychological Association” website it comes to prove how video games can actually provide learning, health and many benefits. As quoted from the article “A 2013 meta-analysis found out that playing shooter video games improved a players capacity to think about objects in three dimensions just as well as academic courses designed to enhance these same skills” (Bowen).Most studies and reports today have actually gone the distance as to connect any unrelated and horrible news to video games. Not to long ago the latest installment of Grand theft auto was released and the news reported its record breaking sales. At the same time the D.C. navy yard shooting had also gained a lot if attention. Many reporters hurried to uncover many…
- 1009 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In this century, the mass media have come to rival with parents, school, and religion as the most influential institution in individual 's lives. There has always been contemplation on whether media is the spark that ignites violence in individuals. Depictions of violence often glamorize vicious behavior. They offend the society and feel less able to respond to others in a sensitive, caring way. This essay will analyze the effects of violent media on the minds of individuals. While it focuses on media vastly, other contributing factors like emotional processing factors or exposure to violence might be reasons too.…
- 1326 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
April 20th 1999 the massacre caused by two students, Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, killed twelve students as well as one teacher only to kill themselves after.(1Moore) The event had pushed the media to question the abuse of firearms availability and the troubles of youth. Apparently though the guns that Harris and Klebold had used were legally purchased at stores and gun shows. The bullets were purchased at a local K-mart in Littleton. This example shows how the media portrayals today affect the minds of youth giving them violent solutions to ideas that should not be solved in such manners. They think, well it’s in video games we see it all over television it must be okay right? And only after realizing the situation they were truly in did they feel the guilt and attempted suicides. Personally I would not be able to live a trouble free life with the fact that someone died because of me running through my…
- 1399 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
During the past few years, more and more people have been discussing the topic of violent media to figure out if it triggers violent behavior to some people. Some media critics believe that young people play violent video games and read violent comic books as a safe place for kids to let out their aggression. Gerald Jones wrote a passage arguing that violent comic books and video games are useful for young people. He was taught as a little kid that violence was wrong and that anger was something you had to learn to overcome. While he was young, he was given violent comic books that also had good life lessons in them. Since those comic books Jones has been writing action movies and comic books, and made him into the man he is today. He believes…
- 247 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays