Preview

Violence In The Aeneid

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1183 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Violence In The Aeneid
Violence and death are a persistent and dominant theme in the Aeneid and Oresteia. In both plays, violence and death are justified as an act of vengeance and response to injustice. Though Virgil and Aeschylus justify violence, they both differ in two aspects. One takes away the power of the protagonists to choose and the other allows the protagonists to make their own decisions. The house curse influences Clytaemnestra to kill Agamemnon and Apollo commands Orestes to kill Clytaemnestra, his mother. In the other hand, the gods give Turnus and Aeneas the choice to kill or not to kill. The other aspect is, Virgil’s deaths and violent acts are between family, while Aeschylus’ acts of violence are between strangers.
Aeschylus justifies Clytaemnestra’s when she kills Agamemnon because he sacrificed their daughter to the god Artemis. She says, “My child is gone. That is my self-defense” (Agamemnon 876). She
…show more content…
During the war many Latins and Trojans died because of Turnus determination to kill Aeneas and drive the Trojans out of Italy. Virgil’s justifies Turnus decision to go to war because Aeneas is a foreigner who is trying to take over their land and most importantly, Aeneas is trying to steal his betrothed, Lavinia. Although Juno, is the god behind all the disasters, she seems to be the most understanding and realistic. She explains how the Trojans are “yoking the fields of others, hauling off the [plunder]/taking their pick of daughters, tearing the sworn bride/ from her husband’s [arms]” (10.93-4). She says this after hearing Venus’ plead Jupiter to help the Trojans because they were being viciously attacked by the Turnus and his army while Aeneas was away. Juno expresses the exasperation of Turnus and how he feels. The Trojans are unwelcomed invaders who are taking over their land forcibly and arrogantly. They took Lavinia which is what bothers most Turnus because it means

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Aeneid Book 6 Part 1

    • 3175 Words
    • 17 Pages

    across the boughs. As in the winter's cold, among the woods the mistletoe-no seed of where U grows-is green with new leaves, girdl11g the tapering stems with yellow fruit: just so the gold leaves seemed against the dark-green Hex; so, in the gentle wind, the thin gold leaf was crackling. And at once Aeneas plucks it and, eager, breaks the hesitating bough and carries it into the Sibyl's house. Meanwhile along the shore the Teucrians were weeping for Misenus, offering their final tributes to his thankless ashes.…

    • 3175 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Aeneid; Books 7-9

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Juno however, is still mad. She just can't seem to keep the Trojans away from the shores, so she decides that she's going to delay the foundation of the city. she sends Allecto to Latium to get the natives angry at the Trojans. First, Allecto gets the Queen to oppose the marriage of Aeneas and Lavinia. Then, he infects Turnus and makes him angry about losing Lavinia. So Turnus gathers up his army and prepares for war against the Trojans. Ascanius goes off to hunt and wounds a stag that turns out to be a pet. The stag wonders back to its owner and dies. the owner of the stag sends people out to track down the hunter and the Trojans come to Ascanius's aid. many natives are killed and the war against the Trojans is about to begin.…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Of course, we must not forget that Juno played a role in leading Aeneas to kill Turnus by sending down one of her furies which crippled Turnus and gave Aeneas the upper hand (Aeneid, 12.1020-1045). I also don’t think that Aeneas seeing the belt of Pallas was…

    • 1461 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A cycle of murder and death spurs from the curse on the House of Atreus in Aeschylus’ The Oresteia but transforms from justice as vengeance to justice as fairness and forgiveness through the wisdom of Athena, establishing a new cycle of growth and life. The curse upon the House of Atreus was brought forth through the event of Zeus’ eagles devouring a pregnant hare which angered Artemis for she is the goddess of young animals and creatures. The big black bird swoops down and “plunged their claws in a hare, a mother bursting with unborn young—the babies spilling, quick spurts of blood-cut off the race just dashing into life!” and instantly this brings forth the curse (A 122-124). The death of the hare’s unborn babies directly relates to the curse on the House of Atreus where children were abruptly killed, hindering growth and fertility for generations. Agamemnon is unable to escape his deathly net of fate once he was ordered by Artemis to kill his own daughter, Iphigenia. The Furies are fueled by this and thus go after Agamemnon which traps him in a fate which he can never escape. At this point, “Justice turns the balance scales, sees that we suffer and we suffer and we learn” (A 250-252). From the “an eye for an eye” perspective, justice is vengeance and it sustains balance and fairness. When King Agamemnon returns home to Argos from the war in Troy, the herald begins to speak of his actions and how “He hoisted the pickaxe of Zeus who brings revenge, he dug Troy down, he worked her soil down, the shrines of her gods and the high altars, gone! –and the seed of her wide earth he ground to bits” (A 516-519) out of admiration. Agamemnon accomplishes a great feat by conquering Troy and is highly praised, but while doing so he kills the seeds of life and plants death in its place, emphasizing his proclamation that he will “burn the cancer at the roots.” (A 836). By burning the cancer at the roots Agamemnon is declaring that he will purify…

    • 1469 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Clytemnestra Deception

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Clytemnestra, a very prevalent character in Aeschlyus’ play Agamemnon, stands as a center point among the most famous speeches in the history of Greek literature. Breaking with the traditions of other plays written during this time period, Clytemnestra wields considerable political power during the time period in which women were sidelines from affairs of the state. Possessing a “male strength heart,” as stated by the watchmen in the beginning of the play, Clytemnestra not only is able to attain political control but she also has the ability to deceive those that surround her. The chorus makes the queen’s deceiving ways apparent to the audience when noting to the Herald not to take everything Clytemnestra says at face-value, for they have learned…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Virgil uses a few techniques in order to extract sympathy for Aeneas from the reader. At some different points in Book 12 of the Aeneid, Virgil makes it seem as if Aeneas is the hero, and Turnus the villain, thus creating sympathy for the former. Virgil, for a large part of this book, portrays Aeneas as being wounded by an arrow wound, making the character seem more heroic, and so we feel sympathy towards him because of this. A number of times, Aeneas is unable to catch Turnus because his wounded knees slow him down. Virgil clearly shows the reader the struggle that Aeneas is facing, and this is illustrated in the simile of the Umbrian hunting dog and the deer. Through this simile, Aeneas – the hunting dog – is unable to grab Turnus, having been deceived by an empty bite. Throughout Book 12 of the Aeneid, Virgil hints that it is possible to feel a small amount of sympathy towards Aeneas, however it is clear that this sympathy cannot extend as far as with Turnus.…

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    We start to view them as being very sneaky and we start to watch as their plan unfolds to attack Troy by surprise. Now the Trojans are now depicted as the victims from Aeneas perspective. Aeneas and the Trojans spared Sinon’s life and only tried to help him. In return, the Trojans are then depicted as being gullible and being completely taken advantage of, “Moved by tears, we granted him his life, and freely pitied him", (Book II.…

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Helen In The Odyssey

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It has been said that Agamemnon is the most unfortunate character in the Odyssey, but truthfully, Clytemnestra had to witness her husband’s death, and suffer the consequences for the murder her lover…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Brutality In The Aeneid

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Aeneid has gone through The Fields of Mourning, where he his greeted by his former lover Dido. Once Aeneas sees Dido he begins to break down with emotion expressing, “Did I bring only death to you?” (602). Aeneid goes onto proclaim to Dido that although he was unwilling to leave her, the gods had a mission for him to execute. Continuing on with his expedition he also sees the decease combatants of the Trojan War. A pivotal moment in the walk is when Aeneas sees a dismantled Deiphobus, sadden by his presence, Aeneas is heartbroken, and the two share a heartfelt conversation (660-724). In the middle of the conversation Sibyl forces Aeneas to move on with his expedition, there he witness a “fortress encircled by a triple wall and girdled by a rapid flood of flames”…

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    (Point) Dido begins to pursue relations with Aeneas, and Aeneas exhibits a lack of self-control by engaging in such relations. (Evidence) On the day of a hunt, Juno wills it to rain so that the hunters would have to seek shelter and the circumstances would allow for the fated union, “Dido and the Trojan leader reach the very same cave… the heavens are party to their union…. That first day is the source of misfortune and death. / Dido’s no longer troubled by appearances or reputation, / she no longer thinks of a secret affair: she calls it marriage: / and with that name disguises her sin" (Vergil 4. 165-172). (Explanation 1) Through these words, Vergil states that Dido and Aeneas sheltered themselves in the same cave, and with the approval of the gods they became one (while noting that this day would cause death and misfortune, no doubt alluding to Dido’s imminent suicide), while Dido suppressed her inhibitions by considering the act as a sign of a marital relationship rather than as a sin. (ex2) Though Vergil describes how Dido overcame her reservations, he makes it apparent that Aeneas had none, and his lack of self-control in dealing with this sensitive matter would put the responsibility of the consequences to come upon himself. (ex3) His decision to allow himself to enter a relationship with Dido proves his lack of the Roman virtue disciplina, and this time, his error would carry the eventual tragic consequence of driving Dido to suicide, which would be a major blow against the Phoenicians. (Transition) He would later make a disciplined decision for once, though it would be too late to undo the wrong that he had done and would serve only to accelerate the consequences of his…

    • 2165 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    It seems as though, as soon as the gods introduce and permit a certain illegal action, the actors dutifully carry out the crimes, which often include very personal domestic violence, in the name of the “greater good.” For Agamemnon, it is almost understandable – I could see how he, as a ruler, may need to prioritize the survival of his empire over his daughter and make the utilitarian choice for the “greater good.” But does he consider his wife, the mother of his child? He acts with impunity because a god said his ships would perform better, and that was apparently all he needed. But for Orestes, his decision to kill his mother in order to restore some type of honor for his father is extreme. Apollo said it was okay, then Orestes decided to murder her because he was convinced it was the right thing to do, which Athena agrees with. Her vote results in an overall split vote and Orestes is acquitted, even though the Chorus says he “is meddling in matters of blood, and it is not your…

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Agamemnon Essay 7

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In Aeschylus' Agamemnon there are many different opinions about what kind of king and commander Agamemnon was. Some argued that he was good, while others dispute that his motives were wrong. Clytemnestra, Agamemnon's wife, gained a strong hatred for him, after he sacrificed his own daughter so he could go to war. Many believe that this was not necessary and could have been overcome. The chorus seems to agree with this to an extent, and feels that Agamemnon could have prayed and requested that he not sacrifice his daughter.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Oresteia Essay

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages

    His sudden death affects numerous people, including his son Orestes, and at this moment, the viewers are devastated that such an honorable man was killed by his own wife. Moreover, the audience is held to think that there is no solution to the identified complication because Agamemnon is already dead. Further, Clytaemnesthra’s reason for killing Agamemnon intensifies the tragic abyss by enlightening the audience about the corruption in the world. As Aeschylus narrates in the play Agamemnon, Clytaemnesthra’s motive for killing Agamemnon revolves around the fact that he killed Iphigeneia, their own daughter. This action reveals that even the most honorable men can be corrupt. If Agamemnon truly loved Iphigeneia, he would not sacrifice his own beloved daughter. Likewise, if Clytaemnesthra truly loved Agamemnon, she would not have killed him. Agamemnon, Clytaemnesthra, and Iphigenia part of an affectionate family and the murders within this household truly show the audience that even the most trusted people can be…

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “On the Murder of Eratosthenes”, written by Lysias, was the defense argument used by Euphiletos during his murder trial. Euphiletos killed fellow Athenian Eratosthenes for committing adultery with his wife. He was on trial to determine if the killing was premeditated murder or justice. While the verdict of the trial is not known, the trial can be evaluated and much can be learned about daily life in an Athenian family and the Athenian views on women from this case that took place ca. 403-380 B.C.…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The curse against the house and against man is represented differently in Aeschylus’ Agamemnon, Agamemnon’s ancestors did horrible acts on others that incurred the wrath of a curse upon their house. While in Sophocles’ Oedipus Rex, Oedipus was sort of thrown into a tragic event that had nothing to do with him. The curse against both men is represented in varying ways. Starting with Agamemnon, the curse on his house starts even before the play begins with a curse thrust upon the house of Atreus who is Agamemnon’s father. This play is a never ending cycle of revenge upon members of this house.…

    • 1994 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays